Carrie Nell's Old Fashioned Desserts

Pecan Sandies are a type of American shortbread-style cookie that has a buttery, rich flavor, a crumbly texture, and is loaded with chopped pecans. They are named for their "sandy" texture, which melts in the mouth. Try it and you will get hooked!

Peanut butter cookies: the ultimate throwback snack that tastes like after‑school freedom and zero responsibilities. Soft in the middle, a little crispy on the edges, and rocking that iconic criss-cross pattern like it’s still 1999. Basically, the edible equivalent of a warm hug and a perfectly curated Spotify playlist.

Snickerdoodles are soft, cinnamon‑sugar clouds that taste like the comfort of a slow morning and the rare moment when your to‑do list isn’t winning. They’re lightly tangy, perfectly tender, and feel like stepping into a memory you didn’t realize you missed.

🍪 Comfort-Core Without the Chores Chocolate chip cookies are warm, golden little pockets of calm—soft in the center, crisp at the edges, and loaded with melty chocolate. They bring that rare moment when everything feels a bit more manageable and the day finally slows down.

Soft, chewy, and loaded with creamy white chocolate and crunchy nuts — these cookies are the cozy bake you didn't know you needed. One bite and they're gone, no notes.

Nothing fancy — just a really good soft sugar cookie that's full of flavor. Customers come back for more, which is the best compliment there is. I genuinely love the craft of keeping things simple while still making cookies that are beautiful and memorable."

Our Peach Cobbler is that homemade comfort food magic - sweet, juicy peaches tucked under flaky pastry that's made from scratch. It's warm, nostalgic, and honestly the kind of dessert people can't stop coming back for. One bite and you'll understand why they always want more.

Blueberry muffins topped with blueberry drizzle, fresh blueberries, and a buttery streusel taste like a bakery dream come true. The drizzle adds a sweet, tangy shine, the berries bring bright flavor, and the streusel gives that perfect crunchy‑crumbly crown. It’s a beautiful balance of tender, juicy, and crisp in every bite.

Cinnamon muffins with a brown sugar filling and topped with a maple sugar glaze taste like cozy comfort wrapped in bakery magic. The warm cinnamon swirls through the soft crumb, the brown sugar center melts into a gooey, caramel‑like pocket, and the maple glaze adds a sweet, glossy finish that feels like a little morning luxury. It’s the kind of treat that makes the whole kitchen smell like a hug.

Pecan pie is pure, golden comfort — a gooey, caramel‑like filling packed with toasted pecans, all sitting in a buttery crust that tastes like home. It’s sweet, warm, and rich in that slow‑down‑and‑savor‑it way, the kind of dessert that feels like a hug from the inside out.

⭐ A Slice of Simple Perfection Whether served warm or chilled, this pie turns any moment into a treat worth savoring. One taste, and you’ll understand why this classic never goes out of style.

Sweet potato pie made with real sweet potatoes, homemade pastry, real butter, and warm spices tastes like comfort turned into dessert. It’s silky and rich, with that natural sweetness only real sweet potatoes can give—earthy, caramel‑like, and deeply satisfying. The butter in the crust adds a flaky, golden crunch that melts into the creamy filling, while the spices lift everything to a whole new level.

Large fluffy 7UP biscuits are pure, cloud‑soft comfort — tall, tender, and impossibly airy, with that subtle citrus lift from the soda that makes them taste fresh and light. They bake up golden on the outside, pillowy on the inside, and feel like the kind of biscuit that turns an ordinary meal into something worth lingering over.

Brownies taste like pure, fudgy happiness—rich, warm, and just decadent enough to make the world go quiet for a moment. Each bite is a mix of gooey chocolate goodness and that slightly crisp, crackly top that gives way to a soft center. They’re comforting, indulgent, and the kind of treat that makes you close your eyes just to savor the moment a little longer.

Coconut cake is tropical vibes meets pure indulgence - covered in sweet coconut flakes that give you that perfect texture contrast. It's light but rich, sweet but not overwhelming, and honestly tastes like a mini vacation.

Caramel cake is comfort food perfection - that rich, buttery caramel over fluffy vanilla layers hits like pure nostalgia. It's cozy, indulgent, and exactly what you need when regular cake won't cut it.

This cake is the one everyone's texting you about - like, genuinely craving it at random times. It hits that perfect sweet spot between nostalgic comfort and "okay this is actually next-level." The kind of dessert that makes people feel something, you know? It's not just good, it's the cake they can't stop thinking about.

NUTS ARE AN EXTRA COST Carrot cake is that underrated gem that always surprises people - moist, spiced perfection with cream cheese frosting that's basically the whole vibe. It's cozy and nostalgic but feels a little fancy, like you're treating yourself to something special.

Our German chocolate cake is that rich, layered masterpiece with the coconut-pecan frosting that absolutely steals the show. It's decadent chocolate meets that sweet, nutty, caramel-y situation that just hits different. Old-school vibes but timeless - the kind of cake that makes you slow down and savor every bite

Our hummingbird cake is that Southern classic everyone sleeps on until they try it - banana, pineapple, and pecans all coming together with cream cheese frosting that's chef's kiss. It's tropical meets homestyle comfort in the best way possible. Sweet, moist, and genuinely unforgettable - the kind of cake that converts people instantly.

MACARONS AND FLOWERS ARE NOT INCLUDED; GO TO "DESIGNING MY SIGNATURE CAKE" section. Our "Million Dollar" Fortune Cake is that cool, refreshing vibe you didn't know you needed - a moist vanilla cake blanketed in dreamy cream cheese, pineapple, and cool whip frosting, served chilled. It's light but indulgent, tropical but comforting, and honestly feels like a little luxury moment. The kind of cake that hits different on a warm day.

Chocolate Cookies and Cream Cake A chocolate cookies and cream cake is a delightful dessert that combines the rich flavors of chocolate with the creamy texture of cookies and cream. It typically features layers of moist chocolate cake, filled and frosted with a fluffy cookies-and-cream buttercream, and topped with Oreo Cookie crumbles for an extra crunch!

Our Nutty Indulgence "Peanut Butter" Cake is for the PB lovers who get it - rich, creamy peanut butter perfection that's unapologetically indulgent. It's that nostalgic comfort with a grown-up twist, sweet and salty vibes in perfect harmony. The kind of cake that has people asking "wait, can I get another slice?" before they've even finished.

Turn dessert on its head with our Caramelized "Pineapple Upside Down Cake"! It's a soft and buttery cake with a caramelized brown sugar pineapple & cherry topping. Its juices cook down into the cake, adding yummier flavor and texture. This classic favorite uses canned pineapple and maraschino cherries, and it's perfect any time of year.

This cake is a mischievously decadent, light‑green pistachio dream—so moist and fluffy it practically winks at you—topped with a creamy, nutty buttercream that dances across your taste buds and dares you not to take another bite.

A 7up pound cake is that zesty, old‑school classic that still knows how to make an entrance, all buttery with a little citrus pop. It’s the kind of dessert that shows up to the party sparkling like it understood the assignment.

A butter pecan cake like this is basically a cozy hug in dessert form, all golden, nutty, and a variety of spices (cinnamon, nutmeg, all-spice) giving main‑character energy. Topped with caramel frosting and roasted pecans. With those toasted pecans flexing on top, it’s serving Southern charm meets millennial snack‑queen vibes.

A modern take on a classic: rich red layers, subtle cocoa warmth, and a smooth cream cheese finish. Crafted for slow mornings, golden‑hour gatherings, and every moment that deserves something beautiful. This is red velvet, elevated—soft, balanced, and effortlessly indulgent.

Strawberries, Drizzle, and Sprinkles are not included. Go to "Design Your Cake" section. The strawberry buttercream–cream cheese frosting spreads over the cake in velvety swirls, giving it a blush‑pink finish that feels warm, inviting, and quietly elegant. It settles into a smooth, dreamy layer that hugs every curve of the cake, creating that soft, cloud‑like look that makes you want to cut a slice immediately.

State your color choice! A vanilla bean cake tastes warm, rich, and naturally sweet, with a smooth, buttery texture that feels both nostalgic and a little upscale. It has that “real ingredient” flavor millennials love—simple, cozy, and quietly elevated, like the dessert version of a well‑made latte.

Italian Cream Cake is a rich, cozy classic — soft and buttery with coconut and pecans for texture, all wrapped in smooth cream cheese frosting that makes every bite feel like a treat worth slowing down for.

Lemon Drop Bliss Cake is pure sunshine on a plate — a bright, moist lemon cake topped with silky lemon buttercream and finished with a glossy yellow lemon glaze that makes every bite feel like warm, happy weather. It’s zesty, cheerful, and instantly mood‑lifting, like a little burst of summer no matter the day.

Florida Key "Lime Cake" is bright, cool, and beach‑day refreshing — a moist key lime cake topped with a creamy frosting made from cream cheese, pineapple, and whipped topping. Every bite feels like a breezy escape, sweet, tangy, and tropical in the best way.

Banana cake is pure comfort — soft, moist, and full of that warm, naturally sweet banana flavor that feels like a hug in dessert form. It’s rich without being heavy, cozy without trying, and just the right kind of nostalgic.

Make your Signature Cake "Pop"! You can add more layers, toppings, drizzle, script (e.g. "happy b-day), toppers, sprinkles and more!

Make your Signature Cake "Pop"! You can add more layers, toppings, drizzle, script (e.g. "happy b-day), toppers, sprinkles and more!

Make your Signature Cake "Pop"! You can add more layers, toppings, drizzle, script (e.g. "happy b-day), toppers, sprinkles and more!

Make your Signature Cake "Pop"! You can add more layers, toppings, drizzle, script (e.g. "happy b-day), toppers, sprinkles and more!

Make your Signature Cake "Pop"! You can add more layers, toppings, drizzle, script (e.g. "happy b-day), toppers, sprinkles and more!

Make your Signature Cake "Pop"! You can add more layers, toppings, drizzle, script (e.g. "happy b-day), toppers, sprinkles and more!

Make your Signature Cake "Pop"! You can add more layers, toppings, drizzle, script (e.g. "happy b-day), toppers, sprinkles and more!

Make your Signature Cake "Pop"! You can add more layers, toppings, drizzle, script (e.g. "happy b-day), toppers, sprinkles and more!

Make your Signature Cake "Pop"! You can add more layers, toppings, drizzle, script (e.g. "happy b-day), toppers, sprinkles and more!