Cibik's Dairy Island Bainbridge/Chagrin Falls Ohio
Homemade Ice Creams
Cibik’s Craft Ice Creams
- Single Scoop$5.50
Homemade, Small Batch, Hand Crafted, Weekly Flavors.
- Double Scoop$7.50
Homemade, Small Batch, Hand Crafted, Weekly Flavors.
- KId's Scoop$4.50
Homemade, Small Batch, Hand Crafted, Weekly Flavors.
- Pint$9.00
Homemade, Small Batch, Hand Crafted, Weekly Flavors
- Quart$15.00
Take home a quart of butter pecan tonight for a midnight snack.
CREATE your own ICE CREAM - It's A Contest!
- CREATE your own Ice Cream$7.50
Win FREE Ice Cream for a Season. Don't Forget to Register your Flavor at www.dairyisland.com
- Ambrosia by Taylor Baryak, 2023$7.50
2023 Flavor of the Year created by Taylor Baryak. Coconut and Pineapple with Mini Marshmallows whipped into Vanilla Frozen Custard. Any requests?
- The Ultimate Banana Bread by Veronica Corsillo, 2022$7.00
2022 Flavor of the Year, curated by Veronica Corsillo. Graham crackers, honey, walnuts and banana whipped into vanilla frozen custard. An absolute ice cream masterpiece!
- Queen Bee by Sarah Freeman, 2021$7.50
2021 Flavor of the Year created by Sarah Freeman. Vanilla Custard with Hungry Bee Honey and Lotus Biscoff Cookies
- Peanut Butter Blast by Christine Sutter, 2020$7.50
2020 Flavor of the Year created by Christine Sutter. Enjoy her peanut butter frozen custard loaded with Nutter Butter cookies.
- Chocolate Rice Krispy Treat by Sydney Corcoran, 2019$7.50
Rice Krispies, chocolate chips and marshmallow sauce whipped into vanilla frozen custard.
- Chagrin S'Mores by Ella Laneve, 2018$7.50
2018 Best Flavor of the Year. Marshmallows, Graham Crackers, Hot Fudge & Caramel
- Take Me Out To The Ballgame by Mia Conti, 2017$7.50
Mia Conti's Grand Slam winner. Cracker Jaxs, peanuts and fudge whipped into vanilla frozen custard. The 2017 contest winner.
- Shock The Monkey$7.50
Peanut butter and bananas whipped into vanilla frozen custard.
- Lemon$7.50
Simple and delicious. Fresh squeezed lemon whipped into vanilla frozen custard.
- Cherry Pie$7.50
Our tribute to Sade Adu. Cherries and graham crackers mixed into vanilla frozen custard.
- Cereal Killer$7.50
Maggie Cibik's best seller! Cpt. Crunch, Fruit Loops, Lucky Charms, and Cookie Dough carefully mixed into vanilla frozen custard.
- Franks & Beans$7.50
Friday Night Franks!
Frozen Custard
- Kids Vanilla$3.50
Don't forget your eyes.
- Kids Chocolate$3.50
Rich & Creamy.
- Kids Twist$3.50
Always Delicious.
- Small Vanilla$4.50
Our signature product: 10% butterfat milk and cream with egg yolks added to create a smooth and creamy frozen custard experience.
- Small Chocolate$4.50
Rich & Creamy, Always Delicious.
- Small Twist$4.50
Yum!
- Medium Vanilla$5.50
Our signature product: 10% butterfat milk and cream with egg yolks added to create a smooth and creamy frozen custard experience.
- Medium Chocolate$5.50
Rich & Creamy, Always Delicious.
- Medium Twist$5.50
Half & Half.
- Large Vanilla$6.50
Our signature product: 10% butterfat milk and cream with egg yolks added to create a smooth and creamy frozen custard experience.
- Large Chocolate$6.50
Go for it!
- Large Twist$6.50
Rich & Creamy, Always Delicious.
- Custard Pint$8.00
Rich & Creamy, Always Delicious
- Custard Quart$13.00
Rich & Creamy, Always Delicious
- Pup Cup$2.00
Treat your best friend tonight.
Pineapple Dole Whip
Hurricanes
Classic Sundaes
- Turtle$7.50
Caramel, Hot Fudge & Pecans
- E.T.$7.50
Peanut Butter, Hot Fudge & Reese's Pieces
- Chocolate Covered Strawberries$7.50
Vanilla Custard topped with Strawberries covered in Chocolate Dip Top
- I Love My Brownies!$7.50
Fudge Brownie with Cibik's Craft I Love Lucy Ice Cream topped with Red Raspberry topping and Hot Fudge
- Mississippi Mud Pie$7.50
Vanilla Frozen with Crushed OREOs and Topped with Hot Fudge
- Pina Colada$7.50
Pineapple Dole Whip topped with Shredded Coconut and Honey
- Peanut Butter Cup$7.50
Peanut Butter, Chocolate Dip Top & Reese's Peanut Butter Cups
- Strawberry Shortcake$7.50
Shortcake Topped with Vanilla Frozen Custard & Strawberries
- Bainbridge Brownie$7.50
Fudge Brownie Topped with Vanilla Frozen Custard & Hot Fudge
- Superman vs. Spiderman$7.50
Cibik's Craft Superman Ice Cream topped with Blue Raspberry and Cherry Dip Tops
- Hero Sundae$7.50
Strawberry & Blueberry. Cibik's Donate $1 to Local First Responders
- S’more$7.50
Hot Fudge, Marshmallow & Graham Crackers
- Tin Roof$7.50
Chocolate Sauce & Spanish Peanuts
- Pirate's Booty$7.50
In Honor of the Dairy Island Pirate's Baseball Team: Black & Red Raspberry, M&Ms, Capt. Crunch & Gummy Sharks
- Sweet Corn & Cream$7.50
Vanilla Frozen Custard topped with Corn Flakes & Honey
Parfaits
- Heathaze Parfait$8.00
Our Genesis Tribute. Caramel & Heath Bar Layered in a Parfait Glass
- Pretzel Logic Parfait$8.00
Great album, great song, great parfait. Layers of Caramel, Hot Fudge, and Salty Pretzels.
- Purple Haze Parfait$8.00
Vanilla and Chocolate Custard with layers of Black Raspberry and Dark Chocolate Chunks
- Hot Fudge Peanut Parfait$8.00
Hot Fudge & Spanish Peanuts Layered in a Parfait Glass
- Breakfast in America Parfait$8.00
Enjoy breakfast all day with frozen custard, Cocoa Puffs, Cpt. Crunch and Fruity Pebbles
- Honolulu Luau Parfait$8.00
Let's take a vacation with frozen custard shredded coconut, pineapple and dark chocolate bits.
Splits
- Banana Split$8.50
Chocolate & Vanilla Frozen Custard topped with Chocolate, Pineapple and Strawberry, Whipped Cream & Nuts: All in a Banana Boat
- Hot Fudge Fantasy$9.50
The Ultimate Banana Split: Chocolate and Vanilla Frozen Custard topped with lots of Hot Fudge, Buttered Pecans and Whipped Cream in a Banana Boat
Old Fashioned Sundaes
Slush & Brain Freezes
Shakes
Specialty Shakes
- Bamm Bamm Specialty Shake$8.50
Our creamy and delicious vanilla shake mixed with Fruity Pebbles. Yabba Dabba Doo!
- Hawaiian Noises Specialty Shake$8.50
You've had the ice cream, now try it as a shake! Dark chocolate bits, pineapple and shredded coconut whipped into our vanilla frozen custard.
- Salty Caramel Pretzel Specialty Shake$8.50
Salty Pretzels & Caramel with Vanilla Frozen Custard
- Chocolate Covered Cherry$8.50
Chocolate Frozen Custard with Maraschino Cherries and Chocolate Dip Top
- Cookie Dough Specialty Shake$8.50
Cookie Dough and Vanilla Frozen Custard
- Mint Chocolate Chip Specialty Shake$8.50
Mint Flavored Frozen Custard with Mini Chocolate Chips & Andes Mints
- Banana Specialty Shake$8.50
Fresh Bananas and Vanilla Frozen Custard
- Cookies & Cream Specialty Shake$8.50
OREO Cookies and Vanilla Frozen Custard
- Peanut Butter Banana Specialty Shake$8.50
Peanut Butter Sauce and Bananas with Vanilla Frozen Custard
- S'Mores Specialty Shake$8.50
Chocolate Custard with Marshmallow Sauce and Graham Crackers