Skip to Main content
  • Brotherhood of Thieves Nantucket

    • Home
    • /
    • Nantucket
    • /
    • Brotherhood of Thieves Nantucket

    This restaurant does not have any images

    American

    Brotherhood of Thieves Nantucket

    23 Broad Street

    Nantucket, MA 02554


    Orders through Toast are commission free and go directly to this restaurant


    Call

    Hours

    Directions

    Food Menu
    Sushi Menu

    Featured Items

    • Spicy Rigatoni

      Panko-breaded chicken in a Calabrian chili vodka cream sauce, topped with Pecorino Romano
      $28.00
    • Boom Boom Shrimp

      Crispy fried, sweet sriracha sauce, sesame seeds
      $22.00
    • Curly Fries

      Classic or Parmesan-truffle
      $9.00

    Food Menu

    Soups + Appetizers

    • CUP Chowder

      New England style
      $11.00
    • BOWL Chowder

      New England style
      $13.00
    • Curly Fries

      Classic or Parmesan-truffle
      $9.00
    • Boom Boom Shrimp

      Crispy fried, sweet sriracha sauce, sesame seeds
      $22.00
    • Spicy Tuna Crispy Rice

      Diced raw tuna, sweet soy sauce, wasabi tobiko, crispy rice
      $24.00
    • Crab & Avocado

      Colossal lump crab, crispy wontons, watermelon radish, yuzu vinaigrette
      $24.00
    • Buffalo Chicken Tenders

      Mango-buffalo sauce, pineapple salsa, and blue cheese dressing
      $18.00
    • Thai Chicken Lettuce Wraps

      Poached chicken, carrots, cabbage, cilantro, peanuts, and sesame-ginger vinaigrette
      $18.00
    • Chicken Dumplings

      Pan-fried, lemongrass, ginger soy dipping sauce
      $18.00
    • Cheesesteak Egg Rolls

      American and provolone cheeses, caramelized onions, and Chinese mustard
      $20.00
    • Heirloom Burrata

      Local burrata, heirloom tomatoes, basil, balsamic pearls, grilled focaccia
      $20.00

    Burgers

    • Brotherhood Burger

      Lettuce, tomato, onion, and choice of cheese on griddled sesame brioche bun
      $22.00
    • Reverend Foster Burger

      American cheese, caramelized onions, lettuce, and special sauce on a griddled sesame brioche bun
      $22.00
    • BBQ Burger

      Cheddar, bacon, BBQ sauce, and onion strings on a griddled sesame brioche bun
      $24.00
    • Cisco Burger

      Blue cheese, caramelized onions, bacon, lettuce, and balsamic on a griddled sesame brioche bun
      $24.00
    • Veggie Burger

      House made with quinoa, sweet potato, and black beans, topped with pickled onion, avocado, cilantro crema
      $20.00

    Sandwiches

    • Caprese

      Fresh mozzarella, arugula, pesto aioli, and tomato jam, on toasted ciabatta
      $22.00
    • Fried Chicken

      Buttermilk or Nashville hot, sour pickles, lemon aioli, and seeded brioche
      $22.00
    • Blackened Swordfish

      Pickled veggies, arugula, cilantro, piri-piri sauce, sriracha aioli, and seeded brioche
      $26.00
    • Scallop Roll

      Lightly fried, shredded lettuce, coleslaw, tartar, griddled brioche bun
      $36.00
    • Cold Lobster Roll

      Celery, chive, lemon, and mayo. With fries and coleslaw, on griddled brioche
      $39.00
    • Warm Lobster Roll

      Warmed in brown butter. With fries and coleslaw, on griddled brioche
      $39.00

    Entrées

    • Spicy Rigatoni

      Panko-breaded chicken in a Calabrian chili vodka cream sauce, topped with Pecorino Romano
      $28.00
    • Chicken Souvlaki

      Lemon-herb marinated grilled chicken skewers, cous cous, tzatziki, pickled onions, cucumber-tomato salad
      $28.00
    • Latin Salmon

      Grilled, avocado, salsa verde, glazed sweet potatoes, grilled corn
      $38.00
    • Sole Piccata

      Pan seared, crispy fingerlings, green beans, capers, lemon-wine butter sauce
      $36.00
    • Pan-Seared Scallops

      Giants, roasted corn and white bean succotash, confit tomato, sautéed spinach
      $48.00
    • Lobster Fettuccine

      Lobster meat, spinach, cherry tomatoes, lobster cream sauce, toasted focaccia
      $44.00
    • Fish and Chips

      Beer battered or lightly fried cod, with curly fries and coleslaw
      $32.00
    • Steak Frites

      Grilled Brandt farms NY strip, chimichurri, garlic aioli, and truffle fries.
      $44.00

    Salads

    • Lobster Avocado

      Chilled lobster, grilled corn, arugula, avocado, pickled red onion, tomato, tortilla strips, chipotle lime dressing
      $40.00
    • Salmon Noodle Bowl

      Mango, avocado, cucumber, cabbage, tomato, cilantro, chilled noodles, mint & basil Thai vinaigrette
      $34.00
    • Poke Bowl

      Diced bluefin or salmon, rice, mango, cucumber, cabbage, cilantro, avocado, carrots, and pineapple-ginger dressing.
      $34.00
    • Chicken Caesar

      Regular or buffalo crispy chicken tenders, romaine, Pecorino, and house croutons
      $24.00
    • Greek Salad

      Lemon-marinated grilled chicken skewer, feta, cukes, tomatoes, red onions, Kalamata olives, romaine, red wine vinaigrette
      $26.00
    • Chicken Cobb

      Grilled chicken, romaine, arugula, avocado, corn, tomatoes, egg, bacon, blue cheese, and champagne vinaigrette
      $28.00
    • Caesar

      Classic
      $14.00
    • Fancy Simple House

      Mixed greens with grape tomato, cucumber, pickled onion, creamy sherry vinaigrette
      $14.00

    Kids Menu

    • Kids Cheeseburger

      4 oz ground beef patty with American cheese on griddled sesame brioche bun
      $12.00
    • Kids Grilled Cheese

      Classic grilled cheese on white bread with American
      $12.00
    • Kids Tenders

      Breaded chicken tenders
      $12.00
    • Kids Grill Chicken

      Grilled Chicken on a griddled sesame brioche bun
      $12.00
    • Kids Pasta

      Butter or Red sauce
      $12.00

    Desserts

    • Brohood Chocolate Chip Cookie Sundae

      In a cast iron skillet, with vanilla ice cream, whipped cream, and chocolate sauce
      $15.00
    • Carrot Cake

      Cream cheese frosting, pecans, and caramel sauce
      $12.00
    • Strawberry Shortcake

      House-made biscuit, vanilla ice cream, strawberries, whipped cream
      $14.00
    • Ice Cream Scoop

      Scoop of vanilla ice cream
      $3.00

    Sides

    • Side roasted potato

      $8.00
    • Side sweet potato

      $8.00
    • Side sushi rice

      $8.00
    • Side green beans

      $8.00
    • Side spinach

      $8.00
    • Side slaw

      $7.00
    • Side bread

      $2.00
    • Side avocado

      $2.00
    • Side pickles

      $2.00
    • Side Cold Lobster

      $24.00
    • Side Warm Lobster

      $24.00
    • Side Grill Chicken

      $8.00
    • Side Breaded Chicken

      $12.00
    • Side Salmon

      $16.00
    • Side Shrimp

      $14.00
    • Side Burger

      $12.00
    • Side NY Strip

      $20.00
    • Side Skewer(1)

      $8.00
    • Side Veg Burger

      $10.00

    Sushi Menu

    Appetizers

    • Spicy Tuna Crispy Rice

      Diced raw tuna, sweet soy sauce, wasabi tobiko, crispy rice
      $24.00
    • Tuna Tartare

      Diced bluefin, avocado, micro cilantro, ginger soy, tortilla chips
      $20.00
    • Hamachi Carpaccio

      Thinly slice yellowtail, micro cilantro, and mustard soy sauce
      $18.00
    • Seaweed Salad

      Traditional wakame style
      $10.00

    Essential Rolls

    • Maki Roll

      Tuna, yellowtail or salmon with avocado
      $15.00
    • Spicy Maki Roll

      Tuna, salmon or yellowtail with cucumber
      $15.00
    • Shrimp Tempura Roll

      Avocado, cucumber, and sweet soy
      $15.00
    • California Roll

      Crab, cucumber, and avocado
      $15.00
    • Tuna Crunch Roll

      Tuna, avocado, tempura crunch, and sweet chili sauce
      $15.00
    • BBQ Eel Roll

      Eel, cucumber, avocado, sweet soy
      $15.00

    Nigiri

    • Tuna Nigiri

      $12.00
    • Yellowtail Nigiri

      $12.00
    • Salmon Nigiri

      $12.00
    • Salmon Roe Nigiri

      $12.00
    • Eel Nigiri

      $12.00
    • Seabass Nigiri

      $12.00
    • Toro Nigiri

      $17.00
    • Sea Urchin Nigiri

      $17.00
    • Kobe Beef Nigiri

      $17.00

    Sashimi

    • Tuna Sashimi

      $15.00
    • Yellowtail Sashimi

      $15.00
    • Salmon Sashimi

      $15.00
    • Salmon Roe Sashimi

      $15.00
    • Eel Sashimi

      $15.00
    • Seabass Sashimi

      $15.00
    • Toro Sashimi

      $20.00
    • Sea Urchin Sashmi

      $20.00
    • Kobe Beef Sashimi

      $20.00

    Specialty Rolls

    • Endless Summer Roll

      Tuna, cucumber, avocado, crab stick, topped with tuna, avocado, spicy mayo, and sweet soy
      $24.00
    • Toro Jalapeño Roll

      Spicy tuna and cucumber, topped with torched Toro, jalapeño, tobiko, and mustard soy sauce
      $26.00
    • Everything Roll

      Tuna, salmon, yellowtail, cucumber, avocado, crab stick, tempura crunch, spicy mayo, and tobiko
      $25.00
    • Triple Salmon Roll

      Spicy salmon, crab, cucumber, avocado, topped with seared salmon, salmon roe, and chef's secret sauce
      $25.00
    • Dynamite Roll

      Spicy yellowtail, crab, cucumber and avocado, topped with spicy tuna, sriracha, spicy mayo, sweet soy, and tempura crunch
      $25.00
    • Nantucket Roll

      Spicy scallops, cucumber and tempura crunch, topped with tobiko
      $26.00
    • Rainbow Roll

      Crab, cucumber, avocado, topped with tuna, salmon, and yellowtail
      $24.00
    • Brohood Roll

      Spicy tuna and cucumber, topped with torched yellowtail, salmon, jalapeño, and sriracha
      $24.00
    • Cisco Beach Roll

      Spicy tuna and cucumber, topped with seared yellowtail, spicy mayo, sweet soy, scallions, lime, and tobiko
      $25.00
    • Angry Dragon Roll

      Shrimp tempura, spicy tuna and avocado, wrapped in soy paper, topped with crab stick, sweet soy, and mango sauce
      $25.00
    • Tornado

      Shrimp tempura, cucumber, avocado and crab meat, wrapped in soy paper and potato, deep-fried and topped with sweet soy, spicy mayo, and sweet chili
      $25.00
    • Shaggy Dog

      Shrimp tempura and avocado, topped with crab stick, sweet soy, spicy mayo, and mango sauce
      $25.00
    • Volcano

      Crab, avocado, cucumber, topped with baked spicy scallop, crab stick, unagi sauce, scallion, and tobiko
      $26.00
    • Pipeline

      Shrimp, crab, avocado, cucumber, topped with lobster, spicy mayo, sweet soy, and tobiko
      $30.00
    • Dragon

      Crab, avocado, cucumber, topped with BBQ eel, avocado, and sweet soy
      $24.00
    • Caterpillar

      Crab and cucumber, topped with avocado, sweet soy, and tempura crunch
      $24.00
    • Veggie Futo

      Soy and yuzu vinegar marinated veggies, with cucumber, carrot, and avocado
      $20.00
    • Spicy Lobster

      Lobster, spicy mayo, avocado, cucumber, and tobiko
      $28.00
    • Surf and Turf

      Shrimp tempura, cucumber, avocado, topped with torched A5 kobe beef, sweet soy, sweet chili, and spicy mayo
      $28.00
    • Kobi-Wan

      Grilled A5 kobe beef, marinated Japanese veggies, soy, topped with cucumber, avocado, and sesame oil
      $28.00
    • Samurai

      Crab, shrimp tempura, avocado, cucumber, topped with lobster, spicy mayo, sweet soy, and tobiko
      $28.00

    Bowls

    • Poke Bowl

      Bluefin tuna, rice, onions, radish, cucumber, avocado, carrots, seaweed salad, tobiko, sesame seed, tempura crunch, garlic soy dressing, and spicy aioli
      $34.00
    • Salmon Sashimi Bowl

      Sliced salmon, spicy seaweed salad, rice, fresh wasabi, ginger, cucumber, avocado, salmon roe, and sesame dressing
      $26.00
    • Chirashi

      A sushi salad of tuna, salmon, yellowtail, tobiko, fresh wasabi, greens, and rice
      $28.00

    Platters

    • Nigiri Sampler

      1 piece each, bluefin tuna, salmon, yellowtail, black seabass, a5 kobe beef, toro, and choice of 1 large roll
      $45.00
    • Toro Sampler

      4 pieces nigiri, 4 pieces sashimi, and 1 Toro jalapeño roll
      $60.00
    • Ferry Boat

      Choice of 8 pieces nigiri, 8 pieces sashimi, one essential roll, and one large roll
      $100.00

    All hours
    Sunday11:30 am - 8:30 pm
    Monday11:30 am - 8:30 pm
    Tuesday11:30 am - 8:30 pm
    Wednesday11:30 am - 8:30 pm
    Thursday11:30 am - 8:30 pm
    FridayClosed
    SaturdayClosed
    Restaurant info

    Come in and enjoy!

    Location

    23 Broad Street, Nantucket, MA 02554

    Directions


    Similar restaurants in your area

    Nantucket Tap Room
    View restaurantnext
    Faraway Nantucket Cymbals Cafe
    View restaurantnext
    CRU Oyster Bar
    View restaurantnext
    The Charlie Noble
    View restaurantnext
    Easy Street Restaurant 31 Easy Street
    View restaurantnext
    Nantucket Club Car
    View restaurantnext
    Search similar restaurants
    © 2026 Toast, Inc.
    Toast
    • About Toast
    • For restaurants
    • Terms of Service
    • Privacy Statement
    • Do not sell my
      personal information
    Made with love in Boston
    • Instagram
    • X (formerly Twitter)
    • Facebook