2x points now for loyalty members
Avery and Jay's Handcrafted Ice Cream Jackson, NJ
Cakes, Novelties & Quarts
Take Home Novelties
Dairy Cakes
- Dairy Cookies N' Cream Explosion Ice Cream Cake 6"$25.00Out of stock
- Dairy Cookies N' Cream Explosion Ice Cream Cake 8"$45.00Out of stock
- Dairy Explosion Peanut Butter Cup Ice Cream Cake 6"$25.00Out of stock
- Dairy Explosion Peanut Butter Cup Ice Cream Cake 8"$45.00Out of stock
- Dairy Cookie Craze Explosion Ice Cream Cake 6"$25.00
- Dairy Cookie Craze Explosion Ice Cream Cake 8"$45.00Out of stock
- Dairy Vanilla Chocolate Cake 6"$40.00Out of stock
- Dairy Vanilla Chocolate Cake 8"$60.00
- Dairy Vanilla Chocolate Cannoli Ice Cream Cake 8"$60.00Out of stock
- Dairy Vanilla Chocolate Log Cake$70.00
Parve Cakes
- Parve Chocolate Peanut Butter 8" Cake$60.00Out of stock
- Parve Chocolate Peanut Butter Log Cake$70.00Out of stock
- Parve Cookies N' Cream 6" Cake$40.00Out of stock
- Parve White Chocolate Hazelnut Cookie Crunch 6” Cake$40.00
- Parve White Chocolate Hazelnut Cookie Crunch 8” Cake$60.00Out of stock
- Parve White Chocolate Hazelnut Cookie Crunch Log Cake$70.00Out of stock
- Parve Cookie Craze 6" Cake$40.00Out of stock
- Parve Cake Batter Log$70.00Out of stock
- Parve Cake Batter 6" Cake$40.00Out of stock
- Parve Cake Batter 8" Cake$60.00Out of stock
Parve Ice Cream Pies
Dairy Ice Cream Pies
Winter 2024 "Limited Time" Menu
Winter 2024 "Limited Time" Milkshakes
Shakes & Beverages
Avery & Jay's Shakes
- Cookies N' Cream Milkshake$12.00
Rich Vanilla Ice Cream with an Emulsion of Chocolate Sandwich Cookies, Finished with Cookie Crumbs, Whole Cookies, Fresh Whipped Cream and Chocolate Syrup.
- Cotton Candy Milkshake$12.00
Sweet Vanilla Ice Cream with Cotton Candy Flavored Fluff Swirled with Cotton Candy Marshmallow Sauce. Topped with Fresh Whipped Cream, Pink & Blue Candies and Sugar.
- Peanut Butter Cup Milkshake$12.00
Rich Vanilla Ice Cream Blended with Peanut Butter Chocolate Syrup and Decadent Store Made Peanut Putter Cups. Topped with Store Made Whipped Cream, Peanuts and Peanut Butter Cups, Drizzled with Chocolate and Peanut Butter Syrup.
- White Chocolate Pistachio Milkshake$12.00
Creamy Vanilla Ice Cream Blended with White Chocolate Pistachio Spread and Real Pistachio Pieces. Decorated with Fresh Whipped Cream, Pistachio Sauce, Crushed Pistachios and Pistachio Praline.
Shake It Up
A&J Frappes
Soda Floats
- Black Cherry Soda Float$12.00
Stewart's Black Cherry Soda Poured over our Rich Vanilla Ice Cream. Topped with our Fresh Homemade Whipped Cream Garnished with a Cherry.
- Key Lime Soda Float$12.00
Stewart's Key Lime Soda Poured over our Rich Vanilla Ice Cream. Topped with our Fresh Homemade Whipped Cream Garnished with a Cherry.
- Orange N' Cream Soda Float$12.00
Stewart's Orange N' Cream Soda Poured over our Rich Vanilla Ice Cream. Topped with our Fresh Homemade Whipped Cream Garnished with a Cherry.
- Root Beer Soda Float$12.00
Stewart's Root Beer Soda Poured over our Rich Vanilla Ice Cream. Topped with our Fresh Homemade Whipped Cream Garnished with a Cherry.
Coffee & Cocoa
Dolce Crema
Soft Beverages
Fresh Iced Lemonade (Served-Not From Fridge)
Ice Cream & Italian Ice
Ice Cream Cups
- Scoops Small$6.00
One Scoop our Delicious Hand Made Ice Cream
- Premium Scoops Small$7.00
One Scoop our Delicious Premium Hand Made Ice Cream
- Scoops Regular$8.00
Two Scoops our Delicious Hand Made Ice Cream
- Premium Scoops Regular$9.00
Two Scoops our Delicious Premium Hand Made Ice Cream
- Scoops Large$10.00
Three Scoops our Delicious Hand Made Ice Cream
- Premium Scoops Large$11.00
Three Scoops our Delicious Premium Hand Made Ice Cream
- Sauces, Glazes & Toppings on the Side