
American
East Ave Deli & Sundae Best
3027 East Ave
Central Square, NY 13036
Orders through Toast are commission free and go directly to this restaurant
Featured Items
The Club
Ovengold Turkey, Maple Glazed Ham, cheddar, bacon, lettuce, and tomato with roasted garlic mayo on toasted Geddes marble rye$13.25The Antipasto
pepperoni, salami, capocollo, provolone, lettuce, tomato, onion, black olives, and banana peppers, with roasted garlic mayo, pesto mayo, deli dressing, and parmesan cheese, on a toasted white ciabatta roll$12.75The Adirondack
Cracked Peppermill Smoked Turkey, bacon, gouda, maple caramelized onions, and spring mix, with mayo on toasted Geddes white bread$12.75
Deli Menu
Specialty Sandwiches
The Thanksgiving
Ovengold Turkey, stuffing, and spring mix, with cranberry mayo on a toasted brioche roll$11.25The Club
Ovengold Turkey, Maple Glazed Ham, cheddar, bacon, lettuce, and tomato with roasted garlic mayo on toasted Geddes marble rye$13.25The Fresh Mozz
fresh mozzarella, prosciutto, roasted red peppers, and spring mix, with pesto mayo on atoasted white ciabbatta roll$10.75The Antipasto
pepperoni, salami, capocollo, provolone, lettuce, tomato, onion, black olives, and banana peppers, with roasted garlic mayo, pesto mayo, deli dressing, and parmesan cheese, on a toasted white ciabatta roll$12.75The Adirondack
Cracked Peppermill Smoked Turkey, bacon, gouda, maple caramelized onions, and spring mix, with mayo on toasted Geddes white bread$12.75The Beef on Brioche
London Broil Roast Beef, swiss, roasted red peppers, onions, and onions, with roasted garlic mayo and horseradish sauce, on a toasted brioche roll$12.75
Specialty Panini
The Wild Bill
London Broil Roast Beef, pepperjack, caramelized onions, and banana peppers, with chipotle mayo on Geddes wheat bread$12.75The Mediterranean
provolone, caramelized onions, roasted red peppers, mushrooms, black olives, and spring mix, with balsamic mayo on a wheat ciabatta roll$9.25The East Ave Ham & Cheese
Maple Glazed Ham, gouda, onions, and pickles, with mayo and spicy mustard on Geddes white bread$11.25The C.C.B.
corned beef, swiss, caramelized onions, and roasted red peppers, with chipotle mayo on Geddes marble rye$12.75
Specialty Wraps
The Buffalo Tender
chicken tenders, lettuce, and tomato, with ranch dressing and hot sauce, on a jalapeño cheddar wrap$12.75The Empire
Cracked Peppermill Smoked Turkey, bacon, cheddar, apple, and spring mix, with cranberry mayo, on a spinach wrap$12.50The Veggie
carrots, cucumbers, lettuce, tomato, onion, and spring mix, with roasted garlic mayo and balsamic vinaigrette, on a roasted red pepper wrap$7.75The Cobb
grilled chicken, bacon, hard-boiled egg, lettuce, tomato, and onion, with blue cheese dressing on a wheat wrap$13.75
Green Salads
The Julius
homemade croutons and parmesan cheese, on romaine lettuce, with caesar dressing$7.00The Basic
cucumbers, tomato, red onion, shredded carrots, and black olives, on romaine and spring mix blend, with choice of dressing$8.00The Sweater Weather
dried cranberries, toasted pumpkin seeds, walnuts, and red onions, on spring mix with balsamic vinaigrette$8.00
Design Your Own
Whole Sandwich
Fresh Geddes Bakery bread with your choice of meat, cheese, vegetables, and spreads$10.50Half Sandwich
Fresh Geddes Bakery bread with your choice of meat, cheese, vegetables, and spreads$7.00Whole Sub
Fresh Geddes Bakery sub roll with your choice of meat, cheese, vegetables, and spreads$13.00Half Sub
Fresh Geddes Bakery sub roll with your choice of meat, cheese, vegetables, and spreads$8.00Wrap
Any flavor wrap with your choice of meat, cheese, vegetables, and spreads$11.50
Smokin' Bill's BBQ
Pulled Pork Sandwich
Smoked pulled pork on a toasted brioche roll, with BBQ sauce on the side$10.50Pulled Pork Dinner
Smoked pulled pork, choice of 2 sides, with BBQ sauce on the side$12.50Beef Brisket Sandwich
Smoked beef brisket on a toasted brioche bun, with BBQ sauce on the side$12.50Beef Brisket Dinner
Smoked beef brisket, choice of 2 sides, with BBQ sauce on the side$14.50
Specials & Secret Menu
The Oneida
Maple Glazed Ham, Swiss Cheese, cucumber, tomato, and spring mix, with honey mustard on a toasted wheat ciabatta$11.25The Firecracker Wrap
Ovengold Turkey, Pepperjack Cheese, red onions, roasted red peppers, banana peppers, and spring mix with firecracker sauce on a white wrap, grilled on the panini press$12.50BLT
$10.50Half BLT
$6.25Grilled Cheese
$7.50Half Grilled Cheese
$4.25Reuben
$12.75Half Reuben
$6.75The Tuna Melt
$10.50
Hot Items
Homemade Mac & Cheese
Sharp Cheddar and American cheese melted together in our homemade sauce mixed up with cavatappi pasta$5.25+Chicken Tenders
$7.75+French Fries
$4.00+Homemade Kettle Chips
Sliced potatoes fried to order and tossed with Bill's seasoned salt$4.00+Onion Rings
$5.00+Sweet Potato Fries
$4.50+Hofmann's Frank
CNY's favorite hot dog on a butter toasted New England Style roll; served with ketchup, mustard and relish on the side$4.00+BBQ Mac & Cheese
Our homemade mac & cheese topped with Smokin' Bill's BBQ pulled pork, bbq sauce, and scallions$10.00Buffalo Mac & Cheese
Our homemade mac & cheese topped with crispy chicken tender, hot sauce, and scallions$10.00
Deli Salad
Chips & Cookies
Maple & Honey
Elderberry Jelly
$4.00Honey Comb
$6.00Honey 1 lb
$8.50Honey Squeeze Bear
$7.00Raw Honey
$17.50Maple Plastic Half Pint
$4.50Maple Plastic Pint
$8.00Maple Plastic Quart
$13.00Maple Plastic Half Gallon
$24.00Maple Plastic Gallon
$42.00Maple Glass Leaf 250mL
$9.00Maple Glass 8.5 oz
$6.00Maple Glass 16.9 oz
$9.50Maple Glass 33.8 oz
$15.00Maple Glass 64 oz
$25.00
Lobby Items
Amish Brittle
$5.50Tom's Bootleg BBQ Sauce
$8.75Roasted Red Peppers
$4.25Chipotle Peppers
$2.80
Pickle Bucket
5 gal plastic bucket that used to hold pickles, could now be used for rocks, chicken feed, garden tools, or even more pickles!$2.00Boar's Head - Half Pounds
$4.39+T Shirt
Show off your dedication to high quality lunch with these premium tees from our friends at One Mission Printing!$25.00+
Beverages Menu
Beverages
Coca-Cola
$2.75Diet Coke
$2.75Cherry Coke
$2.75Barq's Root Beer
$2.75Boylan Soda
$3.75Beak & Skiff Apple Cider
$4.00Canada Dry Ginger Ale
$2.75Canada Dry Sparkling Water
$2.75
Dasani Water
$2.25Diet Dr. Pepper
$2.75Dr. Pepper
$2.75
Fairlife Chocolate Milk
$3.25
Fairlife Strawberry Milk
$3.25Fanta Orange Soda
$2.75
Fresca
$2.75Gold Peak Rasberry
$3.00
Gold Peak Tea & Lemonade
$3.00
Gold Peak Unsweetened
$3.00Joe Tea
$3.75Mexican Coke
$3.75Minute Maid Lemonade
$2.75Minute Maid Cran Apple Rasp
$2.90
Smart Water
$3.25Sprite
$2.75Vitamin Water XXX
$3.00
Vitamin Water Focus
$3.00
Vitamin Water Energy
$3.00
Vitamin Water Refresh
$3.00
Vitamin Water Elevate
$3.00
Poland Springs 20oz
$2.00
Gold Peak Green Tea
$3.00Smart Water Alkaline
$3.50Topo Chico
$3.50Jarritos
$2.75Maine Root Beer
$3.75
All hours
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday | 11:00 am - 6:00 pm |
| Tuesday | 11:00 am - 6:00 pm |
| Wednesday | 11:00 am - 6:00 pm |
| Thursday | 11:00 am - 6:00 pm |
| Friday | 11:00 am - 7:00 pm |
| Saturday | 11:00 am - 3:00 pm |
Restaurant info
🥪Specialty Sandwiches and Wraps 🥗Fresh Salads 🥣Hot Soups 🍨Homemade Ice Cream
Location
3027 East Ave, Central Square, NY 13036
Similar restaurants in your area
© 2026 Toast, Inc.










