Skip to Main content
  • East of Chicago Pizza - Lima Lima

    • Home
    • /
    • Lima
    • /
    • East of Chicago Pizza
    Restaurant banner image
    pizza, wings, sandwiches

    East of Chicago Pizza

    2899 West Elm Street

    Lima, OH 45805


    Orders through Toast are commission free and go directly to this restaurant


    Call

    Hours

    Directions

    Beverages
    Pizzas
    Wings
    Oven Baked Subs
    No Crust Pizza Bowl
    Salads
    Great Additions
    Desserts
    Veggie Sides
    Sauces

    Featured Items

    • Pizza Foldover

      $7.49
    • Pizza Sub

      $5.49+
    • CinnaPOPs

      $4.99

    Beverages

    • 20oz Bottle

      $2.15
    • 2 Liter

      $3.29

    Pizzas

    6" Flash Pan Pizzas

    • 6" Build Your Own Pizza

      $4.49
    • 6" Just Cheese

      $4.49
    • 6" All Meat

      $6.99
    • 6" BBQ Chicken

      $6.99
    • 6" BLT

      $6.99
    • 6" Buffalo Chicken

      $6.99
    • 6" Chicago Melt

      $6.99
    • 6" Chicken Bacon Ranch

      $6.99
    • 6" Deluxe

      $6.99
    • 6" Kicken Chicken

      $6.99
    • 6" Taco w/ Meat or Chicken

      $6.99
    • 6" 7 Layer Veggie

      $6.99
    • 6" Hawaiian

      $6.99
    • 6" The Tower

      $8.99

    9" Small Pizzas

    • 9" Build Your Own Pizza

      $8.49
    • 9" Just Cheese

      $8.49
    • 9" All Meat

      $11.99
    • 9" BBQ Chicken

      $11.99
    • 9" BLT

      $11.99
    • 9" Buffalo Chicken

      $11.99
    • 9" Chicago Melt

      $11.99
    • 9" Chicken Bacon Ranch

      $11.99
    • 9" Deluxe

      $11.99
    • 9" Kicken Chicken

      $11.99
    • 9" Taco w/ Meat or Chicken

      $11.99
    • 9" 7 Layer Veggie

      $11.99
    • 9" Hawaiian

      $11.99
    • 9" The Tower

      $13.99

    12" Medium Pizzas

    • 12" Build Your Own Pizza

      $10.99
    • 12" Just Cheese

      $10.99
    • 12" All Meat

      $15.99
    • 12" BBQ Chicken

      $15.99
    • 12" BLT

      $15.99
    • 12" Buffalo Chicken

      $15.99
    • 12" Chicago Melt

      $15.99
    • 12" Chicken Bacon Ranch

      $15.99
    • 12" Deluxe

      $15.99
    • 12" Hawaiian

      $15.99
    • 12" Kicken Chicken

      $15.99
    • 12" Taco w/ Meat or Chicken

      $15.99
    • 12" 7 Layer Veggie

      $15.99
    • 12" The Tower

      $17.99

    14" Large Pizzas

    • 14" Build Your Own Pizza

      $12.99
    • 14" Just Cheese

      $12.99
    • 14" All Meat

      $18.99
    • 14" BBQ Chicken

      $18.99
    • 14" BLT

      $18.99
    • 14" Buffalo Chicken

      $18.99
    • 14" Chicago Melt

      $18.99
    • 14" Chicken Bacon Ranch

      $18.99
    • 14" Deluxe

      $18.99
    • 14" Hawaiian

      $18.99
    • 14" Kicken Chicken

      $18.99
    • 14" Taco w/ Meat or Chicken

      $18.99
    • 14" 7 Layer Veggie

      $18.99
    • 14" The Tower

      $20.99

    16" Extra Large Pizzas

    • 16" Build Your Own Pizza

      $14.99
    • 16" Just Cheese

      $14.99
    • 16" All Meat

      $22.99
    • 16" BBQ Chicken

      $22.99
    • 16" BLT

      $22.99
    • 16" Buffalo Chicken

      $22.99
    • 16" Chicago Melt

      $22.99
    • 16" Chicken Bacon Ranch

      $22.99
    • 16" Deluxe

      $22.99
    • 16" Hawaiian

      $22.99
    • 16" Kicken Chicken

      $22.99
    • 16" Taco w/ Meat or Chicken

      $22.99
    • 16" 7 Layer Veggie

      $22.99
    • 16" The Tower

      $24.99

    16" Square Pizzas

    • 16" SQ Build Your Own Pizza

      $15.99
    • 16" SQ Just Cheese

      $15.99
    • 16" SQ All Meat

      $23.99
    • 16" SQ BBQ Chicken

      $23.99
    • 16" SQ BLT

      $23.99
    • 16" SQ Buffalo Chicken

      $23.99
    • 16" SQ Chicago Melt

      $23.99
    • 16" SQ Chicken Bacon Ranch

      $23.99
    • 16" SQ Deluxe

      $23.99
    • 16" SQ Hawaiian

      $23.99
    • 16" SQ Kicken Chicken

      $23.99
    • 16" SQ Taco w/ Meat or Chicken

      $23.99
    • 16" SQ 7 Layer Veggie

      $23.99
    • 16" SQ The Tower

      $25.99

    Wings

    • Regular Wings

      $12.99+
    • Boneless Wings

      $8.99+

    Oven Baked Subs

    • BLT

      $5.49+
    • Buffalo Chicken Sub

      $5.49+
    • Chicken Bacon Ranch Sub

      $5.49+
    • Deluxe Sub

      $5.49+
    • Fajita Chicken

      $5.49+
    • Ham & Cheese

      $5.49+
    • Italian

      $5.49+
    • Meatball

      $5.49+
    • Pizza Sub

      $5.49+
    • Steak

      $5.49+
    • 7 Layer Veggie Sub

      $5.49+
    • American

      $5.49+

    No Crust Pizza Bowl

    • Build Your Own Pizza Bowl

      $7.99
    • Specialty Pizza Bowl

      $8.99

    Salads

    • Buffalo Chicken Salad

      $7.49
    • Chef Salad

      $7.49
    • Grilled Chicken Salad

      $7.49
    • Taco Salad

      $7.49
    • Side Salad

      $3.49

    Great Additions

    • ParmPOPs

      $4.99
    • Fiesta for Two

      $7.99
    • Chips & Cheese

      $3.99
    • Garlic Cheese Bread

      $3.99+
    • Pizza Foldover

      $7.49
    • Breadsticks

      $2.99+
    • Fiesta for Four

      $11.99
    • Chips & Salsa

      $3.99
    • Garlic Pizza Bread

      $8.99
    • Extra Dressing

      $0.75
    • Lays Classic

      $1.00

    Desserts

    • Peanut Butter & Jelly Pizza

      $9.99+
    • Dutch Crunch

      $9.99+
    • CinnaPOPs

      $4.99
    • Chewy Chocolate Chip Cookie

      $5.99
    • Double Chocolate Pizza Brownie

      $5.99
    • Apple Pops

      $4.99

    Veggie Sides

    Banana Peppers

    • Banana Peppers

      $0.75

    Black Olives

    • Black Olives

      $0.75

    Green Olives

    • Green Olives

      $0.75

    Green Peppers

    • Green Peppers

      $0.75

    Jalapenos

    • Jalapenos

      $0.75

    Mushrooms

    • Mushrooms

      $0.75

    Onions

    • Onions

      $0.75

    Pineapple

    • Pineapple

      $0.75

    Tomatoes

    • Tomatoes

      $0.75

    Sauces

    Sour Cream

    • Sour Cream

      $0.75

    BBQ

    • BBQ

      $0.75

    BBQ Ranch

    • BBQ Ranch

      $0.75

    Garlic Butter

    • Garlic Butter

      $0.75

    Hot Sauce

    • Hot Sauce

      $0.75

    Marinara

    • Marinara

      $0.75

    Mild

    • Mild

      $0.75

    Nacho Cheese

    • Nacho Cheese

      $0.75

    Pizza Sauce

    • Pizza Sauce

      $0.75

    Ranch

    • Ranch

      $0.75

    Zesty BBQ

    • Zesty BBQ

      $0.75

    Zesty Garlic

    • Zesty Garlic

      $0.75

    Salsa

    • Salsa

      $0.75

    Garlic Parm

    • Garlic Parm

      $0.75

    All hours
    Sunday10:45 am - 8:45 pm
    Monday10:45 am - 8:45 pm
    Tuesday10:45 am - 8:45 pm
    Wednesday10:45 am - 8:45 pm
    Thursday10:45 am - 8:45 pm
    Friday10:45 am - 8:45 pm
    Saturday10:45 am - 8:45 pm
    Restaurant info

    In 1991, East of Chicago Pizza was founded on our signature fresh pan pizza, devotion to quality, and the belief customers deserve the best tasting pizza with every bite. We believe our commitment to these three principles is the driving force behind our growth and success.

    Location

    2899 West Elm Street, Lima, OH 45805

    Directions

    © 2026 Toast, Inc.
    Toast
    • About Toast
    • For restaurants
    • Terms of Service
    • Privacy Statement
    • Do not sell my
      personal information
    Made with love in Boston
    • Instagram
    • X (formerly Twitter)
    • Facebook