Penny's
700 East Main Street
Lexington, KY 40502
Orders through Toast are commission free and go directly to this restaurant
Featured Items
Chicky Sal
Shady Lane Chicken Salad, made with dried cranberries & almonds on milk bread, developed especially for Penny's by Midway Bakery
$10.00Eggy Sal
Our egg salad is made with fresh parsley, red onions, and mustard. Our take on a classic favorite. Served on Midway Bakery milk bread.
$10.00Shady Lane Chicken Salad (Pint)
Take home some of our famous chicken salad to have on a sandwich, on a salad, or straight out of the container!
$15.00
Food
Sandwiches
Chicky Sal
Shady Lane Chicken Salad, made with dried cranberries & almonds on milk bread, developed especially for Penny's by Midway Bakery
$10.00Ham & Pim
Broadbent country ham and our house-made White Cheddar Pimento Spread on milk bread.
$12.00OUT OF STOCKEggy Sal
Our egg salad is made with fresh parsley, red onions, and mustard. Our take on a classic favorite. Served on Midway Bakery milk bread.
$10.00Classic Tuna Sal
Made with hard boiled egg, celery, and red onion. Served on Midway Bakery milk bread.
$10.00OUT OF STOCKTurkey & Ched
Oven roasted turkey breast with white cheddar and house made Pesto mayo. Served on Midway Bakery milk bread.
$10.00OUT OF STOCKThe BABz
$10.00Andy's Gal Wrap
Fried tofu with spicy peanut mayo, pickled carrot and jalapeño, and cilantro in a vegan wrap. Served with nuoc cham.
$11.00Greek Chicky Wrap
Sweet peppers, tomatoes, cucumber, crumbled feta, grilled marinated chicken, mint leaves and greens, with lemon and garden oregano vinaigrette.
$13.00
Salads
Penny's Garden
Local lettuces, shredded carrots, cabbage, cherry tomatoes, sliced radishes, cucumber, alfalfa sprouts with choice of pomegranate vinaigrette, smoked tomato ranch, or lemon tahini dressing.
$12.00OUT OF STOCKGreek Chicken Grain Bowl
Sweet peppers, tomatoes, cucumbers, feta, crumbled feta, bulgar and quinoa, toasted pumpkin seeds, green beans, marinated grilled chicken, mint leaves and greens. Served with Lemon Oregano Vinaigrette.
$13.00Chicky Chaat Salad
$13.00
Soup
Bakery
7 Layer Bar
Fresh from the Midway Bakery! Graham cracker crust with chocolate chips, butterscotch chips, coconut & pecans.
$5.00OUT OF STOCKBrownie Bar
Fresh from the Midway Bakery! Dense and rich, topped with chocolate ganache (aka "The Danger Brownie").
$5.00Lemon Bar
Fresh from the Midway Bakery! Made with lemon juice and zest and a rich, buttery crust.
$5.00Chocolate Chip Cookie
Fresh from the Midway Bakery, this classic is the perfect midday treat!
$4.00Corn Cookie
Fresh from the Midway Bakery, our corn cookie magically taste like buttery corn on the cob, thanks to a healthy helping of Weisenberger Mill cornmeal from just down the road.
$4.00Peanut Butter Cookie
Fresh from the Midway Bakery, this cookie will satisfy all your peanut-buttery cravings!
$4.00Sorghum Cookie
Fresh from the Midway Bakery. An old family recipe from local cookbook author Rona Roberts and her mother, made with Country Rock sorghum, boiled down every autumn by Randal Rock on his Woodford County farm.
$4.00OUT OF STOCKOatmeal Raisin Cookie
$4.00
Retail
Benedictine
A Kentucky cucumber spread, perfect for tea sandwiches or with crudites. Take some home today!
$8.00Egg Salad (Half Pint)
$8.00Shady Lane Chicken Salad (Half Pint)
$8.00Shady Lane Chicken Salad (Pint)
Take home some of our famous chicken salad to have on a sandwich, on a salad, or straight out of the container!
$15.00White Cheddar Pimento Spread
Our house-made Pimento Spread is delicious on crackers, crudites, sandwiches, or pretzels. Take some home today!
$8.00Palm Size Pide
Fresh from the Midway Bakery, these crispy yeast risen flat bread crackers are perfect for dipping in our house made spreads!
$4.00Sea Salt Kettle Chips
$3.00Curry Potato Salad
$4.00
Boxes
Loaded Hummus Nibbler
Local veggies served with 100% chickpea hummus, topped with rotating house made garnishes.
$10.00Classic Protein Power Nibbler
Rolled roast turkey with garden Pesto, hard boiled egg with roasted red pepper romesco (*contains peanuts*), Tillamook sharp white cheddar-stuffed gordal olives
$10.00Bluegrass Nibbler
$12.00
Drinks
Cold Drinks
Elixir Kombucha
Made right up the road in Louisville, KY. Revel in the magic of Elixir Kombucha - where flavor and wellbeing unite. Available in either Blueberry Pomegranate or Lavender Lemonade.
$6.00Natalie's Lemonade
Refresh with Natalie's fresh-press lemonade, available in classic or strawberry.
$4.00Frothy Cold Brew
Frothy Monkey cold brew coffee is natural, sugar-free, low calorie, and plant-based, making it vegan, vegetarian, keto, and paleo-friendly.
$6.00Phocus
Refresh your taste buds with this caffeinated sparkling water that enhances clarity and drives focus. Available in Blood Orange, Lemon Lime, or Mixed Berry.
$4.00Coca Cola Product
Always cold and in a can! Choose from Regular Coke, Diet Coke, or Sprite.
$2.00
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | 11:00 am - 5:30 pm |
| Wednesday | 11:00 am - 5:30 pm |
| Thursday | 11:00 am - 5:30 pm |
| Friday | 11:00 am - 5:30 pm |
| Saturday | 11:00 am - 5:30 pm |
Intentionally intensely local bites for now, for later, for any time — always fresh. In the Pomegranate courtyard for patio dining and to go orders!
in Boston
