Skip to Main content
  • Bella Mia Cafe 134 West Main Street

    • Home
    • /
    • Bay Shore
    • /
    • Bella Mia Cafe 134 West Main Street
    Restaurant banner image
    Italian

    Bella Mia Cafe 134 West Main Street

    134 West Main Street

    Bay Shore, NY 11706


    Orders through Toast are commission free and go directly to this restaurant


    Call

    Hours

    Directions

    Gift Cards

    Drinks
    Dessert & Coffee
    Grand Opening
    ‌
    ‌

    Drinks

    Non-Alcoholic Beverages

    • Coke

      $4.00
    • Diet Coke

      $4.00
    • Orange Juice

      $4.00
    • Cranberry Juice

      $4.00
    • Sprite

      $4.00
    • Ginger Ale

      $4.00
    • Red Bull

      $8.00
    • Pineapple Juice

      $4.00
    • Grapefruit Juice

      $4.00
    • Ginger Beer

      $4.50
    • Milk

      $3.00
    • Apple Juice

      $4.50
    • Shirley Temple

      $6.00
    • Chocolate Milk

      $3.50
    • Still Bottled Water

      $3.00
    • Sparkling Bottled Water

      $7.00

    Dessert & Coffee

    Gelato

    • Vanilla Bean

      $0+
    • Stracciatella

      creamy vanilla with shards of dark chocolate
      $4.50+
    • Pistacchio

      $4.50+
    • Chocolate

      $4.50+
    • Hazelnut (Nocciola)

      $4.50+
    • Strawberry (Fragola)

      $4.50+
    • Amarena

      Black Cherry
      $4.50+
    • Chocolate Hazelnut Crunch

      $4.50+
    • mango

      $4.50+

    Coffee, Espresso, Tea

    • Americano

      Bold shot of espresso paired with hot water, creating a smooth, strong cup with a clean finish.
      $3.50+
    • Espresso

      A concentrated shot of pure coffee with a rich, velvety crema. Intense, bold, and expertly extracted.
      $3.00
    • Cappuccino

      A classic Italian balance of 1/3 espresso, 1/3 steamed milk, and 1/3 creamy microfoam.
      $4.50+
    • Crema di Caffe

      $3.50
    • Latte

      Velvety steamed milk poured over a double shot of espresso, topped with a thin layer of foam. Smooth and comforting.
      $4.50+
    • Macchiato

      A single or double shot of espresso topped with a small spoonful of foamed milk.
      $4.50+
    • Drip Coffee

      $3.25+
    • Hot Chocolate

      $3.25+
    • Hot Tea

      $3.25+
    • Coke

      $4.00
    • Diet Coke

      $4.00
    • Orange Juice

      $4.00
    • Cranberry Juice

      $4.00
    • Sprite

      $4.00
    • Ginger Ale

      $4.00
    • Red Bull

      $8.00
    • Pineapple Juice

      $4.00
    • Grapefruit Juice

      $4.00
    • Ginger Beer

      $4.50
    • Milk

      $3.00
    • Apple Juice

      $4.50
    • Shirley Temple

      $6.00

    Grand Opening

    Appetizers

    • Fried Calamari

      Crispy lemons and capers, herb medley, marinara
      $17.50
    • Arancini della Casa

      Mascarpone, parmigiano, mozzarella rice balls, pesto drizzle, marinara
      $14.50
    • Italian Nachos

      Pinsa, sausage, broccoli rabe, bruschetta, cherry peppers, fresh mozzarella
      $16.50

    Handhelds

    • Bella Mia Chicken Bruschetta

      Basil crusted chicken, provolone, tomato bruschetta, balsamic glaze
      $15.50
    • Italian Meatball Sausage Parmigiano

      Sweet pork sausage and basil pesto meatballs, provolone
      $15.50
    • Caesar Con Pollo Sandwich

      Lemon and basil grilled chicken, greens, parmigiano, sun-dried tomatoes, grilled lemon caesar dressing
      $15.50

    Burgers

    • Bella Mia Burger

      Double stuffed smashed patty, mozzarella, marinated roasted red peppers, greens, balsamic aioli, focaccia or brioche bun, Tuscan fries
      $16.50
    • Build Your Own Burger

      Double stuffed smashed patty or sweet sausage smashed patty
      $16.50
    • Burger di Fagioli

      Black bean patty with peppers, onions, provolone, greens, basil aioili
      $15.50
    • Salsiccia Dolce Burger

      Double stuffed sweet sausage smashed patty, peppers, onions, provolone, greens, basil aioli, focaccia or brioche bun, tuscan fries
      $16.50

    Pinsas

    • Margherita

      Tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, basil, basil pesto
      $15.50
    • Prosciutto

      Prosciutto, ricotta, arugula, shaved parmigiano, balsamic glaze
      $16.50
    • Calabrese

      Hot soppressata, nduja, ricotta, calabrian chili oil, mozzarella, marinara drizzle
      OUT OF STOCK
      $17.50
    • Mortadella

      Crispy mortadella, pistachio cream, pistachios, burrata, balsamic glaze
      $18.50
    • Mediterranean

      Artichokes, sun-dried tomatoes, roasted peppers, fresh mozzarella
      $16.50

    Salads

    • Bella Mia Garden Salad

      Greens, cucumbers, red onions, tomatoes, basil balsamic vinaigrette
      $11.50
    • Caesar Salad

      Romaine, rosemary pinsa crisps, shaved parmigiano, grilled lemon caesar dressing
      $12.50

    Entrees

    • Pollo Parmigiano

      Basil crusted chicken, fresh mozzarella, cherry tomato ragout, parmigiano and spaghetti
      $23.50
    • Bella Mia Spaghetti e Polpette

      Sausage meatballs, basil pesto, marinara, garlic crustade
      $22.50
    • Penne alla Vodka

      Ricotta salata, crispy prosciutto, mascarpone, pink vodka sauce
      $21.50
    • Costoletta al Rosmarino

      Double cut pork chop, vinegar pepper, rosemary demi
      $32.50
    • Gamberi al Burro

      Jumbo shrimp, roasted garlic, diced tomatoes, herb breadcrumbs, limoncello brown butter sauce. Served with pasta and vegetable of the day.
      $32.00

    Kids Menu

    • Chicken Fingers and Fries

      $13.00
    • Bella mia kids spaghetti e polpette

      $12.00
    • Pinsa Margherita for kids

      $13.00

    Dessert

    • Lemon Pistacchio Cheesecake

      Individual cheesecake, candied pistacchios, pistachio crème anglaise, vanilla whip cream
      $10.50
    • Nutella Pinsa Pizza Grand Open

      Marinated strawberries, candied hazelnuts
      $12.50
    • Triple Chocolate Layer Cake

      Espresso whip cream, chocolate shavings, chocolate crunch, raspberry glaze
      $10.50
    • Flourless Chocolate Cake

      Espresso whip cream, chocolate shavings, chocolate crunch, raspberry glaze
      $12.00
    • To Go Gelato

      $4.50+
    • Affogato

      $6.50

    All hours
    Sunday11:00 am - 8:00 pm
    MondayClosed
    Tuesday11:30 am - 8:00 pm
    Wednesday11:00 am - 8:00 pm
    Thursday11:00 am - 8:00 pm
    Friday11:00 am - 9:00 pm
    Saturday11:00 am - 9:00 pm
    Restaurant info

    A Taste of Italy!

    Location

    134 West Main Street, Bay Shore, NY 11706

    Directions


    Similar restaurants in your area

    Kismet- Coffee, Kitchen, Cocktails
    View restaurantnext
    The Pizzeria of Bay Shore
    View restaurantnext
    The Pie at Salvatore's 120 E Main St
    View restaurantnext
    Bar Lucy
    View restaurantnext
    Le Dock
    View restaurantnext
    Mama Mia's Pizza 635 East Main Street
    View restaurantnext
    Search similar restaurants
    © 2026 Toast, Inc.
    Toast
    • About Toast
    • For restaurants
    • Terms of Service
    • Privacy Statement
    • Do not sell my
      personal information
    Made with love in Boston
    • Instagram
    • X (formerly Twitter)
    • Facebook