Goldstein's Bagels

Whaddya like on YOUR bagel?

Egg Salad, Pickled Red Onion, Banana Peppers, Sprouts, Potato Chips, Mustard and served on your choice of Bagel or Bialy

Vegan Cream Cheese, Vegan Pesto, Arugula, Sprouts, Cucumbers & Potato Chips served on your choice of Bagel or Bialy

Nova Lox, Lemon Dill Cream Cheese, Tomatoes, Pickled Red Onion & Capers served on your choice of Bagel or Bialy

Kippered Salmon, Lemon Dill Cream Cheese, Cucumbers, Arugula served on your choice of Bagel or Bialy

Pastrami Cured Lox, Garlic Scallion Cream Cheese, Banana Peppers & Sprouts served on your choice of Bagel or Bialy

Nova Lox, Whitefish Salad, Garlic Scallion Cream Cheese, Tomatoes, Pickled Red Onion & Capers served on your choice of Bagel or Bialy

Smoked Whitefish Salad, Lemon Dill Cream Cheese & Arugula served on your choice of Bagel or Bialy

Crispy Bacon, Romaine Lettuce, Tomatoes & Chipotle Mayo served on your choice of Bagel or Bialy

Crispy Prosciutto, Sliced Kosher Pickles & Zab's Hot Honey served on your choice of Bagel or Bialy

Pastrami, Sliced Kosher Pickles & Mustard served on your choice of Bagel or Bialy

Turkey Breast, Melted Muenster, Tomatoes, Arugula & Vegan Pesto served on your choice of Bagel or Bialy

Pastrami, Melted Gruyere, House Sauerkraut & Russian Dressing served on your choice of Bagel or Bialy

Egg & Melted Muenster Cheese served on your choice of Bagel or Bialy

Bacon, White Cheddar, Sausage, White Cheddar Again, Egg, Salt Pepper & Ketchup on your choice of Bagel or Bialy

Egg, Muenster Cheese, Hatch Chiles, Tomatoes, Garlic and Scallion Cream Cheese, Sprouts & Chipotle Mayonnaise on your choice of Bagel or Bialy

Sautéed Nova Lox, Caramelized Onions, Egg and Plain Cream Cheese served on your choice of Bagel or Bialy

Egg, Prosciutto, Szechuan Cream Cheese, Spicy Chili Crisp & Micro greens on your choice of Bagel or Bialy

Egg, Prosciutto, Gruyere, Vegan Pesto, Arugula, & Potato Chips served on your choice of Bagel or Bialy

Vegan Egg, Vegan Sausage, Vegan Cream Cheese, Salt, Pepper, and Ketchup.

The best you've ever had! We recommend buying one for today and one for this weekend's french toast. You're welcome.

3 pieces per order

An assortment of both chocolate and cinnamon rugelach. (8 pieces)

2 pieces might satisfy 1 person's sweet tooth.

Is it a cookie or is it a cake? One thing is for sure, they will disappear before you make up your mind. One cake might satisfy the sweet tooth of about 6 people.

All of our bagel flavors are baked fresh throughout the day. We will always do our best to fulfill your order but on occasion substitutions are unavoidable. If your bagel flavors are unavailable at the time of your online order, plain or similar bagels may be chosen for you. This tends to happen during busy times & at the end of the day. If you do not want us to choose substitutions for you or you have dietary restrictions we urge you to come in to the store and order in person.

All of our bagel flavors are baked fresh throughout the day. We will always do our best to fulfill your order but on occasion substitutions are unavoidable. If your bagel flavors are unavailable at the time of your online order, plain or similar bagels may be chosen for you. This tends to happen during busy times & at the end of the day. If you do not want us to choose substitutions for you or you have dietary restrictions we urge you to come in to the store and order in person.

What's a bialy?! We like to say it's a jewish english muffin. Let your imagination run wild. Unlike bagels, we recommend toasting bialy's for maximum flavor fulfillment.

Our bagels, sliced thin & sturdy enough to dip, then baked. No seasoning or oil needed. No frills. Buy some egg salad or whitefish salad and you've got the most delicious snack.

***We recommend 3 1/2lb containers of cream cheese per dozen bagels***

Aunt Marilyn would never make egg salad without dill and neither will we.

Like tuna salad but way, way better! Like, insanely delicious.

This will likely feed a crew of 5-8 lox lovers.

This is enough lox to feed a family. Up to 24 standard sandwiches or way fewer if you love lox the way we do ;)

This is enough pastrami lox to feed a family. Up to 24 standard sandwiches or way fewer if you love lox the way we do ;)

Banner's premium crafted Nova is your quintessential smoked salmon: rich, silky, and the slightest bit smoky. The definition of simple pleasure. But somehow, even better. Pre-sliced.

Banner's premium crafted Nova is your quintessential smoked salmon: rich, silky, and the slightest bit smoky. The definition of simple pleasure. But somehow, even better. Pre-sliced.

Dealer's Choice. We'll choose your flavor, they're all delicious! Handmade daily from real dried fruit. Brooklyn Made & Kosher certified.

LOCALLY MADE! If we run out of a flavor we will substitute it with the next closest option.

LOCALLY MADE! If we run out of a flavor we will substitute it with the next closest option.

LOCALLY MADE! If we run out of a flavor we will substitute it with the next closest option.

Ubet's malted chocolate milk is poured over iced coffee and sprinkled with dark chocolate.

Take a Diet Coke break with this refreshing, no-calorie soft drink

IYKYK. We stock original, vanilla and mocha. All delicious. We'll make the decision for you!

Pure-squeezed and pasteurized — We never use concentrated orange juice

LOCALLY MADE! We carry an assortment of their delicious flavors. Let us choose yours for you.

LOCALLY MADE! We carry an assortment of their delicious flavors. Let us choose yours for you.

Squirt is a caffeine-free, grapefruit-flavored soda known for its crisp, citrus taste.

A wildly popular Brazilian soda.

Lorina's Sparkling Pink Lemonade combines carbonated water with sugar, citric acid, and natural lemon and lime flavors. The pink color comes from fruit and vegetable juice, creating a refreshing effervescent drink with a balanced citrus profile.

Iconic NY deli soda-sweet, fizzy & nostalgic.

Iconic NY deli soda-sweet, fizzy & nostalgic.

Iconic NY deli soda-sweet, fizzy & nostalgic.

Iconic NY deli soda-sweet, fizzy & nostalgic.

Iconic NY deli soda-sweet, fizzy & nostalgic.