Seafood
Mr. Bill's Fresh Seafood & The Fat Crab Cafe
Orders through Toast are commission free and go directly to this restaurant
Pickup Only
Mr. Bill's Seafood Market
Fresh Fish
Online fish varieties are limited compared to what we have in store. Call 717-299-2791 or stop in for for our most up to date availability for same-day or holiday preorders!
Atlantic Salmon, Scottish/Nor/Faroe Is.
Fresh Scottish, Norwegian, or Faroe Island Atlantic Salmon, farm-raised, filleted, pin-bones removed, raw, skin-on, cut by hand. Approx 1 lb$27.00Atlantic Salmon, Canadian
Fresh Canadian Atlantic Salmon, farm-raised, filleted, pin-bones removed, raw, skin-on, cut by hand. Approx 1 lb$20.00Wild Boston Blue
Fresh wild Boston Blue (Pollock), filleted, skinless, raw, cut by hand. Approx 1 lb$19.00
Wild Cod
Fresh wild Cod, filleted, skinless, raw. Approx 1 lb$27.00Wild Nova Scotia Day Boat Halibut
Wild Nova Scotia day boat halibut, filleted, skinless, raw, cut by hand. Approx 1 lb$39.00Arctic Char
Fresh arctic char, farm raised, filleted, skin-on, raw. Approx 1 lb$27.00
Saltwater Tilapia
Saltwater tilapia, farm raised, filleted, skinless, raw. Approx 1 lb$9.00
Wild Yellowfin Ahi Tuna
Fresh wild Yellowfin Ahi Tuna steaks, raw. Approx 1 lb$39.00Wild Jumbo Flounder
Fresh wild Jumbo Flounder, filleted, skinless, raw. Approx 1 lb$25.00Haddock
Fresh haddock filets, approx 1 lb$24.00
Shrimp
31-35ct Medium Shrimp, Raw
Raw Medium Shrimp (31-35ct) approx 1lb, shell-on, headless, Central America, previously frozen$12.00
21-25ct LG Shrimp, Raw
Raw XL Shrimp (21-25ct), approx 1lb, shell-on, headless, Central America, previously frozen$15.00Jumbo U-15ct Shrimp, Raw
Raw Jumbo Shrimp (U-15ct) approx 1lb, shell-on, headless, Central America, previously frozen$21.00
21-25ct LG Shrimp, Steamed & Chilled
Approx 1lb LG Shrimp (21-25ct), Central America, shell-on, steamed with our pure spice and chilled$19.00
Peeled and Deveined 21-25ct LG Shrimp, Raw
Approx 1lb, peeled & deveined from 21-25ct Shrimp, Central America, raw$21.00
Peeled and Deveined 21-25ct LG Steamed Shrimp, Steamed & Chilled
Approx 1lb peeled & deveined from 21-25ct Shrimp, Central America, steamed with our pure spice and chilled$27.004 lb Box 21-25ct LG Shrimp, Shell-on, Raw, Frozen
4 lb box of LG shrimp (21-25ct/lb), shell-on, headless, raw, frozen, farm raised, Central America$58.005 lb Box 21-25ct LG Shrimp, Shell-on, Raw, Frozen
5 lb box of LG shrimp (21-25ct/lb), shell-on, headless, raw, frozen, farm raised, Central America$72.005 lb Box 16-20ct, XL Shrimp, Shell-on, Raw, Frozen
5 lb box of XL shrimp (16-20ct/lb), shell-on, headless, raw, frozen, farm raised, Central America$82.005 lb Box U-12 Jumbo Shrimp, Shell-on, Raw, Frozen
Wild jumbo shrimp (U-12ct/lb), shell-on, headless, raw, frozen, Central America$99.00
Crab Legs & Clusters
Medium Snow Crab Clusters, Frozen (5-8oz)
By the pound, 5-8oz Medium Snow Crab Clusters, frozen$25.00OUT OF STOCKXL Snow Crab Clusters, Frozen (10oz+)
By the pound, 10oz+ XL Snow Crab Clusters, frozen$35.00OUT OF STOCKJumbo Snow Crab Clusters, Frozen (12oz+)
By the pound, 12oz+ Jumbo Snow Crab Clusters, frozen$39.00
Huge Snow/Bairdi Crab Clusters, Frozen (14oz+)
By the pound, 14oz+ Huge Snow or Bairdi Crab Clusters, frozen$49.00XL Norwegian Arctic Red King Crab
XL Red King Crab Legs and Claws, by the pound$99.00OUT OF STOCKJumbo Norwegian Arctic Red King Crab
Huge King Crab Legs and Claws, by the pound$139.00OUT OF STOCKFrozen King Crab Legs & Claws, Jumbo
XL King Crab Legs and Claws, by the pound$139.00Med. Snow 5-8oz, 30lb Case
$675.00Jumbo Snow Crab Clusters, 12oz+, 20lb Box
10 lb box of jumbo (12oz+) frozen snow crab clusters. Naturally sweet, tender meat. Perfect for steaming or boiling at home.$630.00Huge Snow Crab Clusters, 14oz+, 20lb Case
$882.00
Party Trays
Regular Shrimp Party Tray
2.5 lb of tender #1 white shrimp of the Americas (approx 70) cooked with our house seasoning served on a party tray with our own made cocktail sauce.$89.00
Large Shrimp Party Tray
5 lb of tender #1 white shrimp of the Americas (approx 140) cooked with our house seasoning served on a party tray with our own made cocktail sauce.$175.00
Regular Shrimp and Cocktail Crab Claw Party Tray
1.25 lb of tender #1 white shrimp of the Americas (approx 70) cooked with our house seasoning and 12 oz of delicious blue crab cocktail claws served on a party tray with our own made cocktail sauce and spicy mustard dipping sauce.$99.00
Large Shrimp and Cocktail Crab Claw Party Tray
2.5 lb of tender #1 white shrimp of the Americas (approx 70) cooked with our house seasoning and 24 oz of delicious blue crab cocktail claws served on a party tray with our own made cocktail sauce and spicy mustard dipping sauce.$185.00Regular Cocktail Crab Claw Party Tray
24oz of delicious blue crab cocktail crab claws served on a party tray with our own made spicy mustard dipping sauce.$99.00Large Cocktail Crab Claw Party Tray
48oz of delicious blue crab cocktail crab claws served on a party tray with our own made spicy mustard dipping sauce.$195.00Regular Shrimp and Snow Crab Claw Party Tray
1.25 lb of tender #1 white shrimp of the Americas (approx 35) cooked with our house spice and 12 oz of sweet and delicate snow crab cocktail claws served on a party tray with our own made cocktail sauce and creamy dill dipping sauce.$119.00Large Shrimp and Snow Crab Claw Party Tray
2.5 lbs of tender #1 white shrimp of the Americas (approx 70) cooked with our house spice and 24 oz of sweet and delicate snow crab cocktail claws served on a party tray with our own made cocktail sauce and creamy dill dipping sauce.$229.00Regular Snow Crab Claw Party Tray
24 oz of sweet and delicate snow crab cocktail claws served with creamy dill dipping sauce.$139.00Large Snow Crab Claw Party Tray
48 oz of sweet and delicate snow crab cocktail claws served with creamy dill dipping sauce.$278.00
Oysters, Clams, and Mussels
Call 717-299-2791 for customized shucking orders!
Clam Raw Bar to Go (1 Dozen)
1 dozen shucked top neck clams with your choice of horseradish, cocktail sauce, lemon sliced, and/or mignonette sauce. Cold-packed in a lidded aluminum tray for fresh and convenient transport.$36.00
Live PEI Mussels - 2lb Bag
Mussels from Prince Edward Island, Canada$14.00Little Neck Clams, Live
Live little neck clams. Small, sweet and tender, perfect for steamingMiddle Neck Clams, Live
Live middle neck clams, slightly larger than little neck clams, great for steaming
Top Neck Clams, Live
Live medium-large top neck clams, great for eating raw on the half-shell or frying
Cherrystone Clams, Live
Our largest clam, excellent for soups and chowders
Soft Shell Clams, Live, by the pound
Ipswich clams, famously known as "steamers" or "soft-shell clams," are a highly prized delicacy. They are universally celebrated for their sweet, briny flavor and distinct, tender "whole bellies". Sold live and by the pound.$11.99OUT OF STOCK
Oyster Raw Bar to Go (1 Dozen)
1 dozen fresh oysters shucked on the half shell. Served with your choice of cocktail sauce, mignonette sauce, horseradish, and sliced lemon on the side. Cold-packed in a lidded aluminum tray for convenient transport. Ready to serve!$42.00Chesapeake Bay Oysters
Fresh Chesapeake Bay Oysters, in the shell (not shucked)$1.00
Box of Chesapeake Bay Oysters (Approx 100ct)
Box of fresh Chesapeake Bay Oysters, in the shell (not shucked), appox 100ct$95.00
Southwest Sensation Oysters
Fresh Southwest Sensation oysters, in the shell (not shucked), by the piece$2.25OUT OF STOCKWellfleet Oysters
Fresh Wellfleet oysters, in the shell (not shucked), by the piece$2.25
Barnstable Oysters
Fresh Barnstable oysters, in the shell (not shucked), by the piece$2.25
Moondancer Oysters
Fresh Moondancer oysters, in the shell (not shucked), by the piece$2.25Irish Point Oysters
Fresh Irish Point oysters, in the shell (not shucked), by the piece$2.25OUT OF STOCK
Duxbury Oysters
Fresh Duxbury oysters, in the shell (not shucked), by the piece$2.25
Standard Oysters, Pint
Shucked Chesapeake or Virginia standard size Oysters$27.00
Select Oysters, Pint
Shucked Chesapeake or Virginia select size Oysters$27.00
Crab Cakes
Crab Meat
Jumbo Lump Crab Meat, Maryland, Fresh
1 lb of fresh Maryland jumbo lump crab meat$79.00
Lump Crab Meat, Maryland, Fresh
1 lb of fresh Maryland lump crab meat,$59.00Jumbo Lump Crab Meat, Mexico, Fresh
$69.00Lump Crab Meat, Mexico, Fresh
$39.00Claw Crab Meat, Mexico, Pasteurized
$29.00Cocktail Crab Claws, 12oz, Mexico, Pasteurized
$49.00Cocktail Crab Claws, 1LB, Louisiana
1 lb of Louisiana cocktail crab claws$45.00Lump Crab Meat, Ecuador
1 lb of Ecuadorian Lump Crab Meat$39.00OUT OF STOCK
Soft Shell Crabs
Frozen
Drinks
Root Beer
Fountain Barq's Root Beer$3.00
Coca-Cola
Fountain Coke$3.00
Diet Coke
Fountain Diet Coke$3.00
Coca-Cola Cherry
Fountain Cherry Coke$3.00
Sprite, Fountain
Fountain Sprite$3.00
Lemonade
Fountain MinuteMaid Lemonade$3.00
Coca-Cola, Glass Bottle
$3.29Sprite Bottle
$3.49
Hot Coffee
$3.00
Iced Tea
Unsweetened$3.00
Boylan Grape Soda
$3.29OUT OF STOCK
S. Pellegrino Sparkling Water
$3.29
Boylan Creme Soda
$3.29
Boylan Ginger Ale
$3.29
Boylan Birch Beer
$3.29
Boylan Orange Soda
$3.29
Boylan Root Beer
$3.29
All hours
| Sunday | 11:00 am - 5:30 pm |
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | 11:00 am - 6:00 pm |
| Wednesday | 11:00 am - 6:30 pm |
| Thursday | 11:00 am - 6:30 pm |
| Friday | 11:00 am - 6:30 pm |
| Saturday | 11:00 am - 6:30 pm |
Restaurant info
Since 1973, Mr. Bill's Seafood has been Lancaster, PA's year-round source for blue crabs! Over the years our fresh seafood market has evolved to bring our customers the very best fresh seafood from around the world. We take pride in the freshness and preparation of every seafood product we sell from crabs and fresh fish to shellfish, shrimp and lobster. In 2017, Mr. Bill's Fresh Seafood expanded to include The Fat Crab Cafe, a casual seafood dining restaurant. The cafe features seafood favorites prepared by our well credentialed chef. Customers can enjoy lunch and dinner year-round along with a fun and festive patio dining experience during the fair-weather months.
Location
© 2026 Toast, Inc.
Made with 
in Boston
in Boston
