Skip to Main content

  • Josie's Pizza Hilltop 3205 W Broad St

    Josie's Pizza Hilltop 3205 W Broad St
  • Home
  • /
  • Columbus
  • /
  • Josie's Pizza Hilltop
Restaurant banner image
Pizza, Salads, Sandwiches

Josie's Pizza Hilltop

3205 W Broad St

Columbus, OH 43204

Orders through Toast are commission free and go directly to this restaurant

phone icon

Call

clock icon

Hours

waypoint sign icon

Directions

gift icon

Gift Cards

Food
Beverage

Featured Items

  • One Item Pizza (large 14")

    14" round thin crust

    $16.50
  • Chicken Wings (6)
    $7.75
  • Italian Sub

    salami, hot ham, provolone cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion & hot pepper

    $8.75

Food

Pizza

  • One Item Pizza (large 14")

    14" round thin crust

    $16.50
  • One Item Pizza (small 10")

    14" round thin crust

    $9.75
  • Cheese Pizza (large 14")

    14" round thin crust

    $15.50
  • Cheese Pizza (small 10'')

    14" round thin crust

    $9.00
  • Pizza Bowl

    Try our gluten-free option! Pizza sauce, cheese & up to 3 toppings of your choice! Additional toppings - $1.00 each

    $7.50

Specialty Pizzas

  • B.L.T (large)

    14" bacon, lettuce & tomato, served with ranch dressing

    $19.50
  • B.L.T (small)

    10" bacon, lettuce & tomato, served with ranch dressing

    $11.50
  • Combination (large)

    14" pepperoni, sausage, mushroom, onion & green peppers

    $19.50
  • Combination (small)

    10" pepperoni, sausage, mushroom, onion & green peppers

    $11.50
  • Gut Buster - Meat Lover's (large)

    14" regular pepperoni, old fashion pepperoni, sausage, bacon, ham & extra cheese

    $23.00
  • Gut Buster - Meat Lover's (small)

    10" regular pepperoni, old fashion pepperoni, sausage, bacon, ham & extra cheese

    $13.00
  • Hawaiian (large)

    14" ham & pineapple

    $18.50
  • Hawaiian (small)

    10" ham & pineapple

    $10.50
  • Mexican (large)

    10" taco-seasoned hamburger, jalapenos, cheddar cheese, lettuce, tomato & sour cream

    $19.75
  • Mexican (small)

    10" taco-seasoned hamburger, jalapenos, cheddar cheese, lettuce, tomato & sour cream

    $11.75
  • Old Fashion Pepperoni (large)

    14" spicy, nickel-sized pepperoni

    $18.50
  • Old Fashion Pepperoni (small)

    10" spicy, nickel-sized pepperoni

    $10.50
  • Supreme (large)

    14" pepperoni, sausage, mushroom, onion, green pepper, hot pepper, black olive, ham & extra cheese

    $23.00
  • Supreme (small)

    10" pepperoni, sausage, mushroom, onion, green pepper, hot pepper, black olive, ham & extra cheese

    $13.00
  • Veggie (large)

    14" tomato, onion, green pepper, hot pepper, black olive, & mushroom

    $18.75
  • Veggie (small)

    10" tomato, onion, green pepper, hot pepper, black olive, & mushroom

    $10.75
  • Grilled Chicken Sp (Lg)
    $18.75
  • Grilled Chicken Sp (Sm)
    $10.50
  • Valentine Special (2 heart shaped, one item pizzas + free 2L)
    $20.00

Calzones

  • Calzone (large)

    Our large homemade pizza shell, wrapped up with your choice of 2 regular toppings (premium toppings available), smothered in butter & garlic sauce, oregano & Romano cheese - served with marinara sauce for dipping

    $16.50
  • Calzone (small)

    Our small homemade pizza shell, wrapped up with your choice of 2 regular toppings (premium toppings available), smothered in butter & garlic sauce, oregano & Romano cheese - served with maranara sauce for dipping

    $9.75

Appetizers & Side Items

  • Cheese Sticks (6)
    $6.75
  • Chicken Nuggets (8)
    $6.50
  • Chicken Wings (6)
    $7.75
  • French Fries
    $4.50
  • Onion Rings
    $4.75
  • Fried Mushrooms (12)
    $4.75
  • Fried Cauliflower
    $4.75
  • Fried Broccoli & Cheese (8)
    $5.75
  • Cheddar Poppers (6)
    $5.75
    OUT OF STOCK
  • Cream Cheese Poppers (6)
    $5.75
  • Garlic Bread with Sauce
    $4.25
  • Garlic Bread with Cheese & Sauce
    $5.50
  • Meatball (1 each)
    $1.00
  • Mini Corn Dogs (10)
    $5.00
  • Crispy Pepperoni (pep only)
    $1.50
  • Fish Patty
    $2.00
  • Garlic butter
  • Crispy Chicken Patty
    $2.00

9" Submarines

  • Italian Sub

    salami, hot ham, provolone cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion & hot pepper

    $8.75
  • Super Sub

    double meats; salami & hot ham along with provolone cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion & hot pepper

    $9.75
  • Stromboli Sub

    seasoned meat patty, lettuce, tomato, onion, & hot pepper

    $9.75
  • The Beast Sub

    italian & stromboli meats, cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion, & hot pepper

    $11.50
  • Meatball Sub

    three Italian meatballs, spaghetti sauce & provolone cheese

    $8.75
  • Crispy Chicken Sub

    fried chicken filets, provolone cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion & hot pepper

    $9.75
  • Ham & Cheese Sub

    ham, provolone cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion & hot pepper

    $8.75
  • Fish Sub

    fried fish patty, American cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion, hot pepper & tarter sauce

    $8.75
  • Grilled Chicken Sub

    grilled chicken, provolone cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion & hot pepper

    $9.75
  • Veggie Sub

    Provolone cheese, American cheese, mushroom, onion, green pepper, hot pepper, black olives & tomato

    $8.25
  • Pizza Sub

    mozzarell cheese, pepperoni & pizza sauce

    $8.75
  • Super Ham And Ch
    $9.75

Salads

  • Garden Salad (small)

    garden mix with tomato

    $5.00
  • Garden Salad (large)

    garden mix with tomato

    $6.50
  • Chef Salad (small)

    ham, salalmi, pepperoni, mozzarella cheese & tomato

    $7.00
  • Chef Salad (large)

    ham, salalmi, pepperoni, mozzarella cheese & tomato

    $8.50
  • Grilled Chick. Salad (small)

    grilled chicken, cheese & tomato

    $8.00
  • Grilled Chick. Salad (large)

    grilled chicken, cheese & tomato

    $9.50
  • Crispy Chicken Salad (small)

    fried chicken strips, bacon, cheese & tomato

    $8.00
  • Crispy Chicken Salad (large)

    fried chicken strips, bacon, cheese & tomato

    $9.50
  • Crispy Pepperoni Salad (small)

    mozzarella cheese, tomato, hot peppers, black olives topped with fried pepperoni

    $7.00
  • Crispy Pepperoni Salad (large)

    mozzarella cheese, tomato, hot peppers, black olives topped with fried pepperoni

    $8.50
  • Junk Salad ( Large)
    $9.75
  • Junk Salad ( Small)
    $8.25
  • Garlic Butter Sauce
    $0.75
  • Sauces/ Dressing

Dinners

  • Spaghetti Dinner

    spaghetti noodles in marinara sauce & with an Italian meatball, garden salad & dinner roll

    $9.75
  • Lasagna Dinner

    topped with cheese & baked in our pizza oven, garden salad & dinner roll

    $9.75
  • Shrimp Dinner

    21 pieces of fried shrimp, served with garden salad & dinner roll

    $9.75
  • Fish Dinner

    two pieces of cod, served with French fries, garden salad & dinner roll

    $9.75
  • Chicken Wing Dinner

    six wings, served with French fries, salad & dinner roll

    $9.50

Sandwiches

  • Cheeseburger

    served with pickle, lettuce & onion

    $6.75
  • Double Cheeseburger

    served with pickle, lettuce & onion

    $8.50
  • Hamburger

    served with pickle, lettuce & onion

    $6.25
  • Double Hamburger

    served with pickle, lettuce & onion

    $7.75
  • Meatball Sandwich

    served with provolone cheese

    $5.00
  • Crispy Chicken Sandwich

    served with provolone cheese, lettuce, tomato & onion

    $6.75
  • Grilled Chicken Sandwich

    served with provolone cheese, lettuce, tomato & onion

    $6.75
  • Grilled Cheese Sandwich
    $4.00
  • Fish Sandwich
    $6.75
    OUT OF STOCK

Beverage

Beverages

  • Bottle Water
    $1.50
  • Pepsi (can)
    $1.50
  • Pepsi (6 pack)
    $5.75
  • Pepsi (20oz)
    $2.50
  • Pepsi (2 liter)
    $3.75
  • Pepsi Zero
    $2.50
  • Diet Pepsi (can)
    $1.50
  • Diet Pepsi (6 pack)
    $5.75
  • Diet Pepsi (20oz)
    $2.50
  • Diet Pepsi (2 Liter)
    $3.75
  • Mt Dew (can)
    $1.50
  • Mt Dew (6 pack)
    $5.75
  • Mt Dew (20oz)
    $2.50
  • Mt Dew (2 Liter)
    $3.75
  • Diet Mt Dew (can)
    $1.50
  • Diet Mt Dew (6 pack)
    $5.75
  • Diet Mt Dew (20oz)
    $2.50
  • Dr Pepper (can)
    $1.50
  • Dr Pepper (6 pack)
    $5.75
  • Dr Pepper (20oz)
    $2.50
  • Dr Pepper (2 Liter)
    $3.75
  • Dr Pepper Zero (20oz)
    $2.50
  • Diet Dr Pepper (can)
    $1.50
  • Diet Dr Pepper (6 pack)
    $5.75
  • Diet Dr Pepper (20 oz)
    $2.50
  • Starry (20oz)
    $2.50
  • Starry (2 Liter)
    $3.75
  • Root Beer (20 oz)
    $2.50
  • Root Beer (2 Liter)
    $3.75
  • Orange Crush (20 oz)
    $2.50
  • Orange Crush (2 Liter)
    $3.75
  • Grape Crush (20 oz)
    $2.50
  • Root Beer Zero(20oz)
    $2.50
All hours
Sunday4:00 pm - 9:15 pm
MondayClosed
Tuesday11:00 am - 9:15 pm
Wednesday11:00 am - 9:15 pm
Thursday11:00 am - 9:15 pm
Friday11:00 am - 10:15 pm
Saturday4:00 pm - 10:15 pm
Restaurant info

Josie's Pizza is a family-owned & operated Hilltop dining tradition dating back to 1959!

Location

3205 W Broad St, Columbus, OH 43204

Directions

Similar restaurants in your area

Gallop's Bar and Kitchen
View restaurantnext
Minico's Italian Restaurant
View restaurantnext
Baseballs Dairy Diamond/Triple Play Pizza
View restaurantnext
Payne's Pizza & More
View restaurantnext
Christys Family Pizzeria
View restaurantnext
Cog's n Gear's 219 E Court St
View restaurantnext
Search similar restaurants
© 2025 Toast, Inc.
Toast
  • About Toast
  • For restaurants
  • Terms of Service
  • Privacy Statement
  • Do not sell my
    personal information
Made with love in Boston
  • Instagram
  • X (formerly Twitter)
  • Facebook