Skip to Main content
  • Brother's Pizza - Newville 25 South High Street

    • Home
    • /
    • Newville
    • /
    • Brother's Pizza - Newville 25 South High Street
    Restaurant banner image
    Pizza

    Brother's Pizza - Newville 25 South High Street

    25 South High Street

    Newville, PA 17241


    Orders through Toast are commission free and go directly to this restaurant


    Call

    Hours

    Directions

    Specials
    Menu
    Pizza
    ‌
    ‌

    Featured Items

    • 16" Large Plain Cheese

      $13.50
    • Cheeseburger Sub Sub

      Lettuce, tomatoes, onions & mayonnaise
      $9.50
    • Italian Sub

      $9.50

    Specials

    Special

    • Large Cheese Pizza, 10 Wings, 2 Liter of Soda

      Choice of sauce
      $23.99
    • 2 Medium Pizzas

      One topping each
      $22.99
    • 2 Large Cheese Pizzas Only

      $23.99
    • 2 Large 1 Topping Pizzas, 2 Liter of Soda

      $30.99

    Menu

    Mexican Specialties

    • Original Taco

      A crunchy corn tortilla shell filled with seasoned ground beef, lettuce, tomatoes, Monterey & cheddar
      $2.65
    • Soft Taco

      The same delicious ingredients as the original taco but in a warm flour tortilla
      $2.65
    • Bean Burrito

      A soft flour tortilla wrapped around refried beans, Monterey, cheddar & green onions
      $3.99
    • Bean Beef Burrito

      A soft flour tortilla wrapped around refried beans, seasoned ground beef, Monterey, cheddar & green onions
      $4.49
    • Special Burrito

      Grilled chicken or steak, salsa, green onions, lettuce, Monterey & cheddar all rolled in a soft warm flour tortilla
      $4.49
    • Gerardo's Special

      A pita bread with refried beans, salsa, seasoned ground beef, Monterey & cheddar, oven baked, topped with tomatoes, green- onions & sour cream
      $7.75
    • Taco Salad

      You can even eat the bowl! A mix of crispy lettuce, tomatoes, seasoned ground beef or grilled chicken, green onions, cheddar & Monterey, topped with sour cream, jalapeño peppers & salsa
      $9.75
    • Special Fajita

      Sautéed onions & green peppers, accompanied by 3 warm flour tortillas, Monterey, cheddar, sour cream, lettuce & taco sauce
      $12.50
    • Nachos Grande

      A mound of tortilla chips sprinkled with beans and your choice of ground beef or grilled chicken topped with melted Monterey & cheddar, tomatoes, green onions, jalapeño peppers, salsa & sour cream
      $9.99
    • Mexican Pizza

      Melted Monterey & cheddar on a crisp tortilla shell, covered with salsa, topped with tomatoes, onions & jalapeño peppers
      $8.15
    • Quesadilla

      A flour tortilla folded over melted Monterey & cheddar, tomatoes, scallions & jalapeño peppers, served with sour cream & salsa
      $7.75
    • Nachos Fajita

      Grilled chicken or steak, green peppers, onion, cheese, sour cream & salsa
      $12.75

    Wraps

    • Tuna Salad Wrap

      Lettuce, tomatoes & hard boiled egg
      $9.50
    • Chicken Caesar Wrap

      Grilled chicken with crisp romaine lettuce, Roma tomatoes & creamy Caesar sauce
      $9.50
    • Buffalo Chicken Wrap

      Buffalo sauce, lettuce, tomato, ranch, or bleu cheese
      $9.50
    • Turkey Wrap

      Turkey breast thin sliced, bacon, lettuce, tomatoes & mayo
      $9.50
    • Texas Wrap

      Brother's very own, thinly sliced sirloin, secret recipe BBQ sauce & grilled onions on a pita bread
      $9.50

    Pasta

    • Fettuccine Alfredo

      Delicious alfredo sauce mixed with fettuccine
      $12.25
    • Spaghetti

      $12.25
    • Chicken Parmigiana

      Breaded chicken & parmesan cheese over spaghetti
      $15.25
    • Eggplant Parmigiana

      Breaded eggplant & parmesan cheese over spaghetti
      $15.00
    • Shrimp Fra Diavolo

      Large shrimp mixed with spicy red sauce & penne
      $16.00
    • Fettuccini Primavera

      Steamed broccoli, chicken, tenderloin & alfredo sauce
      $16.00
    • Seafood Pasta

      $18.25
    • Lobster Ravioli

      $15.75
    • Spaghetti Italiano

      $14.25
    • Grilled Chicken Pasta

      $14.99
    • Lagsana

      $15.49

    Pasta Al Forno (Baked)

    • Manicotti (3)

      Ricotta filled manicotti shells baked with red sauce & mozzarella
      $12.25
    • Beef Ravioli (6)

      Italian seasoned beef raviolis baked with red sauce & mozzarella
      $12.25
    • Stuffed Shells (3)

      Shells filled with ricotta & then baked with red sauce & mozzarella
      $12.25

    Hot Subs

    • Cheese Steak Plain Sub

      $9.50
    • Cheese Steak Special Sub

      With mushrooms, onions, roasted green peppers & sauce
      $9.75
    • Cheese Steak Works Sub

      Lettuce, tomatoes, onions & mayonnaise
      $9.75
    • Chicken Cheese Steak Hoagie Sub

      Lettuce, tomatoes, onions & mayonnaise
      $9.75
    • Cheese Steak Bomb Sub

      Fried onions, roasted green peppers, mushrooms, pepperoni, ham & mayonnaise
      $10.25
    • Pizza Burger Sub

      Topped with pizza sauce & melted mozzarella
      $9.75
    • Cheeseburger Sub Sub

      Lettuce, tomatoes, onions & mayonnaise
      $9.50
    • Pizza Steak Sub

      Topped with pizza sauce & melted mozzarella
      $9.50
    • Meatball Parmesan Sub

      $9.50
    • Sausage Parmesan Sub

      With green peppers & onions
      $9.50
    • Eggplant Parmesan Sub

      Served with ricotta, in addition to mozzarella
      $9.50
    • Chicken Parmesan Sub

      All the above are made with red sauce & melted mozzarella, baked to perfection
      $9.50
    • Bufalo chicken Sub

      $10.25
    • Chicken bacon ranch sub

      $10.25

    Cold Subs

    • Italian Sub

      $9.50
    • Ham Sub

      $9.50
    • Salami Sub

      $9.50
    • Capicolla Sub

      $9.50
    • Provolone Sub

      $9.50
    • Turkey Sub

      $9.50
    • Tuna Sub

      $9.50
    • Leave It to Us Sub

      Ham, salami & capicola toasted in the oven
      $10.00
    • B L T

      $9.75
    • Veggie Sub

      $9.75

    Appetizers

    • Mozzarella Sticks

      Served with red sauce
      $7.00
    • Chicken Nuggets (9 Pieces)

      Served with BBQ sauce or sweet & sour sauce
      $5.99
    • Breaded Mushrooms (16)

      Served with ranch dressing
      $6.99
    • Cheese Fries

      Bacon, green onions, Monterey cheddar & sour cream
      $6.99
    • Chicken Tenders (4 Pieces)

      Served with BBQ sauce or honey mustard sauce
      $6.85
    • Garlic Bread

      Served with melted mozzarella & red sauce
      $4.25
    • French Fries

      $3.49
    • Onion Rings (9)

      $4.25
    • Sampler

      (2) mozzarella stix, (4) onion rings, (4) breaded mushrooms, (2) chicken tenders
      $10.35
    • Breaded Zucchini Sticks

      Served with ranch dressing
      $4.99
    • Buffalo Chicken Tenders

      5 chicken tenders covered in hot sauce with celery & blue cheese or ranch
      $8.85
    • Jalapeño Poppers

      $7.30
    • Fried Pickles

      $7.99
    • new app

      $10.00
    • Chips in the Bag (lays)

      $2.49
    • Corn Nuggets

      $4.50
    • Homade Chips

      $2.99
    • Nacho Cheese

      $1.99
    • Pizza Fries

      $7.15
    • Shrimp Basket

      $9.99
    • Garlic Nuts

      $6.49
    • 4 Chicken Tenders & French Fries

      $10.25
    • 8 Mac and cheese bites

      $7.50

    Wings

    • 10 Wings Wings (Traditional)

      Served with celery & blue cheese or ranch. Plain, mild, hot, nuclear, BBQ, honey BBQ, roasted garlic & mango habanero
      $12.25
    • 20 Wings Wings (Traditional)

      Served with celery & blue cheese or ranch. Plain, mild, hot, nuclear, BBQ, honey BBQ, roasted garlic & mango habanero
      $23.50
    • 30 Wings Wings (Traditional)

      Served with celery & blue cheese or ranch. Plain, mild, hot, nuclear, BBQ, honey BBQ, roasted garlic & mango habanero
      $35.50
    • 10 Wings Wings (Boneless)

      Serve with celery & blue cheese or ranch. Plain, mild, hot, nuclear, BBQ, honey BBQ, roasted garlic & mango habanero
      $11.50
    • 20 Wings Wings (Boneless)

      Serve with celery & blue cheese or ranch. Plain, mild, hot, nuclear, BBQ, honey BBQ, roasted garlic & mango habanero
      $22.50
    • 30 Wings Wings (Boneless)

      Serve with celery & blue cheese or ranch. Plain, mild, hot, nuclear, BBQ, honey BBQ, roasted garlic & mango habanero
      $33.75

    Panini

    • Italian Panini

      Ham, Genoa salami, pepperoni, lettuce, tomatoes, provolone & olive oil
      $10.25
    • Turkey Club Panini

      Turkey, bacon, lettuce, tomatoes & mayo
      $10.25
    • Grilled Chicken Caprese

      Grilled chicken breast, ripe tomatoes, fresh mozzarella cheese and pesto mayonnaise on ciabatta bread
      $10.25
    • Cheeseburger Panini

      Chipotle mayonnaise, tomatoes, onions
      $10.25
    • Sierra Grilled Chicken Panini

      Grilled chicken tenders with chipotle mayonnaise, tomatoes & onions
      $10.25
    • Philly Panini

      Chopped grilled sirloin, sautéed onions & mayo
      $10.25
    • Scrambled Egg Panini

      Scrambled egg, bacon with provolone cheese and tomatoes
      $10.25

    Salads

    • Garden Salad

      Mix of lettuce, cucumbers, tomatoes, croutons & onions
      $6.75
    • Side Salad

      $4.75
    • Tuna Salad

      Mix of lettuce, cucumbers, tomatoes, croutons & onions
      $8.50
    • Antipasto

      Mix of lettuce, cucumbers, tomatoes, onions, and croutons, with ham, salami, provolone & mozzarella
      $9.75
    • Caesar Salad

      Crispy romaine, lettuce, asiago cheese, and croutons
      $7.50
    • Chef Salad

      Mix of lettuce, cucumbers, tomatoes, onions, black olives, hard-boiled egg, croutons, ham & turkey with American cheese
      $9.75
    • Grilled Chicken Salad

      Mix of lettuce, tomatoes, cucumber, red onion, hard-boiled egg, cheddar and Monterey cheese
      $9.75
    • Greek Salad

      Mix of lettuce, tomatoes, feta cheese, onions, pepperoncini, kalamata olives & Greek dressing
      $9.75
    • Black & Blue Salad

      Shrimp, fresh mixed greens, tomato, onion & blue cheese crumbles
      $11.25
    • Philly Steak Salad

      Mix of lettuce, cucumbers, tomatoes, cheese croutons & onions
      $11.25

    Burgers, Gyros & Fish

    • California Burger

      Lettuce, tomatoes, onions & mayonnaise
      $8.49
    • Gyro

      Sliced lamb on pita bread with lettuce, onions, tomatoes and tzatziki sauce
      $7.25
    • Chicken Gyro

      Grilled chicken on pita bread with lettuce, onions, tomatoes and tzatziki sauce
      $7.50
    • Fish Sandwich

      Lettuce, tomatoes, onions with mayonnaise or tartar sauce
      $7.25
    • Chicken Patties Sandwich

      Lettuce, tomatoes, onions & mayonnaise
      $7.25
    • Hawaiian Burger

      Lettuce, onions, tomato, chipotle mayonnaise, cheddar cheese, bacon & pineapple
      $8.25
    • 1/3 Lb Cheeseburger Works

      Burgers only. No fries or onion rings. Lettuce, tomato, onion, mayonnaise
      $6.25
    • 1/3 Lb Special Cheeseburger

      Burgers only. No fries or onion rings. Lettuce, tomato, onion, mayonnaise, ketchup, mustard & pickles
      $7.25
    • Double Cheeseburger

      Burgers only. No fries or onion rings. Lettuce, tomatoes, onions & mayonnaise
      $8.75
    • Mushroom & Swiss Burger

      Burgers only. No fries or onion rings. Sautéed mushrooms & swiss cheese
      $7.75
    • Grilled Chicken Sandwich

      $8.49
    • Lobster Bisque Soup

      $4.99
    • Broccoli & Cheese Soup

      $4.99
    • Italian Wedding Soup

      $4.99
    • Chicken Noodle Soup

      $4.99

    Kid's Menu

    • Kid Sized Pizza

      $7.50
    • kid's Spaghetti & Meatball

      $7.50
    • Chicken Nuggets & Fries

      $7.50
    • Chicken Strips & Fries

      $7.50
    • Grilled Cheese & Chips

      $7.50
    • Slice of Cheese Pizza, Celery Sticks and Ranch

      $4.50

    Soft Drinks

    • Soft Drinks

      $2.70
    • 2 Liter Soda

      $3.75
    • Water

      $1.50
    • Pure Leaf Tea

      $2.95

    Desserts

    • Canoli

      $4.50
    • Fried Cheesecake

      $4.50
    • Cold Cheesecake

      $4.50
    • Cinnamon bites

      $4.50
    • Rolls Churros

      $4.50

    Pizza

    Regular Pizzas

    • 12" Small Plain Cheese

      $11.00
    • 14" Medium Plain Cheese

      $12.25
    • 16" Large Plain Cheese

      $13.50
    • Plain Cheese By the Slice

      $2.75
    • Sicilian: The Thick One

      16" X 16" (12 slices)
      $16.99

    12in Specialty Pizzas

    • 12" Small BBQ Chicken

      Barbecued grilled chicken with onions
      $16.00
    • 12" Small Buffalo Chicken

      $16.00
    • 12" Small Chicken Bacon Ranch

      $16.00
    • 12" Small Hawaiian

      Ham & pineapple
      $13.50
    • 12" Small Meat Lovers

      Pepperoni, sausage, bacon & ham
      $16.75
    • 12" Small Philly Steak

      Onions, banana peppers & Philly steak
      $15.50
    • 12" Small Supreme

      Green peppers, pepperoni, ham, mushrooms, bacon, onions, sausage, hamburger, olives and extra cheese
      $17.25
    • 12" Small Vegetarian

      Roasted green peppers, onions, mushrooms, black olives & tomatoes
      $15.50
    • 12" Small White Veggie

      Tomatoes, broccoli, spinach, garlic, ricotta & mozzarella
      $15.50
    • 12" Taco Pizza

      $15.75

    14in Specialty Pizzas

    • 14" Medium (6 Slices) Brother's Pizzas

      Special 6 toppings
      $17.50
    • 14" Medium BBQ Chicken

      Barbecued grilled chicken with onions
      $17.00
    • 14" Medium Buffalo Chicken

      $17.00
    • 14" Medium Chicken Bacon Ranch

      $17.00
    • 14" Medium Hawaiian

      Ham & pineapple
      $15.75
    • 14" Medium Meat Lovers

      Pepperoni, sausage, bacon & ham
      $17.75
    • 14" Medium Philly Steak

      Onions, banana peppers & Philly steak
      $16.50
    • 14" Medium Supreme

      Green peppers, pepperoni, ham, mushrooms, bacon, onions, sausage, hamburger, olives and extra cheese
      $20.75
    • 14" Medium Vegetarian

      Roasted green peppers, onions, mushrooms, black olives & tomatoes
      $16.75
    • 14" Medium White Veggie

      Tomatoes, broccoli, spinach, garlic, ricotta & mozzarella
      $16.75
    • 14" Taco Pizza

      $16.50

    16in Specialty Pizzas

    • 16" Large (8 Slices) Brother's Pizzas

      Special 6 toppings
      $18.50
    • 16" Large BBQ Chicken

      Barbecued grilled chicken with onions
      $18.00
    • 16" Large Buffalo Chicken

      $18.00
    • 16" Large Chicken Bacon Ranch

      $18.00
    • 16" Large Hawaiian

      Ham & pineapple
      $17.50
    • 16" Large Meat Lovers

      Pepperoni, sausage, bacon & ham
      $18.75
    • 16" Large Philly Steak

      Onions, banana peppers & Philly steak
      $17.50
    • 16" Large Supreme

      Green peppers, pepperoni, ham, mushrooms, bacon, onions, sausage, hamburger, olives and extra cheese
      $21.75
    • 16" Large Vegetarian

      Roasted green peppers, onions, mushrooms, black olives & tomatoes
      $17.50
    • 16" Large White Veggie

      Tomatoes, broccoli, spinach, garlic, ricotta & mozzarella
      $18.00
    • 16" X 16" Sicilian (12 Slices) Brother's Pizzas

      Special 6 toppings
      $22.00
    • 16" Taco Pizza

      $17.50

    Stromboli & Calzones

    • Pepperoni Roll

      Medium. Mozzarella, pepperoni & pizza sauce on the size
      $10.40
    • Medium Italian Calzone

      Ham or sausage, mozzarella, parmesan & ricotta
      $11.40
    • Medium Veggie Calzone

      Broccoli, mushrooms, onions & green peppers
      $11.40
    • Medium Chicken Calzone

      Grilled chicken with onions & mushrooms
      $11.65
    • Medium Meat Lovers Calzone

      Pepperoni, sausage, bacon & ham
      $12.15
    • Medium Italian Stromboli

      Ham, salami, pizza sauce, mozzarella & parmesan
      $10.90
    • Medium Special Italian Stromboli

      Pizza sauce, mozzarella, parmesan, pepperoni, mushrooms, roasted green peppers, onions & sausage
      $12.15
    • Medium Steak Stromboli

      Thinly sliced sirloin, mozzarella & pizza sauce
      $12.15
    • Medium Chicken Stromboli

      Grilled chicken, mozzarella & pizza sauce
      $12.15
    • Medium Meat Lovers Stromboli

      $12.15
    • Medium Stromboli Ham

      $10.90
    • Large Italian Calzone

      Ham or sausage, mozzarella, parmesan & ricotta
      $14.90
    • Large Veggie Calzone

      Broccoli, mushrooms, onions & green peppers
      $14.90
    • Large Chicken Calzone

      Grilled chicken with onions & mushrooms
      $15.40
    • Large Meat Lovers Calzone

      Pepperoni, sausage, bacon & ham
      $15.65
    • Large Italian Stromboli

      Ham, salami, pizza sauce, mozzarella & parmesan
      $14.65
    • Large Special Italian Stromboli

      Pizza sauce, mozzarella, parmesan, pepperoni, mushrooms, roasted green peppers, onions & sausage
      $16.15
    • Large Steak Stromboli

      Thinly sliced sirloin, mozzarella & pizza sauce
      $15.65
    • Large Chicken Stromboli

      Grilled chicken, mozzarella & pizza sauce
      $15.65
    • Large Meat Lover Stromboli

      $15.65

    All hours
    Sunday11:00 am - 9:00 pm
    Monday11:00 am - 9:00 pm
    Tuesday11:00 am - 9:00 pm
    Wednesday11:00 am - 9:00 pm
    Thursday11:00 am - 9:00 pm
    Friday11:00 am - 10:00 pm
    Saturday11:00 am - 9:00 pm
    Restaurant info

    Come in and enjoy!

    Location

    25 South High Street, Newville, PA 17241

    Directions


    Similar restaurants in your area

    Brothers Pizza Shippensburg 18 Shippensburg Shopping center
    View restaurantnext
    Italian Village II Restaurant and Pizza 2 Neil Road
    View restaurantnext
    George's Pizza
    View restaurantnext
    The Italian Taxi
    View restaurantnext
    Italian Village
    View restaurantnext
    Ciao Bella 6418 Chambersburg Rd
    View restaurantnext
    Search similar restaurants
    © 2026 Toast, Inc.
    Toast
    • About Toast
    • For restaurants
    • Terms of Service
    • Privacy Statement
    • Do not sell my
      personal information
    Made with love in Boston
    • Instagram
    • X (formerly Twitter)
    • Facebook