Skip to Main content
Add-on’s to drinks & food that are typed in and not charged will not added to your item
  • Erie Island Coffee Co.

    Erie Island Coffee Co.
    • Home
    • /
    • Elyria
    • /
    • Erie Island Coffee - Elyria
    Restaurant banner image
    Coffee Shop/Cafe

    Erie Island Coffee - Elyria

    148 Middle Ave

    Elyria, OH 44035


    Orders through Toast are commission free and go directly to this restaurant


    Call

    Hours

    Directions

    Gift Cards

    DRINKS
    FOOD
    RETAIL

    Featured Items

    • E.I.C. Classic

      Bacon, sausage, or turkey sausage - plain bagel - scrambled eggs - cheddar cheese

      $5.79
    • The S.O.B. (South of the Border)

      Flour tortilla - scrambled eggs, pepper jack cheese, chorizo sausage, tomatoes, jalapenos - chipotle mayo

      $7.29
    • Breakfast Smoothie

      Banana, strawberries, oats, protein powder (V), peanut butter, milk

      $5.75

    DRINKS

    Brewed Coffees

    • Signature House Blend Coffee

      Hint of cocoa and the sweet aroma of medium roast

      $2.69
    • Jamiacan Me Crazy Coffee

      Lightly roasted Latin American beans - A delightful sensory treat.

      $2.69
    • Blueberry Cinnamon Crumble

      $2.69
    • Decaf House Blend Coffee

      This blend boasts a full, complex body, low acidity, and a soft finish with hints of cocoa.

      $2.69
    • Cafe Creme

      Brewed Coffee with steamed milk

      $3.80
    • Red Eye

      Brewed Coffee with a shot of Espresso

      $3.20
    • Coffee- No Cup

      $2.49

    Espresso Specialties

    • Lattee

      Double shot of espresso with steamed milk (little bit of foam)

      $4.35
    • Cappuccino

      Double shot of espresso, steamed milk with a thick layer of milk foam on top

      $4.20
    • Americano

      Erie Island espresso and hot water

      $3.80
    • Mocha - Dark or White Chocolate

      Double shot of espresso, steamed milk and mocha sauce

      $4.95
    • Caramel Daddy

      Caramel sauce, steamed milk with a thick layer of foam topped with a double shot of espresso

      $5.20

    Classics

    • Cappuccino - 6oz.

      Double shot of Erie Island espresso with a dollop of milk foam

      $3.75
    • Latte - 6oz

      Double shot of Erie Island espresso with 4oz of steamed milk

      $3.75
    • Espresso

      $2.75
    • Macchiato

      Erie Island espresso with a splash of steamed milk and a thick layer of milk foam

      $3.00

    Other Offerings

    • Hot Chocolate

      $3.45
    • Hot Chai Latte

      Chai with steamed milk

      $4.50
    • Hot Tea - Steep Organic Tea

      $3.00
    • Kids Hot Cocoa - 8oz

      $2.75
    • Kids Milk - 8oz

      $2.69

    Iced Coffees

    • Iced Coffee

      Black iced coffee

      $3.90
    • Iced Latte

      Double shot of Erie Island espresso over ice with milk

      $4.85
    • Iced Mocha - Dark or White Chocolate

      Mocha sauce, double shot of Erie Island espresso over ice with milk

      $5.45
    • Iced Red Eye

      Black iced coffee with a single shot of Erie Island espresso

      $4.70
    • Iced Caramel Daddy

      Caramel syrup with milk over ice, topped with a double shot of Erie Island espresso and caramel drizzle

      $5.60
    • Iced Americano

      Erie Island espresso and water over ice

      $3.90

    Cold Brews

    • Cold Brew Espresso (Toddy)

      Cold brewed coffee steeped in cold water for 24 hours

      $4.90
    • Nitro Cold Brew

      $4.95
      OUT OF STOCK
    • Nitro Reese's Cup

      Peanut butter and mocha syrups with cold brew coffee topped with cold foam

      $5.25
      OUT OF STOCK
    • Nitro Salted Caramel

      Salted caramel syrup with cold brew, topped with cold foam

      $5.25
      OUT OF STOCK
    • Nitro Vanilla Sweet Cream

      Vanilla syrup with cold brew coffee topped with cold foam

      $5.25
      OUT OF STOCK

    Blended Coffees

    • Mocha Frappe - Dark or White Chocolate

      Dark or White Mocha sauce with Ghirardelli Frappe base and cold brew coffee topped with whipped cream

      $5.70
    • Caramel Frappe

      Caramel sauce with Ghirardelli Frappe base and cold brew coffee topped with whipped cream

      $5.70

    Iced Teas

    • Iced Tea - Traditional

      $3.60
    • Iced Tea - Green

      $3.60
    • Iced Chai

      Chai with milk over ice

      $4.95
    • Boba Tea

      $5.65

    Smoothies

    • Breakfast Smoothie

      Banana, strawberries, oats, protein powder (V), peanut butter, milk

      $5.75
    • Banana Matcha

      Banana, matcha powder, spinach, flax seed, vanilla, almond milk

      $5.50
      OUT OF STOCK
    • P.B. Cold Brew

      Banana, peanut butter, protein powder (V), cold brew coffee, almond milk

      $6.25
    • Going Green

      Grapes, pineapple, banana, spinach

      $5.00
      OUT OF STOCK
    • Triple Berry

      Chia seeds, Flax seed, Matcha powder, protein powder (V)

      $6.00
    • Smoothie Add - On's

      OUT OF STOCK

    Bottled Beverages

    • 20oz Coca-Cola Products

      $2.69
    • Minute Maid Juice

      $3.45
    • Dasani Bottled Water

      $2.09
    • Red Bull

      $2.85
    • S/F Red Bull

      $2.85
    • Monster Energy Drinks

      $3.19
    • Body Armour

      $2.99
    • Gold Peak Sweet Tea 18.5oz

      $2.99

    Specialty Drinks

    Specialty drink flavors created by Erie Island Baristas
    • Barista’s Choice Latte

      Let our Baristas surprise you with their own creations. Please note if you have any flavor dislikes or allergies.

      $5.60
    • Birthday Cake Latte

      White Mocha and Cookie Dough

      $5.60
    • Coconut Chai

      Chai with Coconut syrup

      $5.05
    • Lavender Fields Latte

      Lavender and Vanilla

      $5.60
    • Pistachio Ice Cream Latte

      White Mocha, Pistachio and Vanilla

      $5.60
    • S’mores Latte

      Dark Mocha, Toasted Marshmallow and Brown Sugar Cinnamon

      $5.60
    • The Grace

      Latte with a base of white chocolate mixed with maple and cookie dough. Our Barista Grace’s specialty drink (:

      $5.60
    • Maple Sea Salt Latte

      Maple, Sea Salt

      $5.60
    • Snickers Latte

      Caramel, Chocolate, Hazelnut

      $5.60
    • Salted Caramel Crème Latte

      Salted Caramel, Splash of Heavy Cream, Sea Salt

      $5.60
    • Tagalong Latte

      Mocha, Peanut Butter and Vanilla

      $5.60
    • Samoa Latte

      Mocha, Coconut, Caramel drizzle

      $5.60
    • Reese’s Latte

      Mocha, Peanut Butter

      $5.60
    • Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough Latte

      Mocha, Cookie Dough

      $5.60
    • Honey Bee Latte

      Vanilla, Banana and Honey

      $5.60
    • Toasted Coconut Latte

      Coconut, Toasted Marshmallow, Honey drizzle

      $5.60
    • Rocky Road Latte

      Mocha, Caramel, Toasted Marshmallow, Hazelnut

      $5.60
    • Maple Cookie Chai

      Chai with maple and cookie dough

      $5.05
    • Lavender Sunset Latte

      Lavender and toasted marshmallow

      $5.60
    • Banana Split Latte

      Banana, mocha, vanilla, cherry

      $5.60
    • Banana Bread Latte

      Banana, Brown sugar cinnamon, vanilla and cinnamon powder

      $5.60
    • French Toast Latte

      Maple, caramel, brown sugar cinnamon and cinnamon powder

      $5.60
    • French Toast Chai

      Chai with maple, caramel, vanilla and cinnamon powder

      $5.05
    • Caramel Apple Latte

      Caramel, apple and caramel drizzle

      $5.60
    • Butterbeer Latte

      Butterscotch, caramel, English toffee

      $5.60
    • Fall Harvest Latte

      White mocha and maple

      $5.60
    • Mostly Ghostly Latte

      White mocha and toasted marshmallow

      $5.60
    • Red Velvet Latte

      Mocha, vanilla and a splash of heavy cream

      $5.60
    • Sweetheart Latte

      White mocha and lavender

      $5.60
    • Puppy Love Latte

      Peanut butter, honey and cinnamon powder

      $5.60
    • Mistletoe Latte

      White mocha and raspberry

      $5.60
    • Nutella Latte

      Mocha and hazelnut

      $5.60
    • Tuxedo Mocha Latte

      Dark and white mocha

      $5.60
    • Cinnamon Roll Latte

      $5.60
    • Lucky Charms Latte

      Toasted marshmallow and vanilla

      $5.60
    • Pot O’ Gold Latte

      Honey, vanilla and hazelnut

      $5.60
    • Shamrock Latte

      Mint, mocha, cookie dough

      $5.60
    • Luck O’ the Irish Latte

      Irish cream and vanilla

      $5.60
    • Irish Cream Cold Brew

      Cold Brew, Irish cream, cold foam

      $6.45

    FOOD

    Bottled Beverages

    • 20oz Coca-Cola Products

      $2.69
    • Minute Maid Juice

      $3.45
    • Dasani Bottled Water

      $2.09
    • Red Bull

      $2.85
    • S/F Red Bull

      $2.85

    Breakfast - Available ALL DAY

    Our freshly cracked eggs are cooked to order. No frozen egg patties..no microwaves
    • E.I.C. Classic

      Bacon, sausage, or turkey sausage - plain bagel - scrambled eggs - cheddar cheese

      $5.79
    • The S.O.B. (South of the Border)

      Flour tortilla - scrambled eggs, pepper jack cheese, chorizo sausage, tomatoes, jalapenos - chipotle mayo

      $7.29
    • Avocado Toast

      toasted honey wheat - avocado mash -over easy egg- chili seasoning

      $6.29
    • Tower Omelette

      3 eggs - cheddar cheese - peppers - onions - bacon, sausage or turkey sausage - choice of toast (Italian, honey wheat or marble rye)

      $8.69
    • Hammy Sandwich

      Ham - scrambled egg - Swiss cheese -toasted honey wheat

      $7.09
    • Veggie Omelette

      3 eggs - feta cheese - spinach - tomatoes - peppers - onions - portobella mushroom - Choice of toast (Italian, honey wheat or marble rye)

      $8.39
    • Biscuits & Sausage Gravy

      2 buttermilk biscuits, sausage gravy, 2 over easy eggs, parsley

      $8.50
    • Biscuits & Sausage Gravy - NO EGGS

      2 buttermilk biscuits, sausage gravy, parsley

      $7.00

    Lunch

    • Craven

      Toasted marble rye - house made chicken salad - lettuce - tomato - bacon

      $7.20
    • B.E.L.T.

      Ciabatta - bacon - lettuce - tomato - fried egg - mayo

      $7.35
    • Turquia Assault

      Oven roasted turkey - pepper jack cheese - tomato - lettuce - avocado mash - jalapenos - flour tortilla

      $7.45
    • Boom!

      Marinated portobella mushrooms - roasted red peppers - caramelized onions - balsamic mayo - Ciabatta

      $7.20
    • Saltly Gorlami

      Salami - ham - bacon - banana peppers - balsamic mayo - provolone - Italian bread

      $7.70
    • California

      Toasted honey wheat - tomatoes - caramelized onions - avocado mash - hard-boiled egg - provolone cheese

      $7.20
    • Studio 54

      Everything bagel - ham - turkey - bacon - American & Swiss cheeses - mayo

      $7.45
    • 3D Pesto Panini

      Italian bread - turkey - lettuce - tomato - provolone - basil mayo

      $7.45
    • Grilled Buffalo Chicken Wrap

      Grilled buffalo chicken breast - pepper jack & cheddar cheese - lettuce - tomato - flour tortilla

      $7.95
    • Cuban

      Panini pressed Cuban bread - sliced ham - shredded pork - dill pickles - mustard sauce - swiss cheese

      $8.00
    • Hot Pastrami Sandwich

      Slow cooked pastrami - marble rye - sliced pickles - Dijonnaise - Swiss cheese

      $8.00
    • Roast Beef Sandwich

      Deli-style roast beef - Italian bread - cheddar cheese - lettuce - tomato - mayo

      $7.75

    Salads

    • Chef

      Mixed greens, turkey, ham, mozzarella, egg, croutons, tomato, avocado mash

      $7.89
    • Caesar

      Romain, parmesan, croutons

      $6.09
    • Greek

      Mixed greens, feta cheese, olives, cucumber, tomatoes

      $6.80
    • Spinach

      Spinach leaves, mozzarella, eggs, tomatoes, bacon

      $6.80

    Add- Ons

    • Bacon - 3 Slices

      $3.20
    • Sausage Patties - 2 Slices

      $3.75
    • Ham

      $2.75
    • Diced Tomatoes

      $0.25
    • Spinach

      $0.59
    • Cheddar Cheese

      $0.89
    • Scrambled Eggs (2)

      $3.70
    • Toast

      $1.79
    • Turkey

      $3.00
    • 1 EGG

      $2.00
    • EICC Side Avocado

      $1.00
    • Chicken Salad - 8oz

      $5.00
    • Granola - 8oz

      $2.99
    • Granola - 4oz

      $1.49

    Soup

    • Pepper stuffed w/ Beef

      THIS SPIN ON A CLASSIC DISH COMBINES GREEN PEPPERS, GROUND BEEF, RICE, SPANISH ONIONS AND DICED TOMATOES IN A TASTY AU JUS BROTH.

      $5.30
    • Chicken Noodle

      An all-American classic. Tender cuts of white chicken coupled with thick Kluski egg noodles accented with carrots, onions, and celery in a rich, homestyle chicken broth.

      $5.35
    • Broccoli Cheddar

      A hearty combination of broccoli florets in a rich creamy cheddar cheese soup

      $6.15
    • Italian Wedding Soup

      Mini Italian-Style meatballs, Acine de Pepe pasta, spinach, carrots and Romano cheese accentuated in a rich seasoned chicken broth

      $5.60
    • Baked Potato Soup

      HEARTY CHUNKS OF FARM-FRESH POTATOES FLAVORED WITH REAL BACON AND ONIONS IN A RICH HOMESTYLE BROTH MADE WITH REAL BUTTER AND CREAM.

      $5.50
      OUT OF STOCK

    Other Goodies

    • Bagel- Toasted w/ Butter & Jelly

      $2.15
    • Bagel - Toasted w/ Cream Cheese

      $3.79
    • Vanilla Yogurt w/ Fresh Fruit Parfait

      $4.65
    • Fresh Fruit Mix

      $4.95
    • Hard Boiled Egg

      $1.50
    • Chips- Miss Vikies

      Gluten Free

      $1.69
    • Dessert Bar - Mount Caramel Oatmeal

      $4.60
    • Dessrt Bar - 7 Layer

      $4.60
    • Dessert Bar - Raspberry Rhapsody

      $4.60
    • Dessert Bar -Old Fashioned Lemon

      $4.60
    • Muffin - Blueberry

      Our blueberry buttermilk muffin is loaded with juicy Georgia wild blueberries and a touch of creamy buttermilk topped with coarse sugar for a nice crunch. With a perfect crumb finish each 4 oz. muffin contains no artificial ingredients

      $3.40
    • Muffin - Apple Cinnamon

      This muffin is filled with delicious Michigan Rome apples and has cinnamon chips throughout. Topped with crumbly streusel each 4 oz. muffin contains no artificial ingediants . Our baking process delivers the perfect crown for this gourmet version of an old favorite every time.

      $3.40
    • Muffin - Double Chocolate Muffin

      Few things in life are more tempting than a soft fresh-baked muffin. Using premium semi-sweet Belgian chocolate chips our double chocolate muffin is finished with cinnamon streusel and chocolate chunks. With a perfect crumb finish each 4 oz. muffin contains no artificial ingredients

      $3.40
    • Cookie - Hershey's Chocolate

      DECADENT TO SAY THE LEAST! THIS COOKIE IS MADE FROM DAVID'S FAMOUS CHOCOLATE CHUNK COOKIE DOUGH THEN GENEROUSLY TOPPED WITH HERSHEY'S KISSES, SEMI SWEET CHUNKS AND MILK CHOCOLATE CHUNKS

      $2.79
    • Cookie - Reese's Peanut Butter

      PEANUT BUTTER LOVERS BEWARE. THIS OVERSIZED COOKIE IS MADE WITH BROKEN PIECES OF REAL REESE'S PEANUT BUTTER CUPS AND REESE'S PEANUT BUTTER CHIPS. A MEMORABLE EXPERIENCE THAT KEEPS THEM COMING BACK FOR MORE

      $2.79
    • Fudge brownie

      A rich chocolate fudge brownie with chocolate drizzle

      $3.99
    • Peanut Butter Toffee Bar

      Inspired by a recipe from one of our very own product developer – you’ll love these peanut butter toffee bars. They’re made with butter brown sugar peanut butter chips peanut butter chocolate chips and toffee bits topped with sugar crystals.

      $4.95
    • Cake -Chocolate Banana Swirled

      To make the batter we used ripened whole bananas midnight cocoa and semi-sweet chocolate to give this must-have delight its balanced flavor. Each tempting 4 oz. slice was made without high-fructose corn syrup artificial flavors or preservatives. Delectable with breakfast coffee and throughout the day on a plate or on the go it satisfies a person’s sweet tooth any time of day or night.

      $3.95
    • Cake - Iced Lemon Loaf

      Made using the juice of fresh California lemons this pre-sliced treat is moist and lemony with a tangy-sweet lemon icing. Each tempting 4 oz. slice was made without high-fructose corn syrup artificial flavors or preservatives. Delectable with breakfast coffee and throughout the day on a plate or on the go it satisfies a person’s sweet tooth any time of day or night.

      $4.29
    • Cake - Cinnamon Coffee

      Made with real ingredients like butter brown sugar and sour cream these cakes look taste and feel like a homemade treat. Delectable with breakfast coffee and throughout the day on a plate or on the go it satisfies a person’s sweet tooth any time of day or night.

      $4.39
    • Donut- Crème Brule Filled

      $3.95
    • Danish - Chef Pierre

      $3.79

    RETAIL

    12oz Ground Coffee

    • Signature Blend

      $12.95
    • Morning Blend 3

      $12.95
    • French Roast

      $12.95
    • Craftsman

      $12.95

    Mug

    • Mug

      $5.00
      OUT OF STOCK

    All hours
    Sunday7:30 am - 1:45 pm
    Monday6:30 am - 3:45 pm
    Tuesday6:30 am - 3:45 pm
    Wednesday7:30 am - 1:45 pm
    Thursday6:30 am - 3:45 pm
    Friday6:30 am - 3:45 pm
    Saturday7:30 am - 1:45 pm
    Restaurant info

    Come in and enjoy!

    Location

    148 Middle Ave, Elyria, OH 44035

    Directions


    Similar restaurants in your area

    Heritage Coffee
    View restaurantnext
    Wallhouse Coffee Company
    View restaurantnext
    Café Rosé
    View restaurantnext
    Bada Bean Bada Booze @ Jeffery Park
    View restaurantnext
    Hocking Hills Coffee Emporium 13984 OH-664 Scenic
    View restaurantnext
    Kava Haus Xenia
    View restaurantnext
    Search similar restaurants
    © 2025 Toast, Inc.
    Toast
    • About Toast
    • For restaurants
    • Terms of Service
    • Privacy Statement
    • Do not sell my
      personal information
    Made with love in Boston
    • Instagram
    • X (formerly Twitter)
    • Facebook