Skip to Main content

  • GoodFellas Pizzeria

    GoodFellas Pizzeria
    • Home
    • /
    • Niagara Falls
    • /
    • GoodFellas Pizzeria
    Restaurant banner image

    GoodFellas Pizzeria

    745 West Market Street

    Niagara Falls, NY 14301

    Orders through Toast are commission free and go directly to this restaurant

    phone icon

    Call

    clock icon

    Hours

    waypoint sign icon

    Directions

    Food
    Drinks

    Food

    Everyday House Specials

    • 1/2 Tray w/ cheese and 20 wings

      $39.95

    • Full Tray w/ cheese and 30 wings

      $62.95

    • Full Tray w/ cheese and 50 wings

      $74.99

    • White Pizza Half Tray w/ cheese and 20 wings

      $45.95

    • White Pizza Full Tray w/ cheese and 50 wings

      $74.95

    Pizzas

    • Tray Pizza

      $30.00

    • 1/2 Tray Pizza

      $16.00

    • Large Pie

      $19.95

    • Medium Pie

      $17.00

    • Slice

      $2.25

    Specialty Pizzas

    • Medium White Pizza

      $19.45

    • Large White Pizza

      $21.95

    • Half Tray White Pizza

      $17.95

    • Full try White Pizza

      $31.95

    • Medium Chicken Finger Pizza

      $22.45

    • Large Chicken Finger Pizza

      $26.95

    • Half Tray Chicken Finger Pizza

      $21.95

    • Full Tray Chicken Finger Pizza

      $36.95

    • Medium Steak Pizza

      $22.45

    • Large Steak Pizza

      $26.95

    • Half Tray Steak Pizza

      $21.95

    • Full Tray Steak Pizza

      $36.95

    • Gluten Free Pie

      $12.45

    • Cauliflower Crust

      $12.45

    Wings/Fingers

    • 10 Wings

      $13.95

    • 20 Wings

      $24.95

    • 30 Wings

      $39.95

    • 50 Wings

      $55.95

    • 4 Fingers

      $12.95

    • 8 Fingers

      $22.00

    • 12 Fingers

      $32.00

    • extra blue cheese

      $1.25

    Old Fashioned Pizzas

    • Full tray Old Fashioned Pizza

      $28.95

    • Half Tray Old Fashioned Pizza

      $14.95

    • Large Old Fashioned

      $18.95

    • Medium Old Fashioned

      $16.45

    Finger Foods

    • pizza logs (5)*

      $9.95

    • Jalapeno Poppers (6)

      $8.95

    • Mozzarella Sticks (5)

      $8.95

    • Fried Ravioli (12)

      $8.95

    • Garlic Bread with Cheese

      $6.50

    • Small Fry

      $4.95

    • Large Fry

      $6.25

    • Small Poutine

      $7.95

    • Large Poutine

      $9.25

    • Onion Rings

      $6.25

    • 3 Fingers w\ fries

      $12.95

    • sm fry mozz cheese

      $6.65

    • lg fry mozz cheese

      $8.65

    • Slice

      $2.50

    Subs

    • Small Steak and Cheese

      $11.95

    • Large Steak and Cheese

      $12.95

    • Small Sausage and Cheese

      $11.95

    • Large Sausage and Cheese

      $12.95

    • Small Ham and Cheese

      $11.95

    • Large Ham and Cheese

      $12.95

    • Small Assorted

      $11.95

    • Large Assorted

      $12.95

    • Small Turkey

      $11.95

    • Large Turkey

      $12.95

    • Small Tuna

      $11.95

    • Large Tuna

      $12.95

    • Small Salami

      $11.95

    • Large Salami

      $12.95

    • Small Capocollo

      $11.95

    • Large Capocollo

      $12.95

    • Small Chicken Finger sub

      $11.95

    • Large Chicken Finger sub

      $12.95

    • Small Pizza sub

      $11.95

    • Large Pizza sub

      $12.95

    • Small BLT Sub

      $11.95

    Specialty Subs

    • Small Stinger sub

      $12.95

    • Large Stinger sub

      $14.95

    • Small Sausage and Capocollo

      $12.95

    • Large Sausage and Capocollo

      $14.95

    • Small Chicken Parmigiana

      $12.95

    • Large Chicken Parmigiana

      $14.95

    • Small Meatball sub

      $12.95

    • Large Meatball sub

      $14.95

    Giant Tacos

    • Steak Taco

      $10.50

    • Chicken Taco

      $10.75

    • Stinger Taco

      $14.75

    Salads

    • Dinner Salad

      $6.25

    • Small Chef Salad

      $7.95

    • Large Chef Salad

      $8.95

    • Small Julienne Salad

      $10.95

    • Large Julienne Salad

      $11.95

    • Small grilled chicken salad

      $11.50

    • Large grilled chicken salad

      $12.50

    • small chicken finger salad

      $12.50

    • large chicken finger salad

      $13.50

    • small antipasto

      $12.50

    • large antipasto

      $13.50

    • Chicken Taco Bowl Salad

      $13.50

    • Steak Taco Bowl Salad

      $13.50

    Dinners

    • Pasta Dinner with meatballs

      $13.95

    • Fish Fry (Fridays only)

      $13.95

    Sandwiches & Burgers

    • 1/2 lb hamburger with fries

      $12.95

    • Grilled Chicken Sandwich with fries

      $12.95

    • Nashville Hot Chicken Sandwich with fries

      $15.99

    Dottie's Chicken Soup

    • Pint of Soup

      $5.25

    • Quart of Soup

      $10.00

    Extra/Sides

    • Blue Cheese

      $1.25

    • Extra Side Sauce

      $1.00

    • Side Gravy

      $2.00

    • Sour Cream

      $1.00

    • Salsa

      $1.00

    • Side honey garlic

      $1.50

    Drinks

    • 2 Liter Cherry Coke

      $3.50

    • 2 Liter Coke

      $3.50

    • 2 Liter Diet Coke

      $3.50

    • 2 Liter Gingerale

      $3.50

    • 2 Liter Sprite

      $3.50

    • 2 Liter Rootbeer

      $3.50

    • 2 Liter Loganberry

      $3.50

    • 2 Liter Fanta Orange

      $3.50

    • 20oz. Gold Peak Sweet Tea

      $3.00

    • 20oz Minute Maid Lemonade

      $2.50

    • 20oz Fanta Orange

      $2.50

    • 20oz Dasani water

      $2.50

    • 20oz Minute Maid Fruit Punch

      $2.50

    • 20oz Rootbeer

      $2.50

    • 20oz Coke

      $2.50

    • 20oz Diet Coke

      $2.50

    • 20oz Gingerale

      $2.50

    • 20oz Sprite

      $2.50

    • 20oz Coke Zero

      $2.50
    All hours
    Sunday11:00 am - 11:00 pm
    Monday11:00 am - 11:00 pm
    Tuesday11:00 am - 11:00 pm
    Wednesday11:00 am - 11:00 pm
    Thursday11:00 am - 11:00 pm
    Friday11:00 am - 11:00 pm
    Saturday11:00 am - 11:00 pm
    Restaurant info

    Dine in, takeout, delivery!

    Location

    745 West Market Street, Niagara Falls, NY 14301

    Directions

    Similar restaurants in your area

    DiCamillo Bakery Linwood
    View restaurantnext
    Wine on Third
    View restaurantnext
    The Mami House 250 Rainbow Blvd.
    View restaurantnext
    Sēvā Kitchen & Bar
    View restaurantnext
    AMALA NY811 - Cambria Niagara Falls
    View restaurantnext
    SPoT Niagara Falls
    View restaurantnext
    Search similar restaurants
    © 2025 Toast, Inc.
    Toast
    • About Toast
    • For restaurants
    • Terms of Service
    • Privacy Statement
    • Do not sell my
      personal information
    Made with love in Boston
    • Instagram
    • X (formerly Twitter)
    • Facebook