This restaurant does not have any images
Italian
Caseys Dugout
2900 Lincoln Avenue
Evansville, IN 47714
Orders through Toast are commission free and go directly to this restaurant
App/Desserts/Sides
Appetizers
Cheese Bread
Fresh local bread topped with garlic butter and bubbly mozzarella. Served with pizza sauce.$7.75Jalapeno Cheese Bread
Fresh local bread topped with garlic butter, mozzarella, and jalapenos. Served with your choice of cheese sauce, marinara, or garlic butter.$8.25Breadsticks
Order of 5 breadsticks with choice of cheese sauce, marinara, or garlic butter$7.00Fireballs
Baked doughballs topped with Mike's Hot Honey & Bacon. Add jalapenos to kick up the heat!$9.50Hot Honey Sticks
Garlic Butter breadsticks, topped with hot honey and a dusting of parmesan. Served with marinara$8.00Bruschetta
$9.50Sausage Cheese Bread
$9.00pepperoni rolls
$10.25Cheesy Breadsticks
$8.00pepperoni breadsticks
$9.00
Sides
Desserts
Tiger Balls
Warm and gooey cinnamon sugar dough balls with vanilla icing drizzle. A perfect sweet bite to end your meal.$9.00Chocolate Chip Cookie
$2.2510" Dogfather's Dessert Pizza
Our pizza crust with a buttery cinnamon sugar topping and a vanilla icing swirl.$10.0010" Smores Pizza
$12.00OUT OF STOCK16" dogfather
$15.00Vanilla Soft Serve
$3.00Chocolate Soft Serve
$3.00Twists Soft Serve
$3.00Plain Cheesecake
$4.25OUT OF STOCKKey Lime Pie
$4.25
Sandwiches
Hot Ham and Cheese
Local shaved ham, green peppers, onions & mozzarella$14.00Stromboli
Stromboli meat, pepperoni, diced onion, green peppers, red sauce, mozzarella cheese$14.00Veggie Strom
Green pepper, onion, mushroom, marinara, and mozzarella cheese$13.00Evansville BBQ Strom
Cumbled stromboli sausage, bbq sauce, onion, cheese, with a BBQ Grippos Dusting.$14.00Meatball Sub
House made sliced meatballs, topped green peppers, onions, marinara, and melty mozzarella. Served with a side of giardiniera.$15.00CBR
Chicken. Bacon. Ranch.$14.00BBQ Veggie Strom
Mushroom, green pepper, onion, black olive, banana peppers, mozzarella, bbq sauce, & topped with Grippo dust.$13.00Caprese
Our stromboli bread toasted and topped with fresh mozzarella slices, tomato, fresh basil & a balsamic glaze drizzle.$14.001/2 Hot Ham
Local shaved ham, green peppers, onions & mozzarella$9.001/2 Strom
$9.001/2 Evansville BBQ Strom
Cumbled stromboli sausage, bbq sauce, onion, cheese, with a BBQ Grippos Dusting.$9.001/2 Veggie Strom
Green pepper, onion, mushroom, marinara, and mozzarella cheese$8.001/2 CBR
Chicken. Bacon. Ranch.$9.001/2 BBQ Veggie Strom
Mushroom, green pepper, onion, black olive, banana peppers, mozzarella, bbq sauce, & topped with Grippo dust.$8.001/2 Caprese
Our stromboli bread toasted and topped with fresh mozzarella slices, tomato, fresh basil & a balsamic glaze drizzle.$9.001/2 Meatball Sub
House made sliced meatballs, topped green peppers, onions, marinara, and melty mozzarella. Served with a side of giardiniera.$10.00whole Parthenon
$15.001/2 Parthenon
$10.00Whole Chicken Parmesan
$15.001/2 Chicken Parmesan
$10.00
Pizza
10" Pizza
10" The Hitman
Sausage, mushroom, and extra cheese... just how Donnie Baseball likes it!$16.0010" The "Graham" Slam
Loaded! Sausage, pepperoni, beef, ham,bacon, onion, green pepper, black olives, mushroom, and pepperoncinis$20.0010" Harper's Hot Honey Hawaiian
Ham, pineapple, brown sugar, red sauce, and a drizzle of hot honey!$19.0010" The Tater
Potato, bacon, red onion, garlic butter sauce, cheddar cheese, and a side sour cream or tzatziki.$16.0010" The Utopian
Chicken, fresh sliced mushrooms, truffle, bacon, and mozzarella cheese.$19.0010" Mary's Little Lamb
Gyro meat, feta, mozzarella, red onion, tomato, with a side of tzatziki sauce$17.0010" BBQ Chicken
BBQ Chicken, green pepper & onion$17.0010" Field of Greens
All the veggies. Green peppers, red onion, mushroom, black olives, & banana peppers.$17.0010" The Meat Head
Pepperoni, sausage, beef, ham, bacon,$20.0010" Chicken Bacon Ranch
Grilled chicken,bacon, ranch, mozzarella cheese$19.0010" Cheese Louise
Order it as is or add toppings to build your own pie!$10.0010" Angry Bird
Buffalo chicken, red onion, blue cheese crumble, and ranch drizzle$19.0010" Rancher Pizza
Ranch base, cheese, & tomato.$14.0010" The Popeye
Garlic olive oil base, mozzarella cheese, red onion, feta, & a mound of spinach.$17.0010" The MARGO-rita
Red sauce, fresh mozzarella, fresh basil, sprinkled with parmesan & finished with a balsamic glaze drizzle.$16.5010" Thai Chicken
Grilled Chicken, thai chili sauce, mozzarella cheese, red onion, zucchinni, & topped with peanuts and toasted sesame seeds$17.0010" Donnie MEATball
Sliced housemade meatballs, herb-infused ricotta, green peppers, onions, red sauce, and mozzarella.$19.0010" Tuscan
$17.0010" Hot Pig
Pepperoni, jalapeno, and hot honey.$16.0010" Garlic Breath
$19.00OUT OF STOCK10" Stomboli Pie
Sausage crumbles, green pepper, onions, pepperoni, extra red sauce, and mozzarella.$18.0010" Chicken Fajita
$17.00OUT OF STOCK10" Flame Thrower
$18.0010" Jamaican Jerk
$19.0010" Big Mac-K
$17.00OUT OF STOCK10" Chicken Caeser Pizza
$16.0010" Hoosier Hot Chick Bad Randy
$20.00OUT OF STOCK10" Dugout Double Play
Double pepperoni pie with extra cheese$17.0010" The Green Standard
$20.00OUT OF STOCK10" Tasty Taco
Taco seasoned ground beef, taco sauce, cheese, jalepenos, topped with lettuce, tomato, and a side of sour cream. Only available on Taco Tuesday!$19.00OUT OF STOCK
16" Pizza
16" Cheese
Order it as is or add toppings to build your own pie!$16.0016" The Hitman
Sausage, mushroom, and extra cheese... just how Donnie Baseball likes it!$23.0016" The "Graham" Slam
Loaded! Sausage, pepperoni, beef, ham,bacon, onion, green pepper, black olives, mushroom, and pepperoncinis$30.0016" Harper's Hot Honey Hawaiian
Ham, pineapple, brown sugar, red sauce, and a drizzle of hot honey!$27.0016" The Tater
Potato, bacon, red onion, garlic butter sauce, cheddar cheese, and a side sour cream or tzatziki.$24.0016" Mary's Little Lamb
Gyro meat, feta, mozzarella, red onion, tomato, with a side of tzatziki sauce$27.0016" Utopian
Chicken, fresh sliced mushroom, truffle and mushroom base, bacon, and mozzarella cheese.$27.0016" BBQ Chicken
BBQ Chicken, green pepper, & onion.$27.0016" Field of Greens
All the veggies. Green peppers, red onion, mushroom, black olives, & banana peppers.$23.0016" The Meat Head
Pepperoni, sausage, beef, ham, bacon,$28.0016" Chicken Bacon Ranch
Grilled chicken,bacon, ranch, mozzarella cheese$26.0016" Angry Bird
Buffalo Chicen, red onion, blue chees crumble, & ranch dressing drizzle.$27.0016" Rancher
Ranch base, mozzarella cheese, red onion & tomato.$23.0016" the Popeye
Garlic olive oil base, melted mozzarella cheese, red onion, spinach, tomato, and feta.$24.0016" The MARGO-rita
Red sauce, fresh mozzarella, fresh basil, sprinkled with parmesan & finished with a balsamic glaze drizzle.$23.0016" Thai Chicken
Grilled Chicken, thai chili sauce, mozzarella cheese, red onion, zucchini, & topped with peanuts and toasted sesame seeds..$25.0016" Donnie Meatball Pizza
Sliced house made meatballs, herb infused ricotta, red onion, green pepper, red sauce, & mozzarella$28.0016" Tuscan
$26.0016" Flame Thrower
$27.0016" Stromboli Pizza
$25.0016" Chicken Fajita
$27.00OUT OF STOCK16" Hot Pig
$24.0016" Garlic Breath
$28.00OUT OF STOCK16" Jamaican Jerk
$27.00OUT OF STOCK16" Big Mac-K
$23.00OUT OF STOCK16" Chicken Caeser Pizza
$24.00OUT OF STOCK16" Hoosier Hot Chick Bad Randy
$30.00OUT OF STOCK16" Dugout Double Play
Double pepperoni and extra cheese$24.0016" The Green Standard
$30.00OUT OF STOCK16" Tasty Taco
Taco seasoned ground beef, taco sauce, cheese, jalepenos, topped with lettuce, tomato, and a side of sour cream. Only available on Taco Tuesday!$28.00OUT OF STOCK
Salads/Sandwiches
Salads
Sandwiches
1/2 Hot Ham
Local shaved ham, green peppers, onions & mozzarella$9.00Hot Ham and Cheese
Local shaved ham, green peppers, onions & mozzarella$14.001/2 Strom
$9.00Stromboli
Stromboli meat, pepperoni, diced onion, green peppers, red sauce, mozzarella cheese$14.001/2 Evansville BBQ Strom
Cumbled stromboli sausage, bbq sauce, onion, cheese, with a BBQ Grippos Dusting.$9.00Evansville BBQ Strom
Cumbled stromboli sausage, bbq sauce, onion, cheese, with a BBQ Grippos Dusting.$14.001/2 CBR
Chicken. Bacon. Ranch.$9.00CBR
Chicken. Bacon. Ranch.$14.001/2 Veggie Strom
Green pepper, onion, mushroom, marinara, and mozzarella cheese$8.00Veggie Strom
Green pepper, onion, mushroom, marinara, and mozzarella cheese$13.001/2 BBQ Veggie Strom
Mushroom, green pepper, onion, black olive, banana peppers, mozzarella, bbq sauce, & topped with Grippo dust.$8.00BBQ Veggie Strom
Mushroom, green pepper, onion, black olive, banana peppers, mozzarella, bbq sauce, & topped with Grippo dust.$13.001/2 Parthenon
$10.00whole Parthenon
$15.001/2 caprese
$9.00Caprese
Our stromboli bread toasted and topped with fresh mozzarella slices, tomato, fresh basil & a balsamic glaze drizzle.$14.00
Drinks
Soft Drinks
If you use a credit card, Caseys Dugout will charge an additional 3.00% ($0.00) to help offset processing costs. This amount is not more than what Caseys Dugout pays in fees.
All hours
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday | 5:00 pm - 8:00 pm |
| Tuesday | 5:00 pm - 9:00 pm |
| Wednesday | 5:00 pm - 9:00 pm |
| Thursday | 5:00 pm - 9:00 pm |
| Friday | 5:00 pm - 9:30 pm |
| Saturday | 5:00 pm - 8:00 pm |
Restaurant info
Come in and enjoy!
Location
Similar restaurants in your area
© 2026 Toast, Inc.
Made with 
in Boston
in Boston
