Butter Burgers
Food
Appetizers
- Cheese Fries$7.00
Crispy Shoestring French Fries Topped with Cheese Sauce, Bacon, and Green Onion.
- Chili Con Queso$8.00
Combination of our House made Queso Dip and Beef Chili, served with Tri-Color Tortilla Chips.
- Coconut Shrimp$14.00
Five Large Shrimp served with Chili Orange Marmalade Dipping Sauce.
- Loaded Nachos$11.00
Tortilla Chips, Chili, Cheese Sauce, Pickled Jalapeño Peppers, Sour Cream, Shredded Monterey Jack and Cheddar Cheeses and Green Onion.
- Onion Rings Full$8.00
Served with Comeback Sauce.
- Paulines Meatballs$10.00
- Pretzels$11.50
Three Freshly Baked Pretzels Served with Beer Cheese Dip.
- Queso Dip$8.00
Roasted Poblano Peppers, and a Blend of Special Cheeses, served with Tortilla Chips.
- Three Tacos$16.50
Three fresh Corn Tortillas, Shredded Cabbage, Red Onion, Cilantro, Queso Fresco, Chipotle Mayo, Choice of Pork Belly, Steak, or Blackened Shrimp.
- Wings$14.00
Six Jumbo Wings Fried Choice of Mango Habanero Hot Sauce, Mild Buffalo, BBQ, or Blackened served with Blue Cheese or Ranch Dressing.
- Cheese Curds$9.00
Wisconsin White Cheddar Cheese, served with Marinara Sauce.
- Chips and Salsa$7.00Out of stock
- Truffle Fries$6.00
- Pita Pizza$7.00
Soup & Salad
- Beef Chili$5.95
Garnished with Shredded Monterey Jack, Cheddar Cheese
- Black And Blue Steak Salad$15.00
Choice of Steak, Grilled Chicken, or Shrimp, Blue Cheese Crumbles, Romaine Lettuce, Tomatoes, Red Onion, Choice of Dressings.
- Cobb Salad$15.00
Turkey, Ham, Bacon, Swiss, Cheddar and Havarti Cheeses, Romaine Lettuce, Tomatoes, Choice of Dressings.
- Side Salad w/cheese$2.95
- Wedge Salad$9.00
Burgers
- Bayshore Boulevard$14.50
Salmon, Green Onion, Fresh Dill, Red Bell Pepper, Lemon Aioli Mayo, Kaiser Roll.
- Channelside Burger$16.00
Black Angus Burger, Sliced Pastrami, Swiss Cheese, Spicy Brown Mustard, Rye Seed Bun
- East Cass Street$20.00
3 – 5 oz. Black Angus Burger, Cheddar, Provolone and American Cheeses, 3 slices of Applewood Smoked Bacon, Shoestring Onions, Iceberg Lettuce and Vine Ripe Tomato, Kaiser Roll.
- East Harrison Street$13.95
Vegan Black Bean Burger, Shredded Iceberg Lettuce, Ketchup, Vine Ripe Tomato, Onion Ring, Kaiser Roll.
- East Polk Street$16.50
Black Angus Burger, Caramelized Onion, Brown Sugar GlazedPeppered Apple Wood Smoked Bacon, Fried Eggs, Chipotle Mayo, Brioche Bun.
- Zack Street Burger$14.00
Black Angus Burger, American Cheese, Iceberg Lettuce, Vine Ripe Tomato, Red Onion, Kaiser Roll. Upgrade to 10 oz. Burger $1.95 Add Thick Sliced Bacon $1.00
- Franklin Street$17.00
Black Angus Burger, Smoked Brisket, Pork Belly, and Applewood Smoked Bacon topped with Baby Rays Sweet BBQ Sauce, and Melted Cheddar Cheese, Kaiser Roll.
- Frogmore Burger$16.00
Peppercorn Encrusted Burger, Gorgonzola Cheese, Thick Cut Bacon, Blueberry Sauce, served on a Brioche Bun. Upgrade to 10 oz. Burger $1.95
- Kid Burger$7.50
- North Ashley Drive$15.50
Black Angus Burger, Swiss Cheese, Fried Prosciutto, Sautéed Cremini Mushrooms, Dijon Mayo, Brioche Bun.
- Tampa Street$17.00
2- 5 oz. Black Angus Burgers, Cheddar Cheese, Swiss Cheese, Bread & Butter Pickle Slices, Mayonnaise, White Onion, Iceberg Lettuce, Kaiser Roll.
- Water Street Burger$15.50
Black Angus Burger, Cheddar Cheese, Grilled Red Onion, Grilled Fresh Jalapeno, Chipotle Mayo, Kaiser Bun. Upgrade to 10 oz. Burger $1.95
- Beyond Burger$16.00
- Butter's Boujee Street!$16.50
Black Angus Burger, Burrata Cheese, Crispy Prosciutto, Arugula, Balsamic Glaze, with Pesto on a Kaiser Bun. Served with TRUFFLE Seasoned Fries
- Burger Flight$21.00
Our Most Popular Burgers, Polk St, Franklin St, and Ashley St!!
- Apple Slice (BOM)$14.95
Specialties
- Philly-Chili Cheese Steak Sandwich$16.00
Shaved Roast Beef, Green Peppers, Onion, Mushrooms, Jalapeño Peppers, White American Cheese, Beef Chili, Hoagie Roll.
- Hot Nash Fried Chicken Sandwich$15.50
Texas Pete's Hot Sauce, Bread and Butter Pickles, Jalapeños, Chipotle Mayonnaise, and Coleslaw on a Brioche Bun.
- Chimichurri Steak$20.50
Marinated for 24 hours, Sliced, Chimichurri Sauce, topped with Fried Onion Strings.
- Pauline's Meatball Parmesan Sub$16.00
Beef Meatballs in Plum Tomato sauce on Hoagie Roll topped with Provolone Cheese.
- Shrimp Stuffed Salmon$20.00
Chargrilled Salmon filet topped with Crabmeat Stuffing, topped with Key Lime Garlic Cream Sauce.
- Pug Dog$14.00
Foot Long All Beef Hot Dog, Cheese Sauce, Bacon, Coleslaw, Yellow Mustard, Jalapeño Peppers, Lettuce, Diced Tomato, and Beef Chili, Hoagie Roll.
- Club Sandwich$15.00
Ham, Havarti Cheese, Iceberg Lettuce, Tomato, Turkey, Bacon, Mayo on Toasted Multigrain Bread
- Fiery Cajun Pasta$17.00
- Kid Chicken Tenders$7.50
- Linguini & Meatballs$16.00
Pauline's Meatballs and linguini Pasta in a Marinara Sauce.
- Mac N Cheese$6.50
- Adult Chicken Tenders$10.95
- Fish n Chips$18.00
Lightly battered cod fish deep fried lightly golden brown. Also comes with our homemade tartar sauce and coleslaw with a side of fries and lemon wedge.
- Texas Tots Special$7.00Out of stock
- Salmon Special$20.00
Desserts
- Caramel Cheesecake$8.00
We start with our NY Cheesecake and swirl in thick, rich Dulce De Leche. As if that wasn’t enough, we top it with a thin layer of HERSHEY’S® Caramel Topping. Where is the Sea Salt? We sprinkle the top of the cheesecake with
- Key Lime Pie$7.00
Our Chef Delroy's Key Lime Pie!
- Red Rover Shake$13.00
- Chocolate Lab Shake$13.00
- Vanilla Terrier$10.00
- Parfait Shake$13.00
Sides
- Extra Beer Cheese Dip$1.00
- Extra Chips$1.00
- Extra Queso Dip$1.00
- Side Balsamic$0.50
- Side BBQ Sauce$0.50
- Side Blue Cheese$0.25
- Side Cheese Sauce$1.00
- Side Chipotle Mayo$0.25
- Side Comeback Sauce$0.25
- Side Hot Sauce
- Side Jalapenos$0.25
- Side Mayo
- Side Oil & Red Wine Vinegar
- Side Ranch$0.25
- Side Sour Cream$0.50
- Side Stone-Ground Mustard$0.50
- Side of Fries$2.00
- Sweet Potato Fries$2.50
- Side Of Onion Rings$2.50
- Side Coleslaw$2.50
- Broccoli$3.50
- Side Truffle Fries$5.00
Beverage
Liquor
- Van Gogh Blue$9.00
- Titos$12.00
- Grey Goose$10.00
- Belvedere$13.00
- Ketel One$13.00
- Ketel One Citroen$13.00
- Absolut Vanilla$10.00
- Absolut Peach$10.00
- Absolut Watermelon$10.00
- Absolut Citron$10.00
- Smirnoff$9.00
- Smirnoff Blue$10.00
- Smirnoff Vanilla$10.00
- Hendricks$12.00
- Aviation$8.00
- Bombay Sapphire$11.00
- Tanqueray$11.00
- Nolets's$11.00
- Flor De Cana$8.00
- Cruzan Banana$9.00Out of stock
- Cruzan Key Lime$9.00
- Malibu Coconut$9.00
- Captain Morgan$9.00
- Myers Dark$9.00
- Bacardi Silver$10.00
- Bacardi Limon$10.00
- Bacardi Dragonberry$10.00Out of stock
- Bacardi Lime$9.00
- Coconut Cartel$10.00
- El Jimador$8.00
- Milagro Reposado$10.00Out of stock
- Milagro Anejo$12.00
- Don Julio$12.00
- Mi Campo$8.00Out of stock
- Patron Silver$11.00Out of stock
- Casamigos Silver$14.00
- Casamigos repo$16.00
- Don Julio Repo$15.00
- 1800 Repo$12.00
- 1942$36.00
- Chocolate Teq$8.00
- Citrus Teq$8.00
- Mezcal$12.00
- Chivas Regal 12 Yr.$10.00
- Dewars White Label$10.00
- Glenlivet 12 Yr.$15.00
- Johnny Walker Black$12.00
- Johnny Walker Red$12.00
- Macallan 12 Yr.$18.00
- Glenfiddich 14 Year$18.00
- Glenfiddich 15 Year$20.00
- Woodford Reserve$13.00
- Basil Hayden's$13.00
- Bulleit$11.00Out of stock
- Jim Beam$9.00
- Maker's Mark$12.00
- Mitchers Bourbon$10.00
- Dickel$9.00
- Jameson$9.00
- Crown Royal$9.00
- Crown Royal Apple$10.00
- Fireball$7.00
- Mitchers Sour Mash$10.00
- Mitchers American Whiskey$10.00
- Mitchers Straight Rye$10.00
- Jack Daniels$9.00
- Jack Daniels Fire$9.00
- Jack Daniels Honey$9.00
- Jameson Black Barrel$10.00
- Kinnity Castle Dapper$10.00Out of stock
- Kinnity Castle Cider$11.00
- Kinnity Castle 10 Year$12.00
- Woodford Reserve Rye$13.00
- Bulleit Rye$10.00
- Disaronno Amaretto$9.00
- Campari$9.00
- Frangelico$9.00
- Grand Marnier$10.00
- Kahlua$9.00
- Melon Liquer$8.00
- Pama Pomegranate$8.00
- St. Germain Elderflower$9.00
- Sambuca$9.00
- Baileys$9.00
- Hennessy$12.00
- Cointreau$9.00
- Rumpleminze$9.00Out of stock
- Godiva Chocolate$9.00
- Redemption Rye$9.00
- Aperol$9.00
- Blue Curaçao$7.00
- MB Roland Elmo's Fire$7.00Out of stock
- Rumple Minze$9.00
- Jager$8.00
- Jager Bomb$10.00
- Blackberry Brandy$7.50
Beer
- Bud Light
- Michelob Ultra
- Yuengling
- 7th Sun- Graffiti OrangeOut of stock
- Tampa Bay Brewing- Reef Donkey
- Cigar City- Jai Alai
- Mermaid Milk
- Coppertail Free Dive
- Keel Farms
- Sample
- Big Storm
- Miller Lite
- Juice Lord
- Stella$6.60+
- Dominga Mimosa Sour
- Truly
- High Noon
- Funky Budda$12.00Out of stock
- Ultra Bucket$25.00Out of stock
- Car Bomb$12.00
- $5 High Noon$5.00
- Riot Juice SourOut of stock
- High Noon Bucket$24.00
- White Claw Bucket$24.00
- Domestic Tower$45.00
- Specialty Tower$50.00
- Domestic Bucket$22.00
- Bud Light Can$5.00
- Miller Lite Can$5.00
- Coors Lite Can$5.00
- Budweiser Can$5.00
- 3D Rocket Pop$7.00
- 3d Oktoberfest Can$5.00
- Ace Pineapple Draft
- Big Storm Can$5.00
- 3D Creamsicle$7.00
- Nutrl Orange$7.00
- Nutrl Watermelon$7.00
- Nutrl Pineapple$7.00
- 3D Beach Blonde
- Mango Cart
Wine
- Pinot Grigio- WineStream$5.60+
- Chardonnay- WineStream$5.60+
- Moscato$10.00+
- SangriaOut of stock
- Cab Sauv- winestream$5.60+Out of stock
- Prosecco$5.60+Out of stock
- Pinot Noir$5.60+Out of stock
- Sav Blanc - Winestream$5.60+
- Merlot- winestream$5.60+Out of stock
- Coppola Merlot Split$5.00
- Coppola Chardonnay Split$5.00
Cocktails
- Amaretto Sour
- Baybreeze
- Black Russian
- Bloody Mary
- Boulevardier
- Cosmopolitan
- Dark N' Stormy
- French 75
- Fuzzy Navel
- Gimlet Gin
- Gimlet Vodka
- Gin Rickey
- Greyhound
- Irish Coffee
- John Collins
- Long Beach Tea
- Long Island Iced Tea
- Lynchburg Lemonade$8.00
- Madras
- Mai Tai$8.00
- Manhattan
- Margarita
- Martini Gin
- Martini Vodka
- Melon Ball
- Melon/Midori Sour
- Mint Julep
- Moscow Mule
- Mudslide
- Frozen Pina Colada$12.00
- Old Fashioned
- Original Mojito
- Paloma
- Pina Colada
- Rum Runner$12.00
- Screwdriver
- Seabreeze
- Sex On The Beach
- Tom Collins
- Whiskey Sour
- White Lady
- White Russian
- Cucumber melon fresca$14.00
Soda/Tea/Other
- Pepsi$3.25
- Diet Pepsi$3.25
- Starry$3.25
- Ginger Ale$3.25
- Unsweet Iced Tea$3.25
- Sweet Tea$3.25
- Coffee$3.25
- Refill Coke
- Refill Diet
- Refill Serria Mist
- Refill Ginger Ale
- Refill Unsweet
- Refill Sweet Tea
- Refill Coffee
- Lemonade$3.25
- Refill Lemonade
- MT.Dew$3.25
- Dr.Pepper$3.25
- Refill MT.Dew
- Refill Dr.Pepper
- Soda Water
- Red Bull$5.00
- Sugarfree Red Bull$5.00
- Ginger Beer$5.00
- Cranberry Juice$3.50
- Orange Juice$3.50
- Pineapple Juice$3.50
- Kid Juice$3.50
- Water
- Bottled Water$2.50
- Perrier Water$5.00
- Hot Choco$3.00
- Espresso$4.00Out of stock
Craft Cocktails
- Latin Love$12.00
- Butter's Mojito$12.00
- Touchdown$13.00
- Mimosa$9.00Out of stock
- Bottomless Mimosa$14.95
- Bottomless Bloody Mary$14.95
- Mimosa Refill
- Bloody Mary Refill
- Espresso$4.00Out of stock
- Muggles Martini$13.00
- Drink Special$10.00
- Ay Chihuahua$12.00
- Butter-rita$13.00
- Wake Up Butter$15.00
- Dog Water$12.00
- My Cousin Snoop$13.00
- Day in the Park$12.00
- Muggles$13.00
- Butter-lada$13.00
- Wishbone$14.00
- Old Dog$14.00
- Lightning Punch$10.00