Pizza
Benelli’s Pizzeria
15 Roosevelt Rd
Valparaiso, IN 46383
Orders through Toast are commission free and go directly to this restaurant
Pickup Only
Featured Items
Build Your Own 12"
Red Sauce Base, Signature Cheese Blend - Mozzarella, Provolone, Münster Topped & finished any way you’d like!$14.00Garlic Parm Benelli Bites
Bread Bites - Garlic Butter, Italian Herbs, Parm Cheese, Side of Red Sauce for dipping$4.00Cheese Pizza 12″
Red Sauce Base, Signature Cheese Blend - Mozzarella, Provolone, Münster$14.00
Appetizers
Garlic Parm Benelli Bites
Bread Bites - Garlic Butter, Italian Herbs, Parm Cheese, Side of Red Sauce for dipping$4.00Cinnamon Benelli Bites
Bread Bites - Cinnamon, Butter$4.00Garlic Cheese Bread
Garlic Butter, Garlic Salt, Italian Herbs, Signature Cheese Blend$5.00Pizza Bread
Red Sauce, Signature Cheese Blend$5.00Tomato Bread
Red Sauce, Signature Cheese Blend, Roma Tomato$5.00Garlic Bread
Garlic Butter, Garlic Salt, Italian Herbs$4.00Apple Pie Pizza 12″
Apple Pie Filling, Finished with Ghirardelli Caramel Sauce Drizzle$10.00Apple Pie Pizza 16″
Apple Pie Filling, Finished with Ghirardelli Caramel Sauce Drizzle$16.00
Detroit Style
Build Your Own 8x10
Wisconsin Brick Cheese, Red Sauce on top Topped & finished any way you’d like!$14.00Build Your Own 10x14
Wisconsin Brick Cheese, Red Sauce on top Topped & finished any way you’d like!$18.00Brickyard Cheese 8x10
Wisconsin Brick Cheese, Red Sauce on top$14.00Brickyard Cheese 10x14
Wisconsin Brick Cheese, Red Sauce on top$18.00Angry Bear 8x10
Wisconsin Brick Cheese, Sausage Pinch, Jalapeño, Red Sauce on top, Finished with Mike's Hot Honey Drizzle$15.00Angry Bear 10x14
Wisconsin Brick Cheese, Sausage Pinch, Jalapeño, Red Sauce on top, Finished with Mike's Hot Honey Drizzle$24.00B.A. BBQ 8x10
Choice of Italian Beef, Sliced Chicken, or Smoked Pulled Pork Wisconsin Brick Cheese, Onion, Green Pepper, Finished with BBQ Drizzle$16.00B.A. BBQ 10x14
Choice of Italian Beef, Sliced Chicken, or Smoked Pulled Pork Wisconsin Brick Cheese, Onion, Green Pepper, Finished with BBQ Drizzle$25.00Brickhouse B.L.T. 8x10
Wisconsin Brick Cheese, Bacon, Roma Tomato, Finished with Romaine Lettuce & Mayo$16.00Brickhouse B.L.T. 10x14
Wisconsin Brick Cheese, Bacon, Roma Tomato, Finished with Romaine Lettuce & Mayo$25.00Detroit O.G. 8x10
Wisconsin Brick Cheese, Pepperoni Cup & Char, Sausage Pinch, Red Sauce on top, Finished with Shaved Parm, Ricotta, Mike's Hot Honey Drizzle$16.00Detroit O.G. 10x14
Wisconsin Brick Cheese, Pepperoni Cup & Char, Sausage Pinch, Red Sauce on top, Finished with Shaved Parm, Ricotta, Mike's Hot Honey Drizzle$25.00Harvest Time 8x10
Wisconsin Brick Cheese, Onion, Green Pepper, Fresh Mushroom, Roma Tomato, Red Sauce on top$16.00Harvest Time 10x14
Wisconsin Brick Cheese, Onion, Green Pepper, Fresh Mushroom, Roma Tomato, Red Sauce on top$25.00Maxxed Out 8x10
Wisconsin Brick Cheese, Sausage Ground, Pepperoni Classic, Onion, Green Pepper, Fresh Mushroom, Red Sauce on top$16.00Maxxed Out 10x14
Wisconsin Brick Cheese, Sausage Ground, Pepperoni Classic, Onion, Green Pepper, Fresh Mushroom, Red Sauce on top$25.00Over & Under 8x10
Only Recommended for Pepperoni Lovers! Wisconsin Brick Cheese, Double Pepperoni Classic, Double Pepperoni Cup & Char, Red Sauce on top$16.00Over & Under 10x14
Only Recommended for Pepperoni Lovers! Wisconsin Brick Cheese, Double Pepperoni Classic, Double Pepperoni Cup & Char, Red Sauce on top$25.00
Hand Tossed Style
Build Your Own 12"
Red Sauce Base, Signature Cheese Blend - Mozzarella, Provolone, Münster Topped & finished any way you’d like!$14.00Build Your Own 16"
Red Sauce Base, Signature Cheese Blend - Mozzarella, Provolone, Münster Topped & finished any way you’d like!$18.00Cheese Pizza 12″
Red Sauce Base, Signature Cheese Blend - Mozzarella, Provolone, Münster$14.00Cheese Pizza 16″
Red Sauce Base, Signature Cheese Blend - Mozzarella, Provolone, Münster$18.00B.A. BBQ 12″
Choice of Italian Beef, Sliced Chicken, or Smoked Pulled Pork BBQ Sauce Base, Signature Cheese Blend, Onion, Green Pepper$17.00B.A. BBQ 16″
Choice of Italian Beef, Sliced Chicken, or Smoked Pulled Pork BBQ Sauce Base, Signature Cheese Blend, Onion, Green Pepper$25.00B.L.T. 12″
Signature Cheese Blend, Bacon, Roma Tomato, Finished with Romaine Lettuce & Mayo$16.00B.L.T. 16″
Signature Cheese Blend, Bacon, Roma Tomato, Finished with Romaine Lettuce & Mayo$24.00Cheesy Does It 12″
Red Sauce Base, Mozzarella, Provolone, Münster, Fresh Mozzarella, Parm, Romano, Finished with Shaved Parm, Ricotta$15.00Cheesy Does It 16″
Red Sauce Base, Mozzarella, Provolone, Münster, Fresh Mozzarella, Parm, Romano, Finished with Shaved Parm, Ricotta$22.00Chicago Combo 12″
Red Sauce Base, Italian Beef, Sausage Pinch, Hot Giardiniera, Signature Cheese Blend$17.00Chicago Combo 16″
Red Sauce Base, Italian Beef, Sausage Pinch, Hot Giardiniera, Signature Cheese Blend$25.00Chicken Bacon Ranch 12"
Ranch Base, Signature Cheese Blend, Sliced Chicken, Bacon$16.00Chicken Bacon Ranch 16"
Ranch Base, Signature Cheese Blend, Sliced Chicken, Bacon$24.00Chicken Benelli 12"
Basil Pesto Base, Ricotta, Signature Cheese Blend, Sliced Chicken, Artichoke Hearts, Fresh Mushroom$17.00Chicken Benelli 16"
Basil Pesto Base, Ricotta, Signature Cheese Blend, Sliced Chicken, Artichoke Hearts, Fresh Mushroom$24.00Fontanella Hunt Club 12″
Extra Virgin Olive Oil Base, Signature Cheese Blend, Hard Salami, Sausage Pinch, Finished with Baby Arugula, Balsamic Glaze Drizzle$16.00Fontanella Hunt Club 16″
Extra Virgin Olive Oil Base, Signature Cheese Blend, Hard Salami, Sausage Pinch, Finished with Baby Arugula, Balsamic Glaze Drizzle$24.00Maui Magic 12″
Red Sauce Base, Signature Cheese Blend, Ham, Green Pepper, Pineapple Add Jalapeño, or Hot Giardiniera to make it erupt!$16.00Maui Magic 16″
Red Sauce Base, Signature Cheese Blend, Ham, Green Pepper, Pineapple Add Jalapeño, or Hot Giardiniera to make it erupt!$24.00Maxxed Out 12″
Red Sauce Base, Sausage Ground, Pepperoni Classic, Onion, Green Pepper, Fresh Mushroom, Signature Cheese Blend$16.00Maxxed Out 16″
Red Sauce Base, Sausage Ground, Pepperoni Classic, Onion, Green Pepper, Fresh Mushroom, Signature Cheese Blend$24.00Meat Me @ Benelli's 12″
Red Sauce Base, Sausage Ground, Pepperoni Classic, Bacon, Ham, Signature Cheese Blend$16.00Meat Me @ Benelli's 16″
Red Sauce Base, Sausage Ground, Pepperoni Classic, Bacon, Ham, Signature Cheese Blend$24.00Mr Fun Guy 12″
Garlic Butter Base, Signature Cheese Blend, Button Mushrooms, Baby Bella Mushrooms, Cremini Mushrooms, Special Herbs$16.00Mr Fun Guy 16″
Garlic Butter Base, Signature Cheese Blend, Button Mushrooms, Baby Bella Mushrooms, Cremini Mushrooms, Special Herbs$24.00Roasted Rita 12″
Basil Pesto Base, Signature Cheese Blend, Fire Roasted Tomato, Fresh Mozzarella$16.00Roasted Rita 16″
Basil Pesto Base, Signature Cheese Blend, Fire Roasted Tomato, Fresh Mozzarella$24.00Sampson 12″
Tavern Horseradish Cheddar Base, Italian Beef, Onion, Green Pepper, Fresh Mushroom, Signature Cheese Blend$17.00Sampson 16″
Tavern Horseradish Cheddar Base, Italian Beef, Onion, Green Pepper, Fresh Mushroom, Signature Cheese Blend$25.00
Oven Baked Sandwiches
B.A. BBQ Sandwich
Choice of Italian Beef, Sliced Chicken, or Smoked Pulled Pork BBQ Sauce, Onion, Green Pepper, Signature Cheese Blend$11.00Chicago Combo Sandwich
Red Sauce, Italian Beef, Sausage Pinch, Hot Giardiniera, Signature Cheese Blend$11.00Chicken Benelli Sandwich
Basil Pesto, Ricotta, Sliced Chicken, Artichoke Hearts, Fresh Mushroom, Signature Cheese Blend$11.00Ham & Cheese Sandwich
Red Sauce, Ham, Signature Cheese Blend$9.00Harvest Time Sandwich
Red Sauce, Onion, Green Pepper, Fresh Mushroom Roma Tomato, Signature Cheese Blend$9.00Italian Beef & Cheese Sandwich
1/4 Pound Italian Beef, Signature Cheese Blend Double the beef for $2 extra!$10.00Sampson Sandwich
Tavern Horseradish Cheddar, Italian Beef, Onion, Green Pepper, Fresh Mushroom, Signature Cheese Blend$11.00Stromboli Sandwich
Red Sauce, Ground Sausage, Onion, Green Pepper, Signature Cheese Blend$10.00
Beverage
Italian Lemonade 32oz
32oz Italian Lemonade$4.00Saratoga Sparkling Spring Water 28oz
28oz Saratoga Sparkling Spring Water Blue Glass Bottle$4.00Coke 20oz
20oz Coke Bottle$3.00Diet Coke 20oz
20oz Diet Coke Bottle$3.00Sprite 20oz
20oz Sprite Bottle$3.00San Pellegrino 16.9oz
16.9oz San Pellegrino Bottle$3.00
Cookies
Double Chocolate Chunk Cookie
Made with Butter, Semi-Sweet and Milk Chocolate Chunks, Chocolate Cookie Batter$1.506 Pack Double Chocolate Chunk Cookies
Made with Butter, Semi-Sweet and Milk Chocolate Chunks, Chocolate Cookie Batter$6.00Dozen Double Chocolate Chunk Cookies
Made with Butter, Semi-Sweet and Milk Chocolate Chunks, Chocolate Cookie Batter$10.00Lemon White Chocolate Cookie
Made with Lemon, Butter, Creamy Chunks of White Chocolate$1.506 Pack Lemon White Chocolate Cookies
Made with Lemon, Butter, Creamy Chunks of White Chocolate$6.00Dozen Lemon White Chocolate Cookies
Made with Lemon, Butter, Creamy Chunks of White Chocolate$10.00Oatmeal Raisin Walnut Cookie
Made with Hearty Oats, Plump Raisins, Tender Walnuts$1.506 Pack Oatmeal Raisin Walnut Cookies
Made with Hearty Oats, Plump Raisins, Tender Walnuts$6.00Dozen Oatmeal Raisin Walnut Cookies
Made with Hearty Oats, Plump Raisins, Tender Walnuts$10.00Peanut Butter Cup Cookie
Made with Creamy Peanut Butter, Mini Peanut Butter Cups, Honey-Roasted Peanuts, Bits of Dark Chocolate$1.506 Pack Peanut Butter Cup Cookies
Made with Creamy Peanut Butter, Mini Peanut Butter Cups, Honey-Roasted Peanuts, Bits of Dark Chocolate$6.00Dozen Peanut Butter Cup Cookies
Made with Creamy Peanut Butter, Mini Peanut Butter Cups, Honey-Roasted Peanuts, Bits of Dark Chocolate$10.00
All hours
| Sunday | 4:00 pm - 8:00 pm |
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | 4:00 pm - 9:00 pm |
| Wednesday | 4:00 pm - 9:00 pm |
| Thursday | 4:00 pm - 9:00 pm |
| Friday | 4:00 pm - 10:00 pm |
| Saturday | 4:00 pm - 10:00 pm |
Restaurant info
Pizzeria
Location
15 Roosevelt Rd, Valparaiso, IN 46383
Similar restaurants in your area
© 2026 Toast, Inc.
Made with 
in Boston
in Boston
