Skip to Main content
  • Caragiulos Italian American Restaurant

    Caragiulos Italian American Restaurant
    • Home
    • /
    • SARASOTA
    • /
    • Caragiulos Italian American Restaurant
    Restaurant banner image

    Caragiulos Italian American Restaurant

    69 S PALM AVENUE

    SARASOTA, FL 34236


    Orders through Toast are commission free and go directly to this restaurant


    phone icon

    Call

    clock icon

    Hours

    waypoint sign icon

    Directions

    APPETIZERS
    SOUPS / SALADS
    DINNER PASTA
    PIZZA
    ENTREES
    SIDES
    DESSERT

    Featured Items

    • 'PIZZA MIA'

      cheese pizza your way with 3 toppings

      $18.95
    • RIGATONI a la VODKA

      crispy pancetta + stracciatella mozzarella + vodka-tomato crema

      $22.95
    • CHICKEN PARMIGIANA DINNER

      pan fried organic chicken breast with + mozzarella + spaghetti a la vodka

      $25.95

    ‌

    APPETIZERS

    • ARTICOKE ALLE BRACE

      chargrilled with pickled fennel salad + preserved lemon aioli

      $15.95
    • POINT JUDITH CALAMARI FRITTI

      calamari + shishito peppers + anchovy aioli + arrabiata

      $17.95
    • MEATBALLS AL FORNO

      whipped ricotta + san Marzano tomato

      $16.95
    • MUSSELS VINO BIANCO

      fennel + confit tomato + lemon + garlic + bruschetta

      $18.95
    • AVOCADO BRUSCHETTA

      heirloom tomatoes + burrata + herb salad + balsamic pearls

      $15.95
    • CHICKEN FEGATINI

      chicken liver pate + fig mostarda + Tuscan toast

      $16.95
    • CRISPY EGGPLANT

      eggplant + goat cheese mousse + truffle honey + rosemary

      $16.95
    • CAPRESE BOARD

      House-made mozzarella + local tomato + basil + red onion + balsamico

      $15.95
    • VEGETARIANO BOARD

      seasonal grilled vegetable + goat cheese + aged balsamic

      $15.95
    • SALUMI e FORMAGGI BOARD

      prosciutto di parma + soppresata + pistachio mortadella + giardiniera + parmigiana + gorgonzola dolce + fresh mozzarella + local honeycomb

      $22.95

    SOUPS / SALADS

    • TUSCAN STEAK SALAD

      tenderloin tips + gorgonzola + portobello + tomato + pickled red onion + lemon vinaigrette

      $18.95
    • CHOPPED 1989

      grilled chicken + chopped lettuces + soppresata + chickpeas + tomato + pepperoncini + olives + bocconcini + creamy-garlic parmesan vinaigrette

      $16.95
    • ROASTED BEET & AVOCADO SALAD

      goat cheese fondue + orange + shallot vinaigrette + local lettuces + toasted pistachios

      $15.95
    • SICILIAN CAESAR SALAD

      romaine + radicchio + fried caper crumbs + dried cherries + peppadew peppers + shaved parmigiana + Caesar dressing

      $14.95
    • HOUSE SALAD

      carrot + tomato + onion + kalamata olive + cucumber + house vinaigrette

      $13.95
    • CLASSIC CAESAR SALAD

      romaine + shaved parmigiana + Caesar dressing

      $13.95
    • SIDE HOUSE SALAD

      carrot + tomato + onion + calamata olive + cucumber + house vinaigrette

      $7.95
    • SIDE CLASSIC CAESAR SALAD

      romaine + shaved parmigiana + Caesar dressing

      $7.95
    • SALAD SPECIAL

      $15.00
      OUT OF STOCK
    • WEDDING SOUP

      spinach stracciatella + pastina + small meatballs

      $8.95
    • ZUPPA di IERI

      yesterday's soup, better today

      $8.95

    DINNER PASTA

    • SPAGHETTI W/ MEATBALLS

      our house-made meatballs

      $19.95
    • SPAGHETTI + SAUSAGE

      $19.95
    • SPAGHETTI + SAUSAGE + MEATBALL

      $19.95
    • PASTA MIA

      pick your pasta: add your favorite sauce

      $14.95
    • RAVIOLI al FRESCO

      spinach + pomodori + ricotta salata

      $19.95
    • LASAGNA al FORNO

      bolognese + béchamel

      $21.95
    • ANGEL HAIR PUTANESCA

      shrimp + san marzano fumet + olive + caper + botarga crumbs

      $27.95
    • RIGATONI a la VODKA

      crispy pancetta + stracciatella mozzarella + vodka-tomato crema

      $22.95
    • SPAGHETTI & CEDAR KEY CLAMS

      white wine-garlic broth + fresh herbs + fresno chili

      $24.95
    • PACCHERI PASOLINI

      roasted chicken + gorgonzola cream + oven-dried tomatoes + large tube pasta

      $22.95
    • PASTA SPEC

      Call in for today's special 941-951-0866

      $25.00

    PIZZA

    • DAVINCI

      fennel sausage + mushroom + pepperoni

      $18.95
    • BIANCA ROSSA

      white pizza with roasted garlic ricotta + arugula

      $18.95
    • PALERMO

      roasted peppers + artichoke + caper + tomato + mozzarella

      $18.95
    • MARGHERITA

      san marzano tomatoes + basil + house-made mozzarella

      $18.95
    • il GRECO

      kalamata olives + baby spinach + feta + tomatoes

      $18.95
    • PEAR & GORGONZOLA

      caramelized onions + white balsamic + spicy honey + arugula

      $18.95
    • CHEESE PIZZA

      with sauce + mozzarella

      $15.95
    • CALZONE

      stuffed with ricotta + any 2 toppings

      $18.95
    • 'PIZZA MIA'

      cheese pizza your way with 3 toppings

      $18.95
    • THE GODFATHER SANDWICH

      toasted Bandit Baquette with salumi misto + porvolone + giardiniera + LTO + garlic aioli + vinaigrette

      $16.95
      OUT OF STOCK

    ENTREES

    • CHICKEN PARMIGIANA DINNER

      pan fried organic chicken breast with + mozzarella + spaghetti a la vodka

      $25.95
    • SCOTTISH SALMON AGRO DOLCE

      spinach + caper butter + risotto cake + caponata

      $29.95
    • PORK CHOP MILANESE

      arugula + lemon + grana padano

      $25.95
    • CHICKEN PICATTA

      oyster mushroom + caper + preserved lemon-butter + English pea risotto

      $25.95
    • FILETTO di MANZO

      black angus beef + porcini ragu + gorgonzola polenta + bone marrow butter

      $44.95
    • CHICKEN MARSALA

      pan roasted organic chicken breast + roasted cippolini + wild mushroom gravy + roasted potatoes

      $25.95
    • CRISPY EGGPLANT

      eggplant + goat cheese mousse + truffle honey + rosemary

      $16.95
    • BURGER SALTIMBOCCA

      Call in for today's special preparation: 941-951-0866

      $19.95

    SIDES

    • SICILIAN CAULIFLOWER

      with currant + caper + spicy crumbs

      $9.95
    • CHARRED BROCCOLINI

      with lemon + EVOO

      $9.95
    • TRUFFLE FRIES

      parmigiano + chives

      $9.95
    • ENGLISH PEA RISOTTO

      $9.95
    • ADDITIONAL SIDE OF FOCACCIA BREAD

      all salads, pastas & entrees come with a side of focaccia bread, add if you would like to order additional extra bread

      $3.50
      OUT OF STOCK
    • SIDE 2 MEATBALLS

      $6.50
    • SIDE 2 SAUSAGE LINKS

      $7.50
    • SIDE ANCHOVIES

      $4.00
    • SIDE MIXED VEGETABLES

      $9.95
    • SIDE PASTA

      $6.95
    • SIDE SAUTEED SPINACH

      $9.95

    DESSERT

    • 3 - CANNOLI

      crispy miniature pastries + sweet ricotta + chocolate chips

      $6.95
    • 6 - CANNOLI

      $10.95
    • ZEPPOLI AFFOGATO

      crispy fritters + hazelnut gelato + espresso cascade

      $10.95
    • SPUMONI SUNDAE

      pistachio + vanilla + amarena cherry gelato + dark rum chocolate brownie + cream

      $10.95
    • CHIARA'S TIRAMISU

      lady fingers + espresso + frangelico + mascarpone + cocoa

      $10.95

    All hours
    Sunday4:30 pm - 9:00 pm
    Monday4:30 pm - 9:00 pm
    Tuesday4:30 pm - 9:00 pm
    Wednesday4:30 pm - 9:00 pm
    Thursday4:30 pm - 9:00 pm
    Friday4:30 pm - 10:00 pm
    Saturday4:30 pm - 10:00 pm
    Restaurant info

    Sarasota's favorite Italian Restaurant Hours: 7 Nights a week. 4-9 pm

    Location

    69 S PALM AVENUE, SARASOTA, FL 34236

    Directions


    Similar restaurants in your area

    Waffle Monkey - Sarasota 52 S Palm Ave
    View restaurantnext
    Green Zebra Cafe
    View restaurantnext
    Element Steak Seafood Pasta
    View restaurantnext
    Duval's Fresh. Local. Seafood.
    View restaurantnext
    Patellini's Pizza
    View restaurantnext
    Buddy Brew Coffee Sarasota
    View restaurantnext
    Search similar restaurants
    © 2025 Toast, Inc.
    Toast
    • About Toast
    • For restaurants
    • Terms of Service
    • Privacy Statement
    • Do not sell my
      personal information
    Made with love in Boston
    • Instagram
    • X (formerly Twitter)
    • Facebook