.jpg)
American
Fred and Ethels Lantern Light Tavern 1 N New York Rd
1 N New York Rd
Galloway, NJ 08205
Orders through Toast are commission free and go directly to this restaurant
Food Menu
Starters

Bang-Bang Shrimp
6 pieces Sweet and Spicy Shrimp$11.00
Cheesesteak Eggrolls
2 Crispy Eggrolls served with our Signature Guinness Cheese Sauce$8.00OUT OF STOCK
Guiness Cheese Fries
French Fries smothered in Guinness Cheese.$5.00
Side French Fries
Basket of French Fries$4.00Loaded Fries
Guinness Cheese, Bacon & Gravy$8.00
Roasted Brussel Sprouts
Crispy Brussel Sprouts Topped with Sesame Garlic Crunch$10.00Quesadilla
Cheddar Jack, Peppers, Onions & Tomatoes$10.00+Fred's Nachos
Tortilla Chips, Diced Onions, Peppers, Black Beans, Tomato and our Signature Guinness Cheese Sauce. Add Chicken or Philly Steak +3$14.00+
Mozzarella Stix
6 Crispy Stix served with Marinara$8.00
Soup & Salad
Soup To Go
$6.00+Chicken Corn Chowder
$4.00+
French Onion Soup
Topped with croutons, swiss & provolone cheese browned to perfection$8.00Tomato Bisque
A homemade Classic$4.00+Steak Chili
Topped with Shredded Cheddar & Onions$6.00+Santa Fe Salad
Buffalo Tenders, black beans, cheddar jack, red onion, tomato, avoado & tortilla crisps over mixed iceberg & romaine served with guacamole ranch dressing$16.00
Chicken Cobb Salad
Chicken, blue cheese crumbles, egg, bacon & diced tomatoes over mixed iceberg & romaine$16.00
Bang Bang Shrimp Salad
Bang Bang Shrimp, mango, shredded cabbage, carrotts, cucumber & wontom crisps over mixed iceberg & romaine$18.00
Caesar Salad
Romaine tossed with caesar dressing, croutons & shredded romano$11.00Garden Salad
Romain Iceberg Mix Cabbage Carrot mix Cucumber Tomato Red Onion Cheddar Jack Choice of Dressing$11.00Chicken & Vegetable
$4.00+
Famous Wings
4 Tenders
Comes with Celery, Carrots and Blue Cheese Dressing. Choose 1 Flavor per Order: Mild, Medium or Hot Buffalo, Garlic Parmesan, Honey Sriracha, Sweet n Tangy BBQ, Teriyaki, Thai Chili, Tajin (dry rub), Cajun (dry rub)$10.006 Tenders
Comes with Celery, Carrots and Blue Cheese Dressing. Choose 1 Flavor per Order: Mild, Medium or Hot Buffalo, Garlic Parmesan, Honey Sriracha, Sweet n Tangy BBQ, Teriyaki, Thai Chili, Tajin (dry rub), Cajun (dry rub)$13.006 Wings
Comes with Celery, Carrots and Blue Cheese Dressing. Choose 1 Flavor per Order: Mild, Medium or Hot Buffalo, Garlic Parmesan, Honey Sriracha, Sweet n Tangy BBQ, Teriyaki, Thai Chili, Tajin (dry rub), Cajun (dry rub)$12.0010 Wings
Comes with Celery, Carrots and Blue Cheese Dressing. Choose 1 Flavor per Order: Mild, Medium or Hot Buffalo, Garlic Parmesan, Honey Sriracha, Sweet n Tangy BBQ, Teriyaki, Thai Chili, Tajin (dry rub), Cajun (dry rub)$17.00
Burgers

Classic Burger
American Cheese, Lettuce Tomato and Onion, served with a Pickle and Chips$14.00Bacon Burger
Bacon & Cheddar served with a pickle and chips$16.00
Tavern Burger
Bacon, Satueed Onions, Mushrooms, Cheddar & American served with a pickle and chips$16.00
Jersey Girl
Pork Roll, Sauteed Onions, Cheddar, American, Lettuce, Tomato, Thousand Island Dressing$17.00Three B's Burger
Blue Cheese, Bacon & Buffalo Sauce$16.00French Onion Burger
Porter Glazed Onions, Swiss & Provolone$15.00Jalapeno Popper Bomb
Jalapeno Garlic Herb Cream Cheese, Cheddar, Bacon, Honey Porter Glazed Onions$16.00Stix Stack Burger
Crispy Mozzarella Sticks, Marinara Sauce & Romano Cheese$16.00
Sandwiches
F&E's Chicken Sandwich
Crispy Chicken Cutlet, Bacon, Lettuce, Tomato, House Pickles & Secret Sauce on a Brioche Bun$14.00
Crab Cake Sandwich
F&E Signature crispy Crab Cake with Lettuce, Tomato, & Red Onion Served on a Brioche Bun with Old Bay Aioli served with a Pickle and Chips$16.00
Cheesesteak
Sauteed Onions, American Cheese on a Tuscan Submarine Roll served with a Pickle and Chips$14.00Ahi Tuna BLT
Cajun Blackened Tuna Seared Rare, Bacon, Arugula, Tomato & Chipotle Aioli on a Brioche Bun$16.00Dirty Jersey Sandwich
Grilled Pork Roll, Sauteed Onions, American, Cheddar, Lettuce, Tomato & 1000 Island on a Brioche Bun$12.00
Short Rib Grilled Cheese
Shaved Short Rib, Honey Porter Glazed Onions, Fontina & Bleu Cheese on Garlic Toasted Rye Bread served with a Pickle and Chips$16.00
Turkey Special Sandwich
Sliced Turkey Breast, Swiss, Coleslaw & 1000 Island on Rye Bread$12.00
Chicken Caesar Wrap
Grilled Chicken, Romaine, Shredded Romano Cheese, Caesar Dressing wrapped in a Flour Tortilla served with a Pickle and Chips$13.00
Tacos

Mahi Tacos
3 Grilled Mahi Tacos, Shredded Lettuce, Roasted Corn Salsa, Chili Lime Aioli, Soft Flour Tortillas$16.00
Bang Shrimp Tacos
3 Flour Tortilla Bang Shrimp, Mango Slaw, Gochu Glaze, Scallions, Toasted Sesame Garlic Crunch$18.00Smash Burger Tacos
Certified Angus Beef, Bacon, Fried Onion, American Cheese, Shredded Lettuce, Tomato, Pickles & 1000 Island Dressing$16.00
Rice Bowls

Ahi Tuna Bowl
Sesame Crusted ahi Tuna seared Rare, Mango, Edamame, Seaweed Salad, Chili Lime Aioli & Wonton Crisps$20.00
Street Corn Chicken
Fajita Style Grilled Chicken, Roasted Corn, Poblanos, Crema, Cotija Cheese, Tajin & Tortilla Crisps$16.00Veggie Bowl
Black Bean Veggie Burger, Cheddar Jack Cheese, Roasted Corn, Poblanos, Guacamole Ranch, Tortilla Strips$14.00
Teriyaki Bowl
Grilled Chicken, Edamame, String Beans, Sweet-n-Spicy Teriyaki Sauce topped with Toasted Sesame Garlic Crunch$16.00+Crab Cake Bowl
Signature F&E Crispy Crab Cake, Arugula, Cucumber Tomato Bruschetta, Old Bay Aioli$21.00
Tavern Favorites

Fish & Chips
Beer Battered Haddock, French Fries, Coleslaw, Lemon and Old Bay Aoili$17.00
Meatloaf Mountain
Grilled Meatloaf over Sourdough topped with Mashed Potatoes, Cheddar Jack, Bacon Crumbles & Brown Gravy$18.00
Chicken Fingers & Fries
5 Golden Brown Fingers & a Pile of Fries. Comes with Honey Mustard$14.00
Entrees
Entree Soup/Salad

NY Strip Steak
Flame Grilled 12oz NY Strip served with Mashed Potatoes & Vegetable Medley$30.00+Crab Cakes Entree
Two F&E Signature Crab Cakes served with Mashed Potatoes, Vegetable Medley & Old Bay Aoili$28.00BBQ Ribs
1/2 Rack Ribs Basted with Sweet-n-Tangy BBQ sauce, Baked Mac-n-Cheese & Vegetable Medley$28.00
Chicken ala Rosa
Sauteed Chicken, Roasted Red Peppers, Fresh Basil, Tomato Cream Sauce, and Romano Cheese over Penne$20.00Thanksgiving Turkey Dinner
Turkey, Gravy, Cranberry, Sausage Stuffing, Mashed Potatoes, Vegetable Medley$18.00Seafood Trio
$27.00Teriyaki Salmon
Grilled Salmon Filet, Sweet & Spicy Teriyaki Glaze, Mashed Potatoes and Cranberry Sauce$25.00
Daily Specials
Phillies (Tavern)
Mexican Monday
Guacamole & Chips
House Made served with Tortilla Chips$12.00House Pico & Chips
House Made Fresh Salsa Served with Tortilla Chips$6.00Cheese Taquitos
Four Crisp Corn Tortillas stuffed & rolled with Cheese and topped with Salsa Verde, Shredded Lettuce, Crema & Queso Fresco$10.00Pozole Rojo
Traditional Slow Cooked Pork & Hominy Soup topped with Shredded Radish & Cilantro served with Tortilla Chips$12.00Chorizo Queso Dip
$10.00Tacos
3 Soft Corn Tortilla Tacos. Choose 1: Chicken, Pork or Beef. Comes with Cilantro, Onion, Lime & Served w/ Red & Green Sauce.$12.00+Burrito
Choose Steak or Fajita Grilled Chicken. Flour Tortilla Stuffed with Choice of Meat, Cheddar Jack Cheese, Lettuce, Tomato, Black Beans & Chipotle Mayo.$14.00+Chicken Chimichanga
Shredded Chicken Breast with Sauteed Onions & Oaxaca Cheese simmered in a Mild Red Salsa stuffed into a Flour Tortilla Fried Golden Brown Topped with Crema & Pico De Gallo served with Rice & Beans$16.00Carne Asada
Two Rib-eye Steaks Pounded Thin, Marinated & Flamed Grilled, topped with Sauteed Onions served with Rice, Beans, Pico de Gallo & Tortilla Chips$28.00Side Rice
$3.00Side Refried Beans
$3.00Side Fresh Pico
$1.00Side Tortilla Chips
$2.00Extra Tortilla
$3.00Avocado
$4.00Jalapenos
$1.00
Italian Tuesday
Entree Soup/Salad
Italian Wedding Soup
$4.00+Antipasto
Salami, Prosciutto, Fresh Mozzarella, Sharp Provolone, Olive Medley, Roasted Peppers, Grilled Asparagus & Marinated Tomatoes$18.00Bruschetta & Fresh Mozz
Comes with Croustini's$10.00Garlic Bread
$3.00Roasted Long Hots
$3.00Tomato Basil Salad
$3.00Chicken Parm - Endless Pasta
Marinara, Ala Rosa, Alfredo or Garlic & Oil. Penne, Linguine or Bowtie Pasta.$22.00Eggplant Parm - Endless Pasta
Marinara, Ala Rosa, Alfredo or Garlic & Oil. Penne, Linguine or Bowtie Pasta.$22.00Italian Sausage- Endless Pasta
Marinara, Ala Rosa, Alfredo or Garlic & Oil. Penne, Linguine or Bowtie Pasta.$22.00Meatballs- Endless Pasta
Marinara, Ala Rosa, Alfredo or Garlic & Oil. Penne, Linguine or Bowtie Pasta.$22.00Chocolate Chip Canoli
Giant Canoli$6.00Pasta Refill
Marinara, Ala Rosa, Alfredo or Garlic & Oil. Penne, Linguine or Bowtie Pasta.
Wokin' Wednesday
Entree Soup/Salad
Shrimp Tempura
Four Crispy Rice Coated Tempura Shrimp served with Chili Dipping Sauce$12.00Spring Roll
Two Crispy Vegetable Spring Rolls Served with Sweet Chili Dipping Sauce$8.00Pork Pot Stickers
Five Succulent Pork Dumplings Pan Seared & Steamed served with Soy Ginger Dipping Sauce$9.00Stir Fry
Stir Fried Broccoli, Peppers, Onions, Carrots & Scallions served over Rice or Lo-Mein Noodles with your choice of: Chicken, Beef, Vegetable or Shrimp.$12.00+General Tso's Chicken
Crispy All White Meat Chicken tossed in a Sweet-n-Spicy Teriyaki Sauce served with Rice & Broccoli$16.00Chicken Fried Rice
Chicken, Rice, Egg, Broccoli, Peppers, Onions, Carrots & Scallions in a Light Soy Ginger Sauce$16.00
Prime & Wing Thursday
Seafood Friday
Sides
Guiness Cheese Fries
$5.00
Loaded Fries
$8.00Side Apple Sauce
$3.00Side Beef Gravy
$1.00Side Buffalo Sauce
$1.00Side Caesar Salad
$5.00Side Coleslaw
$4.00
Side French Fries
Basket of French Fries$4.00Side Grilled Asparagus
$4.00Side Grilled Chicken
$4.00Side Guac
$1.00Side Guiness Cheese
$1.00Side Jasmine Rice
$4.00Side Mac & Cheese
$5.00Side Mashed Potatoes
$4.00Side Pickles
$1.00Side Potato Chips
$3.00Side Salad
Mixed Greens, Tomato, Cucumber, Carrots, red onion, choice dressing.$4.00Side Teriyaki sauce
$1.00Side Turkey Gravy
$1.00Side Vegetable Medley
$4.00Side Pork Roll
$5.00
From the Bar
Beer
Miller Light Draft
4.2% ABV$5.00Yuengling Draft
4.5% ABV American Amber Lager$5.00Icarus Yacht All the Time
6.5% ABV. North East style India Pale Ale copiously dry-hopped with Lupulin Citra, Lupulin Mosaic, and Columbus$8.00Downeast Cider Draft
$9.00Kane Draft
$8.00Garden State Blue Jersey
$8.00Tired Hands Alien Church
7% ABV Hazy IPA$9.00Double Nickel Liberty Lager
$7.000 Blue Moon N/A
$6.500 Guinness Zero
$8.000 Heinekin Zero.0
$6.500 Michelob Ultra N/A
$5.00Alagash White
$6.50Amstel Light
$6.50Angry Orchard
$6.50Blue Moon
$6.50Bud Light Bottle
$5.00Budweiser bottle
$5.00Coors Light Bottle
$5.00Corona
$6.50Dos Equis XX
$6.50OUT OF STOCKGuinness
$8.00Heinekin
$6.50Mackensies Black Cherry Cider
$7.00Michelob Ultra
$5.00Miller High Life Bottle
$5.00Miller Light Bottle
$5.00Sam Adams Boston Lager
$6.50Stella Artois
$6.50Surfside Green Tea
$9.00Surfside IT & Lemonade
$9.00Surfside Lemonade
$9.00Surfside Peach Tea
$9.00White Claw Black Cherry
$8.00Yuengling Bottle
$5.00Yuengling Flight
$5.00Alagash White
$6.50Cape May Always Ready
$7.00Cape May Coastal Evacuation
$8.00Cape May IPA
$8.00Cape May Orange Crushin' It
$8.00Carlsburg Pilsner
$8.00Dogfish Head Citrus DayDream Lager
$8.00Dogfish Head Grateful Dead IPA
$8.00Erdinger Dunkel
$7.00Friday Beers Tasty Light
$6.00High Noon Pineapple Vodka
$9.00Manafirkin Fuzzy Nuggets (16oz)
6.8% ABV. Brewed with Mackinac, Mistral and the ever sought after Nectron hops, this beer gets its seemingly tropical aroma and flavor from just the hops. And this may be the best batch yet… smooth, light and Firkin delicious!$9.00Manafirkin Ozzie's Orange Hefe
6.5% ABV. Brewed with generous portions of wheat malts and complimented with a touch of crystal malt. Coriander, clove, and citrus peel are added to the boil with a late dry hop of orange-noted hops. Lastly, fresh oranges were juiced in house and added directly into the fermenter, giving this hefe a crisp and citrusy finish.$8.00Manafirkin Wake the Firk Up (16oz)
$9.00Mule Kick Obscura Brewing
$8.00Paradise in the Pines Pinelands
$8.00Pinelands Blueberry Ale
$8.00Pinelands Evan John Porter
$8.00Pinelands Swamp Donkey
$8.00Slack Tide Flounder Pounder
$6.00Slack Tide Intracoastal
$8.00Slack Tide Manatee Milk
$8.00Sun Cruiser
$9.00Surfside Green Tea
$9.00Surfside IT & Lemonade
$9.00Surfside Lemonade
$9.00Surfside Peach Tea
$9.00Victory Golden Monkey
$8.00Yards Trash Talk
$7.00
Seltzers, Teas, Ciders (Copy)
Angry Orchard
$6.50High Noon Pineapple Vodka
$9.00Mackensies Black Cherry Cider
$7.00Nutrl Blueberry Vodka Seltzer
$8.00Nutrl Cranberry Vodka Seltzer
$8.00Nutrl Orange Vodka Seltzer
$8.00Nutrl Pineapple Vodka Seltzer
$8.00Sun Cruiser
$9.00Surfside Green Tea
$9.00Surfside IT & Lemonade
$9.00Surfside Lemonade
$9.00Surfside Peach Tea
$9.00White Claw Black Cherry
$8.00The Long Drink Strong Gin Cocktail
$10.00Lemon Lime SuperLyte
$9.00Blue Raspberry SuperLyte
$9.00Fruit Punch SuperLyte
$9.00Orange SuperLyte
$9.00
All hours
| Sunday | 11:30 am - 9:00 pm |
| Monday | 11:30 am - 9:00 pm |
| Tuesday | 11:30 am - 9:00 pm |
| Wednesday | 11:30 am - 9:00 pm |
| Thursday | 11:30 am - 9:00 pm |
| Friday | 11:30 am - 9:00 pm |
| Saturday | 11:30 am - 9:00 pm |
Restaurant info
Located in the heart of Historic Smithville. Casual spot with homemade food. Open daily for lunch and dinner. Full bar, live entertainment on weekends and outside seating available. Private banquet space for parties of 25-80 guests. The perfect spot to meet friends or make new ones. Open year round.
Location
Similar restaurants in your area
© 2026 Toast, Inc.




