
American
Mustang's 305 Indiana 62
305 Indiana 62
New Washington, IN 47162
Orders through Toast are commission free and go directly to this restaurant
Stang Starters
Try any of our Stang Starters to get you off to the right start!

Bavarian Pretzel Sticks
Our authentic Bavarian-style soft pretzels are served in a order of 3, baked to perfection with a crisp, golden-brown crust and a soft, chewy center for true traditional flavor. Served with Mustang’s signature beer cheese.$9.00
Beer Battered Jalapeno Halves Poppers
This bold appetizer features 5 hot and spicy mini bite-sized red and green jalapeño slices, coated in a crispy American pale ale beer batter.$9.00
Marble Hill Battered Mozzarella Sticks
Order of 5 Beere Battered Mozzarella Sticks$9.00
Cassie's Mac 'n Cheese Wedges
These 5 Creamy cheddar cheese blended wedges with macaroni are coated in a crispy cheddar batter. Served with a dipping sauce of your choice.$9.00
Cowboy Carl T Corn Bites
These Cowboy Corn Bites are breaded with sweet corn kernels, jalapenos, cream cheese with bacon just the way Carl T likes. Served with a dipping sauce$9.00
Jones Battered Pickle Chips
An order of 12 Fried Battered Pickle Chips. Topped with some fresh Parsley, served with your choice of a sauce.$8.00
Pizza Zone

Halee's Build Your Own Pizza
Stang's Build your own pizza starts Mustang's pizzas are cooked with fresh ingredients and cooked to perfection. Cut in squares and served with a pepperchini and side of Garlic Butter.$10.00
Ashley's Lock & Loaded Supreme Pizza
This thin crust pizza is sauced with Marinara Sauce layered with Black Olive, Green Pepper, Mushroom, Onion, Sausage, Pepperoni and topped with real Mozzarella cheese cooked in our stone oven. Served with a pepperoncini and a side of garlic butter.$13.00Hailey's Garden Veggie Pizza
This thin crust pizza with a Marinara Sauce base and layered with Susanne's favorite local fresh garden grown veggies. Black Olive, Green Pepper, Mushroom, Onion, Tomato and topped with real Mozzarella cheese.$13.00
Hunter's Wild Hawaiian Pizza
This thin crust pizza is features a BBQ sauce base, topped with pineapple and ham, and finished with real mozzarella cheese$13.00Lilly's Belt Bustin' Meats Pizza
This thin crust pizza is bustin' Lilly's belt with Marinara Sauce layered with Bacon Beef Ham Sausage and Pepperoni topped with real Mozzarella cheese.$13.00The " Stang" Buffalo Chicken Ranch Pizza
This thin crust pizza features zesty buffalo sauce base with chicken, topped with real mozzarella cheese and a drizzle of ranch.$13.00
Fresh Garlic Parmesan Breadsticks
Order of 7 Breadstix tossed in Garlic Parmesan served with Mustang's Red Sauce$8.00
Fresh Hand tossed Breadstix
Order of 7 Breadstix tossed in Garlic Parmesan served with Mustang's Red Sauce$7.00
Mustang's Cheese Stix
Made fresh to order, covered in garlic sauce and topped with mozzarella cheese, and baked in our stone oven, cut into 12 pieces, our cheese sticks are absolutely amazing! Served with a side of Marinara.$10.00
Burger Zone
Enjoy our 8oz fresh beef Pattie served on your choice of a Brioche Bun or Texas Toast with a Trail Side. Make it a double, a whole pound, for just $4 more.

Blue Ridge Build your own Burger
A half pound of juicy, flavorful ground beef cooked just the way you like it, served on your choice of a Brioche Bun or Texas Toast. Served with a trail sides, it’s a meal guaranteed to satisfy your hunger.$13.00Tami's Wrangler Burger
A half pound of juicy, flavorful ground beef cooked just the way you like it, served on your choice of a Brioche Bun or Texas Toast. Served with a trail sides, it’s a meal guaranteed to satisfy your hunger.$14.00All American Cheeseburger
The All American Cheeseburger is a half pound of juicy and flavorful ground beef cooked to a gold standard with American Cheese. Cooked and Made special to your liking and served on a Brioche Bun or Texas Toast with one of our trail sides.$13.00Bucked Off Pitkin's BBQ Brilliant Burger
A Half Pound of juicy and flavorful ground beef soaked in BBQ, topped with an onion ring with cheddar cheese to Pitkin's standard. Cooked and dressed to your liking and served with one of our trail sides, fulfilling your hunger.$15.00Earl's Double Barrell Burger
A whole pound of juicy, flavorful ground beef cooked and topped just the way you like, served on Texas Toast with your choice of one of our trail sides.$17.00Kettle Bottom Burger
A Half Pound of beef, with Munster Cheese and soaked in Ghost Pepper Sauce with Jalapeños topped to your likin and served with a Trail Side.$14.00Kicki'n Courtney's Boot Burger
Spice things up with this half pound of juicy, flavorful ground beef, smothered in Mustang’s signature beer cheese. Cooked and dressed just the way you like, and served with your choice of one of our trail sides to satisfy your hunger.$14.00Magruder's Rodeo Bacon Burger
Bob's Rodeo Bacon Burger is for the true bacon lovers. It has more than double the bacon with Provolone Cheese. Half Pound of juicy and flavorful ground beef for a gold standard. Cooked and dressed to your liking and served with a trail side.$15.00Nicks Harvarti Burger
A Half Pound Burger Pattie with Havarti Cheese soaked in Garlic Parmesan Sauce dressed to your likin, Served with a Trail Side.$14.00Papa Burton's Bourbon Cheddar Burger
A Half Pound of juicy and flavorful ground beef for a gold standard. This Bourbon burger is just the way Randy dreams about. Cooked and dressed to your liking and served with one of our trail sides, fulfilling your hunger.$14.00Route 62 Cowboy Burger
$14.00Susanne's Favorite Firehouse Burger
Double 8oz Burger Patties with Ghost Pepper Cheese delivering a spicy kick that will leave you feeling the heat. Dressed with double the toppings of your likin! Just the way Susanne likes it. Served with your choice of a Trail Side.$17.00Tammy's Wild West Mushroom Swiss
A half pound of juicy, flavorful ground beef prepared to Tammy’s standard, topped with mushrooms, Sauteed onions and Swiss cheese. Cooked and dressed just the way you like, and served with your choice of one of our trail side.$14.00The Otto Jalapeno Burger
A Half Pound of juicy and flavorful ground beef for a gold standard. This Jalapeno burger is cooked and dressed to your liking and served with one of our trail sides, fulfilling your hunger.$14.00The Stang Burger
A Half Pound of juicy and flavorful ground beef for a gold standard. The " Stang" Burger is served with our incredible Ghost Pepper Jack Cheese. This burger will leave you feeling hot. Dressed to your liking served with a side$14.00
Wing Zone
Mustangs Wings are always Fresh and cooked to an internal temperature of 165 degrees.
Calzone
Our Calzones are made in-house with hand-tossed dough and fresh ingredients. A classic favorite that’s sure to please any crowd.

Build Your Own Calzone
$12.00
Cowboy Meats Calzone
This calzone packs a punch with marinara sauce base, layered with bacon, beef, ham, sausage, and pepperoni, then topped with real mozzarella cheese$15.00
Cowgirl's Vegi Calzone
Marinara Sauce base and layered with local fresh garden grown veggies. Black Olive, Green Pepper, Mushroom, Onion, Tomato and topped with real Mozzarella cheese.$15.00
The Yee Haw Supreme Calzone
$15.00
Fish Zone

Jacob's Fish & Chips
A 8 oz cod fillet dipped in a classic New England-style batter and cooked to a crisp, light golden brown. Served with crinkle cut fries & 4 golden hushpuppies$15.00
New Wash Fish Sandwich
A 8 oz cod fillet dipped in a classic New England style batter and cooked to a crisp light golden brown on a brioche bun dressed to your likin. Served with your choice of a Trail side.$14.00
Crafted Sandwich Zone

Brenda's Bare Back BLT
Grandma’s Classic BLT, stacked with double bacon, double lettuce and double tomato on triple Texas Toast served with your choice of a Trail Side.$10.00
Cherry Creek's Rope it down Pork Tenderloin Sandwich
This Fried 8 oz Pork Tenderloin Sandwich is one to brag about. Served on a Brioche Bun with your favorite toppings and dressings, you’ll be beyond satisfied. Just like Joey Cherry himself. Served with a Trail Side$14.00
Route 362 Rope It Down Double Bologna
$11.00OUT OF STOCK
Josh's Saddled Grilled Cheese
A grilled cheese sandwich that even Josh can’t resist! Layered with double American and double Swiss cheese on triple Texas toast. Served with your choice of a Trail Side.$10.00
Hibernia Chicken Sandwich
Golden, crispy breaded chicken breast fillets coated in a savory blend of fine flour and breadcrumbs for a rich flavor and crunchy texture. Served with your choice of covering and a dipping sauce with a Trail Side.$13.00
Trail Side's
Carry-Out / Delivery Beverage's

20 oz Pepsi
$3.00
20 oz Diet Pepsi
$3.00
20 oz Mountain Dew
$3.00
20 oz Dr. Pepper
$3.00
20 oz Big Red
$3.00OUT OF STOCKDiet Mountain Dew
$3.00
2 Liter Pepsi
$4.00
2 Liter Diet Pepsi
$4.00
2 Liter Mountain Dew
$4.00
2 Liter Dr. Pepper
$4.00
2 Liter Big Red
$4.002 Liter Diet Moutain Dew
$4.00
Red Bull
$3.50
Red Bull Sugar Free
$3.50
All hours
| Sunday | 10:00 am - 12:00 am |
| Monday | 10:00 am - 12:00 am |
| Tuesday | 10:00 am - 12:00 am |
| Wednesday | 10:00 am - 12:00 am |
| Thursday | 10:00 am - 12:00 am |
| Friday | 10:00 am - 12:00 am |
| Saturday | 10:00 am - 12:00 am |
Restaurant info
Pizza Burger Wings
Location
Similar restaurants in your area
© 2026 Toast, Inc.











