
Italian
Bella Mia Cafe 134 West Main Street
134 West Main Street
Bay Shore, NY 11706
Orders through Toast are commission free and go directly to this restaurant
Drinks
Dessert & Coffee
Gelato
Coffee, Espresso, Tea
Americano
Bold shot of espresso paired with hot water, creating a smooth, strong cup with a clean finish.$3.50+Espresso
A concentrated shot of pure coffee with a rich, velvety crema. Intense, bold, and expertly extracted.$3.00Cappuccino
A classic Italian balance of 1/3 espresso, 1/3 steamed milk, and 1/3 creamy microfoam.$4.50+Crema di Caffe
$3.50Latte
Velvety steamed milk poured over a double shot of espresso, topped with a thin layer of foam. Smooth and comforting.$4.50+Macchiato
A single or double shot of espresso topped with a small spoonful of foamed milk.$4.50+Drip Coffee
$3.25+Hot Chocolate
$3.25+Hot Tea
$3.25+Coke
$4.00Diet Coke
$4.00Orange Juice
$4.00Cranberry Juice
$4.00Sprite
$4.00Ginger Ale
$4.00Red Bull
$8.00Pineapple Juice
$4.00Grapefruit Juice
$4.00Ginger Beer
$4.50Milk
$3.00Apple Juice
$4.50Shirley Temple
$6.00
Grand Opening
Appetizers
Handhelds
Bella Mia Chicken Bruschetta
Basil crusted chicken, provolone, tomato bruschetta, balsamic glaze$15.50Italian Meatball Sausage Parmigiano
Sweet pork sausage and basil pesto meatballs, provolone$15.50Caesar Con Pollo Sandwich
Lemon and basil grilled chicken, greens, parmigiano, sun-dried tomatoes, grilled lemon caesar dressing$15.50
Burgers
Bella Mia Burger
Double stuffed smashed patty, mozzarella, marinated roasted red peppers, greens, balsamic aioli, focaccia or brioche bun, Tuscan fries$16.50Build Your Own Burger
Double stuffed smashed patty or sweet sausage smashed patty$16.50Burger di Fagioli
Black bean patty with peppers, onions, provolone, greens, basil aioili$15.50Salsiccia Dolce Burger
Double stuffed sweet sausage smashed patty, peppers, onions, provolone, greens, basil aioli, focaccia or brioche bun, tuscan fries$16.50
Pinsas
Margherita
Tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, basil, basil pesto$15.50Prosciutto
Prosciutto, ricotta, arugula, shaved parmigiano, balsamic glaze$16.50Calabrese
Hot soppressata, nduja, ricotta, calabrian chili oil, mozzarella, marinara drizzle$17.50OUT OF STOCKMortadella
Crispy mortadella, pistachio cream, pistachios, burrata, balsamic glaze$18.50Mediterranean
Artichokes, sun-dried tomatoes, roasted peppers, fresh mozzarella$16.50
Salads
Entrees
Pollo Parmigiano
Basil crusted chicken, fresh mozzarella, cherry tomato ragout, parmigiano and spaghetti$23.50Bella Mia Spaghetti e Polpette
Sausage meatballs, basil pesto, marinara, garlic crustade$22.50Penne alla Vodka
Ricotta salata, crispy prosciutto, mascarpone, pink vodka sauce$21.50Costoletta al Rosmarino
Double cut pork chop, vinegar pepper, rosemary demi$32.50Gamberi al Burro
Jumbo shrimp, roasted garlic, diced tomatoes, herb breadcrumbs, limoncello brown butter sauce. Served with pasta and vegetable of the day.$32.00
Kids Menu
Dessert
Lemon Pistacchio Cheesecake
Individual cheesecake, candied pistacchios, pistachio crème anglaise, vanilla whip cream$10.50Nutella Pinsa Pizza Grand Open
Marinated strawberries, candied hazelnuts$12.50Triple Chocolate Layer Cake
Espresso whip cream, chocolate shavings, chocolate crunch, raspberry glaze$10.50Flourless Chocolate Cake
Espresso whip cream, chocolate shavings, chocolate crunch, raspberry glaze$12.00To Go Gelato
$4.50+Affogato
$6.50
All hours
| Sunday | 11:00 am - 8:00 pm |
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | 11:30 am - 8:00 pm |
| Wednesday | 11:00 am - 8:00 pm |
| Thursday | 11:00 am - 8:00 pm |
| Friday | 11:00 am - 9:00 pm |
| Saturday | 11:00 am - 9:00 pm |
Restaurant info
A Taste of Italy!
Location
© 2026 Toast, Inc.



