
Pizza
Italian Affair Pizza And Pasta.
3845 Bayshore Road
North Cape May, NJ 08204
Orders through Toast are commission free and go directly to this restaurant
Main Menu
starters
antipasto
all your favorite imported Italian meats, cheeses and veggies$17.00bacon wrapped scallops
5 luscious scallops with crisp bacon$19.00bruschetta
charred baguette, tomato, basil, evoo, balsamic reduction$9.00cheese fries
crispy coated and soft interior with cheddar sauce on the side$8.00cheese fries (cheese on top)
$9.50cheesesteak eggrolls
loaded with fresh steak and cooper sharp cheese$15.00cheesy garlic bread
slathered with a buttery garlic spread and toasted$8.50chicken tender basket
Juicy and tender, breaded and fried to golden perfection, served with honey dijon$13.50mozzarella stix
homemade and gooey mozzarella golden fried$10.00coconut shrimp
shrimp coated in coconut flakes and fried until crispy, served with orange dipping sauce$14.00fried calamari
dipped and dusted, served with crisp wontons and pepperoncini, marinara$16.00fried shrimp basket
panko breaded and golden, served with fries$16.00fries
crispy coated and soft interior$6.50zucchini fries
hand battered, served with tomato sauce for dipping$8.00garlic bread
slathered with a buttery garlic spread and toasted$7.50garlic knots
A classic snack, our garlic knots are strips of pizza dough tied in a knot, baked, and then topped with melted butter, garlic, and parsley.$7.00mozzarella fries
loaded with melty mozzarella$9.50mussels marinara app
mussels are cooked in a tomato-based OR Wine/butter sauce with garlic, herbs, and wine.$16.00onion rings
thin, crispy and savory$9.00pizza fries
loaded with melty mozzarella, tangy tomato sauce and parmesan cheese$10.00steamed little neck clams
tender clams steeped in a garlic lemon-white wine-butter reduction$16.00Old Bay FF
$9.00Broccoli Rabe
$12.00jalapeno cheddar poppers
Juicy jalapeno poppers breaded and filled with cheese and fried to golden perfection.$8.00
soup and salad
Pasta Fagioli
tomato base, cannelinni, pasta$3.29+crab bisque
creamy and rich$4.95+Stuffed pepper soup
Beef, bell peppers, rice$3.29+OUT OF STOCKsoup of the day
ask for today's selection$3.64+OUT OF STOCKtuna garden salad
spinach mix, tomato, onion, tuna, crouton$16.00garden salad
spring lettuce, iceberg, romaine, cherry tomato, cucumber, onion, crouton$8.00
tomato caprese
vine tomato, basil leaf, fresh mozzarella, balsamic reduction, evoo$13.00caesar salad
our famous caesar with iceberg romaine blend, shaved parm cheese, buttery crouton, tableside-style dressing$8.00
classics
1/2 side meatballs (2)
old world recipe with beef pork and veal$4.001/2 side sausage (1)
locally sourced$4.00baked ziti
blend of cheeses, baked to a light crisp$16.00cheese ravioli
10 mouth watering pasta pillows topped with our old world recipe sauce$16.00fettucine alfredo
our famous alfredo made with rich cream and parmigiano reggiano$17.00lasagna
layer upon layer of fresh pasta sheets, beef, pork, veal, sauce, cheeses$17.00linguini and clam sauce
little neck and chopped clams$26.00pasta
$15.00pasta and meatballs
old world sauce and meatball recipe$16.50pasta and meatsauce
old world sauce with beef, pork and veal$16.50pasta and sausage
old world sauce and locally sourced sausage$16.50side of meatballs (4)
old world recipe with beef pork and veal$6.00side of sausage (2)
locally sourced$8.00Penne A La Vodka
$17.00Beef Ravioli
$16.00
burgers
smash-style, served with fries
wraps
Turkey & Cheese Wrap
Turkey breast Made with 2 ingredients (turkey breast and salt) our turkey is not only clean, but it's delicious! Over 50 grams of satisfying protein. Lettuce and tomato$15.00chicken caesar wrap
like the salad, rolled up$12.50chicken cheesesteak wrap
shaved breast, cooper sharp, lettuce tomato$13.50b.l.t. Wrap
green leaf lettuce, crisp bacon, vine tomato mayo$11.50cheesesteak wrap
shaved premium cuts of real beef, cooper sharp, lettuce tomato$16.00buffalo chicken cheesesteak wrap
shaved breast, cooper sharp, lettuce tomato, creamy buffalo$14.00Tuna Wrap
Fresh, made-to-order solid white albacore tuna, lettuce tomato mayo$16.00
entrees
served with side salad and homemade rolls
chicken alfredo
rich parm cream sauce, fettuccine$21.00chicken and broccoli
garlic lemon white wine reduction pasta$19.00Chicken & Broccoli ALFREDO
rich parm cream sauce, fettuccine$24.00chicken marsala
mushroom marsala reduction pasta$20.00chicken parmigiana dinner
saucy and cheesy, side of pasta$22.00Chicken Piccata
In a lemon butter white wine reduction with pasta$19.00eggplant parmigiana dinner
layers of thin fried eggplant, saucy and cheesy, pasta$18.00GRILLED chicken parmigiana dinner
saucy and cheesy, pasta$22.00mussels marinara dinner
seafood infused sauce, pasta$26.00seafood alfredo
seared scallops and shrimp, rich parm cream sauce, fettuccine$38.00seared scallop scampi
garlic lemon white wine reduction pasta$37.00shrimp and crab scampi
garlic lemon white wine reduction pasta$32.00shrimp fra diavolo
spicy robust marinara, pasta$29.00shrimp Scampi
White wine-lemon butter reduction over pasta$29.00veal Marsala
mushroom marsala reduction, pasta$26.00veal parmigiana dinner
real tender veal hand breaded, saucy and cheesy, pasta$27.00veal Piccatta
mushroom marsala reduction, pasta$26.00
sandwiches

Turkey & Cheese Hoagie
Made with 2 ingredients (turkey breast and salt) our turkey is not only clean, but it's delicious! Served on a fresh Aversa's Italian Bakery sub roll, you'll get over 50 grams of satisfying protein. GOING KETO? Ditch the ROLL 🥖, get a BOWL 🥗 Ask for our "hoagie bowl"$14.50bbq chicken cheesesteak
smothered in tangy smoky BBQ, cooper sharp$13.50buffalo chicken cheesesteak
smother in our buttery house buffalo$13.50cheesesteak
real, quality cuts of shaved beef, cooper sharp$14.00cheesesteak hoagie
real, quality cuts of shaved beef, cooper sharp, lettuce tomato onion$15.00chicken cheesesteak
shaved real chicken breast, cooper sharp$12.50Chicken Italiano
$15.25Chicken Parm Sub
$13.00Chicken pizza steak
shaved real chicken breast, cooper sharp, lettuce tomato onion$14.00Chicken cheesesteak hoagie
shaved real chicken breast, cooper sharp, lettuce tomato onion$14.50eggplant parm sub
thin fried eggplant, sauce, cheese, toasted$11.00grilled cheese
buttery and loaded with melty cooper sharp$9.00italian hoagie
quality italian meats and cheeses, lettuce tomato onion$13.00meatball parm sub
simmered in our old world sauce, cheesy, toasted$12.50mixed cheese hoagie
swiss, provolone, cooper sharp, lettuce tomato onion$13.00pizzasteak
real, quality cuts of shaved beef, sauce, provolone$14.50GRILLED Chicken Sandwich
Griled chicken, pickles, lettuce, tomato, brioche$10.00CRISPY Chicken Sandwich
crispy chicken, pickles, lettuce, tomato, brioche$10.00Sausage Peppers & Onion Parm Sub
provolon, sauce, toasted$13.00steak sandwich NO CHEESE
real, quality cuts of shaved beef$13.00tuna hoagie
made to order tuna, lettuce tomato onion$14.00veal parm sub
tender hand breaded real veal cutlet$13.50b.l.t. sandwich
green leaf lettuce, crisp bacon, vine tomato mayo$10.95Sausage Parm Sub
provolon, sauce, toasted$13.00Fried Shrimp Po'Boy
Golden fried jumbo shrimp on a long roll with lettuce tomato and house made Chipotle Ranch.$13.95Italian cheesesteak
$14.95
children's menu
sweets

Dubai Chocolate Torte
chocolate graham crust topped with a luscious ganache and a crunchy layer of pistachio and kataifi, topped with more velvety chocolate ganache – making it a perfect salty, crunchy, decadent bite. Rich flavors of pistachio and chocolate mixed with crunch from kataifi (shredded phyllo dough that is baked until crispy)$8.95
Mississippi Mud Cake
Rich chocolate brownie cake is covered with chocolate mousse, then topped with more brownie chunks and finished with chocolate ganache.$7.95brownie
$3.00cannoli
$4.00cannoli brownie
$6.00triple chocolate cake
$4.95Tiramisu Classico
$7.50Tiramisu Cake
$6.95Raspberry Crumb Cake
Topped With Raspberry Sauce$5.29OUT OF STOCKMini Cannolis (4)
$5.00cannoli cookie
$7.95carrot cake
$4.95cheesecake
$5.00reese's pb pie
$8.29strawberry cheesecake
$6.00zepp bites
$5.00
Monster Cookie
Satisfy big cookie cravings with our Premium Monster Cookie. Each bite is full of different textures and tastes from milk chocolate candies and crunchy caramel pieces to butterscotch-flavored chips, pretzels and oats. Naturally flavored brown butter offers an irresistible nutty, caramelized depth of flavor.$3.39
Pizza
12" personal pizzas
12" personal cheese pizza
$12.50
12" italian affair works pizza
$19.0012" chicken italiano pizza
$17.0012" hawaiian pizza
$16.0012" margherita
$14.0012" chicken florentine pizza
$17.5012" marinara pizza
$12.5012" buffalo chicken pizza
$17.5012" b.b.q. chicken pizza
$17.5012" meatlovers pizza
$18.5012" veggie lovers pizza
$17.5012" cheesesteak pizza
$18.5012" personal Vodka PIzza
drizzled with our famous vodka sauce$15.0012" four cheese pizza
$15.5012" white pizza
$14.50
12" Blazin Luau
Tender mango habanero chicken brings the heat, paired with sweet, juicy pineapple for a tropical twist and fiery rings of Jalapeño. All atop a crisp- saucy crust with melted cheese, this pie is a spicy-sweet celebration that’ll transport you straight to a fiery island feast.$18.00
12" Veg-Italy
In Italian "Vegetable" translated to "Vegetale" (veh-jeh-TAH-leh) but that's boring. So, we came up with The "Veg-Italy" topped with fresh baby spinach, caramelized sweet onion, cherry tomato, eggplant cutlets and roasted red peppers, smothered in evoo, garlic and creamy mozzarella cheese.$22.0012" chicken bacon ranch pizza
$18.5012" personal Hot-Honey Hog (pepperoni)
Pepperoni drizzled with Hot-Honey$16.0012" MeatBall Vodka Pizza
With fresh mozzarella$19.5012" Bruschetta Pie
$14.5012" Fiery Florentine Pizza
This pizza combines the spicy kick of hot Italian sausage with the vibrant flavor of broccoli rabe giving a nod to the pizza's Florence influences.$17.50
The "Joe Rogan" Personal pizza
Double Anchovy and Double Pineapple, Joe Rogan's favorite pizza! He's been known to finish an entire extra large in one sitting. Salty and sweet. The citrus of the pineapple hides the fishiness of the anchovy.$16.50The "Kate Middleton" Personal Pizza
Royals are no strangers to the divinity of pizza. Kate Middleton is said to be an avid pizza lover, and while on many trips to the U.S., she often indulges in a royal pizza featuring prosciutto and sausage toppings.$18.50The "Ed Sheeran" Personal Pizza
Ed Sheeran The famous English songwriter has a unique idea about a pizza and its toppings. For Sheeran, his pizza starts with a traditional sauce and cheese pie, then he tops it with chips (French fries) and rolls it up to dip it in ketchup before he indulges in this tasty creation.$16.00The "Saquon Barkley" Pizza
Number 26's favorite pizza, Extra Steak, Fried onion, Extra Cooper Sharp, no sauce.$26.00
16" large pizzas
16" Large Cheese Pizza
$17.5016" buffalo chicken pizza
$22.5016" b.b.q. chicken pizza
$22.5016" Bruschetta Pizza
$18.5016" cheesesteak pizza
$25.5016" Large Cheese Pizza
$17.5016" chicken italiano pizza
$22.5016" four cheese pizza
$21.0016" hawaiian pizza
$20.00
16" italian affair works pizza
$27.0016" margherita
$20.0016" chicken florentine pizza
$22.5016" Large Vodka Pizza
drizzled with our famous vodka sauce$20.0016" marinara pizza
$17.0016" meatlovers pizza
$24.5016" veggie lovers pizza
$22.50
16" "Buffalo Bleu Blast
Crispy chicken cutlet tossed in Buffalo layered over mozzarella, bleu cheese dressing and more Buffalo$24.0016" Large Boardwalk Dayz Pizza
Inspired by Wildwood, NJ. This classic "upside-down" pizza has a tangy cheddar-mozzarella blend, swirled with sweet tomato sauce on a crispy, thin crust.$18.5016" Large Hot-Honey Hog (pepperoni)
Pepperoni drizzled with Hot-Honey$21.0016" white pizza
$19.50
16" Blazin Luau
Tender mango habanero chicken brings the heat, paired with sweet, juicy pineapple for a tropical twist and fiery rings of Jalapeño. All atop a crisp- saucy crust with melted cheese, this pie is a spicy-sweet celebration that’ll transport you straight to a fiery island feast.$23.5016" chicken bacon ranch pizza
$24.5016" MeatBall Vodka Pizza
With fresh mozzarella$25.50
16" Veg-Italy
In Italian "Vegetable" translated to "Vegetale" (veh-jeh-TAH-leh) but that's boring. So, we came up with The "Veg-Italy" topped with fresh baby spinach, caramelized sweet onion, cherry tomato, eggplant cutlets and roasted red peppers, smothered in evoo, garlic and creamy mozzarella cheese.$28.5016" Fiery Florentine Pizza
This pizza combines the spicy kick of hot Italian sausage with the vibrant flavor of broccoli rabe giving a nod to the pizza's Florence influences.$25.50
The "Joe Rogan" Large Pizza
Double Anchovy and Double Pineapple, Joe Rogan's favorite pizza! He's been known to finish an entire extra large in one sitting. Salty and sweet. The citrus of the pineapple hides the fishiness of the anchovy.$24.50The "Ed Sheeran" Large Pizza
Ed Sheeran The famous English songwriter has a unique idea about a pizza and its toppings. For Sheeran, his pizza starts with a traditional sauce and cheese pie, then he tops it with chips (French fries) and rolls it up to dip it in ketchup before he indulges in this tasty creation.$22.00The "Kate Middleton" Large Pizza
Royals are no strangers to the divinity of pizza. Kate Middleton is said to be an avid pizza lover, and while on many trips to the U.S., she often indulges in a royal pizza featuring prosciutto and sausage toppings.$25.00The "Saquon Barkley" Pizza
Number 26's favorite pizza, Extra Steak, Fried onion, Extra Cooper Sharp, no sauce.$37.00
18" extra large pizzas
18" Extra Large Cheese Pizza
$19.0018" italian affair works pizza
$29.5018" chicken italiano pizza
$26.0018" hawaiian pizza
$23.0018" margherita
$22.0018" chicken florentine pizza
$26.0018" marinara pizza
$21.0018" buffalo chicken pizza
$26.0018" b.b.q. chicken pizza
$26.0018" meatlovers pizza
$27.0018" veggie lovers pizza
$26.0018" cheesesteak pizza
$28.0018" Extra Large Vodka Pizza
drizzled with our famous vodka sauce$24.0018" four cheese pizza
$23.0018" Extra Large Hot-Honey Hog (pepperoni)
Pepperoni drizzled with Hot-Honey$23.5018" white pizza
$22.0018" chicken bacon ranch pizza
$28.0018" MeatBall Vodka Pizza
With fresh mozzarella$29.0018" Fiery Florentine Pizza
This pizza combines the spicy kick of hot Italian sausage with the vibrant flavor of broccoli rabe giving a nod to the pizza's Florence influences.$29.00
The "Joe Rogan" Extra Large Pizza
Double Anchovy and Double Pineapple, Joe Rogan's favorite pizza! He's been known to finish an entire extra large in one sitting. Salty and sweet. The citrus of the pineapple hides the fishiness of the anchovy.$30.00The "Ed Sheeran" Extra Large Pizza
Ed Sheeran The famous English songwriter has a unique idea about a pizza and its toppings. For Sheeran, his pizza starts with a traditional sauce and cheese pie, then he tops it with chips (French fries) and rolls it up to dip it in ketchup before he indulges in this tasty creation.$24.00The "Kate Middleton" Extra Large Pizza
Royals are no strangers to the divinity of pizza. Kate Middleton is said to be an avid pizza lover, and while on many trips to the U.S., she often indulges in a royal pizza featuring prosciutto and sausage toppings.$27.0018" bruschetta
$22.50The "Saquon Barkley" Pizza
Number 26's favorite pizza, Extra Steak, Fried onion, Extra Cooper Sharp, no sauce.$40.00
slices and novelties
Slice Pizza
$2.75pepperoni slice
$3.60garlic knots
$4.00+Veggie Slice
$4.50Chix Brusc Slice
$4.50OUT OF STOCKMeatLover's Slice
Pepperoni sausage bacon meatballs$4.50Philly Roll
$3.95OUT OF STOCKBuff Chix Slice
$3.75Chix Parm Slice
$4.50OUT OF STOCKIA Special Slice
$4.50Pizza Kit
$16.95brocc roll
$2.95OUT OF STOCKbbq chix slice
$3.95Cheesesteak Slice
$3.95gma vodka pesto
$4.00OUT OF STOCKItalian Meats Roll
$3.75Veggie Ital. Slice
$4.50Cheesesteak peppers and onions
$4.50
Bolis, Calzones, Panzerottis
regular size
Beverages
Soda Can
Soda 20oz

Coca-Cola, 20oz
Coca-Cola Original Taste — the crisp, refreshing taste you know and love$2.49
Diet Coke, 20oz
Take a Diet Coke break with this refreshing, no-calorie soft drink$2.49
Sprite, 20oz
Classic, cool, crisp lemon-lime flavored taste that's caffeine free$2.49
Coca-Cola Zero Sugar, 20oz
Enjoy the great taste of Coca-Cola with zero sugar, zero calories$2.49OUT OF STOCKdr pepper 20oz
$2.49
Soda 2 Liter
Iced Tea & Water
Sweet Gold Peak
$2.98
Gold Peak Green Tea
Gold Peak is real brewed tea made from tea leaves picked for peak taste. Gold Peak Real Brewed Tea has a variety of flavors that pair marvelously with any family occasion, from backyard get-togethers, to holiday traditions, to weekend getaways. Real Brewed. Real Tea. Real Good.$2.98Diet Gold Peak
$2.98
Gold Peak Lemon Tea
Gold Peak is real brewed tea made from tea leaves picked for peak taste. Gold Peak Real Brewed Tea has a variety of flavors that pair marvelously with any family occasion, from backyard get-togethers, to holiday traditions, to weekend getaways. Real Brewed. Real Tea. Real Good.$2.98
Gold Peak Peach Tea
Gold Peak Real Brewed Georgia Peach Black Tea$2.98bottle water
$1.39
Miscellaneous
community
Miscellaneous
Lg Dough ball
$4.65Sm Dough Ball
$3.65Dinner roll
$1.00Side Ranch
$0.65Side Bleu Ch
$0.65Lg Sos
$1.75Sm Sos
$1.00Side Hot Sauce
$0.65Side Parm
$0.75Side Cheese Sauce
$1.50Side BBQ
$0.65Plates And Napkins
$2.00Side Hot Peppers
$0.65Side Ceaser
$0.65Quart of Sauce
$8.00Side Honey Mustard
$0.65sauteed spinach
$4.00side broc
$4.00
Back Of House Tips
Menu Additions
Lunch Menu Additions
Crispy Chicken Bacon Ranch Wrap
Crispy chicken tenders, bacon, lettuce, tomato and ranch dressing$12.95
Fish 'n' Chips
A whole 12 ounce beer battered filet, crisp "chips," cole slaw, malt vinegar, tarter sauce & lemon.$29.95OUT OF STOCK
Fried Grouper PoBoy
Golden fried grouper filets on a long roll with lettuce tomato and house made tarter sauce. Side of fries$18.95OUT OF STOCK
2 For $20 Pasta Bowls
CATERING (minimum 24 hours notice required)
Serves Approximately Twenty (20) Guests
Garden Salad
$48.00Caesar Salad
$48.00Bruschetta
$55.00Antipasto
$160.00Coconut Shrimp
$85.00Lasagna
$125.00Penne A La Vodka
$95.00Baked Ziti
$95.00Cheese Ravioli
$110.00Penne tomato sauce
$75.00Penne Alfredo
$95.00Chicken Alfredo
$145.00Chicken Parmigiana
$125.00Mac 'N' Cheese
$145.00Eggplant Parmigiana
$85.00Chicken Marsala
$125.00Meatballs
$100.00Sausage & Peppers
$125.00Shrimp Scampi & Linguini
$180.00Italian Hoagie Tray
$98.00Cannoli
$90.00Tiramusu
$90.00Cheesecake
$80.00Strawberry Cheesecake
$95.001 dozen rolls
$8.00Chicken Tenders
$130.00
Serves Approximately Ten (10) Guests
Garden Salad
$25.00Caesar Salad
$25.00Bruschetta
$30.00Antipasto
$85.00Coconut Shrimp
$45.00Lasagna
$65.00Penne A La Vodka
$50.00Chicken Parmigiana
$65.00Baked Ziti
$50.00Cheese Ravioli
$60.00Penne tomato sauce
$40.00Penne Alfredo
$50.00Chicken Alfredo
$75.00Chicken Tenders
$70.00Eggplant Parmigiana
$45.00Chicken Marsala
$65.00Meatballs
$52.00Mac 'N' Cheese
$75.00Sausage & Peppers
$65.00Shrimp Scampi & Linguini
$95.00Italian Hoagie Tray
$55.00Cannoli
$45.00Tiramusu
$45.00Cheesecake
$45.00Strawberry Cheesecake
$50.00
All hours
| Sunday | 11:00 am - 9:45 pm |
| Monday | 11:00 am - 9:45 pm |
| Tuesday | 11:00 am - 9:45 pm |
| Wednesday | 11:00 am - 9:45 pm |
| Thursday | 11:00 am - 9:45 pm |
| Friday | 11:00 am - 9:45 pm |
| Saturday | 11:00 am - 9:45 pm |
Restaurant info
ITALIAN AFFAIR PIZZA & PASTA offers Authentic Old World Cooking and provides a large selection of pasta dishes including: Chicken, Veal, Seafood, and New York Style Thin Crust Pizza. Our sauces, pizza dough, dinner rolls and more are made fresh daily and our chef works hard to prepare every dish from scratch. Hoagies and Cheesesteaks are a Must-Try.
Location
Similar restaurants in your area
© 2026 Toast, Inc.











