This restaurant does not have any images
American
Otter Bay deli
W State Road 120
Fremont, IN 46737
Orders through Toast are commission free and go directly to this restaurant
Otter Bay Deli
Sandwiches
Anchors away
Roast beef, ham, turkey, tomato, lettuce, cheddar cheese, ( served on a New York bagel, or bread$12.50Barnyard
Turkey, bacon, tomato, lettuce, Swiss cheese, mustard and mayonnaise ( served on a New York bagel, or bread)$10.25Chips
Chip$2.50Coleslaw
$5.75Cream Cheese
$2.25cream cheese chocolate chip
$2.75Cream Cheese Honey Cinnamon
$2.75Cream Cheese Jalapeno
$2.75Cream cheese orange with pecan
$2.75Cream cheese Strawberry
$2.75Cream cheese Blackberry
$2.75Cream Cheese Veg
$2.75Daily soup
Ask cashier for the soup of the day.$5.75Egg
$1.50Even Keel
Turkey, tomato, sprouts, mustard the mayonnaise, ( served on a New York bagel, or bread)$9.75Fish tales veggie
Sprouts, tomato, red onion, cucumber, mustard and mayonnaise ( served on a New York bagel, or bread)$9.50fruit
Orange, Apple, Banana$1.50Full Sail
Turkey, tomato, avocado, lettuce, Swiss cheese, mayonnaise and mustard. ( on New York Bagel, or Bread)$10.25Hen House
Chicken salad, tomato, lettuce, Swiss cheese, ( served on a New York bagel, or bread)$10.00Houseboat
Turkey, corn beef, tomato, sprouts, jack cheese, mustard and mayonnaise, ( served on a New York bagel, or bread)$10.50Macaroni Salad
$5.75Man Overboard
Corned beef, sauerkraut, spicy mustard, Swiss cheese. ( on a rye bread, or marble rye bagel, served hot)$18.50Meat Plater
$75.00Motorboat
Roast beef, lettuce, cheddar cheese, barbecue sauce, served hot on request. ( served on New York bagel, or bread)$10.00Plain Hotdog
$3.00Port Pastrami
New York Pastrami, Swiss cheese, Spicy mustard, ( on the rye bread, or marble rye bagel, served hot)$18.50Potato Salad
$5.75Salads
Toasted green salad, chicken salad, and green egg salad on green$9.00Soup
Ask Cashier for soup of the day$5.75Swim with the fishes
Tuna salad, tomato, lettuce, Mustard and mayonnaise, ( served on a New York bagel or bread)$9.50Take the helm
Ham, tomato, lettuce, cheddar cheese, mustard and mayonnaise, (served on New York bagel, or Bread)$9.75Water
Bottled Water$2.50What came 1st chicken or the egg
Egg salad, tomato, lettuce, mustard and mayonnaise ( Served on a New York bagel, or bread)$9.50cream Cheese Chive
$2.75High Tide
BLT style sandwich. Bacon, lettuce, tomato, avocado, mayo.$9.75Life Boat
Roast beef, ham, turkey, bacon, eggs (2), tomatoes, lettuce, avocado, cheddar cheese, mayo, mustard.$16.00Sailor
Pastrami, eggs, tomatoes, red onions, swiss cheese, garlic, and cream cheese.$14.00
New York Bagels
Chicago Hotdogs
Jumbo Chicago hotdog
Relish, Onion, mustard, sports papers, pickle spear, Puppy seed bun$7.00Jumbo All American dog
Mustard, Ketchup, Onion, Relish$4.00Jumbo Coney Dog
Chili, onion, grated cheese$5.50Jumbo Fenway Dog
Mustard, Onion, Roasted Garlic$5.50Jumbo Ohio Dog
Mustard, Chili, Grated cheese, Hot sauce$6.00Jumbo Spicy Angola
Spicy Tomato sauce, Jalapeno, Grated cheddar cheese,$6.75Jumbo Carolina Slaw Dog
Mustard, Chili, Onion, Slow$6.95Jumbo Reuben Dog
Corned Beef, Sauerkraut, Grated Swiss cheese, Becon bits, Russian Dressing$8.25Jumbo Hawaiin Dog
Slew, Relish, Onion, Pineapple, Becon bits, Teriyaki sauce$6.75
Breakfast New York Bagels
Lox, Cream Cheese, Sprouts, Tomato, Red onion, Capers
Capsize
Ham, 3 Eggs, Jack Cheese, Or Chedder Cheese, On a New York Bagel.$9.50Paddle board
Bacon, 3 Eggs, Jack Cheese, Or Chedder Cheese, On a New York Bagel.$9.75Lil Dighy
$9.50Out of the coop
$9.75Hot Yacht
$9.50Rudder
$9.75Buoy
$9.25Chumming
$9.75Gone fishing
$13.95Sailor
Pastrami, eggs, tomatoes, red onions, swiss cheese, garlic, and cream cheese.$14.00
Extra items
Ice/Ice creams
10# Ice/Ice cream
All hours
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | Closed |
| Thursday | Closed |
| Friday | Closed |
| Saturday | Closed |
Location
W State Road 120, Fremont, IN 46737
Similar restaurants in your area
© 2026 Toast, Inc.


