Pies in Madison
Madison restaurants that serve pies
MADISON SOURDOUGH
916 Williamson St, Madison
Strawberry Pie Slice | $6.00 |
Lattice topped strawberry pie |
FISH AND CHIPS • SEAFOOD • SANDWICHES • GRILL
Quivey's Grove
6261 Nesbitt Rd, Fitchburg
Turtle Pie - TO | $8.75 |
Chocolate Bavarian Cream over caramel and pecans, a house favorite. | |
Turtle Pie | $8.75 |
Chocolate Bavarian Cream over caramel and pecans, a house favorite. |
Parkway Family Restaurant
1221 Ann St, Fitchburg
Lemon meringue Pie | $3.99 |
SMOOTHIES • SANDWICHES
Ancora - Maple Bluff
611 N Sherman Ave, Madison
Apple Pie Donut | $4.25 |
filled with apple pie filling, cider glaze, and crumble topping |
Salvatore's Tomato Pies - Livingston
10 N Livingston Street, Madison
10" Build Your Own Pie | $12.25 |
Crust, Olive Oil, Romano, Wisconsin Whole Milk Mozzarella, and House Red Sauce. DOES NOT COME WITH BASIL | |
16" Build Your Own Pie | $17.85 |
The Classic but built in reverse; Crust, Olive Oil, Romano, Wisconsin Whole Milk Mozzarella, and House Red Sauce | |
10" Tomato Pie with Basil | $12.25 |
The Classic but built in reverse; Crust, Olive Oil, Romano, Wisconsin Whole Milk Mozzarella, and House Red Sauce, finished with Fresh Basil. This style of pizza was created in Trenton, NJ, back in 1911. Just the original Tomato pie, no toppings. |
ORIGIN Breads
931 E. Main St. #1, Madison
pan pie: sausage with cornmeal-dipped crust | $22.00 |
dipping our pizza dough in cornmeal before putting it in the pan adds layers of flavor and crunch to an already delicious pie. if you like our pan pies, you should give this one a try. trust us on this one. sourdough pizza crust, organic tomato sauce, house-pulled fresh mozzarella, house italian sausage made with enos farms pork. prior to baking the dough is dipped in organic red flint cornmeal. post-bake, dressed with organic basil oil, sarvecchio parmesan, maldon sea salt & olive oil. rectangular pan pie. 8 pieces. feeds 2 (usually). Our long-fermented sourdough pizza crust is made with 100% local, organic grains from Meadowlark Organics (Ridgeway, WI). | |
pan pie: pepperoni, ricotta, hot honey | $22.00 |
pan pies mean a crispy bottom fried in olive oil and a heartier base to hold more toppings. sourdough pizza crust, organic tomato sauce, house-pulled fresh mozzarella, tempesta pepperoni. post-bake, dressed with whipped ricotta, hot honey, basil oil, sarvecchio parmesan, maldon sea salt, olive oil. rectangular pan pie feeds 2 (usually). please note that since we can't currently source fresh basil, we are using a thick basil oil to dress our pizzas. if you or your kids are opposed (it can't be picked off like basil leaves), please include a note asking us to leave it off. Our long-fermented sourdough pizza crust is made with 100% local, organic grains from Meadowlark Organics (Ridgeway, WI). | |
pan pie: pepperoni with cornmeal-dipped crust | $21.00 |
dipping our pizza dough in cornmeal before putting it in the pan adds layers of flavor and crunch to an already delicious pie. if you like our pan pies, you should give this one a try. trust us on this one. pan pies mean a crispy bottom fried in olive oil and a heartier base to hold more toppings. sourdough pizza crust, organic tomato sauce, house-pulled fresh mozzarella, underground pepperoni, organic red flint cornmeal. post-bake, dressed with organic basil oil, sarvecchio parmesan maldon sea salt, evoo rectangular pan pie feeds 2 (usually). Our long-fermented sourdough pizza crust is made with 100% local, organic grains from Meadowlark Organics (Ridgeway, WI). |
PIZZA
Grampa's Pizzeria
1374 Williamson St, Madison
Basic Pie | $13.00 |
tomato sauce, house blend cheese - start here to build your own pizza with any toppings you'd like! |
Great Dane - Hilldale
357 Price Pl, Madison
Chicken Pot Pie | $15.00 |
Slow simmered white meat chicken, baked in a crock with vegetables and potato, topped with puff pastry, served with warm applesauce and a soft pretzel stick |
Vintage Brewing Company - Madison West - 674 S Whitney Way
674 S Whitney Way, Madison
Shepherd's Pie | $16.00 |
Ground beef, garlic mashed potatoes, peas, carrots, beef gravy & shredded cheese. |
North and South Seafood & Smokehouse-Madison
6604 Mineral Point Rd, Madison
Bourbon Pecan Pie | $6.50 |
Housemade classic pecan pie with chocolate and a splash of bourbon | |
Key Lime Pie | $6.00 |
Housemade with authentic Key Lime Juice |
Great Dane - Downtown
123 E Doty Street, Madison
Chicken Pot Pie | $15.00 |
Slow simmered white meat chicken, baked in a crock with vegetables and potato, topped with puff pastry, served with warm applesauce and a soft pretzel stick |
Great Dane - Eastside
876 Jupiter Dr, Madison
Chicken Pot Pie | $15.00 |
Slow simmered white meat chicken, baked in a crock with vegetables and potato, topped with puff pastry, served with warm applesauce and a soft pretzel stick |
PIZZA • TACOS • SALADS
Lucille
101 King St., Madison
Grasshopper Pie | $11.00 |
A slice of Traditional Grasshopper Pie filled with Mint-Marshmallow Cream on an Oreo cookie crust (Gluten-Free) | |
Wood-Fired 'Umami Pie' | $24.00 |
Black Garlic Cream, Manchego, Roasted Mushroom, Lacinato Kale, Caramelized Onion, topped with Scallions and Balsamic Glaze |
Gates & Brovi
3502 Monroe Street, Madison
MAPLE PECAN PIE | $8.00 |
BOSTON CREAM PIE | $7.00 |
BANANAS FOSTER PIE | $9.00 |
BeneBlends - 558 Junction Road
558 Junction Road, Madison
LTD EDITION -- PECAN PIE BITES! | $5.00 |
Our house-made pecan pie filling rolled into 4 perfect little bites with a salted date caramel filled center. Gluten free & vegan, as always! | |
Blueberry Pie SMOOTHIE | |
Banana, blueberry, oats, vanilla pea protein, cinnamon, almond butter, almond milk | |
Blueberry Pie BOWL | $12.00 |
base: blueberries, banana, oats, plant-based van. protein, cinnamon, almond milk toppings: chocolate cashew granola, fresh fruit, dried mulberries, almond butter |
La Taguara Bar & Grill
3010 Crossroads Drive, Madison
Passion Fruit Pie | $5.99 |
Made from scratch passion fruit pie topped with whipped cream and drizze with passion fruit syrup. |
Great Dane - Fitchburg
2980 Cahill Main, Fitchburg
Chicken Pot Pie | $15.00 |
Slow simmered white meat chicken, baked in a crock with vegetables and potato, topped with puff pastry, served with warm applesauce and a soft pretzel stick |
Salvatore's Tomato Pies - Monona
5507 Monona Drive, Monona
10" Tomato Pie (BYO) | $11.75 |
The Classic but built in reverse; Crust, Olive Oil, Romano, Wisconsin Whole Milk Mozzarella, and House Red Sauce, finished with Fresh Basil. This style of pizza was created in Trenton, NJ, back in 1910. BYO do not get basil unless added. | |
16" One Topping Pie | $16.00 |
Tuesday's Only! Get our Classic Tomato Pie with the topping of your choice for just $16. | |
16" Tomato Pie (BYO) | $17.50 |
The Classic but built in reverse; Crust, Olive Oil, Romano, Wisconsin Whole Milk Mozzarella, and House Red Sauce, finished with Fresh Basil. This style of pizza was created in Trenton, NJ, back in 1910. BYO do not get basil unless added. |