Skip to Main content
  • Erie Island Coffee Co.

    • Home
    • /
    • Elyria
    • /
    • Erie Island Coffee - Elyria
    Restaurant banner image
    American

    Erie Island Coffee - Elyria

    148 Middle Ave

    Elyria, OH 44035


    Orders through Toast are commission free and go directly to this restaurant


    Call

    Hours

    Directions

    Gift Cards

    DRINKS
    FOOD
    RETAIL
    ‌
    ‌

    Featured Items

    • E.I.C. Classic

      Bacon, sausage, or turkey sausage - plain bagel - scrambled eggs - cheddar cheese
      $5.79
    • The S.O.B. (South of the Border)

      Flour tortilla - scrambled eggs, pepper jack cheese, chorizo sausage, tomatoes, jalapenos - chipotle mayo
      $7.29
    • Blueberry Cinnamon Crumble

      $2.69+

    DRINKS

    Brewed Coffees

    • Signature House Blend Coffee

      Hint of cocoa and the sweet aroma of medium roast
      $2.69+
    • Jamiacan Me Crazy Coffee

      Lightly roasted Latin American beans - A delightful sensory treat.
      $2.69+
    • Blueberry Cinnamon Crumble

      $2.69+
    • Decaf House Blend Coffee

      This blend boasts a full, complex body, low acidity, and a soft finish with hints of cocoa.
      $2.69+
    • Cafe Creme

      Brewed Coffee with steamed milk
      $3.80+
    • Red Eye

      Brewed Coffee with a shot of Espresso
      $3.20+
    • Coffee- No Cup

      $2.49
    • Butter Pecan

      Light Roasted Arabica blend with flavors of vanilla, rich butter, and roasted pecans
      $2.69+

    Espresso Specialties

    • Lattee

      Double shot of espresso with steamed milk (little bit of foam)
      $4.35+
    • Cappuccino

      Double shot of espresso, steamed milk with a thick layer of milk foam on top
      $4.20+
    • Americano

      Erie Island espresso and hot water
      $3.80+
    • Mocha - Dark or White Chocolate

      Double shot of espresso, steamed milk and mocha sauce
      $4.95+
    • Caramel Daddy

      Caramel sauce, steamed milk with a thick layer of foam topped with a double shot of espresso
      $5.20+
    • Cortado

      $4.75

    Classics

    • Cappuccino - 6oz.

      Double shot of Erie Island espresso with a dollop of milk foam
      $3.75
    • Latte - 6oz

      Double shot of Erie Island espresso with 4oz of steamed milk
      $3.75
    • Espresso

      $2.75+
    • Macchiato

      Erie Island espresso with a splash of steamed milk and a thick layer of milk foam
      $3.00+

    Other Offerings

    • Hot Chocolate

      $3.45+
    • Hot Chai Latte

      Chai with steamed milk
      $4.50+
    • Hot Tea - Steep Organic Tea

      $3.00+
    • Kids Hot Cocoa - 8oz

      $2.75
    • Kids Milk - 8oz

      $2.69
    • London Fog

      Earl grey tea with steamed milk and vanilla syrup
      $4.50+

    Iced Coffees

    • Iced Coffee

      Black iced coffee
      $3.90+
    • Iced Latte

      Double shot of Erie Island espresso over ice with milk
      $4.85+
    • Iced Mocha - Dark or White Chocolate

      Mocha sauce, double shot of Erie Island espresso over ice with milk
      $5.45+
    • Iced Red Eye

      Black iced coffee with a single shot of Erie Island espresso
      $4.70+
    • Iced Caramel Daddy

      Caramel syrup with milk over ice, topped with a double shot of Erie Island espresso and caramel drizzle
      $5.60+
    • Iced Americano

      Erie Island espresso and water over ice
      $3.90+

    Cold Brews

    • Cold Brew Espresso (Toddy)

      Cold brewed coffee steeped in cold water for 24 hours
      $4.90+
    • Nitro Cold Brew

      $5.45
    • Nitro Reese's Cup

      Peanut butter and mocha syrups with cold brew coffee topped with cold foam
      $5.75
    • Nitro Salted Caramel

      Salted caramel syrup with cold brew, topped with cold foam
      $5.75
    • Nitro Vanilla Sweet Cream

      Vanilla syrup with cold brew coffee topped with cold foam
      $5.75

    Blended Coffees

    • Mocha Frappe - Dark or White Chocolate

      Dark or White Mocha sauce with Ghirardelli Frappe base and cold brew coffee topped with whipped cream
      $5.70+
    • Caramel Frappe

      Caramel sauce with Ghirardelli Frappe base and cold brew coffee topped with whipped cream
      $5.70+

    Iced Teas

    • Iced Tea - Traditional

      $3.60+
    • Iced Tea - Green

      OUT OF STOCK
      $3.60+
    • Iced Chai

      Chai with milk over ice
      $4.95+
    • Boba Tea

      $5.85+

    Smoothies

    • Breakfast Smoothie

      Banana, strawberries, oats, protein powder (V), peanut butter, milk
      $5.75
    • Banana Matcha

      Banana, matcha powder, spinach, flax seed, vanilla, almond milk
      OUT OF STOCK
      $5.50
    • P.B. Cold Brew

      Banana, peanut butter, protein powder (V), cold brew coffee, almond milk
      $6.25
    • Going Green

      Grapes, pineapple, banana, spinach
      $5.00
    • Triple Berry

      Mixed Berry, Banana, Chia seeds, Protein powder, Almond Milk
      $6.00
    • Smoothie Add - On's

      OUT OF STOCK

    Bottled Beverages

    • 20oz Coca-Cola Products

      $2.79
    • Minute Maid Juice

      $3.55
    • Dasani Water, Bottle

      Enhanced with minerals for a crisp, clean and fresh taste
      $2.29
    • Red Bull

      $2.95
    • S/F Red Bull

      $2.95
    • Monster Energy Drinks

      $3.25
    • BODYARMOR

      $3.09
    • Gold Peak Sweetened Black Tea, 18.5oz

      Sweetened with real cane sugar for a deliciously real brewed sweet tea
      $3.09

    Specialty Drinks

    Specialty drink flavors created by Erie Island Baristas
    • Barista’s Choice Latte

      Let our Baristas surprise you with their own creations. Please note if you have any flavor dislikes or allergies.
      $5.60+
    • The Padawan

      A latte with honey and lavender
      $5.60+
    • Beskar Brew Latte

      A Latte with white chocolate, blueberry, and vanilla
      $5.60+
    • I am your Father Latte

      A Latte with mocha and toasted marshmallow
      $5.60+
    • The Foundling Latte

      A latte with a cupcake and vanilla
      $5.60+
    • The High Ground Latte

      A Chai Latte with white mocha, hazelnut, and cookie dough
      $5.60+
    • The Balance Latte

      A Latte with white mocha and dark mocha
      $5.60+
    • Maple Sea Salt Latte

      A Latte with Maple and Sea Salt
      $5.60+
    • Snickers Latte

      A Latte with Caramel, Chocolate, Hazelnut
      $5.60+
    • Salted Caramel Crème Latte

      Salted Caramel, Splash of Heavy Cream, Sea Salt
      $5.60+
    • Tagalong Latte

      Mocha, Peanut Butter and Vanilla
      $5.60+
    • Samoa Latte

      Mocha, Coconut, Caramel drizzle
      $5.60+
    • Reese’s Latte

      Mocha, Peanut Butter
      $5.60+
    • Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough Latte

      Mocha, Cookie Dough
      $5.60+
    • Honey Bee Latte

      Vanilla, Banana and Honey
      $5.60+
    • Toasted Coconut Latte

      Coconut, Toasted Marshmallow, Honey drizzle
      $5.60+
    • Rocky Road Latte

      Mocha, Caramel, Toasted Marshmallow, Hazelnut
      $5.60+
    • Barista's Choice Chai

      Chai with maple and
      $5.05+
    • Lavender Sunset Latte

      Lavender and toasted marshmallow
      $5.60+
    • Cookie Butter Latte

      Banana, mocha, vanilla, cherry
      $5.60+
    • Banana Bread Latte

      Banana, Brown sugar cinnamon, vanilla and cinnamon powder
      $5.60+
    • French Toast Latte

      Maple, caramel, brown sugar cinnamon and cinnamon powder
      $5.60+
    • French Toast Chai

      Chai with maple, caramel, vanilla and cinnamon powder
      $5.05+
    • The High Ground Latte

      A Chai Latte with white mocha, hazelnut, and cookie dough
      $5.60+
    • Butterbeer Latte

      Butterscotch, caramel, English toffee
      $5.60+
    • The Foundling Latte

      A latte with a cupcake and vanilla
      $5.60+
    • Mostly Ghostly Latte

      White mocha and toasted marshmallow
      $5.60+
    • Red Velvet Latte

      Mocha, vanilla and a splash of heavy cream
      $5.60+
    • Sweetheart Latte

      White mocha and lavender
      $5.60+
    • Puppy Love Latte

      Peanut butter, honey and cinnamon powder
      $5.60+
    • Mistletoe Latte

      White mocha and raspberry
      $5.60+
    • Nutella Latte

      Mocha and hazelnut
      $5.60+
    • Tuxedo Mocha Latte

      Dark and white mocha
      $5.60+
    • Cinnamon Roll Latte

      $5.60+
    • Lucky Charms Latte

      Toasted marshmallow and vanilla
      $5.60+
    • Pot O’ Gold Latte

      Honey, vanilla and hazelnut
      $5.60+
    • Shamrock Latte

      Mint, mocha, cookie dough
      $5.60+
    • Luck O’ the Irish Latte

      Irish cream and vanilla
      $5.60+
    • Irish Cream Cold Brew

      Cold Brew, Irish cream, cold foam
      $6.45+
    • Birthday Cake Latte

      White Mocha and Cookie Dough
      $5.60+
    • Smores Latte

      Dark Mocha, Toasted Marshmallow and Brown Sugar Cinnamon
      $5.60+
    • Lavender Fields Latte

      Lavender and Vanilla
      $5.60+
    • Pistachio Ice Cream Latte

      White Mocha, Pistachio and Vanilla
      $5.60+
    • Gingerbread Chai

      Chai with Toffee syrup and Cinnamon
      $5.05+
    • The Grace Latte

      A Latte with White Chocolate, Maple, and Cookie Dough
      $5.60+
    • Kat’s Chai

      A Chai with Maple, Peanut Butter, and Cinnamon Powder
      $5.05+
    • Honey Bunny Latte

      A Latte with White Chocolate, Honey and Cinnamon Powder
      $5.60+
    • Peeps Latte

      A Latte with Toasted Marshmallow and Vanilla
      $5.60+
    • Spring Showers Latte

      A Latte with Blueberry & Toasted Marshmallow
      $5.60+
    • Easter Bunny Latte

      A Latte with Chocolate, Vanilla, and Toasted Marshmallow
      $5.60+
    • Pumpkin Pie Latte

      A Latte with Pumpkin and vanilla
      $5.60+
    • Fall Harvest Latte

      A Latte with maple and white mocha
      $5.60+
    • Blueberry Cinnamon Latte

      A Latte with blueberry, cinnamon
      $5.60+
    • Maple Cookie Chai

      A Chai with maple and cookie dough
      $5.05+
    • Brownie Batter Latte

      A Latte with vanilla and dark mocha
      $5.60+
    • Toasted Coconut Latte

      A Latte with coconut, toast marshmallow and honey
      $5.60+
    • Banana Split Latte

      A Latte with banana, chocolate vanilla and cherry
      $5.60+
    • Pumpkin Cinnamon Roll Latte

      A Latte with pumpkin, cinnamon powder, vanilla and white mocha
      $5.60+
    • Expresso Patronus Latte

      A Latte with white chocolate and maple
      $5.60+
    • Halloweentown Chai

      A Chai with pumpkin
      $5.05+
    • RedRum Latte

      A Latte with apple, vanilla and cinnamon powder
      $5.60+
    • Salted Caramel Cookie Dough Latte

      A Latte with carmel, cookie dough, and hazelnut
      $5.60+
    • Winter Spice Latte

      A Latter with white mocha, cookie butter and cinnamon powder
      $5.60+
    • Santa Claus Latte

      A Latte with peppermint, and mocha of your choice
      $5.60+
    • Hershey (Kiss Me) I’m Irish Latte

      A Latte with white chocolate and irish cream
      $5.60+
    • Frosty the Snowman Latte

      A Latte with coconut, white mocha and toasted marshmallow
      $5.60+
    • Coconut Chai

      A Chai with coconut
      $5.05+
    • Rudolph Chai

      A Chai with toffee and cinnamon
      $5.05+
    • Cadbury Crème Latte

      A Latte with dark mocha, caramel and white mocha
      $5.60+
    • Snowball Latte

      A latte with vanilla and toasted marshmallow
      $5.60+
    • Love Potion #9 Latte

      A Latte with mocha, hazelnut and cookie dough
      $5.60+
    • Cupid Mocha Latte

      A Latte with your choice of mocha with raspberry
      $5.60+
    • Cupid’s Arrow Cappuccino

      A Cappuccino marshmallow and cinnamon powder
      $4.75+
    • Cookie Chai

      A Chai with cookie dough
      $5.05+
    • The Grinch Latte

      A Latte with salted caramel and cookie dough
      $5.60+
    • Ohana Latte

      $5.60+
    • Hunny Pot Latte

      A latte with honey and butterscotch
      $5.60+
    • Mad Hatter Latte

      A latte with mocha, raspberry, and toasted marshmallow
      $5.60+
    • Posion Apple Latte

      a latte with apple and caramel
      $5.60+
    • Mushu’s Fire Chai Latte

      A chai latte with maple and cinnamon
      $5.10+
    • Pixie Dust Latte

      A latte with white mocha, cookie, butter, and cinnamon powder
      $5.60+

    FOOD

    Bottled Beverages

    • 20oz Coca-Cola Products

      $2.79
    • Minute Maid Juice

      $3.55
    • Dasani Water, Bottle

      Enhanced with minerals for a crisp, clean and fresh taste
      $2.29
    • Red Bull

      $2.95
    • S/F Red Bull

      $2.95

    Breakfast - Available ALL DAY

    Our freshly cracked eggs are cooked to order. No frozen egg patties..no microwaves
    • E.I.C. Classic

      Bacon, sausage, or turkey sausage - plain bagel - scrambled eggs - cheddar cheese
      $5.79
    • The S.O.B. (South of the Border)

      Flour tortilla - scrambled eggs, pepper jack cheese, chorizo sausage, tomatoes, jalapenos - chipotle mayo
      $7.29
    • Avocado Toast

      toasted honey wheat - avocado mash -over easy egg- chili seasoning
      $6.29
    • Tower Omelette

      3 eggs - cheddar cheese - peppers - onions - bacon, sausage or turkey sausage - choice of toast (Italian, honey wheat or marble rye)
      $8.69
    • Hammy Sandwich

      Ham - scrambled egg - Swiss cheese -toasted honey wheat
      $7.09
    • Veggie Omelette

      3 eggs - feta cheese - spinach - tomatoes - peppers - onions - portobella mushroom - Choice of toast (Italian, honey wheat or marble rye)
      $8.39
    • Biscuits & Sausage Gravy

      2 buttermilk biscuits, sausage gravy, 2 over easy eggs, parsley
      $8.50
    • Biscuits & Sausage Gravy - NO EGGS

      2 buttermilk biscuits, sausage gravy, parsley
      $7.00
    • Steak Egg & Cheese Bagel

      Everything bagel - shaved ribeye - sauteed onions - american cheese - steak aioli
      $7.99

    Lunch

    • Craven

      Toasted marble rye - house made chicken salad - lettuce - tomato - bacon
      $7.20
    • B.E.L.T.

      Ciabatta - bacon - lettuce - tomato - fried egg - mayo
      $7.35
    • Turquia Assault

      Oven roasted turkey - pepper jack cheese - tomato - lettuce - avocado mash - jalapenos - flour tortilla
      $7.45
    • Boom!

      Marinated portobella mushrooms - roasted red peppers - caramelized onions - balsamic mayo - Ciabatta
      $7.20
    • Saltly Gorlami

      Salami - ham - bacon - banana peppers - balsamic mayo - provolone - Italian bread
      $7.70
    • California

      Toasted honey wheat - tomatoes - caramelized onions - avocado mash - hard-boiled egg - provolone cheese
      $7.20
    • Studio 54

      Everything bagel - ham - turkey - bacon - American & Swiss cheeses - mayo
      $7.45
    • 3D Pesto Panini

      Italian bread - turkey - lettuce - tomato - provolone - basil mayo
      $7.45
    • Grilled Buffalo Chicken Wrap

      Grilled buffalo chicken breast - pepper jack & cheddar cheese - lettuce - tomato - flour tortilla
      $7.95
    • Cuban

      Panini pressed Cuban bread - sliced ham - shredded pork - dill pickles - mustard sauce - swiss cheese
      $8.00
    • Hot Pastrami Sandwich

      Slow cooked pastrami - marble rye - sliced pickles - Dijonnaise - Swiss cheese
      $8.20
    • Roast Beef Sandwich

      Deli-style roast beef - Italian bread - cheddar cheese - lettuce - tomato - mayo
      $7.95

    Salads

    • Chef

      Mixed greens, turkey, ham, mozzarella, egg, croutons, tomato, avocado mash
      $7.89
    • Caesar

      Romain, parmesan, croutons
      $6.09
    • Greek

      Mixed greens, feta cheese, olives, cucumber, tomatoes
      $6.80
    • Spinach

      Spinach leaves, mozzarella, eggs, tomatoes, bacon
      $6.80

    Add- Ons

    • Bacon - 3 Slices

      $3.20
    • Sausage Patties - 2 Slices

      $3.75
    • Ham

      $2.75
    • Diced Tomatoes

      $0.25
    • Spinach

      $0.59
    • Cheddar Cheese

      $0.89
    • Scrambled Eggs (2)

      $3.70
    • Toast

      $1.79
    • Turkey

      $3.00
    • 1 EGG

      $2.00
    • EICC Side Avocado

      OUT OF STOCK
      $1.00
    • Chicken Salad - 8oz

      $5.00
    • Granola - 8oz

      $2.99
    • Granola - 4oz

      $1.49

    Soup

    • Pepper stuffed w/ Beef

      THIS SPIN ON A CLASSIC DISH COMBINES GREEN PEPPERS, GROUND BEEF, RICE, SPANISH ONIONS AND DICED TOMATOES IN A TASTY AU JUS BROTH.
      $5.30+
    • Chicken Noodle

      An all-American classic. Tender cuts of white chicken coupled with thick Kluski egg noodles accented with carrots, onions, and celery in a rich, homestyle chicken broth.
      $5.35+
    • Broccoli Cheddar

      A hearty combination of broccoli florets in a rich creamy cheddar cheese soup
      $6.15+
    • Italian Wedding Soup

      Mini Italian-Style meatballs, Acine de Pepe pasta, spinach, carrots and Romano cheese accentuated in a rich seasoned chicken broth
      $5.60+
    • Baked Potato Soup

      HEARTY CHUNKS OF FARM-FRESH POTATOES FLAVORED WITH REAL BACON AND ONIONS IN A RICH HOMESTYLE BROTH MADE WITH REAL BUTTER AND CREAM.
      $5.50+

    Other Goodies

    • Bagel- Toasted w/ Butter & Jelly

      $2.35
    • Bagel - Toasted w/ Cream Cheese

      $3.99
    • Vanilla Yogurt w/ Fresh Fruit Parfait

      $4.65
    • Fresh Fruit Mix

      $4.95
    • Hard Boiled Egg

      $1.50
    • Chips- Miss Vikies

      Gluten Free
      $1.69
    • Dessert Bar - Mount Caramel Oatmeal

      $4.60
    • Dessrt Bar - 7 Layer

      OUT OF STOCK
      $4.60
    • Dessert Bar - Raspberry Rhapsody

      OUT OF STOCK
      $4.60
    • Dessert Bar -Old Fashioned Lemon

      OUT OF STOCK
      $4.60
    • Muffin - Blueberry

      Our blueberry buttermilk muffin is loaded with juicy Georgia wild blueberries and a touch of creamy buttermilk topped with coarse sugar for a nice crunch. With a perfect crumb finish each 4 oz. muffin contains no artificial ingredients
      $3.40
    • Muffin - Apple Cinnamon

      This muffin is filled with delicious Michigan Rome apples and has cinnamon chips throughout. Topped with crumbly streusel each 4 oz. muffin contains no artificial ingediants . Our baking process delivers the perfect crown for this gourmet version of an old favorite every time.
      $3.40
    • Muffin - Double Chocolate Muffin

      Few things in life are more tempting than a soft fresh-baked muffin. Using premium semi-sweet Belgian chocolate chips our double chocolate muffin is finished with cinnamon streusel and chocolate chunks. With a perfect crumb finish each 4 oz. muffin contains no artificial ingredients
      $3.40
    • Cookie - Hershey's Chocolate

      DECADENT TO SAY THE LEAST! THIS COOKIE IS MADE FROM DAVID'S FAMOUS CHOCOLATE CHUNK COOKIE DOUGH THEN GENEROUSLY TOPPED WITH HERSHEY'S KISSES, SEMI SWEET CHUNKS AND MILK CHOCOLATE CHUNKS
      $2.79
    • Cookie - Reese's Peanut Butter

      PEANUT BUTTER LOVERS BEWARE. THIS OVERSIZED COOKIE IS MADE WITH BROKEN PIECES OF REAL REESE'S PEANUT BUTTER CUPS AND REESE'S PEANUT BUTTER CHIPS. A MEMORABLE EXPERIENCE THAT KEEPS THEM COMING BACK FOR MORE
      $2.79
    • Fudge brownie

      A rich chocolate fudge brownie with chocolate drizzle
      $3.99
    • Cake -Chocolate Banana Swirled

      To make the batter we used ripened whole bananas midnight cocoa and semi-sweet chocolate to give this must-have delight its balanced flavor. Each tempting 4 oz. slice was made without high-fructose corn syrup artificial flavors or preservatives. Delectable with breakfast coffee and throughout the day on a plate or on the go it satisfies a person’s sweet tooth any time of day or night.
      $3.95
    • Cake - Iced Lemon Loaf

      Made using the juice of fresh California lemons this pre-sliced treat is moist and lemony with a tangy-sweet lemon icing. Each tempting 4 oz. slice was made without high-fructose corn syrup artificial flavors or preservatives. Delectable with breakfast coffee and throughout the day on a plate or on the go it satisfies a person’s sweet tooth any time of day or night.
      $4.29
    • Cake - Cinnamon Coffee

      Made with real ingredients like butter brown sugar and sour cream these cakes look taste and feel like a homemade treat. Delectable with breakfast coffee and throughout the day on a plate or on the go it satisfies a person’s sweet tooth any time of day or night.
      $4.79
    • Cake - Pound Cake

      Moist and tender large buttery pound cake.
      $2.49
    • Cheese Danish

      Authentic hand-formed Danish dough with generous cream cheese filling, finished with a sweet drizzle of icing
      $4.09

    RETAIL

    12oz Ground Coffee

    • Signature Blend

      $13.95
    • Morning Blend 3

      $13.95
    • French Roast

      $13.95
    • Craftsman

      $13.95

    All hours
    Sunday7:30 am - 1:45 pm
    Monday6:30 am - 3:45 pm
    Tuesday6:30 am - 3:45 pm
    Wednesday6:30 am - 3:45 pm
    Thursday6:30 am - 3:45 pm
    Friday6:30 am - 3:45 pm
    Saturday7:30 am - 1:45 pm
    Restaurant info

    Come in and enjoy!

    Location

    148 Middle Ave, Elyria, OH 44035

    Directions


    Similar restaurants in your area

    Foundry Kitchen & Bar
    View restaurantnext
    Cozzeria Pizzeria Elyria, OH
    View restaurantnext
    Top Fish and Chicken 1509 Grafton Road
    View restaurantnext
    Dirty Donkey Tavern & Grill
    View restaurantnext
    Dawg House Bar & Grill
    View restaurantnext
    Whisky Barn Grill 11043 Durkee Road
    View restaurantnext
    Search similar restaurants
    © 2026 Toast, Inc.
    Toast
    • About Toast
    • For restaurants
    • Terms of Service
    • Privacy Statement
    • Do not sell my
      personal information
    Made with love in Boston
    • Instagram
    • X (formerly Twitter)
    • Facebook