Seafood
Out Of The Blue Seafood 252 E Montauk Hwy
Orders through Toast are commission free and go directly to this restaurant
Pickup Only
Menu
Soups
Raw Bar
Shrimp Cocktail - 6 pieces
Freshly steamed and peeled, served with Cocktail Sauce$12.00
Shrimp Cocktail - 12 pieces
Freshly steamed and shelled, served with Cocktail Sauce$20.00
Oyster 1\2 Shell - 6pc
Shucked to order and served with Cocktail sauce and lemon$18.00
Oyster 1\2 Shell - 12 Pc
Shucked to order and served with Cocktail sauce and lemon$27.00
Clam 1\2 Shell - 6pc
Shucked to order and served with Cocktail sauce and lemon$12.00
Clam 1\2 Shell - 12pcs
Shucked to order and served with Cocktail sauce and lemon$19.00
Raw Bar Trio
6 Clams on the half shell, 6 oysters on the half shell and 6 pieces Shrimp Cocktail, Shucked to order and served with Cocktail sauce and lemon$32.00
Appetizers
Fried Calamari
Piping hot, served with Marinara sauce$17.95
Crab Cake App
Our house receipe, served with Remoulade sauce$18.95
Fried Oysters App
Shucked and fried to order$18.95
Fried Clam App
Shucked and fried to order$13.95
Ahi Tuna App
Served with Garlic sesame sauce, seaweed salad, ginger and wasabi$21.95
Smoked Fish App.
An assortment of our in-house artisanally smoked fish$18.95
Baked Clams
House recipe, a favorite with our customers$17.95
Shrimp App
$14.95
Scallop App
$16.95Soft Shell Crab App
$16.95
Wings - 12pc
$25.00Seafood Stuffed Shell
$9.95
Wings- 6pc
$15.00
Salads
Mixed Greens Salad
Fresh and simple : mesclun greens$11.95
Caesar Salad
Romaine Lettuce, croutons and grated parmesan cheese$11.95
Ahi Tuna Salad
Seared tuna on a bed of tomato, cucumber,onion and carrot$23.95
Lobster Tortilla Bowl
Lobster salad over lettuce, tomatoes, cucumber, carrots and red onion, in a tortilla bowl$41.95
Goat Cheese salad
Tomatoes, cucumber, carrots, cranberries and, of course, goat cheese$18.95
Mixed Green Salad - Small
$7.95
Caesar Salad - Small
$7.95Seafood Salad Over Mixed Greens
$24.95
Entrees
Black Sea Bass
$24.95Bronzini
$24.95
Codfish
Served with a choice of two sides$24.95Crab Cake Platter
$28.95
Flounder/Fluke
Served with a choice of two sides$24.95
NY Sirloin Steak
Served with a choice of two sides$31.95Red Snapper
$32.95
Salmon
Served with a choice of two sides$24.95
Sea Scallops
Served with a choice of two sides$26.95
Seafood Combo
Shrimp, scallops, flounder and clams, served with a choice of two sides$31.95Sesame Crusted Tuna
Served with a choice of two sides$24.95
Shrimp Platter
$24.95Striped Bass
$28.95
Stuffed Flounder
$28.95
Surf and Turf
NY Strip Steak and a 1 1/4lb steamed lobster, served with a choice of two sides$71.95
Swordfish
Served with a choice of two sides$24.95
Teriyaki Sea Scallops
Served with a choice of two sides$26.95
Tuna
Served with a choice of two sides$24.95
Pasta
Shrimp Scampi
Served over Linguini with Garlic Bread$23.95
Chicken Parmesan Linguini
Served over Linguini with Garlic Bread$23.95
Mussels Fra Diavolo
Served over Linguini with Garlic Bread$23.95
Seafood Pasta
Shrimp, clams,mussels and calamari, Served over Linguini with Garlic Bread$26.95
Lobster Mac n Cheese
As indulgent as it sounds$27.95
Linguine w. Clams
Served over Linguini with Garlic Bread$23.95
Sides
Kids Menu
Lobsters/Cooked
Lobster Dinner 1.25lb
One 1 1/4lb Steamed Lobster, served with corn and baked potato$45.95
Lobster Dinner 1.5lb
One 1 1/2lb Steamed Lobster, served with corn and baked potato$55.95
Lobster Dinner 2lb
One 2lb Steamed Lobster, served with corn and baked potato$71.95
Lobster Dinner 2.5lb
One 2 1/2lb Steamed Lobster, served with corn and baked potato$81.95King Crab Legs
Two legs, served with butter and lemon$84.95OUT OF STOCK
Snow Crab Clusters
Two Clusters, served with Scampi sauce$54.95
Lobster bake 1.25lb (PUP 1.25lb)
Our beloved Pick-up a Party - steamed 1 1/4lb lobster, shellfish medley, baked potato, corn, clam juice and drawn butter$55.95
Lobster bake 1.5lb (PUP 1.5lb)
Our beloved Pick-up a Party - steamed 1 1/2lb lobster, shellfish medley, baked potato, corn, broth and drawn butter$65.95
Lobster bake 2lb (PUP 2)
Our beloved Pick-up a Party - steamed 2lb lobster, shellfish medley, baked potato, corn, broth and drawn butter$81.95
Lobster bake 2.5lb (PUP 2.5lb)
Our beloved Pick-up a Party - steamed 2 1/2lb lobster, shellfish medley, baked potato, corn, broth and drawn butter$91.95Seafood Stuffed
$12.00
Sandwiches
Seared Tuna BLT
Served with french fries and coleslaw$23.95
Fish Taco
Served with french fries and coleslaw$21.95
Flounder Sandwich
Served with french fries and coleslaw$21.95
Buffalo Shrimp Wrap
Served with french fries and coleslaw$21.95
Crab Cake Sandwich
Served with Remoulade sauce, french fries and coleslaw$21.95
Grilled Salmon Wrap
Served with french fries and coleslaw$21.95
Oyster Po'Boy
Served with Chipotle Aioli, french fries and coleslaw$21.95
Hot lobster Roll
Served with french fries and coleslaw$42.95
New England Lobster Roll
Served with french fries and coleslaw$42.95
Lobster Roll Combo
Half a Hot lobster Roll and half a New England style, served with french fries and coleslaw$42.95
Shrimp Parmesan Sandwich
On a Seed Roll, served with french fries and coleslaw$21.95
Angus Beef Burger
Served Lettuce and tomato, with french fries and coleslaw$14.00Soft Shell Crab Sandwich
$26.95Grilled Sword Sandwich
$23.95Tuna Salad Wrap
$18.95Shrimp Salad Wrap
$19.95Grilled Chicken Sandwich
$18.95
Drinks
Coca-Cola
Coca-Cola's crisp, refreshing taste has stood the test of time since 1886. These carefully crafted soft drinks are meant to be enjoyed anytime, anywhere. Pop open a Coca-Cola soda for a taste experience like no other. The familiar fizz and caffeine create an instant magic moment. Refreshing the world for over 130 years, Coca-Cola brings people together and spreads optimism wherever it goes. Find your magic and make life delicious with an ice-cold Coca-Cola.$3.75
Diet Coke
Enjoy a break with Diet Coke, the perfect no-sugar, no-calorie companion. With its bold taste and distinctive blend of flavors, Diet Coke is an everyday hero when it comes to refreshing your day. Every sip of Diet Coke delivers the same great taste that's delighted fans for over 40 years. When you want a sugar-free soda that doesn't sacrifice on taste, reach for a Diet Coke.$3.75
Sprite
Sprite's cool and crisp lemon-lime flavor will keep you invigorated and inspired. You know why? Because Sprite keeps it real just like you when pursuing your passions. No caffeine. Just you, an iconic flavor, and whatever you can think of next.$3.75
Sprite Zero Sugar
Sprite Zero Sugar is the classic lemon-lime soda without the sugar. Who says you can't do more with less? Quench your thirst with the classic, cool, crisp, lemon-lime taste that's caffeine-free and contains zero sugar.$3.75
Smart Water
Every drop of smartwater tastes pure and will leave you feeling refreshed. It's everything you want from a bottled water—pure, hydrating and crisp. It might be thanks to the fact that it's vapor-distilled through a process inspired by the clouds. Or the fact that we've added electrolytes for taste. Either way, you can bet on a premium water experience with every bottle. So whenever you're on the move, working out or need a quiet moment for yourself, smartwater is a smart way to hydrate.$3.75Ginger Ale
$3.75Diet Ginger Ale
$3.75Snapple
$3.75Seltzer
$3.75Dr. Pepper
$3.75Diet Dr. Pepper
$3.75Lemonade
$3.75Fruit Punch
$3.75Sweet tea
$3.75Unsweetened Tea
$3.75
Take Out (3PD)
Homemade Soups
Raw Bar
Shrimp Cocktail - 6 pieces
Freshly steamed and peeled, served with Cocktail Sauce$17.00Shrimp Cocktail - 12 pieces
Freshly steamed and shelled, served with Cocktail Sauce$25.00Oyster 1\2 Shell - 6pc
Shucked to order and served with Cocktail sauce and lemon$23.00Oyster 1\2 Shell - 12 Pc
Shucked to order and served with Cocktail sauce and lemon$32.00Clam 1\2 Shell - 6pc
Shucked to order and served with Cocktail sauce and lemon$17.00Clam 1\2 Shell - 12pcs
Shucked to order and served with Cocktail sauce and lemon$24.00Raw Bar Trio
6 Clams on the half shell, 6 oysters on the half shell and 6 pieces Shrimp Cocktail, Shucked to order and served with Cocktail sauce and lemon$37.00
Appetizers
Fried Calamari
Piping hot, served with Marinara sauce$22.95Crab Cake App
Our house receipe, served with Remoulade sauce$23.95Fried Oysters App
Shucked and fried to order$21.95Fried Clam App
Shucked and fried to order$18.95Ahi Tuna App
Served with Garlic sesame sauce, seaweed salad, ginger and wasabi$26.95Smoked Fish App.
An assortment of our in-house artisanally smoked fish$23.95Baked Clams
House recipe, a favorite with our customers$22.95Shrimp App
$19.95Scallop App
$21.95
Salads
Mixed Greens Salad
Fresh and simple : mesclun greens$15.95Caesar Salad
Romaine Lettuce, croutons and grated parmesan cheese$15.95Ahi Tuna Salad
Seared tuna on a bed of tomato, cucumber,onion and carrot$28.95Lobster Tortilla Bowl
Lobster salad over lettuce, tomatoes, cucumber, carrots and red onion, in a tortilla bowl$44.95Goat Cheese salad
Tomatoes, cucumber, carrots, cranberries and, of course, goat cheese$23.95Mixed Green Salad - Small
$12.95Caesar Salad - Small
$12.95
Entrees
Codfish
Served with a choice of two sides$29.95Swordfish
Served with a choice of two sides$29.95Tuna
Served with a choice of two sides$29.95Salmon
Served with a choice of two sides$29.95Surf and Turf
NY Strip Steak and a 1 1/4lb steamed lobster, served with a choice of two sides$81.95Teriyaki Sea Scallops
Served with a choice of two sides$31.95NY Sirloin Steak
Served with a choice of two sides$38.95Flounder/Fluke
Served with a choice of two sides$29.95Sea Scallops
Served with a choice of two sides$31.95Seafood Combo
Shrimp, scallops, flounder and clams, served with a choice of two sides$36.95Shrimp Platter
$29.95Stuffed Flounder
$33.95
Pasta
Shrimp Scampi
Served over Linguini with Garlic Bread$28.95Chicken Parmesan Linguini
Served over Linguini with Garlic Bread$28.95Mussels Fra Diavolo
Served over Linguini with Garlic Bread$28.95Seafood Pasta
Shrimp, clams,mussels and calamari, Served over Linguini with Garlic Bread$31.95Lobster Mac n Cheese
As indulgent as it sounds$31.95Linguine w. Clams
Served over Linguini with Garlic Bread$28.95
Sides
Little Guppies
From the Steamer
Lobster Dinner 1.25lb
One 1 1/4lb Steamed Lobster, served with corn and baked potato$55.95Lobster Dinner 1.5lb
One 1 1/2lb Steamed Lobster, served with corn and baked potato$65.95Lobster Dinner 2lb
One 2lb Steamed Lobster, served with corn and baked potato$81.95Lobster Dinner 2.5lb
One 2 1/2lb Steamed Lobster, served with corn and baked potato$91.95King Crab Legs
Two legs, served with butter and lemon$94.95OUT OF STOCKSnow Crab Clusters
Two Clusters, served with Scampi sauce$64.95Lobster bake 1.25lb (PUP 1.25lb)
Our beloved Pick-up a Party - steamed 1 1/4lb lobster, shellfish medley, baked potato, corn, clam juice and drawn butter$65.95Lobster bake 1.5lb (PUP 1.5lb)
Our beloved Pick-up a Party - steamed 1 1/2lb lobster, shellfish medley, baked potato, corn, broth and drawn butter$75.95Lobster bake 2lb (PUP 2)
Our beloved Pick-up a Party - steamed 2lb lobster, shellfish medley, baked potato, corn, broth and drawn butter$91.95Lobster bake 2.5lb (PUP 2.5lb)
Our beloved Pick-up a Party - steamed 2 1/2lb lobster, shellfish medley, baked potato, corn, broth and drawn butter$101.95
Sandwiches
Seared Tuna BLT
Served with french fries and coleslaw$28.95Fish Taco
Served with french fries and coleslaw$26.95Flounder Sandwich
Served with french fries and coleslaw$26.95Buffalo Shrimp Wrap
Served with french fries and coleslaw$26.95Crab Cake Sandwich
Served with Remoulade sauce, french fries and coleslaw$26.95Grilled Salmon Wrap
Served with french fries and coleslaw$26.95Oyster Po'Boy
Served with Chipotle Aioli, french fries and coleslaw$26.95Hot lobster Roll
Served with french fries and coleslaw$46.95New England Lobster Roll
Served with french fries and coleslaw$46.95Lobster Roll Combo
Half a Hot lobster Roll and half a New England style, served with french fries and coleslaw$46.95Shrimp Parmesan Sandwich
On a Seed Roll, served with french fries and coleslaw$26.95Angus Beef Burger
Served Lettuce and tomato, with french fries and coleslaw$16.95
All hours
| Sunday | 11:30 am - 8:30 pm |
| Monday | 11:30 am - 8:30 pm |
| Tuesday | 11:30 am - 8:30 pm |
| Wednesday | 11:30 am - 8:30 pm |
| Thursday | 11:30 am - 8:30 pm |
| Friday | 11:30 am - 8:30 pm |
| Saturday | 11:30 am - 8:30 pm |
Restaurant info
Out of the Blue Seafood is proud to offer the finest and freshest seafood in the Hamptons. We purchase from local baymen daily so we can provide our customers with all of their seasonal favorites, whether it is time for sea scallops, bay scallops, striped bass, flounder, tuna or monkfish.
Location
© 2026 Toast, Inc.
Made with 
in Boston
in Boston
