Skip to Main content
  • Pagliai's Pizza 509 South Illinois Avenue

    • Home
    • /
    • Carbondale
    • /
    • Pagliai's Pizza 509 South Illinois Avenue

    This restaurant does not have any images

    Pizza

    Pagliai's Pizza 509 South Illinois Avenue

    509 South Illinois Avenue

    Carbondale, IL 62901


    Orders through Toast are commission free and go directly to this restaurant


    Call

    Hours

    Directions

    Gift Cards

    Pizzas
    Full Menu
    Lunch Specials
    Thursday Specials
    Drinks Menu
    Catering Menu
    ‌
    ‌

    Pizzas

    BUILD YOUR OWN

    • SMALL

      $10.50
    • MEDIUM

      $15.50
    • LARGE

      $17.00

    SMALL SPECIALTY

    • SM BIG RED

      $18.00
    • SM CHICKEN FAJITA

      $18.00
    • SM CHICKEN RANCH

      $16.75
    • SM EVERYTHING

      $25.35
    • SM HOUSE

      $16.00
    • SM JOE'S

      $16.65
    • SM LIL' RED

      $17.00
    • SM MEATFEST

      $17.00
    • SM PAGLIAI'S

      $16.65
    • SM SIGNATURE PEPPERONI

      $17.00
    • SM BBQ CHICKEN

      $14.50
    • SM Veg #2

      $14.90
    • SM VEGGIE

      $16.00

    MEDIUM SPECIALTY

    • MED BIG RED

      $23.00
    • MED CHICKEN FAJITA

      $23.00
    • MED CHICKEN RANCH

      $22.00
    • MED EVERYTHING

      $31.65
    • MED HOUSE

      $19.00
    • MED JOE'S

      $21.75
    • MED LIL' RED

      $22.00
    • MED MEATFEST

      $22.00
    • MED PAGLIAI'S

      $21.75
    • MED SIGNATURE PEPPERONI

      $22.00
    • MED BBQ CHICKEN

      $19.50
    • MED Veg #2

      $19.75
    • MED VEGGIE

      $19.00

    LARGE SPECIALTY

    • LG BIG RED

      $26.00
    • LG CHICKEN FAJITA

      $26.00
    • LG CHICKEN RANCH

      $26.00
    • LG EVERYTHING

      $37.25
    • LG HOUSE

      $22.00
    • LG JOE'S

      $24.85
    • LG LIL' RED

      $25.00
    • LG MEATFEST

      $27.00
    • LG PAGLIAI'S

      $26.75
    • LG SIGNATURE PEPPERONI

      $25.00
    • LG BBQ CHICKEN

      $22.50
    • LG Veg#2

      $22.60
    • LG VEGGIE

      $22.00

    SLICE / SPECIAL

    • SLICE

      $5.00

    Full Menu

    APPETIZERS

    • BREADSTICKS (2 with sauce)

      $3.00
    • GARLIC BREAD

      $3.50
    • 12" GARLIC CHEESE STICKS

      $15.95
    • 14” GARLIC CHEESE STICKS

      $19.95
    • HOTN SPICY WINGS HALF

      $9.75
    • HOT N SPICY WINGS FULL

      $18.25
    • Cheese Bread

      $5.00

    PASTA

    • SMALL SPAGHETTI

      Pagliai's Homemade Bolognese Meat Sauce, or Zesty House Marinara Over Al Dente Pasta
      $8.95
    • LARGE SPAGHETTI

      Pagliai's Homemade Bolognese Meat Sauce, or Zesty House Marinara Over Al Dente Pasta
      $11.50
    • spaghetti Dinner small

      $12.75
    • Spaghetti Dinner Full

      $15.95
    • SMALL MOSTACCIOLI

      Pagliai's Homemade Bolognese Meat Sauce, or Zesty House Marinara Over Al Dente Pasta
      $8.95
    • LARGE MOSTACCIOLI

      Pagliai's Homemade Bolognese Meat Sauce, or Zesty House Marinara Over Al Dente Pasta
      $11.50
    • SMALL FETTUCCINE ALFREDO

      Al Dente Fettuccine Pasta in Pag's Rich Creamy House Alfredo
      $10.15
    • LARGE FETTUCCINE ALFREDO

      Al Dente Fettuccine Pasta in Pag's Rich Creamy House Alfredo
      $11.75
    • DINNER 1/2 FETT ALF

      Pagliai's Homemade Bolognese Meat Sauce, Ricotta, Mozzarella & Penne Pasta
      $12.75
    • DINNER FULL FETT ALF

      Pagliai's Homemade Bolognese Meat Sauce, Ricotta, Mozzarella & Penne Pasta
      $15.95
    • Half Primavera

      $9.00
    • Full Primavera

      $11.85
    • Dinner Half Primavera

      $12.75
    • Dinner Full Primavera

      $15.95
    • SMALL CHICKEN FETTUCCINE ALFREDO

      Al Dente Fettuccine Pasta in Pag's Rich Creamy House Alfredo, with Grilled Chicken
      $11.15
    • large chicken alfredo

      $12.75
    • DINNER HALF CKN FET

      $13.75
    • DINNER FULL CKN FETT

      Al Dente Fettuccine Pasta in Pag's Rich Creamy House Alfredo, with Grilled Chicken
      $15.95
    • LASAGNA

      $13.75
    • LASAGNA DINNER

      $16.75
    • MANICOTTI

      Ricotta, Grana Padano, Sardinian Pecorino, and Parmesan Stuffed Shells, with Choice of Sauce
      $12.45
    • MANICOTTI DINNER

      $16.45

    SANDWICHES

    • HAM N' CHEESE

      1/2 Pound Smoky Ham, Provolone & Mozzarella, Zesty Dijon Mustard on the side
      $9.99
    • ITALIAN BEEF

      1/2 Pound of Chicago Style Italian Beef on a Turano Roll, with Au Jus & Mild or Hot Giardiniera
      $10.99
    • MEATBALL SANDWICH

      4 Hearty Meatballs (1/2 pound) on a Turano Roll with Zesty House Marinara
      $9.99
    • POOR BOY

      $10.00
    • VEGGIE SANDWICH

      Mushroom, Onion, Black Olive, Green Pepper, Tomato and Provolone
      $9.99

    SALADS

    • DINNER SALAD

      $5.00
    • ITALIAN CHEF SALAD

      Salami, Pepperoni, Tomato, Red Onion, Black Olive, Banana Peppers & Mozzarella
      $10.00
    • VEGGIE SALAD

      Roma Tomato, Cucumber, Red Onion, Green Pepper, Banana Pepper, Black Olive
      $9.00

    SIDES

    • ALFREDO SAUCE

      $1.50
    • ANCHOVIES

      $2.00
    • BANANA PEPPER

      $1.50
    • DRESSINGS

      $1.50
    • GREEN PEPPER

      $1.50
    • JALAPENO

      $1.50
    • MARINARA

      $1.50
    • MEAT SAUCE

      $1.50
    • ONION

      $1.50
    • PEPPERONCINI

      $1.50
    • PIZZA SAUCE

      $1.50
    • TWO MEATBALLS

      $4.00
    • PAGS SWEET VIN BOTTLE

      $6.95
    • CHIPS

      $1.50
    • MILD GIARDINIERA

      $1.50
    • HOT GIARDINIERA

      $1.50
    • OLIVE TAPENADE

      $1.50

    DESSERT

    • NEW YORK CHEESECAKE

      $9.20
    • TIRAMISU

      $10.25
    • Carrot Cake

      $6.79

    Lunch Specials

    • Cheese Lunch Pizza Slice, Salad & Soda Lunch

      $9.99
    • Pepperoni Lunch Pizza Slice, Salad & Soda Lunch

      $9.99
    • Sausage Lunch Pizza Slice, Salad & Soda Lunch

      $9.99
    • Spinach Garlic Lunch Pizza Slice, Salad & Soda Lunch

      $9.99
    • Specialty Lunch Pizza Slice, Salad & Soda Lunch

      $9.99

    Thursday Specials

    BUCKET THURSDAY

    • BUCKET THURSDAY

      $10.00

    Drinks Menu

    Beverages

    • 2 Liter Bottled Soda

      Nothing like a cold soda to go with your pizza
      $3.99
    • 20 Oz. Bottled Soda

      Nothing like a cold soda to go with your pizza
      $2.50
    • COFFEE

      $3.00
    • HOT COCOA

      $3.10
    • Large soda

      $3.50
    • Small Soda

      Nothing like a cold soda to go with your pizza
      $2.75
    • Soda Pitcher (No Refills)

      $7.45

    Draft Beer

    • 8oz Coors Light

      $3.00
    • 16oz Coors Light

      $5.00
    • Pitcher Coors Light

      $15.00
    • 8oz Blue Moon

      $4.00
    • 16oz Blue Moon

      $6.00
    • Pitcher Blue Moon

      $19.00
    • 8oz Stella Artois

      $4.00
    • 16oz Stella Artois

      $6.00
    • Pitcher Stella Artois

      $19.00
    • 8oz Yuengling

      $3.00
    • 16oz Yuengling

      $6.00
    • Pitcher Yuengling

      $15.00
    • 8oz Bush Light

      $3.00
    • 16oz Bush lite

      $5.00
    • Pitcher Bush Light

      $15.00
    • 8oz Michelob Ultra

      $3.00
    • 16oz Michelob Ultra

      $6.00
    • Pitcher Michelob Ultra

      $19.00
    • 8oz Amber Bock

      OUT OF STOCK
      $3.00
    • 16oz Amber Bock

      OUT OF STOCK
      $5.00

    Bottled & Canned Beer

    • Bud Light

      $4.00
    • Budweiser

      $4.00
    • Corona

      $5.00
    • Dunkeldog

      $6.00
    • Bottle Galaxy IPA

      OUT OF STOCK
      $6.00
    • High Life

      $3.00
    • Michelob Ultra

      $5.00
    • Miller Lite

      $4.00
    • Modelo

      $5.00
    • PBR

      $3.00
    • Peroni

      $5.00
    • Can Galaxy IPA

      OUT OF STOCK
      $7.00
    • Yuengling Lager

      $4.00
    • Flight (Yuengling)

      $4.00
    • Bush lite

      $4.00

    Wine by the GLS

    • G - CABERNET HOUSE

      $6.00
    • G - CHARDONNAY HOUSE

      $6.00
    • G - MERLOT HOUSE

      $6.00
    • G - MOSCATO HOUSE

      $6.00
    • G - PINOT GRIGIOT HOUSE

      $6.00
    • G - WHITE ZIN HOUSE

      $6.00
    • G - GRAFTON VIGNOLES

      $7.00
    • G - TORRE BRUNA SANGIOVESE

      $8.00
    • G - CONCORD BLUE SKY

      $8.00
    • G - ROCKY COMFORT BLUE SKY

      $8.00
    • G - UNO PIEMONTE

      $9.00
    • G - HEARTLAND BLUSH (ALTO PASS)

      $9.00
    • G - BLACK AND BLUE (PHEASANT HOLLOW)

      $9.00
    • G - THREADCOUNT CABERNET

      $10.00
    • G - PASO ROBLES CHARDONNAY

      $10.00
    • G - ARGIANA TOSCANA ROSSO

      $11.00
    • G - DAVINCI CHIANTI

      $12.00

    Wine by the BTL

    • B - GRAFTON VIGNOLES

      $25.00
    • B - CONCORD BLUE SKY

      $28.00
    • B - ROCKY COMFORT BLUE SKY

      $28.00
    • B - TORREBRUNA SANGIOVESE

      $28.00
    • B - UNO PIEMONTE

      $32.00
    • B - BLACK AND BLUE PHEASANT HOLLOW

      $32.00
    • B - THREADCOUNT CABERNET

      $42.00
    • B - PASO ROBLES CHARDONNAY

      $42.00
    • B - ARGIANA TUSCANA ROSSO

      $48.00
    • B - DAVINCI CHIANTI

      $55.00

    Catering Menu

    CATERING

    • SALAD W/ 2 DRESSINGS

      $45.00
    • SPECIALTY SALAD- CATERING

      OUT OF STOCK
      $95.00
    • HALF SALAD- CATERING

      OUT OF STOCK
      $22.00
    • EXTRA DRESSING BOWL

      $6.95
    • GARLIC BREAD*

      $1.25
    • SPAGHETTI

      $69.50
    • MOSTACCIOLI

      $69.50
    • FETTUCINI- CATERING

      $72.50
    • CHICKEN ALFREDO- CATERING

      $104.50
    • BAKED PENNE - CATERING

      OUT OF STOCK
      $81.50
    • MANICOTTI/LASAGNA- CATERING

      $113.50
    • VEAL FLORENTINE- CATERING

      OUT OF STOCK
      $113.50
    • SERVICEWARE

      $0.50
    • ROOM FEE

      $50.00

    All hours
    SundayClosed
    Monday11:00 am - 9:00 pm
    TuesdayClosed
    WednesdayClosed
    ThursdayClosed
    FridayClosed
    SaturdayClosed
    Restaurant info

    Come in and enjoy!

    Location

    509 South Illinois Avenue, Carbondale, IL 62901

    Directions


    Similar restaurants in your area

    Rip’s Brick Oven Pizzeria Rip’s Brick Oven Pizzeria
    View restaurantnext
    Walt's Pizza
    View restaurantnext
    Joe's Pizza & Pasta Pinckneyville
    View restaurantnext
    Pagliai's Pizza and Pasta
    View restaurantnext
    T-Ravs 3582 E Jackson Blvd
    View restaurantnext
    Galatis Ristorante 124 N Main St
    View restaurantnext
    Search similar restaurants
    © 2026 Toast, Inc.
    Toast
    • About Toast
    • For restaurants
    • Terms of Service
    • Privacy Statement
    • Do not sell my
      personal information
    Made with love in Boston
    • Instagram
    • X (formerly Twitter)
    • Facebook