
American
McGraths Burger Shack - Outer Banks
5000 South Croatan Highway
11-14
Nags Head, NC 27959
Orders through Toast are commission free and go directly to this restaurant
Pickup Only
Featured Items

Bacon Cheese
1/2 pound grass fed burger topped with Cheddar, bacon, lettuce, tomato and onion$18.00
McGrath's Irish Nachos
Steak Fries topped with Guinness beer cheese,shredded lettuce, diced tomato, fresh sliced jalapeno and sour cream. Add Chicken for $6 or Beef $4.00$19.00
Reuben
Corned Beef on Rye with Swiss cheese, grilled sauerkraut and thousand island served with hand cut fries$18.00
Food
Appetizers

Buffalo Chicken Fries.
A Pile of our hand cut fries topped with fried Buffalo Chicken and covered in our House made beer cheese$16.00
Chicken Tenders
Hand breaded and fried served with Ranch for dipping$14.00
Mozzarella Sticks
Served with Garlic Parmesan Sauce for dipping$14.00
Reuben Pierogies
Our Pierogies stuffed with mashed potatoes and cheese, deep fried and topped with Corned Beef and Sauerkraut served with Thousand Island for dipping$15.00
McGrath's Irish Nachos
Steak Fries topped with Guinness beer cheese,shredded lettuce, diced tomato, fresh sliced jalapeno and sour cream. Add Chicken for $6 or Beef $4.00$19.00
Beer Cheese And Pretzels
Our house made beer cheese served with pretzel bites and Pub mustard$14.00
Fried Pickles
Our hand breaded flash fried pickle spears served with Ranch$14.00Curry Chips
$10.00The Dublin Drip
$12.00Reuben Fries
$12.00Shamrock Fries
$12.00Late Night Lad
$12.00
Gourmet Hot Dogs
McGrath Dog
Grilled 1/4 lb dog topped with yellow mustard and relish$9.00
Irish Beer Cheese Dog
Grilled and topped with fried onions and our Guinness beer cheese$9.00
Jalapeno Kraut Dog
Grilled topped with fresh sliced Jalapenos and Sauerkraut$9.00
New Yorker
Grilled and topped with Sauerkraut and Brown Mustard$9.00
BLT Dog
Grilled and topped with black pepper crusted bacon, shredded lettuce, diced tomato and mayo$10.00
All American Dog
Grilled and topped with ketchup and mustard$8.00Bacon Jam Dog
$10.00
Seafood
Fried Grouper Sandwich
Beer Battered Grouper with lettuce, tomato and onion topped with Sriracha Tarter served with hand cut fries$19.00
Blackend Grouper Sandwich
Cajun dusted Grouper fillet on a Brioche roll with lettuce, tomato and onion with Sriracha Tarter Sauce served with hand cut fries$19.00
Fried Grouper BLT
Beer battered Grouper with Black Pepper Crusted Bacon,Lettuce, tomato and Sriracha Tarter on a Brioche Roll with house cut fries$21.00
Wings

Bone In 6 Wings
WET SAUCES: MILD, MEDIUM, HOT, BELOW HELL, "THE WRATH OF MCGRATH" CAROLINA REAPER SAUCE, TERIYAKI, JAMESON BBQ, BLACK RASPBERRY BBQ, KOREAN BBQ, GARLIC PARMESAN DRY RUBS : OLD BAY, LEMON PEPPER, CAJUN, SRIRACHA$13.50
Bone In 12 Wings
WET SAUCES: MILD, MEDIUM, HOT, BELOW HELL, "THE WRATH OF MCGRATH" CAROLINA REAPER SAUCE, TERIYAKI, JAMESON BBQ, BLACK RASPBERRY BBQ, KOREAN BBQ, GARLIC PARMESAN DRY RUBS : OLD BAY, LEMON PEPPER, CAJUN, SRIRACHA$24.00Bone In 18 Wings
WET SAUCES: MILD, MEDIUM, HOT, BELOW HELL, "THE WRATH OF MCGRATH" CAROLINA REAPER SAUCE, TERIYAKI, JAMESON BBQ, BLACK RASPBERRY BBQ, KOREAN BBQ, GARLIC PARMESAN DRY RUBS : OLD BAY, LEMON PEPPER, CAJUN, SRIRACHA$36.00Boneless 6 Wings
WET SAUCES: MILD, MEDIUM, HOT, BELOW HELL, "THE WRATH OF MCGRATH" CAROLINA REAPER SAUCE, TERIYAKI, JAMESON BBQ, BLACK RASPBERRY BBQ, KOREAN BBQ, GARLIC PARMESAN DRY RUBS : OLD BAY, LEMON PEPPER, CAJUN, SRIRACHA$13.50Boneless 12 Wings
WET SAUCES: MILD, MEDIUM, HOT, BELOW HELL, "THE WRATH OF MCGRATH" CAROLINA REAPER SAUCE, TERIYAKI, JAMESON BBQ, BLACK RASPBERRY BBQ, KOREAN BBQ, GARLIC PARMESAN DRY RUBS : OLD BAY, LEMON PEPPER, CAJUN, SRIRACHA$24.00Boneless 18 Wings
WET SAUCES: MILD, MEDIUM, HOT, BELOW HELL, "THE WRATH OF MCGRATH" CAROLINA REAPER SAUCE, TERIYAKI, JAMESON BBQ, BLACK RASPBERRY BBQ, KOREAN BBQ, GARLIC PARMESAN DRY RUBS : OLD BAY, LEMON PEPPER, CAJUN, SRIRACHA$36.00Grilled Boneless 6 Wings
WET SAUCES: MILD, MEDIUM, HOT, BELOW HELL, "THE WRATH OF MCGRATH" CAROLINA REAPER SAUCE, TERIYAKI, JAMESON BBQ, BLACK RASPBERRY BBQ, KOREAN BBQ, GARLIC PARMESAN DRY RUBS : OLD BAY, LEMON PEPPER, CAJUN, SRIRACHA$13.50Grilled Boneless 12 Wings
WET SAUCES: MILD, MEDIUM, HOT, BELOW HELL, "THE WRATH OF MCGRATH" CAROLINA REAPER SAUCE, TERIYAKI, JAMESON BBQ, BLACK RASPBERRY BBQ, KOREAN BBQ, GARLIC PARMESAN DRY RUBS : OLD BAY, LEMON PEPPER, CAJUN, SRIRACHA$24.00Grilled Boneless 18 Wings
WET SAUCES: MILD, MEDIUM, HOT, BELOW HELL, "THE WRATH OF MCGRATH" CAROLINA REAPER SAUCE, TERIYAKI, JAMESON BBQ, BLACK RASPBERRY BBQ, KOREAN BBQ, GARLIC PARMESAN DRY RUBS : OLD BAY, LEMON PEPPER, CAJUN, SRIRACHA$36.00
Irish Burgers
Irish Burger
Half pound Guinness beef topped with Dubliner cheddar cheese, lettuce, tomato,ketchup and mustard. Add Bacon $2.00$16.00
Irish Car Bomb
Our Half pound Guinness beef topped with fried onions, Jameson BBQ sauce, fried egg and Baileys candied bacon$18.00Irish Whiskey Burger
1/2 lb Guinness beef topped with our house made Jameson Whiskey Glaze, sautéed onions, Dubliner cheddar cheese and bacon$18.00Breakfast Burger
Half pound Guinness beef with Horseradish mayo, fried egg, Dubliner cheddar and bacon$18.00
Irish Beer Cheese Burger
Half pound Guinness beef topped with fried onions, bacon and Guinness beer cheese$18.00Luck Of The Irish Burger
Half pound of Guinness beef topped with 1/4lb or Corned beef, fresh sauerkraut, 1000 Island Dressing and Swiss cheese served on Rye bread$22.00
Classic American Burgers

Bacon Cheese
1/2 pound grass fed burger topped with Cheddar, bacon, lettuce, tomato and onion$18.00
Mushroom Swiss
1/2 pound burger with sautéed mushrooms, Swiss cheese, lettuce, tomato and onion$18.00All American
1/2 pound grass fed burger topped with American cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion, ketchup and mustard$17.00
Jalapeno Heat
1/2 lb pound beef topped with Grilled jalapenos, sautéed onions and Sriracha dry$18.00
2 Sliders
Topped with American Cheese, lettuce, tomato and onion (Sub any Irish or Classic American Burgers for $1)$14.00
4 Sliders
Topped with American Cheese, lettuce, tomato and onion (Sub any Irish or Classic American Burgers for $2)$24.00Bologna Sandwich
$14.00Bologna BLT
$16.00Carnivore Platter
Two 1/2 pound grass fed burgers topped with Cheddar, bacon, fried eggs$20.00Cranberry Gobbler Slider
Turkey, Bacon Cranberry Sauce and Honey Mustard with Irish Cheddar$6.00Holiday Ham Slider
Ham, Irish Cheddar, Bacon and Cranberry Sauce$6.00Blitzers Melt Slider
Turkey, American Cheese and Bacon$6.00Cupids Club Slider
Turkey, Bacon, Ham, Irish Cheddar, Mayo, shredded lettuce and tomato$7.00Kringels Klucker Slider
Grilled Turkey, Honey Mustard and Irish Cheddar$7.00
Irish Favorites
Chicken Burgers

Mojito Lime Chicken
Marinated Mojito lime chicken breast topped with Dubliner cheddar, lettuce, tomato and onion$18.00Mayo Chicken
Grilled chicken breast topped with our Horseradish mayo, lettuce, tomato and onion. Add Bacon $2.00$17.00Cajun Chicken
Cajun Marinated chicken breast topped with cheddar cheese, lettuce, tomato and onion$17.00Buffalo Irishman
Our chicken breast breaded in panko Parmesan then deep fried and tossed in Buffalo Hot sauce with bacon, lettuce, tomato and onion$18.00Chicken Parm Sandwich
Our Panko Crusted Fried Chicken Breast smothered in Marinara and Irish Cheddar on our Brioche Roll$18.00
Salads
Kids
Sides
Chips
Steak Fries$6.00Garlic Chips
Steak fries topped with our Garlic Parmesan sauce$8.00Sweet Potato Fries
Hand cut in house$8.00Old Bay Chips
Steak fries tossed on Old Bay$8.00Cheese Chips
Steak Fries topped with Guinness beer cheese$9.00Truffle Chips
Steak Fries tossed in Truffle Oil and Parmesan$9.00Onion Rings
$10.00Side Beer Cheese
$5.00
Desserts
Carry Out Burger Boxes
4 Burger Box
Cheddar Burgers with Hand Cut Fries and a side box of Shredded Lettuce, Sliced Tomatoes, Sliced Onion, Dill Pickles, Ketchup and Mustard. Add Bacon to each burger for $2.25, Sub a Beyond Burger for $3$60.006 Burger Box
Cheddar Burgers with Hand Cut Fries and a side box of Shredded Lettuce, Sliced Tomatoes, Sliced Onion, Dill Pickles, Ketchup and Mustard. Add Bacon to each burger for $2.25, Sub a Beyond Burger for $3$90.008 Burger Box
Cheddar Burgers with Hand Cut Fries and a side box of Shredded Lettuce, Sliced Tomatoes, Sliced Onion, Dill Pickles, Ketchup and Mustard. Add Bacon to each burger for $2.25, Sub a Beyond Burger for $3$120.0016 Burger Box
Cheddar Burgers with Hand Cut Fries and a side box of Shredded Lettuce, Sliced Tomatoes, Sliced Onion, Dill Pickles, Ketchup and Mustard. Add Bacon to each burger for $2.25, Sub a Beyond Burger for $3$240.00
Beverages
Liquor
Hornitos
$8.00Well Vodka
$6.00Absolut
$8.50Titos
$9.00Goose
$10.50Well Gin
$6.00Well Rum
$6.00Captain Morgan
$8.00Bacardi
$8.00Malibu
$7.50Rumchata
$8.00Captain Coconut
$8.25Well Tequila
$6.50Patrone
$13.00Cuervo
$8.00Teremana
$12.00Lunazul
$12.00Sauza
$8.00Thursday Well Tequila
$2.00Well Whiskey
$6.00Crown Royal
$9.00Jack Daniels
$9.00Jameson
$7.00Jim Beam
$8.00Makers Mark
$10.00Kilbeggan
$7.00Proper 12
$8.00Larceny
$8.00Basil Haydens
$11.00Bookers
$14.00Elijah Craig
$12.00Woodford
$11.00Tullemore Dew
$11.00Fireball
$6.00Crown Apple
$9.00Dewars
$9.00Angels Envy
$14.00Buffalo Trace
$14.00Russells Reserve
$15.00Jagermeister
$6.50Kahlua
$8.00Rumple
$9.00Gran Marnier
$12.00Baileys
$9.00
Cocktails
Bloody Mary Sunday
$3.00Coconut Crush
$12.00Green Tea
$8.00Irish Lemonade
$10.00Irish Trashcan
$17.00Irish Mary
$8.00Irish Mosa
$5.00Irish Car Bomb
$12.00Irish Summer
$10.00Long Island Iced Tea
$12.00Orange Crush
$12.00Margarita
$9.00Martini
$12.00Mermaid Water
$9.00Mule
$11.00Screwdriver
$7.00Summer Blues
$8.00Tequila Sunrise
$9.00White Russian
$8.00Whiskey Sour
$7.00Dreamsicle
$7.00Lemon Crush
$12.00Grapefruit Crush
$12.00Blood Mary
$7.00Trivia Margarita
$7.00Irish Coffee
$10.00Irish Hot Chocolate
$10.00Luck Of Irish
$10.00Irish Green Tea
$10.00Baileys Irish Shake
Jameson Milkshake$14.00Milkshake Non Alcohol
$12.00The Grasshopper
$14.00Spiked Caramel
$14.00Drunken Leprechan
$14.00Howdy Hooch
$9.00Minty Mule
$10.00Irish Goodbye
$10.00Irish Sunshine
$10.00
Draft Beer
Wine
Soft Drinks
Bottled Beer
Bud Light
$3.75Coors Light
$3.75Michelob Ultra
$4.00Miller Light
$3.75Killians
$7.00Yuengling
$3.50Corona
$6.00Guinness
$7.00White Claw Cherry
$4.50White Claw Mango
$4.50Bold Rock
$6.00Cape Charles Puddle
$9.00Cape Charles Assateague
$9.00HopFly Krunchtime
$9.00HopFly Sour
$9.00Happy Dad Grape
$5.25Happy Dad Fruit Punch
$5.25Happy Dad Banana
$5.25Honor Dress Blues
$9.00Honor Hazy
$9.00DB Vienna
$7.00Busch Light
$2.00Friday Guinness
$5.00Climbing THC
$9.00
All hours
| Sunday | 11:00 am - 8:30 pm |
| Monday | 11:00 am - 8:30 pm |
| Tuesday | 11:00 am - 8:30 pm |
| Wednesday | 11:00 am - 8:30 pm |
| Thursday | 11:00 am - 8:30 pm |
| Friday | 11:00 am - 8:30 pm |
| Saturday | 11:00 am - 8:30 pm |
Restaurant info
Come in and enjoy!
Location
Similar restaurants in your area
© 2026 Toast, Inc.












