
American
McGraths Burger Shack - Outer Banks
5000 South Croatan Highway
11-14
Nags Head, NC 27959
Orders through Toast are commission free and go directly to this restaurant
Pickup Only
Featured Items

Beer Cheese And Pretzels
Our house made beer cheese served with pretzel bites and Pub mustard$14.00
Irish Beer Cheese Burger
Half pound Guinness beef topped with fried onions, bacon and Guinness beer cheese$18.00
Irish Car Bomb
Our Half pound Guinness beef topped with fried onions, Jameson BBQ sauce, fried egg and Baileys candied bacon$18.00
Food
Appetizers

Buffalo Chicken Fries.
A Pile of our hand cut fries topped with fried Buffalo Chicken and covered in our House made beer cheese$16.00
Chicken Tenders
Hand breaded and fried served with Ranch for dipping$14.00
Mozzarella Sticks
Served with Garlic Parmesan Sauce for dipping$14.00
Reuben Pierogies
Our Pierogies stuffed with mashed potatoes and cheese, deep fried and topped with Corned Beef and Sauerkraut served with Thousand Island for dipping$15.00
McGrath's Irish Nachos
Steak Fries topped with Guinness beer cheese,shredded lettuce, diced tomato, fresh sliced jalapeno and sour cream. Add Chicken for $6 or Beef $4.00$19.00
Beer Cheese And Pretzels
Our house made beer cheese served with pretzel bites and Pub mustard$14.00
Fried Pickles
Our hand breaded flash fried pickle spears served with Ranch$14.00Curry Chips
$10.00The Dublin Drip
$12.00Reuben Fries
$12.00Shamrock Fries
$12.00Late Night Lad
$12.00
Gourmet Hot Dogs
McGrath Dog
Grilled 1/4 lb dog topped with yellow mustard and relish$9.00
Irish Beer Cheese Dog
Grilled and topped with fried onions and our Guinness beer cheese$9.00
Jalapeno Kraut Dog
Grilled topped with fresh sliced Jalapenos and Sauerkraut$9.00
New Yorker
Grilled and topped with Sauerkraut and Brown Mustard$9.00
BLT Dog
Grilled and topped with black pepper crusted bacon, shredded lettuce, diced tomato and mayo$10.00
All American Dog
Grilled and topped with ketchup and mustard$8.00Bacon Jam Dog
$10.00
Seafood
Fried Grouper Sandwich
Beer Battered Grouper with lettuce, tomato and onion topped with Sriracha Tarter served with hand cut fries$19.00
Blackend Grouper Sandwich
Cajun dusted Grouper fillet on a Brioche roll with lettuce, tomato and onion with Sriracha Tarter Sauce served with hand cut fries$19.00
Fried Grouper BLT
Beer battered Grouper with Black Pepper Crusted Bacon,Lettuce, tomato and Sriracha Tarter on a Brioche Roll with house cut fries$21.00
Wings

Bone In 6 Wings
WET SAUCES: MILD, MEDIUM, HOT, BELOW HELL, "THE WRATH OF MCGRATH" CAROLINA REAPER SAUCE, TERIYAKI, JAMESON BBQ, BLACK RASPBERRY BBQ, KOREAN BBQ, GARLIC PARMESAN DRY RUBS : OLD BAY, LEMON PEPPER, CAJUN, SRIRACHA$13.50
Bone In 12 Wings
WET SAUCES: MILD, MEDIUM, HOT, BELOW HELL, "THE WRATH OF MCGRATH" CAROLINA REAPER SAUCE, TERIYAKI, JAMESON BBQ, BLACK RASPBERRY BBQ, KOREAN BBQ, GARLIC PARMESAN DRY RUBS : OLD BAY, LEMON PEPPER, CAJUN, SRIRACHA$24.00Bone In 18 Wings
WET SAUCES: MILD, MEDIUM, HOT, BELOW HELL, "THE WRATH OF MCGRATH" CAROLINA REAPER SAUCE, TERIYAKI, JAMESON BBQ, BLACK RASPBERRY BBQ, KOREAN BBQ, GARLIC PARMESAN DRY RUBS : OLD BAY, LEMON PEPPER, CAJUN, SRIRACHA$36.00Boneless 6 Wings
WET SAUCES: MILD, MEDIUM, HOT, BELOW HELL, "THE WRATH OF MCGRATH" CAROLINA REAPER SAUCE, TERIYAKI, JAMESON BBQ, BLACK RASPBERRY BBQ, KOREAN BBQ, GARLIC PARMESAN DRY RUBS : OLD BAY, LEMON PEPPER, CAJUN, SRIRACHA$13.50Boneless 12 Wings
WET SAUCES: MILD, MEDIUM, HOT, BELOW HELL, "THE WRATH OF MCGRATH" CAROLINA REAPER SAUCE, TERIYAKI, JAMESON BBQ, BLACK RASPBERRY BBQ, KOREAN BBQ, GARLIC PARMESAN DRY RUBS : OLD BAY, LEMON PEPPER, CAJUN, SRIRACHA$24.00Boneless 18 Wings
WET SAUCES: MILD, MEDIUM, HOT, BELOW HELL, "THE WRATH OF MCGRATH" CAROLINA REAPER SAUCE, TERIYAKI, JAMESON BBQ, BLACK RASPBERRY BBQ, KOREAN BBQ, GARLIC PARMESAN DRY RUBS : OLD BAY, LEMON PEPPER, CAJUN, SRIRACHA$36.00Grilled Boneless 6 Wings
WET SAUCES: MILD, MEDIUM, HOT, BELOW HELL, "THE WRATH OF MCGRATH" CAROLINA REAPER SAUCE, TERIYAKI, JAMESON BBQ, BLACK RASPBERRY BBQ, KOREAN BBQ, GARLIC PARMESAN DRY RUBS : OLD BAY, LEMON PEPPER, CAJUN, SRIRACHA$13.50Grilled Boneless 12 Wings
WET SAUCES: MILD, MEDIUM, HOT, BELOW HELL, "THE WRATH OF MCGRATH" CAROLINA REAPER SAUCE, TERIYAKI, JAMESON BBQ, BLACK RASPBERRY BBQ, KOREAN BBQ, GARLIC PARMESAN DRY RUBS : OLD BAY, LEMON PEPPER, CAJUN, SRIRACHA$24.00Grilled Boneless 18 Wings
WET SAUCES: MILD, MEDIUM, HOT, BELOW HELL, "THE WRATH OF MCGRATH" CAROLINA REAPER SAUCE, TERIYAKI, JAMESON BBQ, BLACK RASPBERRY BBQ, KOREAN BBQ, GARLIC PARMESAN DRY RUBS : OLD BAY, LEMON PEPPER, CAJUN, SRIRACHA$36.00
Irish Burgers
Irish Burger
Half pound Guinness beef topped with Dubliner cheddar cheese, lettuce, tomato,ketchup and mustard. Add Bacon $2.00$16.00
Irish Car Bomb
Our Half pound Guinness beef topped with fried onions, Jameson BBQ sauce, fried egg and Baileys candied bacon$18.00Irish Whiskey Burger
1/2 lb Guinness beef topped with our house made Jameson Whiskey Glaze, sautéed onions, Dubliner cheddar cheese and bacon$18.00Breakfast Burger
Half pound Guinness beef with Horseradish mayo, fried egg, Dubliner cheddar and bacon$18.00
Irish Beer Cheese Burger
Half pound Guinness beef topped with fried onions, bacon and Guinness beer cheese$18.00Luck Of The Irish Burger
Half pound of Guinness beef topped with 1/4lb or Corned beef, fresh sauerkraut, 1000 Island Dressing and Swiss cheese served on Rye bread$22.00
Classic American Burgers

Bacon Cheese
1/2 pound grass fed burger topped with Cheddar, bacon, lettuce, tomato and onion$18.00
Mushroom Swiss
1/2 pound burger with sautéed mushrooms, Swiss cheese, lettuce, tomato and onion$18.00All American
1/2 pound grass fed burger topped with American cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion, ketchup and mustard$17.00
Jalapeno Heat
1/2 lb pound beef topped with Grilled jalapenos, sautéed onions and Sriracha dry$18.00
2 Sliders
Topped with American Cheese, lettuce, tomato and onion (Sub any Irish or Classic American Burgers for $1)$14.00
4 Sliders
Topped with American Cheese, lettuce, tomato and onion (Sub any Irish or Classic American Burgers for $2)$24.00Carnivore Platter
Two 1/2 pound grass fed burgers topped with Cheddar, bacon, fried eggs$20.00
Irish Favorites
Chicken Burgers

Mojito Lime Chicken
Marinated Mojito lime chicken breast topped with Dubliner cheddar, lettuce, tomato and onion$18.00Mayo Chicken
Grilled chicken breast topped with our Horseradish mayo, lettuce, tomato and onion. Add Bacon $2.00$17.00Cajun Chicken
Cajun Marinated chicken breast topped with cheddar cheese, lettuce, tomato and onion$17.00Buffalo Irishman
Our chicken breast breaded in panko Parmesan then deep fried and tossed in Buffalo Hot sauce with bacon, lettuce, tomato and onion$18.00Chicken Parm Sandwich
Our Panko Crusted Fried Chicken Breast smothered in Marinara and Irish Cheddar on our Brioche Roll$18.00
Salads
Kids
Sides
Chips
Steak Fries$6.00Garlic Chips
Steak fries topped with our Garlic Parmesan sauce$8.00Sweet Potato Fries
Hand cut in house$8.00Old Bay Chips
Steak fries tossed on Old Bay$8.00Cheese Chips
Steak Fries topped with Guinness beer cheese$9.00Truffle Chips
Steak Fries tossed in Truffle Oil and Parmesan$9.00Onion Rings
$10.00Side Beer Cheese
$5.00
Desserts
Carry Out Burger Boxes
4 Burger Box
Cheddar Burgers with Hand Cut Fries and a side box of Shredded Lettuce, Sliced Tomatoes, Sliced Onion, Dill Pickles, Ketchup and Mustard. Add Bacon to each burger for $2.25, Sub a Beyond Burger for $3$60.006 Burger Box
Cheddar Burgers with Hand Cut Fries and a side box of Shredded Lettuce, Sliced Tomatoes, Sliced Onion, Dill Pickles, Ketchup and Mustard. Add Bacon to each burger for $2.25, Sub a Beyond Burger for $3$90.008 Burger Box
Cheddar Burgers with Hand Cut Fries and a side box of Shredded Lettuce, Sliced Tomatoes, Sliced Onion, Dill Pickles, Ketchup and Mustard. Add Bacon to each burger for $2.25, Sub a Beyond Burger for $3$120.0016 Burger Box
Cheddar Burgers with Hand Cut Fries and a side box of Shredded Lettuce, Sliced Tomatoes, Sliced Onion, Dill Pickles, Ketchup and Mustard. Add Bacon to each burger for $2.25, Sub a Beyond Burger for $3$240.00
Beverages
Liquor
Hornitos
$8.00Well Vodka
$7.00Absolut
$8.50Titos
$9.00Goose
$10.50Well Gin
$7.00Well Rum
$7.00Captain Morgan
$8.00Bacardi
$8.00Malibu
$7.50Rumchata
$8.00Captain Coconut
$8.25Well Tequila
$8.00Patrone
$13.00Cuervo
$9.00Teremana
$12.00Lunazul
$12.00Sauza
$10.00Thursday Well Tequila
$4.00Well Whiskey
$7.00Crown Royal
$9.00Jack Daniels
$9.00Jameson
$9.00Jim Beam
$8.00Makers Mark
$10.00Kilbeggan
$7.00Proper 12
$8.00Larceny
$8.00Basil Haydens
$11.00Bookers
$14.00Elijah Craig
$12.00Woodford
$11.00Tullemore Dew
$11.00Fireball
$6.00Crown Apple
$9.00Dewars
$9.00Angels Envy
$15.00Buffalo Trace
$14.00Russells Reserve
$15.00Jagermeister
$8.00Kahlua
$8.00Rumple
$9.00Gran Marnier
$12.00Baileys
$9.00
Cocktails
Bloody Mary Sunday
$3.00Coconut Crush
$12.00Green Tea
$8.00Irish Lemonade
$10.00Irish Trashcan
$17.00Irish Mary
$8.00Irish Mosa
$5.00Irish Car Bomb
$12.00Irish Summer
$10.00Long Island Iced Tea
$12.00Orange Crush
$12.00Margarita
$9.00Martini
$12.00Mermaid Water
$9.00Mule
$11.00Screwdriver
$7.00Tequila Sunrise
$9.00White Russian
$8.00Whiskey Sour
$7.00Dreamsicle
$7.00Lemon Crush
$12.00Grapefruit Crush
$12.00Blood Mary
$7.00Trivia Margarita
$7.00Irish Coffee
$10.00Irish Hot Chocolate
$10.00Luck Of Irish
$10.00Irish Green Tea
$10.00The Grasshopper
$14.00Spiked Caramel
$14.00Minty Mule
$10.00Irish Goodbye
$10.00Irish Sunshine
$10.00
Draft Beer
Wine
Soft Drinks
All hours
| Sunday | 11:00 am - 8:30 pm |
| Monday | 11:00 am - 8:30 pm |
| Tuesday | 11:00 am - 8:30 pm |
| Wednesday | 11:00 am - 8:30 pm |
| Thursday | 11:00 am - 8:30 pm |
| Friday | 11:00 am - 8:30 pm |
| Saturday | 11:00 am - 8:30 pm |
Restaurant info
Come in and enjoy!
Location
5000 South Croatan Highway, 11-14, Nags Head, NC 27959
Similar restaurants in your area
© 2026 Toast, Inc.














