Skip to Main content

  • Blue Highway Pizza TIOGA

    • Home
    • /
    • Newberry
    • /
    • Blue Highway Pizza - TIOGA
    Restaurant banner image
    Pizza

    Blue Highway Pizza - TIOGA

    13005 SW 1st Road

    Newberry, FL 32669

    Orders through Toast are commission free and go directly to this restaurant

    Call

    Hours

    Directions

    Gift Cards

    Food
    Drinks
    Grab and Go

    Featured Items

    • Blue Highway

      Fresh garden greens, feta, grape tomatoes, red onions, Kalamata olives, and toasted pecans
      $9.50+

    • Cheese Pizza

      $14.50

    • Blue Highway Wings

      Our crispy wings are tossed in buffalo, BBQ or Burt's Dragonfire (little sweet, little spicy) sauce served with house-made Gorgonzola or ranch, carrots and celery sticks

    Food

    Features

    • Bacon Spinach Salad

      Arugula, watermelon, feta, Kalamata olives, cucumber, sherry mint vinaigrette
      $10.00+

    • Arancini Di Roso

      $15.00

    • Pizza di Cucina

      $14.25+

    • Nana's Mac and Cheese

      OUT OF STOCK
      $23.00

    Small Plates

    A little something to start your meal off

    • Soup Of The Day: Creamy Tomato with basil

      $8.00

    • Bomba Shrimp

      Crispy fried shrimp tossed in a sweet & spicy Calabrian sauce. Served over a bed of arugula
      $15.00

    • Herbed Tuscan Fries

      Parmesan and herbed seasoned crispy fries, served with house-made peppadew tomato jam, lemon aioli
      $8.50

    • Fried Calamari

      Crispy, fried, U.S.-caught calamari, marinara sauce
      OUT OF STOCK
      $16.00

    • Blue Highway Wings

      Our crispy wings are tossed in buffalo, BBQ or Burt's Dragonfire (little sweet, little spicy) sauce served with house-made Gorgonzola or ranch, carrots and celery sticks

    • Highway Parmesan Cheese Bread

      Our fresh from the oven flatbread, rosemary, garlic and Parmesan served with marinara
      $12.75

    • Antipasti Plate

      Assortment of meats, cheeses, olives, roasted vegetables, Tuscan hummus, toasted focaccia
      $17.75

    • Brie & Spinach Flatbread

      Spinach, Brie, bacon, roasted red onion, balsamic glaze, on a crispy flatbread.
      $15.50

    • Tuscan Hummus

      Tuscan white beans pureed with tahini, garlic, lemon and spices, served with our made-to-order flatbread
      $12.25

    • Bruschetta

      Our house-made toasted focaccia, vine-ripe plum tomato, garlic, basil, balsamic, extra virgin olive oil topped with shaved Grana Padano
      $12.75

    • Hummchetta

      Our house-made toasted focaccia, vine-ripe plum tomato, garlic, basil, balsamic, extra virgin olive oil, Tuscan hummus topped with shaved Grana Padano
      $17.75

    Salads

    We use local organic greens when available and in season. Our dressings are all made in house, using extra virgin olive oil, top-quality vinegars, cheese and herbs. Take a bottle of our balsamic vinaigrette or our Gorgonzola dressing home to enjoy.

    • Micanopy

      Fresh garden greens, carrots, grape tomatoes, cucumbers, red onions
      $8.25+

    • Caesar

      Crisp romaine hearts, shaved Grana Padano, house-made croutons, Caesar dressing
      $9.50+

    • Blue Highway

      Fresh garden greens, feta, grape tomatoes, red onions, Kalamata olives, and toasted pecans
      $9.50+

    • Tuscan Bean

      Fresh spinach, cannellini beans, sun-dried tomatoes, roasted red onions, olives, feta, lemon vinaigrette
      $9.50+

    • Mediterranean

      Fresh garden greens, grape tomatoes, artichoke hearts, kalamata olives, red onion, pepperoncini, fresh mozzarella and ham
      $10.00+

    • Tioga Salad

      Fresh garden greens, toasted pecans, gorgonzola crumbles, granny smith apples, sundried cherries, balsamic gorgonzola dressing
      $10.00+

    Sandwiches

    Our sandwiches feature premium meats and cheeses served with house-made chips and pickles on focaccia baked fresh daily

    • Roast Turkey Club

      Roasted turkey breast, bacon, provolone, lettuce, tomato, roasted garlic aioli on fresh house-baked focaccia
      OUT OF STOCK
      $15.50

    • The Highway

      Roast beef, caramelized red onion, Vermont white cheddar cheese and tangy horseradish sauce on fresh house-baked focaccia
      OUT OF STOCK
      $15.50

    • The Gino

      Genoa salami, capicola, provolone, lettuce, tomato, banana peppers and oil and vinegar on a fresh house-baked focaccia
      OUT OF STOCK
      $15.50

    • The Incredible Hot Tuna

      Our classic albacore tuna salad on fresh house-made toasted focaccia, melted provolone cheese, crispy fried onions, tomato and honey dill mayo
      OUT OF STOCK
      $16.50

    • Apple Pecan Chicken Salad Sandwich

      Roasted chicken, apple, pecans, sun-dried cherries and onion with lettuce, tomato and dijonnaise on toasted focaccia
      OUT OF STOCK
      $15.50

    • Chicken Rustico Panini

      Roasted chicken breast, provolone, spinach and sun-dried tomato mayo on fresh house-baked focaccia
      OUT OF STOCK
      $15.50

    • Roasted Veggie Panini

      Roast garlic aioli, eggplant, squash, zucchini, roasted red pepper, caramelized red onion, fresh mozzarella on focaccia
      OUT OF STOCK
      $15.50

    • Meatball Sandwich

      Meatballs, marinara, mozzarella on fresh house-baked focaccia
      OUT OF STOCK
      $16.50

    • Anthony Bourdain's Mortadella Sandwich

      Pan fried Mortadella, provolone, Dijonaise and toasted focaccia.
      OUT OF STOCK
      $15.00

    Piadines

    This tasty Italian treasure is one of our signature dishes. Many know it as an Italian flatbread sandwich from the Romagna region in Italy. Pronounced "Pee-uh-deen-ay". These flatbreads straight from the oven are topped with cool salads and protein. Find your own way to eat them, but we suggest folding the flatbread in half and eating it like a sandwich!

    • Turkey Piadine

      Roasted turkey breast, pesto aioli, mixed greens, red onion, feta, Parmesan, red wine vinaigrette
      $16.50

    • Lamb Piadine

      Roasted lamb, mint pesto aioli, mixed greens, red onion, feta, Parmesan, red wine vinaigrette
      $18.75

    • Tuscan Bean Piadine

      Tuscan hummus, spinach, Parmesan, Tuscan bean salad, feta, lemon vinaigrette
      $16.50

    • Parma Piadine

      Prosciutto, arugula, extra virgin olive oil, balsamic glaze, fresh mozzarella, Parmesan, bruschetta tomatoes
      $18.75

    Hand Tossed (12 inch)

    Our Hand Tossed pizzas are 12" crispy and hand-crafted the old fashioned Neapolitan way (8 slices, serves 1-2)

    • Create Your Own Hand Tossed

      Start with our hand-tossed dough, 100% whole milk mozzarella, and one of our house-made sauces, then get creative. (We recommend no more than 3-4 toppings to ensure proper cooking)
      $14.50

    • Cheese Pizza

      $14.50

    • Margherita Pizza

      House made pizza sauce, Parmesan, Romano, fresh mozzarella, fresh basil
      $16.00

    • Abruzzese Pizza

      House-made pizza sauce, mozzarella, house-made meatballs, sliced roasted garlic, parsley, Parmesan, Romano
      $18.75

    • Carne Pizza

      House-made pizza sauce, mozzarella, pepperoni, sweet fennel sausage, Genoa salami, Parmesan, Romano
      $18.75

    • Funghi Pizza

      Portabello, shiitake, fancy white and oyster mushrooms, Parmesan, Romano, fontina, white wine cream sauce, parsley
      $18.75

    • Bianca Pizza

      Ricotta, fontina, Parmesan, Romano, mozzarella, vine ripe plum tomato, sliced roasted garlic
      $16.50

    • BBQ Chicken Or Tempeh Pizza

      Sweet BBQ sauce, house-made pizza sauce, chicken breast or tempeh, red onion, mozzarella, smoked Gouda, cilantro
      $18.75

    • Buffalo Chicken Or Tempeh Pizza

      Buffalo sauce base, chicken breast or tempeh, mozzarella, Gorgonzola. (Celery upon request!)
      $18.75

    • Vedure Arrosto Pizza

      House made pizza sauce, mozzarella, eggplant, zucchini, yellow squash, roasted red onion and roasted red peppers
      $18.75

    • Lombardo Pizza

      Fresh mozzarella, Parmesan, Romano, prosciutto, arugula, extra virgin olive oil, Grana Padano
      $18.75

    • Greek Pizza

      House made pizza sauce, mozzarella, spinach, green peppers, red onion, feta, Kalamata olives
      $18.75

    • Scampi Pizza

      Garlic butter, mozzarella, Parmesan, Romano, fontina, shrimp, roasted shallots, parsley
      $19.25

    • Maui Pizza

      Pizza sauce, mozzarella, chicken, bacon, pineapple, jalapeno, buffalo sauce
      $18.75

    Sicilian

    Sicilian pizzas are thick crust, pan pizzas and require a longer cooking time. (12 slices, serves 3-4)

    • Create Your Own Sicilian

      Start with our hand-tossed dough, 100% whole milk mozzarella, and one of our house-made sauces, then get creative. (We recommend no more than 3-4 toppings to ensure proper cooking)
      $18.00

    • Cheese Sicilian

      $18.00

    • Carne Combo Sicilian

      House-made pizza sauce, mozzarella, pepperoni, sweet fennel sausage, Genoa salami, Parmesan, Romano
      $26.50

    • Abruzzese Sicilian

      House made pizza sauce, mozzarella, house-made meatballs, sliced roasted garlic, parsley, Parmesan, Romano
      $26.50

    • BBQ Chicken Or Tempeh Sicilian

      Sweet BBQ sauce, house-made pizza sauce, chicken breast or tempeh, red onion, mozzarella, smoked Gouda, cilantro
      $26.50

    • Buffalo Chicken Or Tempeh Sicilian

      Buffalo sauce base, chicken breast or tempeh, mozzarella, Gorgonzola. (Celery upon request!)
      $26.50

    • Funghi Sicilian

      Portabello, shiitake, fancy white and oyster mushrooms, Parmesan, Romano, fontina, white wine cream sauce, parsley
      $26.50

    • Bianca Sicilian

      Ricotta, fontina, Parmesan, Romano, mozzarella, vine ripe plum tomato, sliced roasted garlic
      $24.25

    • Vedure Arrosto Sicilian

      House made pizza sauce, mozzarella, eggplant, zucchini, yellow squash, roasted red onion and roasted red peppers
      $26.50

    • Greek Sicilian

      House made pizza sauce, mozzarella, spinach, green peppers, red onion, feta, Kalamata olives
      $26.50

    Pizzettas (8 inch)

    • Create Your Own Pizzetta

      Personal 8-inch hand-tossed pizza.
      $10.50

    • Carne Pizzetta

      $13.75

    • Abruzzese Pizzetta

      $13.75

    • BBQ Chicken Or Tempeh Pizzetta

      $13.75

    • Buffalo Chicken Or Tempeh Pizzetta

      $13.75

    • Funghi Pizzetta

      $13.75

    • Margherita Pizzetta

      $12.75

    • Bianca Pizzetta

      $13.25

    • Scampi Pizzetta

      $15.50

    • Vedure Arrosto Pizzetta

      $13.75

    • Greek Pizzetta

      $13.75

    • Rustica Pizzetta

      pizza sauce, parmesan, romano, fresh mozzarella, roasted eggplant, garlic, kalamata olives, capers
      $13.75

    • Maui Zetta

      $13.75

    • Lombardo Zetta

      $16.00

    Cauliflower Crust (Contains Cheese & Egg)

    Our Cauliflower crust is crispy and contains dairy. 10" feeds 1-2

    • Create Your Own Cauliflower

      Start with our hand-tossed dough, 100% whole milk mozzarella, and one of our house-made sauces, then get creative. (We recommend no more than 3-4 toppings to ensure proper cooking)
      $18.00

    • Cheese Pizza Cauliflower

      $18.00

    • Margherita Pizza Cauliflower

      House made pizza sauce, Parmesan, Romano, fresh mozzarella, fresh basil
      $19.50

    • Abruzzese Pizza Cauliflower

      House-made pizza sauce, mozzarella, house-made meatballs, sliced roasted garlic, parsley, Parmesan, Romano
      $22.25

    • Carne Combo Cauliflower

      House-made pizza sauce, mozzarella, pepperoni, sweet fennel sausage, Genoa salami, Parmesan, Romano
      $22.25

    • Funghi Pizza Cauliflower

      Portabello, shiitake, fancy white and oyster mushrooms, Parmesan, Romano, fontina, white wine cream sauce, parsley
      $22.25

    • Bianca Pizza Cauliflower

      Ricotta, fontina, Parmesan, Romano, mozzarella, vine ripe plum tomato, sliced roasted garlic
      $20.00

    • BBQ Chicken Or Tempeh Pizza Cauliflower

      Sweet BBQ sauce, house-made pizza sauce, chicken breast or tempeh, red onion, mozzarella, smoked Gouda, cilantro
      $22.25

    • Buffalo Chicken Or Tempeh Pizza Cauliflower

      Buffalo sauce base, chicken breast or tempeh, mozzarella, Gorgonzola. (Celery upon request!)
      $22.25

    • Vedure Arrosto Pizza Cauliflower

      House made pizza sauce, mozzarella, eggplant, zucchini, yellow squash, roasted red onion and roasted red peppers
      $22.25

    • Greek Pizza Cauliflower

      House made pizza sauce, mozzarella, spinach, green peppers, red onion, feta, Kalamata olives
      $22.25

    • Scampi Pizza Cauliflower

      Garlic butter, mozzarella, Parmesan, Romano, fontina, shrimp, roasted shallots, parsley
      $22.75

    • Lombardo Cauliflower

      Fresh mozzarella, Parmesan, Romano, prosciutto, arugula, extra virgin olive oil, Grana Padano
      $22.50

    Gluten Free

    Our thin crust pizza are 12" crispy and hand-crafted the old fashioned Neapolitan way. (8 slices, serves 1-2)

    • Create Your Own Gluten Free

      Start with Udi's Gluten Free dough, 100% whole milk mozzarella, and one of our house-made sauces, then get creative. (We recommend no more than 3-4 toppings to ensure proper cooking)
      $18.00

    • Cheese Pizza GF

      $18.00

    • Margherita GF

      House made pizza sauce, Parmesan, Romano, fresh mozzarella, fresh basil
      $19.50

    • Abruzzese GF

      House-made pizza sauce, mozzarella, house-made meatballs, sliced roasted garlic, parsley, Parmesan, Romano
      $22.25

    • Carne GF

      House-made pizza sauce, mozzarella, pepperoni, sweet fennel sausage, Genoa salami, Parmesan, Romano
      $22.25

    • Funghi GF

      Portabello, shiitake, fancy white and oyster mushrooms, Parmesan, Romano, fontina, white wine cream sauce, parsley
      $22.25

    • Bianca GF

      Ricotta, fontina, Parmesan, Romano, mozzarella, vine ripe plum tomato, sliced roasted garlic
      $20.00

    • BBQ Chicken Or Tempeh GF

      Sweet BBQ sauce, house-made pizza sauce, chicken breast or tempeh, red onion, mozzarella, smoked Gouda, cilantro
      $22.25

    • Buffalo Chicken Or Tempeh GF

      Buffalo sauce base, chicken breast or tempeh, mozzarella, Gorgonzola. (Celery upon request!)
      $22.25

    • Vedure Arrosto GF

      House made pizza sauce, mozzarella, eggplant, zucchini, yellow squash, roasted red onion and roasted red peppers
      $22.25

    • Lombardo GF

      Fresh mozzarella, Parmesan, Romano, prosciutto, arugula, extra virgin olive oil, Grana Padano
      $22.25

    • Greek GF

      House made pizza sauce, mozzarella, spinach, green peppers, red onion, feta, Kalamata olives
      $22.25

    • Scampi GF

      Garlic butter, mozzarella, Parmesan, Romano, fontina, shrimp, roasted shallots, parsley
      $22.75

    Calzones

    Start with our hand-tossed dough, 100% whole milk mozzarella, then get creative. (We recommend no more than 3-4 toppings to ensure proper cooking)

    • Create Your Own Calzone

      Comes with shredded mozzarella and a side of house-made marinara
      $13.50

    Pastas

    • Pappardelle Bolognese

      Pappardelle is a wide, flat pasta tossed with our house-made slowed cooked Bolognese meat sauce made with ground beef, ground pork, tomato sauce and cream, garnished with Parmesan and Romano served with garlic bread
      $23.00

    • Mama Josephine Spaghetti

      Tomato sauce, house-made meatballs served with garlic bread
      $20.00

    • Spaghetti Carbonara

      Spaghetti, bacon, onion, cream, Parmesan, Romano
      $22.00

    • Penne Ala Pesto

      Penne pasta with chicken breast, sun-dried tomatoes tossed in a pesto white wine cream sauce garnished with Grana Padano and pine nuts, served with garlic bread
      $22.00

    • Fettuccine Alfredo

      House-made Alfredo sauce
      $16.50

    • *Vegetarian Bolognese

      Brown rice, rolled oats, bulgur wheat, soy protein, mushrooms, onion, garlic, cheddar and mozzarella cheese. ***NOT VEGAN**** ***HAS DAIRY***
      OUT OF STOCK
      $23.00

    • Chicken Parmesan *Thursdays only*

      Crispy fried chicken breast topped with our house-made marinara, mozzarella, served with fettuccine *Only available on Thursdays
      OUT OF STOCK
      $23.00

    • Eggplant Parmesan*Thursdays only*

      Crispy fried eggplant layered with fresh herbs, ricotta, our house-made marinara and mozzarella, served with fettuccine Only available on Thursdays
      OUT OF STOCK
      $23.00

    Desserts

    Fresh house-made desserts

    • Cannoli

      Crispy pastry shell filled with our house-made sweetened ricotta and chocolate chips
      $4.75

    • Key Lime Tart

      House-made Key lime tart in a buttery graham cracker crust, whipped cream
      OUT OF STOCK
      $8.00

    • *Key Lime Pie Ice Cream

      OUT OF STOCK
      $9.00

    Kids

    Created for children 10 and under, our Bambini menu features fresh, handcrafted dishes even the pickiest eaters will love.

    • Bambini Pizza

      Choice of one topping
      $7.00

    • Chicken Nuggets

      Three gluten free, antibiotic & hormone free chicken tenders served with our house chips or broccoli
      $6.00

    • House-Made Mac-N-Cheese

      This entree is a source of calcium and Vitamin D
      $6.00

    • Spaghetti & Meatball

      House made marinara with a meatball and garlic bread
      $7.00

    • Kids Pasta

      spaghetti with butter & garlic bread
      $5.00

    • Grilled Cheese

      Parmesan, Romano, mozzarella, garlic butter on focaccia
      $5.00

    • Veggie Dippers

      Cool carrot, celery sticks and broccoli with ranch dressing
      $5.00

    • Broccoli & Chicken Pasta

      Penne, Chicken, Broccoli, butter
      $7.00

    Sides

    • Spirit Night!

    • 3 Meatballs

      Three house made meatballs served with marinara, Parmesan Romano
      $8.00

    • 4 Piece Focaccia

      $1.50

    • Ari's Hot Honey

      $1.50

    • Mayo

    • Aiolis

      $0.75

    • Broccoli

      $3.00

    • Bruschetta.

      $5.00

    • Carrots

      $0.75

    • Celery

      $0.75

    • Chicken Salad

      $4.00+

    • Chips

      $1.50

    • Pickles

      $0.75

    • Garlic Bread

      $1.00

    • Hummus

      $5.00

    • Hummus Bread

      $5.00

    • Sauce

    • Pecans

      $1.50

    • Roast Veggies

      $4.50

    • Sauteed Chicken*

      $6.00

    • Shrimp*

      $4.00+

    • Hummus Veggies

      $1.25

    • Side Dressings

      $0.75

    • Tuna Salad

      $4.00+

    • Tuscan Bean Mix

      $4.00+

    • Gluten Free Crust

      $4.00

    • Cauliflower Crust Shell

      $4.00

    • Soup Sample

    Drinks

    Vintage Sodas

    • Aranciata *blood orange*

      $3.00

    • Abita Root Beer

      $3.50

    • IBC Diet RB

      $3.50

    • Maine Root Ginger Brew

      Non-alcoholic ginger brew made with cane sugar
      $3.50

    • Caruso's Dark Cream

      $3.50

    • Sprecher's Orange Dream

      $3.50

    • Sour App!e

      $3.50

    • Abita King Cake

      $3.50

    • Romano's White Peach

      $3.50

    • Ale 8 Cherry

      $3.50

    • Boots coconut cream soda

      $3.50

    • Sprecher Peaches n Cream

      $3.50

    Water

    • Still San Benedetto Artesian Water

      $3.50

    • Sparkling San Benedetto Mineral Water

      $3.50

    • Tonic Water

      $2.50

    Mocktails

    • N/A Summer Solstice

      $8.00

    • Shirley Temple

      Ginger Ale, Grenadine, Lime, Cherry
      $5.00

    • Basil Mint Limeade

      Basil Simple Syrup, Mint, Lime, Soda
      $5.00

    • Cranberry Ginger Fizz

      Cranberry, Ginger Beer, Lime
      $5.00

    • Peach Smash

      Peach, lemon, mint, ginger ale
      $5.00

    • N/A Ciao Persephone

      $8.00

    Grab and Go

    • Canned Soda

      $2.00

    • Balsamic Dressing (12 oz)

      16 ounces of Blue Highway's house made balsamic vinaigrette dressing *contains honey*
      $8.00

    • Ranch Dressing (12 oz)

      16 ounces of Blue Highway's house made Ranch dressing
      $8.00

    • Gorgonzola Dressing (12 oz)

      16 ounces of Blue Highway's house made Gorgonzola dressing
      $8.00

    • Balsamic Gorgonzola (12oz)

      $8.00

    • Caesar Dressing (12 oz)

      16 ounces of Blue Highway's house made Caesar dressing *Contains anchovies*
      $10.00

    • Lemon Vinaigrette (12oz)

      $8.00

    • Red Wine Vinaigrette (12oz)

      16 ounces of Blue Highway's house made Red Wine Vinaigrette
      $8.00

    • Pickles (12 oz)

      16 ounces of our famous Blue Highway pickles
      $8.00
    All hours
    Sunday11:00 am - 8:30 pm
    Monday11:00 am - 8:30 pm
    Tuesday11:00 am - 8:30 pm
    Wednesday11:00 am - 8:30 pm
    Thursday11:00 am - 9:00 pm
    Friday11:00 am - 9:00 pm
    Saturday11:00 am - 9:00 pm
    Restaurant info

    Eat well, Live well...

    Location

    13005 SW 1st Road, Newberry, FL 32669

    Directions

    Similar restaurants in your area

    MidiCi Celebration Pointe Gainesville
    View restaurantnext
    Peppino's Pizza & Pasta 3731 W University Ave
    View restaurantnext
    Bowie Pizza 1522 NW 13th Street
    View restaurantnext
    V Pizza - Gainesville
    View restaurantnext
    Blue Highway Pizza MICANOPY
    View restaurantnext
    Betty's Pizza
    View restaurantnext
    Search similar restaurants
    © 2026 Toast, Inc.
    Toast
    • About Toast
    • For restaurants
    • Terms of Service
    • Privacy Statement
    • Do not sell my
      personal information
    Made with love in Boston
    • Instagram
    • X (formerly Twitter)
    • Facebook