Cockeye Creamery
Featured Items
- Love Thy Neighbor$5.99+
Fresh strawberry pureé super-premium ice cream w/ chocolate-covered strawberries, brownies, and dark chocolate chunks.
- Peanut Butter Pie$5.99+
Creamy Reese’s peanut butter, marshmallow, graham cracker, chocolate chunks.
- Coffee-Caramel Crumb$5.99+
Fresh-ground local (Grand River Grounds, Middlefield, OH) espresso, caramel and graham crumb streaks
Online Flavor Selection
Current Flavors - updated in real time!
- (Vegan/Dairy-free) Chocolate$5.99+
Oat milk, cocoa, sugar.
- (Vegan/Dairy-free) Strawberry Banana$5.99+
Oat milk, strawberry purée, bananas
- Andromeda$5.99+
Chocolate ice cream, brownies, candy-coated mini chocolate chips.
- Blackberry Chocolate Chunk$5.99+
Real blackberries, chocolate chunks. Your wife will love this one.
- Blueberry Cheesecake$5.99+
Real blueberries in a cheesecake ice cream.
- Butter Pecan$5.99+
Hillson buttered pecans in smooth nutty base.
- Buttermilk Pie$5.99+
Cockeye Creamery’s signature chef-inspired flavor; made with fresh-baked buttermilk pies from Cockeye BBQ’s kitchen.
- Cherry the Hatchet$5.99+
Chocolate and black cherry flavored ice cream w/ brownies, black cherry halves, and chocolate chunks
- Chocolate Pecan$5.99+
Chocolate super-premium ice cream with salted pecan halves
- Coffee-Caramel Crumb$5.99+
Fresh-ground local (Grand River Grounds, Middlefield, OH) espresso, caramel and graham crumb streaks
- Cookie Monster$5.99+
Cookie dough ice cream with Oreos and chocolate chip cookie dough.
- Cuckoo Clock$5.99+
Real Ohio maple syrup (Seldom Seen Farms), cinnamon, candied praline pecans, and hunks of cheesecake
- Darkest Hour$5.99+
Chocolate ice cream, brownies, fudge, chocolate chunks, Oreo
- Deep Chocolate$5.99+
Cockeye Creamery's take on traditional, American chocolate ice cream.
- Down on the Corner$5.99+
Vanilla bean super-premium ice cream w/ maraschino cherries, fudge swirl, and chocolate-covered peanuts
- French Vanilla Bean$5.99+
Egg, premium vanilla bean.
- Fresh Strawberry$5.99+
Strawberry puree and hunks of fresh strawberry.
- Honey Lavender$5.99+
Real Ohio wildflower honey (Kline Honey, Rootstown, OH) and lavender
- Honeycomb Crunch$5.99+
Dulce de leche ice cream w/ chocolate-covered honeycomb candy
- King Cake$5.99+
House-baked yellow cake, almond flavoring, purple créme swirl.. for good luck!
- Kong$5.99+
Banana ice cream with graham crackers and mini buckeyes.
- Love Thy Neighbor$5.99+
Fresh strawberry pureé super-premium ice cream w/ chocolate-covered strawberries, brownies, and dark chocolate chunks.
- Mint To Be$5.99+
Creme de menthe, chocolate chunks.
- Peach$5.99+Out of stock
Peach super-premium ice cream with hunks of real peaches
- Peanut Butter Pie$5.99+
Creamy Reese’s peanut butter, marshmallow, graham cracker, chocolate chunks.
- Pistachio$5.99+
Beautifully green pistachio ice cream with salty Hillson pistachios.
- Samoa$5.99+
Coconut super-premium ice cream w/ toasted coconut, fudge swirl, and real Samoa Girl Scout cookies (Troop 80008, Howland, OH)
- Spumoni$5.99+
Chocolate, pistachio, and black cherry super-premium ice cream
- Station Six$5.99+
Fiery cinnamon-flavored super-premium ice cream w/ crushed cinnamon imperial candies
- Toffeescotch$5.99+
Butterscotch super-premium ice cream w/ Heath candies and a fudge swirl
- White House$5.99+
Our French vanilla bean ice cream with maraschino cherries throughout.
- Wired!$5.99+
Coffee ice cream made with fresh ground Third Day 'Black Lab' espresso beans, chocolate chunks, and brownies.
Ice Cream Sandwiches
- Super-Premium Ice Cream Sandwich - Sugar$4.99
Our made-to-order ice cream sandwich with fresh-baked (and then frozen) sugar cookies. Just choose your flavor!
- Super-Premium Ice Cream Sandwich - Chocolate Chip$4.99
Our made-to-order ice cream sandwich with fresh-baked (and then frozen) chocolate chip cookies. Just choose your flavor!
Super-Premium Ice Cream Pies
Ice Cream Pies
- Cookie Monster Ice Cream Pie$22.99
Our Cookie Monster ice cream inside a graham cracker pie crust!
- Peanut-Butter Pie Ice Cream Pie$22.99
Our Peanut-Butter Pie ice cream inside a graham cracker pie crust!
- PumQueen Ice Cream Pie$20.00
Our PumQueen ice cream inside a graham cracker pie crust!
- Buttermilk Pie Ice Cream Pie$22.99
Our Buttermilk Pie ice cream inside a graham cracker pie crust!
Retail
Merch
Third Day Coffee
Creamery Tee Shirts
- Iris (Blue) Logo Tee (XXL)$18.74
- Black Logo Tee (S)$18.74Out of stock
- Black Logo Tee (M)$18.74Out of stock
- Black Logo Tee (L)$18.74Out of stock
- Black Logo Tee (XL)$18.74Out of stock
- Black Logo Tee (XXL)$18.74
- Black Logo Tee (XXXL)$18.74
- Berry (Pink) Logo Tee (S)$18.74Out of stock
- Berry (Pink) Logo Tee (M)$18.74Out of stock
- Berry (Pink) Logo Tee (L)$18.74
- Berry (Pink) Logo Tee (XL)$18.74
- Berry (Pink) Logo Tee (XXL)$18.74
- Berry (Pink) Logo Tee (XXXL)$18.74