Billy's Bakery Chelsea
No reviews yet
184 9th Ave
New York City, NY 10011
Orders through Toast are commission free and go directly to this restaurant
Popular Items
- Bourbon Pecan Pie$41.00
A southern classic—a rich, sweet custard chock full of fresh pecans...with a kick of bourbon! Don't worry, the bourbon is baked-in, so you won't get drunk. 9" / Approx 6 servings
- B&W Sandwich$4.25
Chocolate Chip Cookie Sandwich w/Black & White (Van & Choco Buttercream) Filling
- Banana Nutella Cupcake$4.25
Reminiscent of banana bread but richer and sweeter; made with fresh bananas and buttermilk and iced with Nutella cream cheese frosting. Contains NUTS.
Cupcakes, Bars & Cookies
Cupcakes
- Mini Cupcakes : Billy's Best$25.00
Billy's Best - 4 Banana mini cupcakes + 4 Carrot mini cupcakes + 4 Red Velvet mini cupcakes, ALL frosted with cream cheese
- Mini Cupcakes : Confetti$25.00
Mini version of our confetti cupcake: classic yellow butter cake flavored with confetti sprinkles baked-in. Frosted with Vanilla buttercream.
- Mini Cupcakes : Pumpkin$31.00Out of stock
- Mini Cupcakes : Traditional$25.00
Assorted Traditionals - 6 Yellow Daisy mini cupcakes + 6 Chocolate mini cupcakes frosted with Vanilla & Chocolate buttercream. Tree nut-free.
- (12) Assorted Cupcakes, Nuts OK$51.00
An assortment of our most-popular cupcakes flavors which may contain nuts. Nut varieties may include Banana Nutella, Carrot, Chocolate Peanut Butter & German Chocolate. Gluten-friendly / Vegan and Specialty varieties are NOT included in the assortment. NOTE that this assortment is packaged all-together, so cross-contamination is probable.
- (12) Assorted Cupcakes, NO Nuts$51.00
An assortment of our most-popular cupcakes flavors containing NO nuts. Nut-free assortment may include Banana, Chocolate, Confetti, Cookies & Buttercream, Crowd Pleaser, Lemon, Red Velvet & Vanilla. Gluten-friendly / Vegan and Specialty varieties are NOT included in this assortment.
- Banana Cupcake$4.25
Reminiscent of banana bread but richer and sweeter; made with fresh bananas and buttermilk and iced with cream cheese frosting.
- Banana Nutella Cupcake$4.25
Reminiscent of banana bread but richer and sweeter; made with fresh bananas and buttermilk and iced with Nutella cream cheese frosting. Contains NUTS.
- Carrot Cupcake$4.25
Cinnamon batter with carrots, coconut, pineapple, and pecans; topped with cream cheese frosting. Contains NUTS.
- Choco/Choco Cupcake$4.25
For the chocolate lover: a deep, moist chocolate cake made with rich, dark cocoa. Frosted with Chocolate Buttercream
- Chocolate w/PB Cupcake$4.25
Chocolate cupcake, frosted and filled with peanut butter buttercream; garnished with peanut crumbles. Contains NUTS.
- Choco/Van Cupcake$4.25
For the chocolate lover: a deep, moist chocolate cake made with rich, dark cocoa. Frosted with Vanilla Buttercream
- Confetti Cupcake$4.25
Classic yellow butter cake flavored with confetti sprinkles baked-in. Frosted with Vanilla buttercream.
- Cookies & Buttercream Cupcake$4.25
Our version of a cookies & cream cupcake: chocolate cake, frosted with chocolate cookie vanilla buttercream. Garnished with cookie crumbles.
- Crowd Pleaser Cupcake$4.25
Classic chocolate and vanilla batters folded into one cupcake. Frosted in vanilla and chocolate buttercream frosting. Garnished with assorted chocolate pearls.
- Cupcake of the Month$4.75
Cupcake varies by month; call for specifics!
- German Chocolate$4.25
A rich classic chocolate cupcake topped with coconut pecan topping. Contains NUTS.
- Gluten-Free VEGAN Chocolate Chip Cupcake$5.25
Our popular Gluten-Friendly Chocolate Chip cupcake is made with NO eggs, NO milk, and NO butter. To top that, we use gluten-free flour, so it's Vegan & Gluten-free! Contains refined sugar. ALLERGENS: almond milk, and soy lecithin. Frosted with choice of Vanilla or Chocolate (Vegan) Buttercream.
- Holiday Cupcake$4.75Out of stock
Assorted Vanilla and Chocolate Cupcakes with assorted sprinkles, confetti and sugar decorations.
- Lemon Cupcake$4.25
Deliciously light lemon cupcakes iced with cream cheese frosting.
- Pumpkin Cupcake$4.75
Fall Seasonal Cupcake PUMPKIN Cinnamon spiced cake filled with chopped pecans and topped with cream cheese icing.
- Red Velvet Cupcake$4.25
A southern classic…a mild cocoa flavor with a bright red color.
- Van/Choco Cupcake$4.25
Classic yellow butter cake flavored with pure vanilla extract. Frosted with Chocolate Buttercream.
- Van/Van Cupcake$4.25
Classic yellow butter cake flavored with pure vanilla extract. Frosted with Vanilla Buttercream.
Cupcake Cups
- Cupcake Cup, Nuts OK$4.75
Our famous cupcake flavors put into a convenient cup. Selected from assortment of daily flavors which may include Banana Nutella, Carrot, Chocolate Peanut Butter & German Chocolate.
- Cupcake Cup, NO Nuts$4.75
Our famous cupcake flavors put into a convenient cup. Selected from assortment of daily flavors which do NOT contain nuts. Varieties include Banana, Chocolate, Confetti, Cookies & Buttercream, Crowd Pleaser, Lemon, Red Velvet & Vanilla.
Cookies
- Confetti Buttercream Cookie$3.25
Our classic chewy sugar cookie with confetti quins baked-in. Frosted with a thick layer of buttercream frosting (assorted pastel colors).
- B&W Sandwich$4.25
Chocolate Chip Cookie Sandwich w/Black & White (Van & Choco Buttercream) Filling
- Butterscotch Sandwich$4.25Out of stock
Butterscotch Gingerbread Cookie Sandwich w/Semi-Sweet Chocolate Buttercream
- Chocolate Sandwich$4.25
Chocolate Chip Cookie sandwich w/ Chocolate Buttercream
- Confetti Sandwich$4.25
Our classic icing sandwiched between two drop-style confetti cookies, rolled in confetti quins.
- Oatmeal Raisin Sandwich$4.25Out of stock
Oatmeal Raisin Cookie Sandwich w//Cream Cheese Frosting
- Peanut Butter Sandwich$4.25
Peanut Butter Cookie Sandwich w/Chocolate Buttercream. Contains NUTS.
- Snickerdoodle Sandwich$4.25
Snickerdoodle Cookie Sandwich w/Cream Cheese Frosting
- Sprinkle Sandwich$4.25
Chocolate Chip Cookie Sandwich w/Vanilla Buttercream rolled in Rainbow Sprinkles
- Vanilla Sandwich$4.25
Chocolate Chip Cookie sandwich w/ Vanilla Buttercream
- White Choco Sandwich$4.25Out of stock
White Chocolate Chip Cookie Sandwich w/Espresso Buttercream
- Butterscotch Gingerbread Cookie$1.50Out of stock
A new take on an old favorite…classic gingerbread cookies filled with sweet butterscotch chips.
- Chocolate Chip Cookie$1.50
Classic brown sugar cookie dough filled with semisweet chocolate chips.
- Confetti Cookie$1.50
Our classic chewy sugar cookie with confetti quins baked-in.
- Oatmeal Raisin Cookie$1.50Out of stock
Rich and chewy cookies loaded with old fashioned oats and golden raisins.
- Peanut Butter Cookie$1.50
Sweet and salty peanut butter dough filled with creamy peanut butter chips. Contains NUTS.
- Snickerdoodle Cookie$1.50
A family tradition…chewy sugar cookie dusted with cinnamon sugar.
- White Chocolate Chip Cookie$1.50Out of stock
Dark cocoa flavored cookies filled with creamy white chocolate chips.
- Deco Sugar Cookie, Wrapped$3.95Out of stock
Our scrumptious sugar cookies are the perfect treat for any special occasion. Hand-cut into festive shapes and frosted with royal icing. Shapes and designs may vary from photo. Available individually wrapped in a cello bag with a Billy's Bakery label.
Bars
- Fudge Brownie$4.25
Rich and fudgy deep chocolate brownies.
- Hello Dolly Bar$4.25
Made with graham crackers, chocolate chips, butterscotch chips, coconut, and chopped pecans. Contains NUTS.
- Peanut Butter Chocolate Bar$4.95
Chocolate cookie crust with creamy peanut butter filling, topped with rich chocolate ganache. Contains NUTS.
- Seasonal Bar$4.95
Fall Seasonal Pumpkin Bar Cinnamon spiced cake filled with chopped pecans and topped with cream cheese icing.
Breakfast
- Cinnamon Bun$4.25Out of stock
In partnership with Balthazar Bakery, various changing sweet buns to go with morning coffee or tea
- Pecan Sticky Bun$4.25Out of stock
In partnership with Balthazar Bakery, various changing sweet buns to go with morning coffee or tea
- Monkey Bread Bun$4.25Out of stock
In partnership with Balthazar Bakery, various changing sweet buns to go with morning coffee or tea
- Almond Croissant$4.25Out of stock
In partnership with Balthazar Bakery, all butter, hand-laminated, lofty; either classic and ready for jam, or filled and topped with almond frangipane, or with chocolate batons tucked inside.
- Butter Croissant$4.25Out of stock
In partnership with Balthazar Bakery, all butter, hand-laminated, lofty; either classic and ready for jam, or filled and topped with almond frangipane, or with chocolate batons tucked inside.
- Chocolate Croissant$4.25Out of stock
In partnership with Balthazar Bakery, all butter, hand-laminated, lofty; either classic and ready for jam, or filled and topped with almond frangipane, or with chocolate batons tucked inside.
- Chili-Cheese Palmier$4.25
For those who prefer something salty in the morning.
- Cheddar-Scallion Scone$4.25
Light and flaky cheddar, scallion scone.
Extras!
- Birthday Candle (Box of 24)$3.75
Add a box of (24) candles to your order. Colors and designs may vary. Cupcakes not included.
- Birthday Card$6.00
For longer notes and deeper thoughts, add a full-size greeting card to your order. Colors and designs vary. Handmade by our very own baker, Alvaro Melo.
- Vintage Note Card$1.00
Add a mini vintage note card to your order. Colors and designs vary.
- Birthday Pick$0.50
"Happy Birthday" cupcake pick. Plastic. Color and styles may vary.
- Cupcake Box (Individual)$1.50
Individual cupcake boxes are perfectly-sized to fit our full-size cupcakes (all flavors fit just fine).
- Logo Cake Server$5.00
Plastic cake server imprinted with Billy's Bakery logo (jadeite green).
- Logo Frosting Spatula$1.00Out of stock
Plastic frosting spatula imprinted with Billy's Bakery logo (jadeite green).
- Number Candles$3.75
Individual number candles 0-9. Colors and styles vary. Please specify number below.
- Wares: 12 utensils OR plates$3.00
12 enviro-friendly disposable plates OR utensils. Perfect for eating on go! Please note which item you are looking for!
Cakes & Slices
Cake Slice
- Banana Cake Slice$7.00
Individual slice of our Banana Cake.
- Carrot Cake Slice$7.00
Individual slice of our Carrot Cake. Contains NUTS.
- Chocolate Cake Slice$7.00
Individual slice of our Chocolate Cake. May be frosted in either Vanilla or Chocolate Buttercream.
- Cookies & Buttercream Cake Slice$7.00Out of stock
Our version of a cookies & cream cake made with layers of chocolate cake, frosted with chocolate cookie vanilla buttercream and garnished with cookie crumbles.
- Crowd Pleaser Cake Slice$7.00
Individual slice of our Crowd Pleaser Cake. May be frosted in either Vanilla or Chocolate Buttercream.
- German Chocolate Cake Slice$7.00
Slice of our classic chocolate cake with coconut pecan topping. Rich and indulgent; enjoy with a glass of milk. Contains NUTS.
8" Cake (serves 8-12)
- 8" Banana Cake$80.00
Classic Delicious! Reminiscent of banana bread but richer and sweeter; made with fresh bananas and buttermilk and iced with cream cheese frosting. Inscription available; just make a note of text and color below!
- 8" Bourbon Salted Caramel Cake$80.00Out of stock
Chocolate cake layered between bourbon salted caramel and semi-sweet chocolate frosting; drizzled with bourbon caramel and sprinkled with sea salt. Don't worry, you won't get tipsy. Inscription available; just make a note of text and color below! ... Please NOTE that delivery is facilitated by DoorDash bicycle couriers. We assume ***NO RESPONSIBILITY*** for mishandling of your items once they leave the bakery. Our guarantee is that your item(s) will taste great! If you need a guarantee that they will LOOK great, you should arrange to transport the items yourself.
- 8" Carrot Cake$80.00
Cinnamon batter with carrots, coconut, pineapple and pecans; topped with cream cheese frosting and chopped pecans. Contains NUTS. Inscription available; just make a note of text and color below!
- 8" Chocolate Cake w/Choco Buttercream$80.00
For the chocolate lover: a deep, moist chocolate cake made with rich, dark cocoa. Frosted with chocolate buttercream icing. Inscription available; just make a note of text and color below!
- 8" Chocolate Cake w/Van Buttercream$80.00
For the chocolate lover: a deep, moist chocolate cake made with rich, dark cocoa. Frosted with vanilla buttercream icing. Frosting colors vary in pastel shades. Inscription available; just make a note of text and color below!
- 8" Confetti Cake w/Vanilla Buttercream$80.00
Classic yellow butter cake with confetti sprinkles baked-in. Frosted with vanilla buttercream. Garnished with multi-colored, sugar confetti. Inscription available; just make a note of text and color below!
- 8" Cookies & Buttercream Cake$80.00Out of stock
Our version of a cookies & cream cake made with layers of chocolate cake, frosted with chocolate cookie vanilla buttercream and garnished with cookie crumbles. Inscription available; just make a note of text and color below!
- 8" Crowd Pleaser Cake w/Choco Buttercream$80.00
Alternating layers of chocolate and vanilla cake filled with alternating layers of chocolate and vanilla frosting. Frosted with chocolate buttercream. Garnished with assorted chocolate pearls. Inscription available; just make a note of text and color below!
- 8" Crowd Pleaser Cake w/Van Buttercream$80.00
Alternating layers of chocolate and vanilla cake filled with alternating layers of chocolate and vanilla frosting. Frosted with vanilla buttercream. Garnished with assorted chocolate pearls. Inscription available; just make a note of text and color below!
- 8" Espresso Cake$80.00Out of stock
Chocolate cake sealed with Kahlua simple syrup and espresso chocolate frosting, garnished with chocolate-covered espresso beans. Inscription available; just make a note of text and color below!
- 8" German Chocolate Cake$80.00
Classic chocolate cake with coconut pecan topping. Rich and indulgent; enjoy with a glass of milk. Contains NUTS.
- 8" Red Velvet Cake$80.00Out of stock
A southern classic…a mild cocoa flavor with a bright red color, finished with cream cheese frosting. Inscription available; just make a note of text and color below!
Icebox Cake
Puddings & Pies
3" Cheesecake
- 3" Blueberry$7.95
Our classic cheesecake topped with plump, juicy blueberries.
- 3" Caramel Pecan$7.95Out of stock
Smooth vanilla cheesecake topped with rich caramel and chopped pecans.
- 3" Cherry$7.95
Our classic cheesecake topped with sweet, juicy cherries.
- 3" Plain$7.95
Smooth and creamy, flavored with pure vanilla extract and baked with a graham cracker crust.
- 3" Pumpkin$7.95
Cinnamon, ginger and clove spiced pumpkin cheesecake batter on a ginger-graham crust.
9" Pies
- Apple Crumb Pie$41.00
Fresh apples flavored with cinnamon and sugar, baked in a flaky crust with an oatmeal crumb topping. 9" / Approx 6 servings
- Banana Cream Pie$39.00
Fresh banana slices layered with vanilla pudding and topped with whipped cream. 9" / Approx 6 servings
- Bourbon Pecan Pie$41.00
A southern classic—a rich, sweet custard chock full of fresh pecans...with a kick of bourbon! Don't worry, the bourbon is baked-in, so you won't get drunk. 9" / Approx 6 servings
- PB Chocolate Pie$39.00Out of stock
Fluffy peanut butter filling in a graham cracker crust, topped with chocolate syrup and peanut butter cups. Contains NUTS. 9" / Approx 6 servings
- Pumpkin Pie$41.00
Classically American; flavored with sugar and spice and baked in a buttery crust. 9" / Approx 6 servings
- Turtle Cheesecake Pie$41.00Out of stock
Fluffy no-bake cheesecake poured over a thick layer of caramel on crust of crushed chocolate wafers. Garnished with pecans, caramel and hot fudge sauce. 9" / Approx 6 servings ..... Our Turtle Cheesecake Pie has a shelf-life of 7 days refrigerated.
Pie Slices
- Apple Crumb Pie Slice$6.95
- Banana Cream Pie Slice$6.95
Fresh banana slices layered with vanilla pudding and topped with whipped cream.
- Bourbon Pecan Pie Slice$6.95
- PB Chocolate Pie Slice$6.95
Fluffy peanut butter filling in a graham cracker crust, topped with chocolate syrup and peanut butter cups. Contains NUTS.
- Pumpkin Pie Slice$6.95
Delivery
Delivery (8A-5P)
Merchandise
Retail
- FreshCut Paper®$12.00
FreshCut Paper's Forever Flowers - always in bloom. Send some colorful and whimsical pop up flower bouquet greeting cards that bring joy to everyone! Selection varies by season.
- Logo Enamel Pin$10.00
Billy's Bakery 1.25" Logo pin in hard enamel (jadeite green enamel with gold metal). Great for gifting and/or swapping.
- Logo Mug$12.00
Ceramic diner-style mug complete with the Billy’s logo. Great for coffee, hot chocolate and more, our mugs are perfect for Billy’s fans of all ages!
- Logo T-Shirt$25.00
100% combed and ring-spun cotton tee, made in the USA by Bella + Canvas. Printed locally by Works in Progress. Design and colors may vary. 2020 Design: black tee w/green logo imprint
- Retro Tote Bag$25.00
Celebrate Homemade with our newly launched, retro-inspired tote!
- Logo Gift Tin$10.00
Send a sweet surprise inside our Billy’s Bakery gift tin.
- Vintage Notecard$1.00
Add a mini vintage note card to your order. Colors and designs vary.
Sunday | 9:00 am - 9:00 pm |
Monday | 9:00 am - 9:00 pm |
Tuesday | 9:00 am - 9:00 pm |
Wednesday | 9:00 am - 9:00 pm |
Thursday | 9:00 am - 10:00 pm |
Friday | 9:00 am - 10:00 pm |
Saturday | 9:00 am - 10:00 pm |
Each day, we bake everything from scratch using the finest ingredients. From apple pie to Red Velvet cupcakes, our treats are meant to bring you back to a time when a bite of something sweet could make the world a little brighter. Stop by our stores in Chelsea, Tribeca, and inside The Plaza Food Hall and let our smiling staff help you choose from our selection of delicious goodies. Or let us deliver a cake or a dozen cupcakes to your next birthday party or office meeting. Whatever the occasion, Billy’s is here to make life a little sweeter.

