
American
Colorado Cherry Co - Lyons
12311 North Saint Vrain Drive
Lyons, CO 80540
Orders through Toast are commission free and go directly to this restaurant
Holiday Pre-Order
Full Sized Pies

Apple Caramel Crisp Pie - Whole
Cinnamon-sweet Granny Smith apples topped with a brown sugar oat crumble topping$26.00
Apple Pie - Whole
Brown sugar & cinnamon Granny Smith apples in our all-butter crust$26.00
Blueberry Pie - Whole
Wild Maine blueberry filling in our all-butter crust$26.00
Cherry Berry Pie - Whole
Tart Montmorency cherry, strawberry and blueberry filling in our all-butter crust$26.00
Cherry Pie - Whole
A classic! Tart Montmorency cherry filling in our all-butter crust$26.00
Cherry Streusel Pie - Whole
$26.00
Chocolate Peanut Butter Pie - Whole
Fluffy whipped peanut butter filling topped with chocolate ganache in our chocolate cookie crust$33.00
French Silk Pie - Whole
Whipped chocolate mousse with vanilla whipped cream in our chocolate cookie crust$33.00
Pumpkin Pie - Whole
Classic spiced pumpkin filling with fresh whipped cream in our all-butter crust$28.00
Pecan Pie - Whole
Sweet filling with pecans in our all-butter crust$33.00
Cherry Cheesecake Pie - Whole
Classic cheesecake filling topped with a sweet cherry topping in our graham cracker crust$33.00
Family Quiche - Lorraine - Bacon and Swiss
Fluffy egg quiche with bacon bits and Swiss cheese in out all-butter crust$28.00
Family Quiche - Vegetarian - Broccoli and Cheddar
Fluffy egg quiche with broccoli and cheddar cheese in out all-butter crust$28.00
Mini Pies

Mini Apple Caramel Crisp
Cinnamon-sweet Granny Smith apples topped with a brown sugar oat crumble topping$11.50
Mini Apple Pie
Brown sugar & cinnamon Granny Smith apples in our all-butter crust$11.50
Mini Blueberry Pie
Wild Maine blueberry filling in our all-butter crust$11.50
Mini Cherry Berry Pie
Tart Montmorency cherry, strawberry and blueberry filling in our all-butter crust$11.50
Mini Cherry Pie
A classic! Tart Montmorency cherry filling in our all-butter crust$11.50
Mini Streusel Pie
Tart Montmorency cherry filling topped with brown sugar streusel in our all-butter crust$11.50
Holiday Pre-Order Take & Bake
Take & Bake Pies

Apple Caramel Crisp T&B
Cinnamon-sweet Granny Smith apples topped with a brown sugar oat crumble topping. This product is provided FROZEN with baking instructions.$26.00
Apple Pie T&B
Brown sugar & cinnamon Granny Smith apples in our all-butter crust. This product is provided FROZEN with baking instructions.$26.00
Blueberry Pie T&B
Wild Maine blueberry filling in our all-butter crust. This product is provided FROZEN with baking instructions.$26.00
Cherry Berry Pie T&B
Tart Montmorency cherry, strawberry and blueberry filling in our all-butter crust This product is provided FROZEN with baking instructions.$26.00
Cherry Pie T&B
A classic! Tart Montmorency cherry filling in our all-butter crust This product is provided FROZEN with baking instructions.$26.00
Cherry Streusel Pie T&B
Tart Montmorency cherry filling topped with brown sugar streusel in our all-butter crust This product is provided FROZEN with baking instructions.$26.00
Gluten Free Cherry Pie T&B
Our famous Cherry Pie filling in our gluten-free crust made with garbanzo bean and tapioca flour, topped with a gluten-free oat streusel topping. This product is provided FROZEN with baking instructions.$29.00
Family Chicken Pot Pie T&B
Classic creamy chicken pot pie with peas, carrots, and onions in our all-butter crust. This product is provided FROZEN with baking instructions.$33.00
Family Bison Pot Pie T&B
Ground bison & beef with potatoes, carrots, peas, onions, and stout gravy in our all-butter crust. This product will be delivered FROZEN with proper BAKING instructions.$33.00
Mini Chicken Pot Pie T&B
Classic creamy chicken pot pie with peas, carrots, and onions in our all-butter crust. This product is provided FROZEN with baking instructions.$12.00
Mini Bison Pot Pie T&B
Ground bison & beef with potatoes, carrots, peas, onions, and stout gravy in our all-butter crust. This product will be delivered FROZEN with proper BAKING instructions.$12.00
Mini Veggie Pot Pie T&B
Cream base with mushrooms, potatoes, carrots, peas and onion in our all-butter crust. This product will be delivered FROZEN with proper BAKING instructions.$12.00
All hours
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | Closed |
| Thursday | Closed |
| Friday | Closed |
| Saturday | Closed |
Restaurant info
A taste of the Colorado High Country! Serving the kind of pie Grandma used to make!
Location
12311 North Saint Vrain Drive, Lyons, CO 80540
Similar restaurants in your area
© 2026 Toast, Inc.




