
American
OLD FASHIONED BUTCHER SHOPPE
7766 Fruitwood Lane STE D
Newburgh, IN 47630
Orders through Toast are commission free and go directly to this restaurant
BEEF

Beef Chuck Roast
A fattier beef roast that will be very tender and shred when cooked. Price my vary by size.$10.50/lb
Beef Eye Of Round
The eye of round is lean, flavorful cut. Can be roasted or slow- cooked. Price my vary by size.$9.50/lb
Beef Femur Bones
Beef femur bones frozen, can be left whole, half cut, or canoe style. Great for making broth ,or for your furry friends$5.50/lb
Beef Flank Steak
Price my vary by size.$15.50/lb
Beef Ground Sirloin
$11.50/lb
Beef Liver
$5.00/lb
Beef Minit steak
Thinly sliced pieces of beef ran through the tenderizer, great for breading or throwing on the grill.$10.50/lb
Beef Mock Tenders
$19.99/lb
Beef Picanha
Comes from the top cap of the top butt, more frequently known for sirloin steaks. This piece is good left whole, cut into cubes, or made into steaks. This is priced for the whole piece.$45.50/lb
Beef Sirloin Tip Roast
The sirloin tip roast also known as round tip roast. The sirloin tip roast is flavorful, lean cuts, it can be tough and should be braised or stewed.$10.50/lbBeef Skirt Steak
$18.99/lbBeef Sliced Shank
$10.50/lb
Beef Tenderloin Whole
This is a whole beef tenderloing tell us how you would like it cut EX. 6-8 oz steaks grind trimmings$196.00/lb
Beef Sirloin Flat
A steak that comes from the top butt, is very lean and is best served on the medium- medium rare doneness$15.50/lbOUT OF STOCKBeef Tri Tip Roast
Price my vary by size.$58.45/lbOUT OF STOCK
Beef Trimmings
$2.95/lb
Boneless Beef For Stew
Lean beef that is cut into 3/4" cubes, good for stew or beef tips.$10.50/lb
Chuck/Brisket Ground Beef
Chuck/Brisket grinds if a blend of chuck roast an brisket grounded up.$10.50/lb
Ground Beef 5 lb Bag
Bulk 80% lean ground beef packaged in a 5lb bag.$25.00
Ground Beef 80/20
Ground beef with an 80% lean and 20% fat ratio.$6.79/lb
Beef Ribeye
An upper 2/3 choice beef steak that has intermuscular marbling and more fat than other steaks. price is per oz of steak.$16.12+
Beef Bacon Wrapped Tenderloin
One of the best cuts of beef comes from the beef tenderloin and is wrapped in bacon. Price is per oz of steak.$23.00+Beef Center Cut Barrel Filet
Beef tenderloin center cut piece. The most tender piece of the cow. Price is per oz of steak$25.50+
Beef T-Bone
Comes from the short loin of the cow, will have a t shapped look and will contain what is known as the ny strip and sometines the filet. Price is per oz of steak$17.75+New York Strip
A tender, more lean steak that comes from the short loin located on the back of the animal. Good for any cooking preference since leannes is somewhere between beef tenderloin and ribeye. Price is per oz of steak.$16.75+OUT OF STOCKBaseball Sirloin
Economical cut that's similar in fat content as the beef tenderloin. Price is per oz of steak.$9.00+
Beef Sirloin Steak
A steak that come from the topp butt, is very lean annd is best served on tha medium- medium rare doneness. Price is per oz per steak$9.87+
4-1 Ground Beef Patties 5 LB Box
5lb frozen box of 80% lean patties, 4 per pound (20 per box)$34.95/lb5# BOX 80/20 GRINDS 1# PKG
$29.95Extra Lean 90/10 5 LB - 1 LB Box
5lb box of 90% lean ground beef, packaged in 1lb bags$34.95/lbChuck Brisket Ground Beef 5 Lb box
5 lb Chuck Brisket Ground Packaged in 1 lb bags placed in a box.$39.95
CHICKEN

Boneless Chicken Breast
6-8oz chicken breasts, boneless skinless$8.49/lb
Boneless Chicken Thighs
Chicken thighs that have been deboned and deskinned$5.29/lb
Chicken Bomb
Chicken bomb is a jumbo chicken breast sliced to make a pocket. Then stuffed with cream cheese, chives, and jalapenos wrapped with two slices of bacon and coated with a bbq seasoning. Great on the smoker but can cook on others. Price my vary by size.$13.50/lbBreaded Chicken Tenders
BREADED CHICKEN TENDERS$10.49/lbOUT OF STOCKBoneless Chicken Breast 6-8oz- FROZEN
Boneless Chicken Breast 6-8oz- FROZEN BOX$39.95
Chicken Wings
Large cut chicken wings with drums and flats separated$3.00/lb
Whole Fryer
Whole chicken without the internal organs. This is priced as a whole. Please list if you need this cut any way.$11.47/lb
DELI

Hard Salami
$9.99/lb
Chicken Salad White Meat
Amish chicken salad, good for spread or cracker.$10.49/lb
Ham Salad
Homemade ham salad that has been around since our inception, good to put on sandwiches or crackers.$6.49/lb
Redskin Potato Salad
Mustard based potato salad, great for any dinner or gathering.$5.49/lb
Smoked Chicken Salad
$10.49/lb
Brown Sugar Ham
$9.99/lb
House Smoked Ham
$8.99/lb
Merkley Round Smoked Ham
$5.99/lb
House Smoked Turkey Breast
$14.99/lb
HONEY TURKEY
$8.99
Colby Cheese
$5.99/lb
Troyer Brick Cheese
$7.49/lb
Troyer Hot Pepper Cheese
$7.49/lb
Troyer Pepper Jack Cheese
$5.99/lbSmoked Bacon Cheddar Cheese
$10.49/lb
Hot Cheese Spread
Our famous pimento cheese spread made with spicy cheeses.$7.49/lb
Pimento Cheese Spread
Homemade famous pimento cheese spread.$7.49/lb
BABY SWISS CHEESE
$9.99
BBQ Smoked Beans
Homemade smoked beans packed with pulled pork, barbeque sauce, and an assortment of beans.$8.49/lb
Apple Slaw
$6.49/lb
Merkley German Bologna
$5.49/lb
Merkley Plain Bologna
$4.49/lb
GRAB N GO

Michigan Cherry Potato Chips
Michigan Cherry Potato Chips offer a unique twist on classic snacking with a hint of cherry sweetness combined with savory crispiness. This unexpected flavor pairing makes a perfect snack for those looking to try something new and adventurous.$4.79
Pickled Jalapeno Potato Chips
These chips blend the spicy kick of pickled jalapenos with the satisfying crunch of potato chips. Perfect for those who appreciate a little heat with their snack.$4.79
Kettle Cooked Potato Chips, Sea Salt & Vinegar
Enjoy the bold flavor of sea salt and tangy vinegar with these kettle-cooked potato chips. They're crisped to perfection for a satisfying crunch with every bite.$4.79
Original Potato Chips
Enjoy the classic taste with Great Lakes Potato Chip Co. Original Potato Chips. These chips offer a crisp texture and are perfect for any snack time.$4.79
Great Lakes, Kettle Cooked Potato Chips, Barbeque
Enjoy a crunchy treat with Great Lakes Kettle Cooked Potato Chips in Barbeque flavor. These chips offer a smoky sweetness that's perfect for your next snack time or gathering.$4.79
Grippo's BBQ Potato Chips
Enjoy the smoky, savory taste of BBQ Potato Chips, perfect for your next snack time. These chips offer a satisfying crunch with every bite, making them a great choice for parties or a quick treat.$4.50OUT OF STOCK
Grippo Bar-B-Q Potato Chips 12oz
Enjoy the bold, smoky flavor of Grippo's Bar-B-Q Potato Chips in a convenient 12oz package. Perfect for sharing at parties or indulging by yourself during a movie night.$5.99OUT OF STOCK
Grippo's BBQ Twin Chips
Bar-B-Q Twin Chips offer a perfect balance of smoky and savory flavors packed into every crunch. Enjoy them solo or pair them with your favorite dip for a flavorsome snack time.$6.49
Grippo BBQ Chip 1.5 LB Box
Enjoy a classic snack with these 1.5-pound bags of Grippo BBQ Chips. Each bag delivers a punch of bold barbecue flavor, perfect for sharing at parties or enjoying solo when you need a savory treat.$9.00OUT OF STOCK
Grippo's Sweet Maui Onion Wavy Potato Chips 2.75oz
Enjoy the tropical taste of sweet Maui onion in every crunchy bite of these wavy potato chips. Each 2.75 oz bag is perfect for a quick and satisfying snack.$2.80
Grippo's Sour Cream & Onion Potato Chips 2.75oz
Enjoy a tasty snack with Grippo's Sour Cream & Onion Potato Chips. Each 2.75 oz bag in this 24-count box delivers a perfect blend of creamy and zesty flavors to satisfy your cravings.$2.80OUT OF STOCKOriginal thick cut potato chip style
$2.80Barbecue wavy potato chips
$2.80
Grippos Potato Chips
Grippos Potato Chips offer a satisfying crunch with every bite. They are perfect for those who enjoy a hearty snack with bold flavor.$2.80OUT OF STOCK
Merkley Jalapeno & Cheese Summer Sausage
$9.49
Merkley Braunschweiger
$3.99
Merkley Snack Stick with Jalepeno
$7.99
Merkley Summer Sausage with Cheese
$9.49
Merkley Pepper Bologna
$7.99
Merkley Summer Sausage
$8.99
Merkley Honey BBQ Snack Sticks
$7.99
Merkley Snack Sticks
$7.90
Merkley Beef Hot Dogs
$8.99
Merkley Skinless Hot Dogs
$5.99
SEASONING

2 LB BBQ Seasoning
$15.99/lb
OFBS Meat Seasoning 2 LB
$15.99
Meat Church BBQ Rub Holy Gospel Seasoning Bottle 14oz
Experience a divine blend of flavors with Meat Church's Holy Gospel BBQ Rub, perfect for all your grilling and smoking needs. This versatile 14 oz seasoning bottle combines unique spices to elevate both meat and vegetable dishes.$9.99OUT OF STOCK
Lane's Brisket Rub Beef Seasoning 12.4oz
Discover the robust flavor of Lane's Brisket Rub, a sugar-free blend perfect for seasoning your beef. This 12.4oz container delivers a savory mix that enhances your brisket without overpowering its natural taste.$11.99OUT OF STOCK
Lane's Nashville Hot Seasoning | Chicken & Wing Seasoning
Introducing Lane's Nashville Hot Seasoning, the perfect blend to spice up your chicken and wings. This 3.14 oz bottle packs a flavorful punch, bringing the heat and taste of Nashville right to your kitchen.$7.99
Lane's Q-NAMI Asian-Flavored Rub & Seasoning 12.6oz
Introducing Lane's Q-NAMI Asian-Flavored Rub & Seasoning: a unique blend perfect for giving your meats and vegetables a touch of Asian-inspired flavors. At 12.6 ounces, this versatile seasoning is a must-have for enhancing your cooking with authentic and aromatic spices.$11.99OUT OF STOCK
Lane's Fiesta Taco Seasoning Mix 12.1oz
Lane's Fiesta Taco Seasoning Mix adds a Southwest flair to your meals, perfect for tacos or as a rub for grilling. It's all-natural and keto-friendly, making it a versatile choice for enhancing flavors without the guilt. All Natural Premium Southwest Seasoning & Rub | Keto Friendly - 12.1oz$11.99OUT OF STOCK
Lane's Signature Rub & Seasoning All-Purpose Seasoning 12.2oz
Add a pop of flavor to your meals with Lane's Signature Rub & Seasoning. This all-purpose blend is perfect for grilling, roasting, and everyday cooking, available in a handy 12.2 oz size.$11.99OUT OF STOCK
Lane's Cubano Cuban Seasoning Rub All-Natural Cuban Spice Blend 12.4oz
Add a touch of Caribbean flair to your dishes with Lane's Cubano Cuban Seasoning Rub. This all-natural spice blend comes in a 12.4 oz container, perfect for marinating or seasoning meats and veggies.$11.99OUT OF STOCK
Meat Church Deez Nuts Honey Pecan BBQ Rub Seasoning 14oz
This Meat Church Deez Nuts Honey Pecan BBQ Rub adds a sweet and nutty flavor to any grilled meat. It comes in a 14 oz bottle and is free from MSG, making it a healthier seasoning choice.$9.99OUT OF STOCK
Lane's Spellbound Rub Smoky Sweet All-Purpose Seasoning 11.7oz
Lane's Spellbound Rub | Gluten-free | Smoky Sweet All-Purpose Seasoning | Great on Pork and Chicken. Experience the deep, smoky sweetness of Lane's Spellbound Rub, an all-purpose seasoning perfect for enhancing the flavor of pork and chicken. This gluten-free blend comes in an 11.7 oz container, making it a versatile staple for your spice rack.$11.99OUT OF STOCK
Big Cock Ranch Bull Shit Steak Seasoning
The Bull Shit Steak Seasoning from Big Cock Ranch is designed to add a robust flavor to your steaks and grilled meats. It's a no-fuss seasoning blend that brings out the natural taste of beef with a perfect mix of spices.$10.99OUT OF STOCK
Big Cock Ranch - Aw Shit Hot N Spicy Seasoning
Check out Big Cock Ranch's "Aw Shit" Hot and Spicy Seasoning for a bold kick to your dishes. Perfect for those who love to add a bit of heat and flavor to their cooking.$10.99OUT OF STOCK
Meat Church BBQ Rub the Gospel All-Purpose Seasoning Bottle 14oz
Check out the Meat Church BBQ Rub, The Gospel All-Purpose Seasoning, for a versatile touch to your grilling or cooking. This 14-ounce bottle offers a flavorful blend perfect for any meat or vegetable dish.$9.99OUT OF STOCK
Big Cock Ranch Chicken Shit Seasoning
Check out this Shit Seasoning, perfect for enhancing your meat dishes. Just a sprinkle adds a rich, savory flavor to any meal.$10.99OUT OF STOCK
Lane's Blackening Rub Cajun Seasoning 10.2oz
Check out the Lane's Blackening Rub, a Cajun seasoning that packs a flavorful punch in a 10.2 oz container. It's perfect for adding a spicy kick to your meats and seafood dishes.$11.99OUT OF STOCK
Lane's Sweet Heat Rub | Sweet & Spicy Seasoning - 10.4oz
Check out Lane's Sweet Heat Rub if you're looking to add a bit of a kick to your cooking. It's a sweet and spicy seasoning blend, perfect for meats and vegetables, and comes in a 10.4-ounce container.$11.99OUT OF STOCK
Big Cock Ranch Special Shit Seasoning
Check out this Special Shit Seasoning, perfect for boosting the flavor of any meat dish. It's versatile, adding a rich, savory kick to both grilled and cooked foods.$10.99OUT OF STOCK
Big Cock Ranch Good Shit Seasoning
Good Shit Seasoning is a versatile spice blend perfect for enhancing the flavors of both meat and vegetarian dishes. It adds a savory touch to your meals with its unique mix of spices.$10.99OUT OF STOCKOFBS Season Shaker
8 oz shaker of our blended spices, great on anything.$6.99
PORK

Pork Piggy Links
$6.49/lb
Chorizo Pork Sausage
$5.49/lb
Hot Italian Pork Sausage
$6.49/lb
Cajun Style Pork Sausage
$6.49/lb
Pork Breakfast Sausage
Ground mild breakfast sausage$5.49/lb
Pork Tenderloin 5 LB Box
$28.00/lb
Breaded Pork Loin Fritters
$6.19/lbBoneless Pork Chops
$6.99/lbBoneless Pork Loin Roast
$5.49/lb
Butterfly Pork Chops
Boneless pork chops cut from the center of the boneless loin in a butterfly style cut.$6.99/lb
Frenched Pork Chop
Please let us know if you are wanting them in single bone or as a roast$6.49/lb
Frenched Pork Rib Roast
$17.89/lb
Pork Baby Back Ribs
Price my vary by size.$5.99/lb
Pork Bellies Whole
Price my vary by size.$70.00/lb
Pork Butt 2PK
Price my vary by size.$62.00/lb
Pork Chops
Bone-in pork chops that include the pork tender piece as well as the pork loin itself. Please lets us know if you would like thick or thin cut$4.99/lb
Pork Cutlets
Pork sirloin that is tenderized and is used with breading when cooking.$4.49/lb
Merkley Smoked Pork Chop
Fully cooked bone in pork chops. Can eat cold out of the case but are typically warmed up in a pan. Please let us know if you would like think or thin chops.$6.99/lbPORK SAUSAGE 5-1LB
5# box of mild breakfast sausage packaged in 1# packs$22.45/lbPork Jambalaya Brat
$7.49/lb
Sweet Italian Pork Sausage Links
$5.49/lb
Pork Steak
Cut from the pork shoulder butt, fattier piece of pork that is good for grilling or pan frying. Please let us know if you would like thick cut or thin cut steaks.$4.29/lb
Pork Tenderette
$5.49/lb
Pork Tenderloin
Pork loin that is tenderized 2 times, usually around 4oz per piece.$7.49/lb
Whole Pork Tenderloin 2pc Pkg
Pork tenderloin two piece package. Price my vary by size.$11.48/lbCOLD PULLED PORK
$13.00
Pork Burger
$6.49Bacon Wrapped Pork Filet
Bacon Wrapped Pork Tenderloin Quanity is for whole piece's$3.75+
If you use a credit card, OLD FASHIONED BUTCHER SHOPPE will charge an additional 3.00% ($0.00) to help offset processing costs. This amount is not more than what OLD FASHIONED BUTCHER SHOPPE pays in fees.
All hours
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | 9:00 am - 4:00 pm |
| Wednesday | 9:00 am - 4:00 pm |
| Thursday | 9:00 am - 4:00 pm |
| Friday | 9:00 am - 4:00 pm |
| Saturday | Closed |
Restaurant info
Come in and enjoy!
Location
© 2026 Toast, Inc.




