Skip to Main content
  • Matty's Bar & Grille

    • Home
    • /
    • New Berlin
    • /
    • Matty's Bar & Grille
    Restaurant banner image
    American

    Matty's Bar & Grille

    14460 College Ave

    New Berlin, WI 53151


    Orders through Toast are commission free and go directly to this restaurant


    Call

    Hours

    Directions

    Gift Cards

    STARTERS
    SMOKED WINGS
    CRAFTED BURGERS
    SANDWICHES
    WRAPS
    BOWLS
    GARDEN SALADS
    HANDCRAFTED PIZZAS
    SAUCES

    STARTERS

    • BAVARIAN BEAST PRETZEL

      SHAREABLE SOFT PRETZEL SERVED WITH STONE GROUND MUSTARD AND HOUSE-MADE YUENGLING BEER CHEESE.
      $17.95
    • BUFFALO CHICKEN DIP

      SEASONED CHICKEN AND HOUSE-MADE BUFFALO CREAM CHEESE DIP TOPPED WITH BLEU CHEESE CRUMBLES. SERVED WITH MATTY'S DIPPER FRIES.
      $13.99
    • CHEESE CURDS

      LIGHTLY BREADED AND DEEP FRIED. MADE WITH FRESH WISCONSIN WHITE CHEDDAR CHEESE. SERVED WITH A SIDE OF HOUSE-MADE RANCH OR CHIPOTLE RANCH.
      $9.99
    • CHICKEN TENDERS

      OUR JUICY, BREADED CHICKEN TENDERS. FIVE PER ORDER. ORDER WITH TWO DIPPING SAUCES. MAKE IT A MEAL! THE ADULTS ASKED, WE DELIVERED. ADD TWO SIDES +3.50
      $12.49
    • ONION DIP & CHIPS

      A GENEROUS PORTION OF FRENCH ONION DIP SERVED WITH A SIDE OF HOUSE-MADE POTATO CHIPS.
      $8.99
    • HATCH CHILI & JALAPEÑO CHEESE CURDS

      WHITE CHEDDAR CHEESE CURDS TOSSED IN A HATCH CHILI & JALAPENO DRY RUB. SERVED WITH A SIDE OF HOUSE-MADE JALAPENO RANCH.
      $10.99
    • MATTY'S MOZZARELLA LOGS

      THESE HAND-BREADED MOZZARELLA LOGS ARE FRIED TO PERFECTION! SERVED WITH HOUSE-MADE MARINARA FOR DIPPING. FOUR PER ORDER.
      $11.49
    • QUESADILLA

      CHOICE OF CHICKEN OR BEEF WITH MONTEREY JACK CHEESE AND HOUSE-MADE PICO DE GALLO.
      $11.99
    • SPINACH & ARTICHOKE DIP

      A BLEND OF CHEESE, SPINACH, RED ONIONS AND ARTICHOKE HEARTS. SERVED IN A BREAD BOWL WITH A SIDE OF TORTILLA CHIPS AND CELERY.
      $14.99
    • ULTIMATE NACHOS

      FRESH TORTILLA CHIPS TOPPED WITH CHOICE OF CHICKEN OR BEEF WITH CHEESE CAUSE, MONTEREY JACK CHEESE, BLACK OLIVES, FRESH JALAPENOS, HOUSE-MADE PICO DE GALLO AND A SIDE OF SALSA AND SOUR CREAM.
      $13.99

    SMOKED WINGS

    • SMOKED WINGS

      MARINATED IN OUR SECRET SEASONING AND SLOW-SMOKED FOR THREE HOURS UNTIL TENDER AND JUICY. SERVED WITH CELERY AND A SIDE OF HOUSE-MADE RANCH OR BLEU CHEESE.
      $12.99+

    CRAFTED BURGERS

    • DOUBLE BEEF DOUBLE CHEESE BEAST

      JUST WHAT IT SOUNDS LIKE, PLUS LETTUCE, TOMATO AND YOUR CHOICE OF CHEESE ON A TOASTED BRIOCHE BUN.
      $22.99
    • FRENCH ONION BURGER

      1/2 LB SMOKEHOUSE BURGER TOPPED WITH CARAMELIZED ONIONS, MELTED SWISS CHEESE AND GRANDMA MARGE'S FRENCH ONION DIP ON A TOASTED BRIOCHE BUN.
      $15.99
    • MUSHROOM SWISS BURGER

      1/2 LB SMOKEHOUSE BURGER TOPPED IWTH SAUTEED MUSHROOMS, SWISS CHEESE AND RICH BEEF GRAVY ON A TOASTED BRIOCHE BUN.
      $15.99
    • NEW BERLIN BURGER

      1/2 LB SMOKEHOUSE BURGER TOPPED WITH SMOKED BRISKET, GOUDA CHEESE, SAUTEED MUSHROOMS AND CARAMELIZED ONIONS ON A TOASTED PRETZEL BUN.
      $16.99
    • PATTY MELT

      1/2 LB SMOKEHOUSE BURGER PATTY TOPPED WITH CARAMELIZED ONIONS, AMERICAN AND SWISS CHEESE ON TOASTED MARBLE RYE.
      $15.99
    • THE HANGOVER BURGER

      $17.99
    • THE LEGENDARY MUSKEGO PIZZA BURGER

      THE ORIGINAL MUSKEGO PIZZA BURGER FEATURING THE DEANGELIS' FAMILY RECIPE. A HANDCRAFTED ITALIAN SAUSAGE PATTY TOPPED WITH MOZZARELLA, SAUTEED MUSHROOMS, DICED ONIONS AND THE FAMILY'S ORIGINAL SECRET PIZZA SAUCE ON A TOASTED FRENCH ROLL.
      $17.99

    SANDWICHES

    • MATTY'S BLT

      LOADS OF BACON, LETTUCE, TOMATO AND GARLIC AIOLI ON TOASTED SOURDOUGH.
      $13.99
    • GROWN-UP GRILLED CHEESE

      AMERICAN, GOUDA, MOZZARELLA AND CHEDDAR CHEESE WITH BACON AND SUN-DRIED TOMATOES ON TOASTED SOURDOUGH.
      $14.99
    • BLACKENED PESTO CHICKEN SANDWICH

      BLACKENED CHICKEN TOPPED WITH FRESH MOZZARELLA, LETTUCE, TOMATO AND PESTO SAUCE ON A TOASTED CIABATTA BUN.
      $15.99
    • MATTY'S STEAK SANDWICH

      60Z GARLIC MARINATED TENDERLOIN STEAK TOPPED WITH GRILLED ONIONS, MUSHROOMS AND A GARLIC HERB SPREAD ON A TOASTED CIABATTA BUN.
      $22.99

    WRAPS

    • BOURBON CHICKEN WRAP

      GRILLED CHICKEN WITH WOODFORD RESERVE BOURBON GLAZE, BROWN RICE, MONTEREY JACK CHEESE, SAUTEED BELL PEPPERS AND ONIONS IN A SUN-DRIED TOMATO TORTILLA.
      $15.49
    • CHICKEN BACON RANCH WRAP

      CHRISPY CHICKEN WITH LETTUCE, TOMATO, BACON, MONTEREY JACK CHEESE AND HOUSE-MADE RANCH DRESSING IN A SUN-DRIED TOMATO TORTILLA.
      $15.49
    • SOUTH OF THE BORDER WRAP

      GRILLED CHICKEN, BLACK BEAN AND CORN RELISH WITH CHIPOTLE RANCH, PICO DE GALLO, LETTUCE, MONTEREY JACK CHEESE AND TORTILLA STRIPS IN A SUN-DRIED TOMATO TORTILLA.
      $14.49
    • TURKEY AVOCADO BLT WRAP

      ROASTED TURKEY WITH LETTUCE, TOMATO, BACON, AVOCADO AND GARLIC AIOLI IN A SUN-DRIED TOMATO TORTILLA.
      $15.49

    BOWLS

    • CHEF TONY'S JAMBALAYA

      A HEARTY BOWL OF SHRIMP, ANDOUILLE SAUSAGE AND A SOUTHERN MIX OF PEPPERS, ONIONS, TOMATOES AND RICE. SERVED WITH CORNBREAD.
      $20.95
    • MAKER'S MARK BOURBON BRUSHED ATLANTIC SALMON BOWL

      GRILLED ATLANTIC SALMON BRUSHED WITH A HOUSE-MADE MAKER'S MARK BOURBON GLAZE SERVED OVER BROWN RICE, TOMATOES AND RED ONIONS WITH SEASONAL VEGGIES AND LEMON WEDGES. SERVED WITH GARLIC BREAD.
      $21.99
    • MATTY'S BURRITO BOWL

      GRILLED CHICKEN SERVED OVER A BOWL OF CILANTRO LIME RICE WITH BLACK BEAN AND CORN RELISH, SHREDDED LETTUCE, PICO DE GALLO, HOUSE-MADE GUACAMOLE, MONTEREY JACK CHEESE AND TORTILLA STRIPS. SERVED WITH A SIDE OF JALAPENO RANCH.
      $17.95
    • PESTO CHICKEN PASTA

      CAVATAPPI PASTA TOSSED IN OUR HOUSE-MADE GARLIC PESTO CREAM SAUCE WITH GRILLED CHICKEN, FRESH TOMATOES AND SHAVED PARMESAN. SERVED WITH GARLIC BREAD.
      $17.49
    • SKILLET MAC 'N' CHEESE

      CAVATAPPI PASTA TOSSED IN A HOUSE-MADE THREE CHEESE SAUCE. TOPPED WITH BACON, SMOKED BRISKET AND BREAD CRUMBS. SERVED WITH GARLIC BREAD.
      $18.99

    GARDEN SALADS

    • CAESAR SALAD

      CRISP ROMAINE LETTUCE TOPPED WITH SHAVED PARMESAN CHEESE AND HOUSE-MADE CROUTONS. SERVED WITH A SIDE OF CAESAR DRESSING.
      $12.99
    • MATTY'S TACO SALAD

      CHOICE OF CHICKEN OR BEEF SERVED OVER A BED OF LETTUCE, BLACK BEAN AND CORN RELISH, PICO DE GALLO, BLACK OLIVES, JALAPENOS AND SHREDDED CHEDDAR CHEESE IN A DEEP FRIED TORTILLA BOWL. SERVED WITH A SIDE OF SALSA AND SOUR CREAM.
      $16.99
    • THE WALDORF SALAD

      FRESH SPRING SALAD MIX AND GRILLED CHICKEN WITH DICED APPLES, WALNUTS, CUCUMBERS, GORGONZOLA CHEESE AND GRAPES. SERVED WITH RASPBERRY VINAIGRETTE.
      $16.99
    • TURKEY COBB SALAD

      CRISP ROMAINE LETTUCE TOPPED WITH ROASTED TURKEY, TOMATOES, BACON, RED ONION, CUCUMBER, HARD BOILED EDD, BLEU CHEESE CRUMBLES AND SHREDDED CHEDDAR CHEESE. SERVED WITH YOUR CHOICE OF DRESSING.
      $15.99

    HANDCRAFTED PIZZAS

    • 9" BYO PIZZA

      $13.99
    • 12" GLUTEN FREE PIZZA

      $18.99
    • 14" BYO PIZZA

      $18.99
    • CHICKEN BACON RANCH PIZZA

      HOUSE-MADE RANCH SAUCE TOPPED WITH GRILLED CHICKEN, BACON AND MOZZARELLA CHEESE. FINISHED WITH A RANCH DRIZZLE.
      $17.99+
    • MARGHERITA PIZZA

      PESTO SAUCE, FRESH MOZZARELLA, SLICED TOMATOES, BASIL AND BALSAMIC GLAZE.
      $17.99+
    • MATTY'S MEAT LOVERS PIZZA

      HOUSE-MADE PIZZA SAUCE, CANADIAN BACON, PEPPERONI, ITALIAN SAUSAGE, BACON AND MOZZARELLA CHEESE.
      $18.99+
    • THE BIG BACKYARD BBQ CHICKEN PIZZA

      BBQ SAUCE TOPPED WITH GRILLED CHICKEN, RED ONIONS, PINEAPPLE, JALAPENOS AND MOZZARELLA CHEESE.
      $17.99+

    SAUCES

    • BALSAMIC VINAIGRETTE

      $0.59
    • BBQ

      $0.59
    • BLEU CHEESE

      $0.59
    • BUFFALO SAUCE

      $0.59
    • CAESAR

      $0.59
    • CHIPOTLE RANCH

      $0.59
    • CREAMY ITALIAN

      $0.59
    • FRENCH

      $0.59
    • GARLIC PARMESAN

      $0.59
    • GOCHUJANG KOREAN BBQ

      $0.59
    • GRANDMA MARGE'S FRENCH ONION DIP

      $0.99
    • HONEY MUSTARD

      $0.59
    • HOT HONEY

      $0.59
    • HOUSE-MADE JALAPENO RANCH

      $0.59
    • HOUSE-MADE RANCH

      $0.59
    • MATTY'S MALLOW DIP

      $0.99
    • NACHO CHEESE

      $0.99
    • PARMESAN PEPPERCORN

      $0.59
    • RASPBERRY VINAIGRETTE

      $0.59
    • STONE GROUND MUSTARD

      $0.99
    • THAI CHILI

      $0.59
    • WOODFORD RESERVE BOURBON BBQ

      $0.59
    • YUENGLING BEER CHEESE

      $0.99

    All hours
    Sunday9:00 am - 9:00 pm
    Monday11:00 am - 9:00 pm
    Tuesday11:00 am - 10:00 pm
    Wednesday11:00 am - 10:00 pm
    Thursday11:00 am - 10:00 pm
    Friday11:00 am - 10:00 pm
    Saturday9:00 am - 10:00 pm
    Restaurant info

    Your Wisconsin sports team authority featuring a chef inspired menu in a friendly, casual sports bar atmosphere. Lunch and dinner are served seven days a week and breakfast is served Saturdays and Sundays. We also happen to have the biggest and best bourbon selection in the area!

    Location

    14460 College Ave, New Berlin, WI 53151

    Directions


    Similar restaurants in your area

    Matty's Catering
    View restaurantnext
    Eagle Park Brewing Company Muskego
    View restaurantnext
    BrunchBerry
    View restaurantnext
    Milk Can Hamburgers
    View restaurantnext
    Vintage Grounds S74W16825 Janesville Rd
    View restaurantnext
    Danny Haskell's W171 S7260 Lannon Dr
    View restaurantnext
    Search similar restaurants
    © 2026 Toast, Inc.
    Toast
    • About Toast
    • For restaurants
    • Terms of Service
    • Privacy Statement
    • Do not sell my
      personal information
    Made with love in Boston
    • Instagram
    • X (formerly Twitter)
    • Facebook