American
Brothers Bagels Neptune Ave
532 Neptune avenue
Brooklyn, NY 11235
Orders through Toast are commission free and go directly to this restaurant
Pickup Only
Food
Bagels
Breakfast Sandwiches
Grilled Cheese
$5.502 Eggs on Bagel
$5.502 Eggs Cheese on Bagel
$6.002 Eggs Ham, Bacon Or Sausage & Cheese on bagel
$7.50Egg Whites Veg Wrap
$8.50Dieters Delight
$8.50Bacon & Egg
$7.00Pastrami Egg Cheese
$8.00Steak Egg & Cheese
$8.00Mrs. Bagel
$8.99Mr. Bagel
$8.99B.L.T
$6.50B.L.OR T
$6.00Bacon/sausage bagel
$5.50Bacon or sausage & cheese bagel
$5.99avocado/smash
$6.99SAUSAGE &EGGS
$7.00Pastrami classic
$9.25Manana Picante
$9.99
Griddle Specials
Muffins & Pastries
Healthy Start
Yogurt & Granola
Egg Omelettes
CC Spreads
Buttered Bagel
$3.00Buttered Bagel
$2.50Buttered Bagel & Jelly
$3.75Cream Cheese
$3.65Cream Cheese
$2.75Cream Cheese Jelly
$4.40Lowfat CC
$3.25Lowfat CC
$2.75Tofu CC
$3.95Tofu CC
$2.75Scallion CC
$4.50Scallion CC 1/4
$3.00Vegetable CC
$4.50Vegetable CC
$3.00Bacon CC
$4.50Bacon CC
$3.00Bacon Scallion CC
$4.50Bacon Scallion CC
$3.00Olive Pimento CC
$4.50Olive Pimento CC
$3.00Lowfat Scallion CC
$4.50Lowfat Scallion CC
$3.00Lowfat Veg CC
$4.50Lowfat Veg CC
$3.00Walnut Raisin CC
$4.50Walnut Raisin CC
$3.00Tofu Scallon CC
$4.50Tofu Scallon CC
$3.00Low Fat Sun-Dried Tom CC
$4.50Low Fat Sun-Dried Tom CC
$3.00Lox Scallion Radish
$4.95Lox Scallion Radish
$3.25Lox Spread
$4.95Lox Spread
$3.25Maple Walnut
$4.50Maple Walnut
$3.25Apple Cinnamon
$4.50Apple Cinnamon
$3.00Strawberry
$4.50Strawberry
$3.00Blueberry
$4.00Blueberry
$3.00Jalapeno Cheddar
$4.50Jalapeno Cheddar
$3.00Nutella CC
$4.50Nutella CC
$3.00PB
$3.95Nutella
$3.95PB & J
$4.50Oreo CC
$4.50Oreo CC
$3.25jelly
$3.00MINI BUTTER
$2.25MINI CC
$3.00MINI FLAVOR
$3.50MINI LOX SPREAD
$3.75
BB Nova Spot
Salad Spread
Cheese
Yellow American Sand
$4.50Yellow American (lbs)
$9.99Swiss Sand
$4.50Swiss (lbs)
$10.99Muenster Sand
$4.50Muenster (lbs)
$10.99Provolone Sand
$4.50Provolone (lbs)
$10.99Sharp Cheddar Sand
$4.50Sharp Cheddar (lbs)
$10.99Monterey Jack Sand
$4.50Monterey Jack (lbs)
$10.99Mozzarella (tom & basil)
$7.00Alpine Lace Sand
$4.50Alpine Lace (lbs)
$10.99Fresh Mozzarella (lbs)
$12.99
Premium Wraps
Chix Caesar
$10.95Crispy Chix & Bacon
$10.95Amazon Trails
$10.95Cajun Chix Wrap
$10.95Roasted Turkey & Swiss
$10.95Brothers Bagel Wrap
$10.95Vermont Wrap
$10.95Low Carb Turkey
$10.95Low Carb Tuna
$10.95Vegetarian Delight
$10.95Thai Chix Wrap
$10.95Sante Fe Chix Wrap
$10.95Philly cheesesteak wrap
$10.95Mediterranean wrap
$10.95Turkey club wrap
$10.95Brothers tuna b.l.t wrap
$10.95Chicken salad b.l.t wrap
$10.95
Cold Cuts
Boiled Ham Sand
$8.00Boiled Ham (lbs)
$13.99Virginia Ham Sand
$8.00Virginia Ham (lbs)
$13.99Black Forest Ham Sand
$8.00Black Forest Ham (lbs)
$13.99Roast Turkey Sand
$8.00Roast Turkey (lbs)
$13.99Roast Beef Sand
$9.95Roast Beef (lbs)
$16.99Corned Beef Sand
$9.95Corned Beef (lbs)
$16.99Pastrami Sand
$9.95Pastrami (lbs)
$16.99Genoa Salami Sand
$8.00Genoa Salami (lbs)
$13.99Liverwurst Sand
$7.00Liverwurst (lbs)
$9.99Pepperoni Sand
$7.00Pepperoni (lbs)
$9.99Prosciutto Sand
$8.95Prosciutto (lbs)
$16.99Bologna Sand
$7.00Bologna (lbs)
$9.99
Burger Corner
Hot Stuff
Panini
Soups
Hot Special Heroes
Chix Fantastic
$13.95The Godfather
$13.95The Texas Melt
$13.95The Ultimate B.L.T
$13.95The Ruben
$13.95The Turkey Explosion
$13.95Grilled Chix Supreme
$13.95Pastrami Supreme
$13.95Turkey Melt
$13.95Philly Cheese Steak
$13.95Roast Beef Supreme
$13.95The Monte Cristo
$13.95The Philly Chix Steak
$13.95The Peter Lugers Steak
$13.95The Chix Ranch
$13.95The Downtown
$13.95Living in Sin
$13.95Meatball Parm
$13.95Chix Cutlet Parm
$13.95Chicken Cutlet Hero
$11.00Chicken Cutlet Roll
$8.00Specialty sandwiches roll
$11.95Chopped cheese hero
$12.95
Breakfast Burritos
Pizza
Rolls
$9.00Stromboli
$9.00Pinwheel
$5.50Calzone
$12.00Garlic knots
$3.00Pizza
$3.50Pepperoni slice
$4.00Sicilian
$5.002 topping pizza
$5.00Supreme
$6.00Fancy square
$5.50Chicken slice
$5.00Caesar slice
$7.00Sicilian/ topping
$5.50Grandma
$5.00Pie
$22.00Sm pie
$15.00Pepperoni pie
$27.00Margherita pie
$27.00Margherita slice
$4.50White slice
$4.50Sofia slice
$5.00Vegetable slice
$5.00Chicken pie
$30.00Grandma pie
$25.00Mushroom slice
$4.00Beef patty
$3.50Beef patty/ cheese
$4.50Beef patty/cheese/pep
$5.00Tristanos cutlet
$9.95Slider
$2.50
Drinks
Hot Coffee
Frozen Coffee
Iced Coffee
$3.00+Iced Tea
$3.00+Iced Cappuccino
$5.00+Iced Latte
$5.00+Iced Macchiato
$5.00+Iced Cafe Mocha
$5.00+Iced Chai
$4.50+Coffee Freezers
$5.00+Mocha Freezers
$5.25+Iced Americano
$4.00+Cold Brew
$4.50+cup of ice
$1.00almond milk
$1.00iced espresso doppio
$3.75Boba chiller
$6.50Refreshers
$6.50Milk Tea
$6.50
Fruit Smoothies
BOTTLE BEVERAGES
All Beverages
BOTTLE SODA
$2.99CAN SODA
$1.50GATORADE
$2.75HARNEY SONS
$3.99boylan
$3.25MANHATTAN SPECIAL
$4.00NAKED
$4.50NESQUICK
$3.50POLAND SPRING 16oz
$1.25POLAND SPRING SPORTS
$2.45REDBULL 12oz
$4.50REDBULL 8oz
$3.50ESSENTIA WATER 1 LITER
$3.25ESSENTIA WATER 1.5 LITER
$4.25ESSENTIA WATER 20oz
$2.75SNAPPLE
$2.65SPARKLING ICE
$2.45STARBUCKS
$3.65TROPICANA
$3.25TROPICANA 46oz
$5.99TROPICANA 32OZ
$4.50VITAMIN WATER
$3.25YOOHOO
$3.50Martinielli
$4.00Calypso
$3.29Essentia sports
$3.25Electrolit
$3.75Poppi
$3.00Coco water
$4.00
Salad Bar
Salad
Beets
$0.75Carrots
$0.75Cherry tomatoes
$0.75Chickpeas
$0.75Cucumber
$0.75Mix beans
$0.75Mushrooms
$0.75Red onions
$0.75Artichoke hearts
$0.75Hard boiled eggs
$1.50Black olives
$0.75Mandarin oranges
$0.75Sundried tomatoes
$0.75Sunflower seeds
$0.75Roasted red peppers
$0.75Roasted corn
$0.75Turkey
$2.25Bacon
$2.50Grilled portobello
$2.50Grilled chicken
$2.00Fried chicken
$2.00Shrimp
$2.75Avocado
$2.50Cheddar cheese
$1.00Crumbled blue cheese
$1.00Feta
$1.00Parmesan
$1.00Salad
$9.95
If you use a credit card, Brothers Bagels Neptune Ave will charge an additional 3.00% ($0.00) to help offset processing costs. This amount is not more than what Brothers Bagels Neptune Ave pays in fees.
All hours
| Sunday | 10:30 am - 12:00 am |
| Monday | 11:00 am - 12:00 am |
| Tuesday | 11:00 am - 12:00 am |
| Wednesday | 11:00 am - 12:00 am |
| Thursday | 11:00 am - 12:00 am |
| Friday | 11:00 am - 12:00 am |
| Saturday | 10:30 am - 12:00 am |
Restaurant info
Come in and enjoy!
Location
532 Neptune avenue, Brooklyn, NY 11235
© 2026 Toast, Inc.
Made with 
in Boston
in Boston
