
American
Chatham Tap Butler 4702 Sunset Avenue
4702 Sunset Avenue
Suite 100
Indianapolis, IN 46208
Orders through Toast are commission free and go directly to this restaurant
Featured Items
Prince Dean's Angel Wings
One dozen jumbo chicken wings fried and tossed in our signature sauce. Served w/ carrots and celery. Choose one of our other sauces if you'd like: Garlic Parmesan, Hot Buffalo, Mild Buffalo, Teriyaki, BBQ, and Chipotle Apricot.$19.99Shenanigans Chicken Finger Platter
Hand breaded chicken tenders with a side of our seasoned fries and honey mustard.$12.99BYO Burger
Create your own burger. We'll start you with a brioche burger bun and a 1/2 lb Angus Beef patty.$11.99
Food
Starters
Breadsticks
Served with a choice of cheese sauce, marinara, or creamy garlic-ranch. Additional sauces $0.75 each.$10.99Buffalo Chicken Dip
Shredded chicken w/ our house-made buffalo sauce and cheese blend. Topped with shredded cheddar and served with seasoned tortilla chips and celery.$12.99Fried Pickles
Batter-dipped pickle slices dusted w/ parmesan and served w/ our house-made Montauk Sauce.$9.99Garlic Cheese Chips
A British Isles favorite. Creamy garlic-ranch topped with french fries and shredded cheddar cheese. Try them your way and add your favorite toppings!$11.99Green Leaf Thai Wraps
Build your own lettuce wraps w/ your choice of either our Chipotle-Apricot sauce or Coconut Curry sauce on grilled chicken. Served with a thai dressing/slaw and green leaf lettuce with a peanut dipping sauce. Substitute portabella mushrooms in place of chicken for a vegetarian option!$11.99Hummus
Chickpeas, garlic, peppers and other seasonings served with your choice of pita chips, our house-made parisien baguettes, or carrots/celery.$9.99Montauks
Smoked gouda & rasher bacon baked on our parisien baguette, topped w/ pan-seared cherry heirloom tomatoes & fresh basil on our Montauk sauce. Substitute portabella mushrooms in place of rasher bacon for a vegetarian option!$10.99Nachos
Seasoned tortilla chips topped w/ a veggie black bean & corn salsa, our shredded nacho cheese blend, house-made guacamole, and pico de gallo. Add chicken, chorizo, steak, ground beef, or pulled pork!$11.99Onion Ring Appetizer
Our hand-breaded cut-to-order onion slices deep fried and served with our garlic-chipotle ranch on the side.$11.99Portabella Mushroom Fries
Fried Portabella slices dusted w/ parmesan and served w/ a garlic chipotle-ranch.$10.99Soft Pretzels
Warm salted soft pretzel bites served w/ our house-made cinnamon caramel, spicy mustard, and cheese sauce for dipping.$10.99Spinach & Artichoke Dip
The classic spread served warm with your choice of pita chips, parisien bread, or carrots & celery.$11.99
Soups/Salads
Soups
Choose from our Leek & Potato Soup, our house-made chili, or our Soup of the Day. Served with your choice of toppings: Cheddar, Onion, and Sour Cream and crackers.$4.99Soup & House Salad Combo
Our House Salad starts with a bed of organic spring and romaine mix topped w/ grape tomatoes, red onioins, shredded mozzarella, and croutons. Choose your soup to pair!$9.99Soup & Caesar Salad Combo
Our Caesar Salad starts with a bed of chopped romaine topped w/ grape tomatoes, shaved parmesan, and croutons. Choose your soup to pair!$9.99Antipasto Salad
A bed of organic spring and romaine mix topped w/ chopped pepperoni, salami, capicola ham, grape tomatoes, black olives, banana peppers, and shredded mozzarella. Served with Italian dressing.$12.99Apple & Candied Walnut Salad
Organic spring and romaine mix topped with spicy candied walnuts, feta cheese crumbles, and apple slices. Served with a Black Raspberry & Walnut vinaigrette.$11.99Balsamic Chicken Salad
Chicken breast grilled and served atop organic spring & romaine mix with sunflower seeds, craisins, and gorgonzola cheese crumbles. Served with a balsamic vinaigrette.$13.99Caesar Salad
Chopped romaine tossed in caesar dressing, topped with shaved parmesan and croutons.$8.99House Salad
Organic spring and romaine mix with grape tomatoes, red onions, shredded mozzarella, and croutons. Select your favorite dressing!$9.99Salmon Salad
A grilled salmon filet served atop organic spring and romaine mix with mandarin oranges and pita chips. Served with a Poppyseed dressing.$14.99Spicy Steak Salad
A spicy grilled steak cut served atop organic spring and romaine mix w/ shredded cheddar cheese, pico de gallo, & our sour cream ranch dressing.$14.99Spinach Caprese Salad
Spinach leaves topped with a row of fresh mozzarella and tomato slices, chopped basil and a drizzle of olive oil and a balsamic glaze.$12.99Turkey Cobb Salad
Organic spring & romaine mix topped w/ chopped smoked turkey, applewood bacon, tomatoes, mushroom slices, shredded cheddar, gorgonzola crumbles, and a hardboiled egg. Select your favorite dressing!$12.99
Sarnies
Buffalo Chicken Sandwich
Breaded chicken breast dredged in buffalo sauce and topped with pepperjack cheese. Served on our brioche burger bun with a side of blue cheese dressing and lettuce, onion, tomato, and pickles.$12.99Chicken Club
Grilled chicken breast topped with lettuce, tomato, rasher bacon, red onion, & swiss cheese. Served on our black bean & salsa bread. Available grilled or breaded, spicy or regular.$12.99Cubano Sandwich
A little bit of heat and a whole lot of flavors pop out of this sarnie. Slow roasted citrus & herb mojo pork pulled and grilled atop slices of rasher bacon, then topped with melted swiss, pickles, and mustard all on a toasted hoagie roll.$12.99Earl's Club
Sliced Smoked Turkey, Rasher bacon, Swiss Cheese, Lettuce, and Tomato served on a grilled Ciabatta bun.$11.99Englishman in Italy
Pepperoni, Salami, & Capicola Ham w/ mozzarella, and spring mix tossed in italian dressing. Served with a side of garlic mayo and banana peppers.$12.99Flint's Meatball Sub
A half pound of beef & pork meatballs topped with marinara, provolone, parmesan, and oregano on a hoagie roll.$12.99French Dip
Hot roast beef and sauteed onioins topped with melted provolone chesese and our horsey sauce. Served 'au jus' on a grilled hoagie bun.$12.99Garlic Pork Tenderloin
Breaded or grilled. Served with lettuce, tomato, onion, and pickle on a grilled brioche bun.$12.99Gorgonzola Pear Melt
Sliced pear and rasher bacon topped with gorgonzola cheese melted on toasted ciabatta.$10.99Pesto Sandwich
Our toasted ciabatta bun sandwiches a generous spread of pesto sauce, sauteed mushrooms, melted mozzarella, and fresh spinach.$10.99Portabella & Smoked Gouda Melt
Vegetarian Option. We sautee and season a giant portabella mushroom cap, melt some smoked gouda cheese on top, and add slices of fresh avocado. We'll set that on a slice of our house-baked parisien bread with a garlic mayo spread. Served open-faced.$12.99Reuben Sandwich
Our classic Reuben. Corned beef, sauerkraut, and 1000 Island dressing on grilled rye bread.$11.99Salmon Sandwich
Our grilled salmon filet topped with spring mix, smoked gouda cheese, sliced avocado, and a cilantro oil on our grilled house-made black bean & salsa bread.$13.99Smoked Gouda Apple Melt
Sliced green apple dusted with a touch of cinnamon and topped with smoked gouda cheese and melted on our house-made parisien bread.$10.99Southern BBQ Pulled Pork Sandwich
Slow cooked shredded pork roast tossed in our house-made BBQ sauce, topped with our hand-battered onion rings all piled on a grilled brioche bun.$11.99War Pig
A hand-breaded pork tenderloin topped with capicola ham, 2 strips of applewood bacon, a fried egg, and a trio of melted swiss, provolone, and smoked gouda cheeses. Then drizzled with our jalapeno hollandaise and served on a brioche bun.$16.99
Burgers (Dbl Smash Burgers)
Butler's BBQ Bacon Burger
A 1/2 lb Angus Beef patty topped with provolone cheese, 2 strips of applewood smoked bacon, and BBQ sauce.$14.49Meaty Kuzola Burger
Our 1/2 LB Angus Beef patty topped w/ marinara, rasher bacon, pepperoni, sausage, and mozzarella cheese. Can't decide between a pizza or a burger? Why not both in one.$13.99Smokin Black & Bleu Burger
Our 1/2 LB Angus Beef patty brushed with chipotle tabasco sauce, then topped with rasher bacon and melted gorgonzola crumbles.$13.99The Heartstopper
TWO 1/2 LB Angus Beef patties topped w/ rasher bacon, a fried egg, sauteed onions and mushrooms, and a melted trio of cheddar, muenster, and swiss cheeses.$18.99Tur-Bacon Burger
A grilled all natural umami turkey burger patty topped with 2 strips of applewood bacon, melted pepperjack cheese, and our house-made bacon aioli.$12.99Veggie Black Bean Burger
Vegan Option. Our house-made black bean, peppers, and rice patty topped with our house-guacamole, lettuce and red onion.$12.99BYO Burger
Create your own burger. We'll start you with a brioche burger bun and a 1/2 lb Angus Beef patty.$11.99
House Specialties
Prince Dean's Angel Wings
One dozen jumbo chicken wings fried and tossed in our signature sauce. Served w/ carrots and celery. Choose one of our other sauces if you'd like: Garlic Parmesan, Hot Buffalo, Mild Buffalo, Teriyaki, BBQ, and Chipotle Apricot.$19.99Prince Dean's Angel Wings 1/2 Order
Six jumbo chicken wings fried and tossed in our signature sauce. Served w/ carrots and celery. Choose one of our other sauces if you'd like: Garlic Parmesan, Hot Buffalo, Mild Buffalo, Teriyaki, BBQ, and Chipotle Apricot.$11.99Steak Sandwich
A dry-rubbed 8 oz cut of steak, topped with rasher bacon, a fried egg, and pepperjack cheese. Served open-faced on our house-baked parisien bread.$16.99Fish & Chips
House cut and hand-batterd cod served with seasoned fries, tartar sauce, and lemon.$17.99Fish & Chips 1/2 Order
House cut and hand-batterd cod served with seasoned fries, tartar sauce, and lemon.$12.99Boneless Wings
A pound of breaded boneless chicken wings tossed in your choice of wing sauce.$15.99Shenanigans Chicken Finger Platter
Hand breaded chicken tenders with a side of our seasoned fries and honey mustard.$12.99
Pizza
BYO Large Pizza
Build Your Own Pizza$15.99BYO Small Pizza
Build Your Own Pizza$12.99Large BBQ Chicken Pizza
$21.99Small BBQ Chicken Pizza
$16.99Large Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Buffalo Dip, Mozzarella, Blue Cheese Crumbles, Hot Sauce.$20.99Small Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Buffalo Dip, Mozzarella, Blue Cheese Crumbles, Hot Sauce.$15.99Large Cheeseburger Pizza
Ground Beef, Rasher Bacon, Shredded Cheddar, House Special Sauce$21.99Small Cheeseburger Pizza
Ground Beef, Rasher Bacon, Shredded Cheddar, House Special Sauce$16.99Large Chicken Ranch Pizza
Grilled Chicken, Tomato, Basil, Rasher Bacon, Ranch Base.$20.99Small Chicken Ranch Pizza
Grilled Chicken, Tomato, Basil, Rasher Bacon, Ranch Base.$15.99Large Garden Grove Pizza
Portabella Mushrooms, Black Olives, Onions, Peppers, Spinach$19.99Small Garden Grove Pizza
Portabella Mushrooms, Black Olives, Onions, Peppers, Spinach$14.99Large Meaty Kuzola Pizza
Pepperoni, Sausage, Rasher Bacon.$20.99Small Meaty Kuzola Pizza
Pepperoni, Sausage, Rasher Bacon.$15.99Large Reuben Pizza
Corned Beef, Sauerkraut, 1000 Island Base.$20.99Small Reuben Pizza
Corned Beef, Sauerkraut, 1000 Island Base.$15.99Large Robert Browning Pizza
Capicola Ham, Salami, pepperoni, Banana Peppers, Spring Mix tossed in Italian Dressing.$21.99Small Robert Browning Pizza
Capicola Ham, Salami, pepperoni, Banana Peppers, Spring Mix tossed in Italian Dressing.$16.99Large Pizza Margherita
Olive oil base, fresh mozzarella & tomato slices, chopped basil, and oregano$19.99Small Pizza Margherita
Olive oil base, fresh mozzarella & tomato slices, chopped basil, and oregano$14.99
Dessert
Chocolate Layer Cake
Four tiers of chocolate caked layered with rich chocolate icing on a bed of raspberry coulis. Finished with powdered sugar and fresh strawberries.$10.99Chef's Choice - Caramel Apple Cheesecake
$10.99OUT OF STOCKChef's Choice - Raspberry Swirl Cheesecake
A rotating selection of desserts.$7.99Yogurt Parfait
Greek yogurt topped with strawberries, blueberries, granola, & a house-made chipotle agave sauce.$6.99Ice Cream Scoop
French Vanilla Ice Cream$4.00
A la Carte
Applewood Bacon
$1.50Burger Patty
$11.00Chicken Breaded
$9.00Chicken Grilled
$9.00Egg
$1.50Pulled Pork
$9.00Salmon Filet 4 oz
$9.00Salmon Filet 6 oz
$12.00Steak 4 oz
$8.00Steak 8 oz
$12.00Tenderloin Breaded
$9.00Tenderloin Grilled
$9.00Full Garden
Lettuce
Chopped Onions
Red Onion
Tomato
Pickle
Apple Slices
$1.00Avocado Slices
$1.50Banana Peppers
$0.75Basil
$0.75Black Bean Burger Patty (Veggie)
$9.00Carrots
$1.50Celery
$1.50Cucumber Slices
$0.75Fried Onion Ring
$1.50Green Peppers
$0.75Guacamole
$1.50Jalapenos
$1.00Pear Slices
$1.00Pico de Gallo
$1.00Portabella Mushroom Cap
$8.00Sauerkraut
$0.75Sauteed Mushrooms
$1.00Sauteed Onions
$1.00Spinach
$2.00Spring Mix
$3.50Salsa, Black Bean & Corn
$1.50Shredded Cheddar
$1.00Cheddar Slice
$1.00Feta Crumbles
$1.50Gorgonzola Crumbles
$1.50Shredded Mozzarella
$1.00Muenster Slice
$1.00Parmesan Shaved
$1.50Parmesan Shredded
$1.00Pepper-Jack Slice
$1.00Provolone Slice
$1.00Smoked Gouda Slice
$1.00Swiss Slice
$1.00Black Bean & Salsa Bread (2 Slices)
$2.00Burger Bun (Brioche)
Ciabatta Bun
Gluten Free Bun
$5.00Hoagie Roll
$1.00Parisien Bread (1 Slice)
$1.00Parisien Bread (2 Slices)
$1.50Parisien Bread (6 Slices)
$3.00Rye Bread (2 Slices)
$2.00Garlic & Cheese Chips Side
$7.00French Fries
$4.00Large Fries
$6.00Tater Tots
$4.00Large Tater Tots
$6.00Sweet Potato Fries
$4.00Large Sweet Potato Fries
$6.00Onion Rings
$5.00House Chips
$3.00Cottage Cheese
$3.00Fruit
$3.00Cole Slaw
$3.00Greek Yogurt (Vanilla)
$3.00Tortilla Chips
$3.00Pita Chips
$3.00Ranch
$1.00Chipotle Ranch
$1.00Garlic Ranch
$1.00Blue Cheese Dressing
$1.001000 Island Dressing
$1.00Balsamic Glaze
$1.50Balsamic Vinaigrette
$1.00Caesar Dressing
$1.00French Dressing
$1.00Honey Mustard Dressing
$1.00Italian Dressing
$1.00Peppercorn Ranch Dressing
$1.00Poppyseed Dressing
$1.00Raspberry Walnut Dressing
$1.25Sour Cream Ranch
$1.00Signature Sauce
$1.25Bacon Aioli
$1.25BBQ Sauce
$1.00Buffalo - Hot
$1.00Buffalo - Mild
$1.00Cheese Sauce
$1.25Chipotle Tabasco
$0.50Chipotle-Apricot
$1.00Cilantro Sauce
$1.00Cinnamon Caramel
$0.50Garlic Mayo
$1.25Garlic Parmesan
$1.00SALSA, GREEN
$1.25SALSA, RED
$1.25Hollandaise
$1.00Horsey Sauce
$1.00Marinara
$1.00Montauk Sauce
$1.00Sour Cream
$0.50Spicy Mustard
$0.25Tartar Sauce
$1.00Teriyaki Sauce
$1.00Thai Peanut Sauce
$0.25
Merchandise
Growlers & Glasses
Short Sleeve Shirts
Black World Cup Short Sleeve Shirt
$25.00Blue World Cup Short Sleeve Shirt
$25.00Green World Cup Short Sleeve Shirt
$25.00Grey World Cup Short Sleeve Shirt
$25.00Red World Cup Shor Sleeve Shirt
$25.00White World Cup Short Sleeve Shirt
$25.00Black Flag Short Sleeve Shirt
$25.00Blue Flag Short Sleeve Shirt
$25.00Pink Flag Short Sleeve Shirt
$25.00Blue Lion Short Sleeve
$25.00Red Lion Short Sleeve
$25.00
Long Sleeve Shirts
All hours
| Sunday | 11:00 am - 9:30 pm |
| Monday | 11:00 am - 9:30 pm |
| Tuesday | 11:00 am - 9:30 pm |
| Wednesday | 11:00 am - 9:30 pm |
| Thursday | 11:00 am - 10:30 pm |
| Friday | 11:00 am - 10:30 pm |
| Saturday | 11:00 am - 10:30 pm |
Restaurant info
A neighborhood pub on the Butler University campus serving the Butler-Tarkington neighborhood and more.
Location
4702 Sunset Avenue, Suite 100, Indianapolis, IN 46208
Similar restaurants in your area
© 2026 Toast, Inc.




