Skip to Main content
  • Mystic Market Old Saybrook

    Mystic Market Old Saybrook
    • Home
    • /
    • Old Saybrook
    • /
    • Mystic Market Old Saybrook
    Restaurant banner image

    Mystic Market Old Saybrook

    70 Millrock Road East

    Old Saybrook, CT 06475


    Orders through Toast are commission free and go directly to this restaurant


    Call

    Hours

    Directions

    Gift Cards

    SANDWICHES
    SALADS & SOUPS
    Delivery Fees

    Featured Items

    • A Make Your Own

    • California Chicken

      Grilled Chicken Breast, Dill Havarti, Bacon, Avocado, Baby Greens, Tomatoes & Chipotle Aioli served Hot & Toasty on a French Roll

      $14.95
    • Big Buffalo

      Crispy Chicken Breast, Spicy Buffalo Wing Sauce, Cheddar, Shaved Celery & Blue Cheese Dressing Served on served Hot & Toasty on a French Roll

      $12.95

    SANDWICHES

    Custom Sandwiches

    • A Make Your Own

    • Falafel & Hummus Wrap

      Our house-made hummus and falafel rolled in a spinach wrap with leaf lettuce, fresh tomatoes, red onions, sweet and spicy pickles, daikon radish pickles and tzatziki

      $11.95
    • Italian Combo

      Ham, hot coppa, genoa salami and provolone with roasted red peppers, lettuce, tomatoes and balsamic on our freshly baked baguette, served cold

      $12.95
    • Green Monster

      All-natural roasted turkey, green goddess dressing, cucumbers, baby spinach, avocado, and pepper jack cheese on fresh sourdough bread

      $12.95
    • Jammin' Turkey

      Roasted turkey, cheddar, bacon jam, lettuce, tomato, cranberry mayo on multigrain bread, served cold

      $11.95
    • Raging Bull

      Our house roasted beef and aged cheddar with lettuce, tomato, red onion and horseradish mayo on a freshly baked baguette, served cold

      $13.95
    • Ham & Brie

      Black Forest Ham, Honey Cup Mustard, Brie, Lettuce & Tomato on Mulitigrain Bread, served cold

      $14.95
    • Mediterranean Tuna Wrap

      Solid White Tuna Salad, Lime Cucumbers, Olive Tapenade, Arugula & Roasted Red Peppers in a Tomato Wrap, served cold

      $12.95

    Artisanal Sandwiches

    • California Chicken

      Grilled Chicken Breast, Dill Havarti, Bacon, Avocado, Baby Greens, Tomatoes & Chipotle Aioli served Hot & Toasty on a French Roll

      $14.95
    • Mystic Cheesesteak

      Our Juicy Smoked Beef Brisket topped with Melted Provolone, Peppers, Onions & Black Garlic Aioli served Hot & Toasty on a French Roll

      $12.95
    • Mystic Meatball

      House Made Meatballs, Mozzarella, Banana Peppers, Pomodoro served Hot & Toasty on a Garlic Bread French Roll

      $12.95
    • Big Buffalo

      Crispy Chicken Breast, Spicy Buffalo Wing Sauce, Cheddar, Shaved Celery & Blue Cheese Dressing Served on served Hot & Toasty on a French Roll

      $12.95
    • BBQ Pulled Pork (Sandwich)

      Our Flavorful Pulled Pork, BBQ, Cheddar, Banana Peppers, Red Onion & Crunchy Slaw served Hot & Toasty on a French Roll

      $12.95
    • Crispy Eggplant Sandwich

      Crispy eggplant, arugula, ricotta,pesto mayo and roasted red peppers served Hot & Toasty on a French Roll

      $11.95
    • Chicken Parmesan

      Crispy Panko Chicken, Pomodoro & Shredded Mozzarella served Hot & Toasty on a French Roll

      $12.95
    • Italian Chicken

      Grilled Chicken Breast, Roasted Tomatoes, Fresh Mozzarella & Pesto Mayo served Hot & Toasty on a French Roll

      $14.95

    Paninis & Grilled Sandwiches

    • Bronx Bomber

      House-Smoked Brisket, Swiss Cheese, Caramelized Onions, Dill Pickles & Grainy Mustard on Rye Bread served hot from the panini press

      $12.95
    • Roasted Turkey

      Roasted Butternut Squash, Sharp Cheddar, Red Onion Marmalade & Cranberry Mayo on Multigrain Bread served hot from the panini press

      $11.95
    • House Roast Beef

      Gorgonzola, Caramelized Onions, Arugula & Black Garlic Aioli on Grilled Flatbread served hot from the panini press

      $13.95
    • Roasted Portobello

      Portobello Mushroom with Fresh Mozzarella, Tomato & Arugula & Pesto Mayo on Grilled Focaccia served hot from the panini press

      $11.95
    • Pressed Prosciutto

      Fresh Mozzarella, Tomato, Arugula & Pesto Mayo on Grilled Flatbread served hot from the panini press

      $14.95
    • Grilled Chicken & Provolone

      Roasted Red Peppers, Baby Spinach & Pesto Aioli served hot from the panini press

      $12.95
    • Flame Grilled Chicken

      Sliced Chicken, Smoked Gouda, Arugula, Roasted Red Peppers & Garlic Aioli on Sour Dough Bread served hot from the panini press

      $13.95
    • Crispy Cauliflower Burrito

      Crispy Cauliflower, Vegan Cheddar, Cowboy Caviar, Pico de Gallo, Avocado, Vegan Chipotle Ranch, Tomato Wrap served hot from the panini press

      $12.95
    • Grilled Cheese

      Gooey Cheese on sourdough served hot from the panini press

      $7.50

    Signature Sandwiches

    • Fish Tacos

      Fried Cod, Chipotle Aioli, Salsa Verde, Shredded Lettuce & Pineapple Cucumber Slaw in White Tortillas

      $12.95
    • Fenwick Tuna Melt

      Solid White Tuna Salad, Baby Arugula, Cheddar & Tomatoes on Rye Bread served hot from the panini press

      $12.95
    • Chicken Caesar Wrap

      Grilled Chicken Breast, Green Leaf Lettuce, Caesar Dressing, Shredded Parmesan & Croutons on a White Wrap

      $11.95
    • Caprese

      Roasted Tomatoes, Pesto, Balsamic Fig Glaze, Fresh Mozzarella & Arugula on Grilled Flatbread, served hot from the panini press

      $12.95
    • Chicken Salad Wrap

      Mystic Market Chicken Salad, Lettuce & Tomato on a White Wrap, Served Cold

      $10.95
    • Tuna Salad Wrap

      Solid White Tuna Salad, Lettuce & Tomato on a Wheat Wrap, served cold

      $10.95
    • Classic Cuban

      Roasted Pork, Black Forest Ham, Swiss Cheese, Dill Pickles, Spicy Green Sauce & Dijon Mustard on a Toasted Baguette served hot from the panini press

      $12.95
    • California BLT

      Crispy bacon, bacon jam, avocado, lettuce, tomato, and black garlic aioli on fresh sourdough bread

      $12.95

    Special Sandwiches

    • Chicken Burrito

      $11.95
    • Crab Cake Sandwich

      Mystic Market Crab Cakes on a Grilled Flatbread with Arugula, Tomatoes, Cole Slaw & Chipotle Aioli

      $12.95
    • Kids Grilled Cheese

      $5.50
    • Kids PB&J

      $3.95
    • Spanakopita- Each

      Buttery Flakey Phyllo Dough with Spinach & Feta

      $5.95
    • The Rachel (Turkey Reuben)

      Turkey, Sauerkraut , Russian Dressing & Swiss on Rye

      $11.95

    Beverages

    • Pepsi

      The bold, refreshing, robust cola, click to add to your meal.

      $3.10
    • Diet Pepsi

      A crisp tasting, refreshing pop of sweet, fizzy bubbles without calories. Click to add to your meal.

      $3.10
    • Pepsi Zero

      Real cola taste, with a refreshing pop of sweet, fizzy bubbles without sugar. Click to add to your meal.

      $3.10
    • Mountain Dew

      Mtn Dew exhilarates and quenches thirst with its one of a kind citrus taste. Click to add to your meal.

      $3.10
    • Starry

      A caffeine-free soda that provides a crisp, clear burst of lemon lime flavor. Click to add to your meal.

      $3.10
    • Aquafina Water

      Pure water for a perfect taste. Add a refreshing water to your meal.

      $3.10
    • Pureleaf Iced Tea Lemonade

      Start with fresh-picked leaves brewed just right, add lemon for balance and finish it with real sugar. Click to add to your meal.

      $4.09
    • Pureleaf- Unsweetened Green Iced Tea

      The crisp, clean taste of green tea brewed and bottled without adding sugar or color. Click to add to your meal.

      $4.09
    • CELSIUS Grape Rush

      this carbonated flavor of CELSIUS has the perfect balance of flavor and energy. Click to add to your meal.

      $4.89
    • Tropicana Orange Juice

      A juice drink with the delicious orange taste you love and the vitamin C nutrition you need. Click to add to your meal.

      $4.09
    • Bubly Grapefruit

      Grapefruit flavored sparkling water - no calories, no sweeteners, all smiles. Click to add to your meal.

      $3.09
    • Bubly Blackberry

      Blackberry flavored sparkling water - no calories, no sweeteners, all smiles. Click to add to your meal.

      $3.09

    SALADS & SOUPS

    Salads

    • Market Salad

      Fresh Greens, Your Choice of Goat Cheese or Gorgonzola Cheese, Toasted Spiced Walnuts, Dried Cranberries, your choice of Dressing

      $9.95
    • Greek Salad

      Romaine, Tomatoes, Feta, Cucumbers, Banana Peppers, Kalamata Olives, Red Onions, Greek Lemon Vinaigrette

      $10.95
    • Classic Caesar Salad

      Crisp Romaine, Herb Croutons, Shredded Parmesan & our Classic Caesar Dressing

      $8.95
    • Chopped Cobb Salad

      Romaine and Fresh Greens, Crumbled Bacon, Turkey, Hard Boiled Egg, Cherry Tomatoes and Gorgonzola with a Balsamic Vinaigrette

      $11.95
    • Fresh Garden Salad

      Fresh Greens, Tomatoes, Carrots, Cucumbers, Sweet Red Peppers & Balsamic Vinaigrette

      $7.95
    • Southwest Chicken Salad

      Spiced Chicken over Romaine with Grape Tomatoes, Cowboy Caviar, Fresh Avocado, Cheddar, Tortilla Strips, Vegan Chipotle Ranch Dressing

      $12.95

    Hot Soup: Weekly Specials

    • Cajun Gumbo- Med 16oz

      $7.95
    • Cajun Gumbo- Small 8oz

      $4.50
    • New England Clam Chowder- Med 16oz

      $7.95
    • New England Clam Chowder- Small 8oz

      $4.50

    Delivery Fees

    • Delivery Fee: 1-5mi

      $25.00
    • Delivery Fee: Every mi over 25

      $1.00

    All hours
    Sunday9:45 am - 4:45 pm
    Monday9:00 am - 6:30 pm
    Tuesday8:00 am - 6:30 pm
    Wednesday8:00 am - 6:30 pm
    Thursday8:00 am - 6:30 pm
    Friday8:00 am - 6:30 pm
    Saturday8:00 am - 6:30 pm
    Restaurant info

    Come in and enjoy!

    Location

    70 Millrock Road East, Old Saybrook, CT 06475

    Directions


    Similar restaurants in your area

    Pizza Works Pie and Suds
    View restaurantnext
    Ashlawn Farm Coffee 455 Boston Post Road
    View restaurantnext
    Skipper's - Old Saybrook
    View restaurantnext
    Sip Wine Bar Old Saybrook
    View restaurantnext
    Liv's Oyster Bar
    View restaurantnext
    DORO Marketplace - Old Saybrook DMP-Old Saybrook
    View restaurantnext
    Search similar restaurants
    © 2025 Toast, Inc.
    Toast
    • About Toast
    • For restaurants
    • Terms of Service
    • Privacy Statement
    • Do not sell my
      personal information
    Made with love in Boston
    • Instagram
    • X (formerly Twitter)
    • Facebook