Skip to Main content
  • Hillary's Chicago Pizza Baileys Plaza

    • Home
    • /
    • St. Augustine
    • /
    • Hillary's Chicago Pizza
    Restaurant banner image
    Pizza

    Hillary's Chicago Pizza

    1974 US 1

    St. Augustine, FL 32086


    Orders through Toast are commission free and go directly to this restaurant


    Call

    Hours

    Website

    Directions

    Gift Cards

    Food
    Beverages
    Catering
    Merchandise
    Pickup Only
    ‌
    ‌

    Food

    Pizza

    • Cheese/BYO - Thin Crust Pizza

      Our signature thin crust, cut in squares. One size, 12 inch only BYO- choose your own toppings
      $18.00
    • The Chicago - Thin Crust Pizza

      The Chicago- Italian sausage, mushroom, green pepper, onion
      $24.00
    • Italian Beef - Thin Crust Pizza

      Thin sliced Italian beef, green peppers and spicy giardiniera
      $24.00
    • White Pie - Thin Crust Pizza

      Garlic oil ricotta base, mozzarella, provolone, parmesan
      $20.00
    • Hillarys Hot Honey - Thin Crust Pizza

      A mash up of Chicago and St. Augustine Pepperoni, goat cheese, mozzarella, provolone , finished with house made datil honey
      $25.00
    • Meat Lover's - Thin Crust Pizza

      Marinara Base, Pepperoni, Sausage, Italian Beef, Ham, bacon
      $26.00
    • Fancy Fungi - Thin Crust Pizza

      Garlic oil base, goat cheese, mozzarella, provolone, cremini mushrooms, prosciutto and finished with arugula and truffle oil
      $25.00
    • Vegan Cheese 12inch/BYO - Thin Crust Pizza

      Our signature vegan dough rolled out thin, 12 inch size only, vegan cheese BYO - add your own toppings.
      OUT OF STOCK
      $18.00
    • Gluten Free Cheese 12inch/BYO - Thin Crust Pizza

      Our 10 "gluten free crust is cauliflower-based. There is a small amount of parmesan, so it is not vegan. BYO - add your own toppings.
      OUT OF STOCK
      $22.00
    • BBQ Chicken

      Bbq base, chicken, bacon, red onion, ranch
      $25.00
    • The Veg

      $25.00
    • 12inch Combo Pizza

      $25.00
    • Heart Pizza deep dish

      The Sweetheart special, sharing size deep dish.
      $25.00
    • Cheese/BYO - Deep Dish Pizza: Personal Size

      A blend of mozzarella and provolone cheese in our signature crispy crust. Personal size
      $16.00
    • Spinach Ricotta Mushroom - Deep Dish Pizza: Personal Size

      Our blend of spinach and ricotta, topped with mushrooms
      $18.00
    • The Works - Deep Dish Pizza: Personal Size

      The Works- Italian sausage, mushroom, green pepper, onion personal size
      $19.00
    • MFW - Deep Dish Pizza: Personal Size

      MFW- Italian sausage, pepperoni, mushrooms, green pepper, onion
      $20.00
    • Italian Sub - Deep Dish Pizza: Personal Size

      A layer of mozzarella + provolone, salami, ham, pepperoni, topped with more mozzarella and provolone, giardianara baked in our deep dish crust then finished with lettuce, tomato, banana peppers and house vinaigrette dressing
      $18.00
    • Cheese/BYO - Deep Dish Pizza: Sharing Size

      A blend of mozzarella and provolone, sauce and crispy crust. Sharing size cut in 6 slices. BYO add your own toppings, no half toppings.
      $25.00
    • Spinach Ricotta Mushroom - Deep Dish Pizza: Sharing Size

      A blend of mozzarella and provolone, layered with a spinach ricotta mix, toped with baby bella mushrooms and our house sauce.
      $35.00
    • The Works - Deep Dish Pizza: Sharing Size

      The Works- Italian sausage, mushroom, green pepper, onion - Sharing size feeds 2-3 cut in 6 slices
      $33.00
    • MFW - Deep Dish Pizza: Sharing Size

      The MFW- Italian Sausage, pepperoni, mushroom, green pepper, onion. Sharing size, feeds 2-3 cut in 6 slices
      $35.00
    • Vegan BYO - Deep Dish Pizza: Personal Size

      Our signature vegan crust, Violife cheese, house sauce. BYO- choose toppings
      OUT OF STOCK
      $16.00
    • Cheese/BYO - Deep Dish Pizza: Family Size

      A blend of mozzarella and provolone, sauce and crispy crust. Family size, feeds 3-6, cut in 8 slices. BYO add your own toppings, no half toppings.
      $30.00
    • Spinach Ricotta Mushroom - Deep Dish Pizza: Family Size

      A blend of mozzarella and provolone, layered with a spinach ricotta mix, toped with baby bella mushrooms and our house sauce. Family size feeds 3-6, cut in 8
      $40.00
    • The Works - Deep Dish Pizza: Family Size

      The Works- Italian sausage, mushroom, green pepper, onion - Family size feeds 3-6 cut in 8 slices
      $38.00
    • MFW - Deep Dish Pizza: Family Size

      The MFW- Italian sausage, pepperoni mushroom, green pepper, onion. Family size feeds 3-6, cut in 8 slices.
      $40.00

    Sandwiches

    • Italian Beef Sandwich

      Our house made Italian beef, sliced thin, french roll and your choice of hot giardiniera, sweet peppers or both.
      $14.00
    • Italian Sausage Sandwich

      An Italian sausage link, and your choice of hot giardiniera, sweet peppers, or both.
      $10.00
    • Combo Sandwich

      3oz of our house made Italian beef, thinly sliced, an Italian sausage link, and your choice of hot giardiniera, sweet peppers, or both.
      $16.00
    • Meatball Sub

      3 3oz scratch made pork and beef meatballs, our marinara, provolone and mozzarella cheese on a toasted Turano french roll, served with chips
      $14.00

    Appetizers

    • Pretzel and Boursin Cheese

      Shareable pretzel with a side of our homemade boursin cheese.
      $12.00
    • Spinach Dip

      Warm and cheesy spinach and artichoke dip served with a side of crostini (tiny toasts)
      $11.00
    • Bruschetta Crostini

      Tomatoes tossed in vinaigrette, served on crostini (tiny toasts), topped with feta and a balsamic glaze.
      $9.00
    • Goat Cheese and Marinara

      Our marinara with dollops of goat cheese. Served warm with a side of crostini (tiny toasts)
      $10.00
    • Meatballs

      3 ounce house made meatballs, pork and beef, marinara
      $4.50+
    • Garlic Cheese Bread

      $6.00+

    Salads and Soup

    • Garden Salad

      Romaine, cherry tomatoes, cucumbers, sweet peppers
      $6.00+
    • Caesar Salad

      Romaine, croutons, fresh shaved parmesan, and our key lime caesar dressing
      $6.00+
    • Greek Salad - Full

      Romaine, tomato, sweet peppers, artichoke, cucumbers, kalamata olives, feta cheese
      $15.00
    • CUP Wedding Soup

      OUT OF STOCK
      $6.00
    • BOWL Wedding Soup

      OUT OF STOCK
      $8.00

    Desserts

    • Tiramisu

      $6.00
    • Apple Crumble cheese cake

      OUT OF STOCK
      $8.00

    Sides and Extras

    • Chips (Plain Lays)

      $2.00
    • Side of Giardiniera

      $1.50
    • Side of Red Sauce

      $0.50+
    • Side of Hot Honey

      $2.00
    • Side of Truffle Oil

      $2.00
    • Side of Pepper Potion

      $2.00
    • Extra Side Of Jus

      $2.00
    • Extra Salad Dressing

      $0.75
    • Extra Crostini

      $1.00
    • Extra Boursin Cheese 2oz

      $1.50

    Pasta Specials

    • Meat Lasagna

      $15.00
    • Spaghetti

      OUT OF STOCK
      $15.00

    Beverages

    Non-Alcoholic Beverages

    • Coca-Cola

      Coca-Cola Original Taste — the crisp, refreshing taste you know and love
      $2.00
    • Diet Coke

      Take a Diet Coke break with this refreshing, no-calorie soft drink
      $2.00
    • Sprite

      Classic, cool, crisp lemon-lime flavored taste that's caffeine free
      $2.00
    • Root Beer

      $3.50
    • Cream Soda

      $3.50
    • Sweet/Unsweet Tea

      $2.00
    • Lemonade

      $2.00
    • Fizzy Water

      $3.00
    • Bottle Of Water

      $2.00

    Catering

    Appetizers

    • Cocktail Meatballs 45

      OUT OF STOCK
      $56.00
    • Stuffed Mushrooms 12

      OUT OF STOCK
      $24.00
    • Baked Wings 35 pieces

      OUT OF STOCK
      $65.00
    • Crostini 24

      OUT OF STOCK
      $32.00

    Charcuterie Board

    • Cheese + Fruit Tray (8-10)

      OUT OF STOCK
      $50.00
    • Meat Tray (8-10)

      OUT OF STOCK
      $60.00
    • Sweet + Savory Board (8-10)

      OUT OF STOCK
      $150.00

    Salad

    • Garden Salad - Small (8-12)

      $48.00
    • Garden Salad - Large (15-20)

      OUT OF STOCK
      $60.00
    • Chopped Salad W/ Chicken - Small (10-12)

      OUT OF STOCK
      $60.00
    • Chopped Salad W/ Chicken - Large (15-20)

      OUT OF STOCK
      $75.00
    • Caesar Salad - Small (8-12)

      OUT OF STOCK
      $45.00
    • Caesar Salad - Large (15-20)

      OUT OF STOCK
      $60.00
    • Greek Salad - Small (8-12)

      OUT OF STOCK
      $55.00
    • Greek Salad - Large (15-20)

      OUT OF STOCK
      $70.00
    • Add Chicken - Small

      OUT OF STOCK
      $20.00
    • Add Chicken - Large

      OUT OF STOCK
      $35.00

    Soup

    • Italian Wedding Soup Quart

      OUT OF STOCK
      $12.00
    • Minestrone (Vegan) Quart

      OUT OF STOCK
      $12.00

    Sandwich Trays

    • Italian Beef - Small (10-20)

      10 Full size sandwiches 4 lbs of sliced Italian beef, jus sweet peppers or giardinieria 10 Turano rolls Can be ordered assembled or served in aluminum pan
      OUT OF STOCK
      $135.00
    • Italian Beef - Large (15-30)

      15 Full size sandwiches 6 lbs of sliced Italian beef, jus sweet peppers or giardinieria 15 Turano rolls Can be ordered assembled or served in aluminum pan
      OUT OF STOCK
      $200.00
    • Italian Sausage + Peppers - (Small 10-20)

      12 Full size sandwiches 7 inch Italian sausage links, sweet peppers Turano rolls Can be ordered assembled or served in aluminum pan
      OUT OF STOCK
      $120.00
    • Italian Sausage + Peppers - Large (15-30)

      17 Full size sandwiches 7 inch Italian sausage links, sweet peppers Turano rolls Can be ordered assembled or served in aluminum pan
      OUT OF STOCK
      $170.00
    • Italian Cold Cut on Focaccia - Small (10-12)

      OUT OF STOCK
      $120.00
    • Italian Cold Cut on Focaccia - Large (15-20)

      OUT OF STOCK
      $220.00

    Pasta

    • Spaghetti and 15 Meatballs - Small (8-10)

      OUT OF STOCK
      $45.00
    • 3 Meat Lasagna - Small

      $72.00
    • 3 Meat Lasagna - Large

      OUT OF STOCK
      $170.00
    • Vegetarian Lasagna - Small

      OUT OF STOCK
      $62.00
    • Vegetarian Lasagna - Large

      OUT OF STOCK
      $150.00
    • Spinach - Ricotta Stuffed Shells (24 pieces)

      OUT OF STOCK
      $60.00

    Merchandise

    • HCP Koozie

    • Bottle of Sea Witch Pepper Potion #4

      $10.00
    • Turtle Pint

      $15.00
    • SIP and Paint Wine Tasting 4/28

      Taste 5 wines, mini charcuterie board and paint a wine glass to take home. Tuesday 4/28 7pm
      $45.00+

    All hours
    Sunday12:00 pm - 6:30 pm
    MondayClosed
    TuesdayClosed
    Wednesday12:00 pm - 8:30 pm
    Thursday12:00 pm - 8:30 pm
    Friday12:00 pm - 8:30 pm
    Saturday12:00 pm - 8:30 pm
    Restaurant info

    We are a Chicago born and bred family business serving up our scratch-made Chicago deep dish and thin crust pizza. We have 24 taps of craft beer and wine. We have a small dining room and bar so you can enjoy dine in or take out. We look forward to serving you!

    Location

    1974 US 1, St. Augustine, FL 32086

    Directions


    Similar restaurants in your area

    Pizzalley's Chianti Room 60 Charlotte Street
    View restaurantnext
    Thunder-J's Pizzeria
    View restaurantnext
    Violas
    View restaurantnext
    NYC Meatballs and Pizzeria - Saint Augustine
    View restaurantnext
    V Pizza St. Augustine V8- St Augustine
    View restaurantnext
    JERSEY SLICE - Palencia
    View restaurantnext
    Search similar restaurants
    © 2026 Toast, Inc.
    Toast
    • About Toast
    • For restaurants
    • Terms of Service
    • Privacy Statement
    • Do not sell my
      personal information
    Made with love in Boston
    • Instagram
    • X (formerly Twitter)
    • Facebook