Skip to Main content
  • PepperBoy Pizza at Benny's

    • Home
    • /
    • New Ulm
    • /
    • PepperBoy Pizza at Benny's
    Restaurant banner image
    Pizza

    PepperBoy Pizza at Benny's

    126 North Minnesota Street

    New Ulm, MN 56073


    Orders through Toast are commission free and go directly to this restaurant


    Call

    Hours

    Directions

    Gift Cards

    Appetizers
    Salads
    Pizza Build Your Own
    Specialty Pizzas (NO SUBS OR ADD-ONS)
    Desserts
    Pickup Only
    ‌
    ‌

    Featured Items

    • Pizza build your own

      Wood-fired cheese pizza with red sauce and your choice of up to 5 toppings
      $13.95
    • 3 Little Pigs

      Red Sauce, mozzarella, sausage, bacon, and Canadian bacon
      $17.95
    • Pig in the Garden

      Red sauce, mozzarella, Italian sausage, bruschetta tomatoes, green olives, onion, mushrooms and roasted red peppers
      $17.95

    Appetizers

    • Balls in a cup *

      5 homemade meatballs served in a cup with your choice of sauce
      $5.00
    • Chicken Leg

      $3.00
    • Spinach Artichoke Dip

      Pepperboy world famous blend of cream cheese, cheeses, artichokes, spices, and spinach served with PepperBoy Spent Grain crisps
      $10.95
    • Trio of Spreads

      Spinach Artichoke, Chipotle whipped feta spread and House made Boursin Spread, served with PepperBoy spent grain crisps
      $10.95

    Salads

    • Greek Salad

      Romaine and cabbage greens with kalamata olives, onions, pepperoncinis, feta cheese, tomatoes and a light vinaigrette
      $9.95
    • Meaty Greek salad

      Romaine and cabbage greens with kalamata olives, pepperoncinis, onions, feta cheese, tomatoes, salami, bacon, pepperoni and a light vinaigrette
      $10.95
    • Beet and Blueberry Salad

      Blend of romaine and cabbage tossed with blueberry chutney, roasted red beets , red peppers, onions, mushrooms, mixed nuts and accented with a honey/whole grain mustard sauce
      $10.95
    • Topher Tibits Salad N Fun

      Todays feature- Israeli cous cous, steeped in hot curry and honey, blended with cauliflower, broccoli, cabbage and peppers, smoked Provolone and a sweet vinaigrette
      $9.95

    Pizza Build Your Own

    • Pizza build your own

      Wood-fired cheese pizza with red sauce and your choice of up to 5 toppings
      $13.95

    Specialty Pizzas (NO SUBS OR ADD-ONS)

    • Pig in the Garden

      Red sauce, mozzarella, Italian sausage, bruschetta tomatoes, green olives, onion, mushrooms and roasted red peppers
      $17.95
    • 3 Little Pigs

      Red Sauce, mozzarella, sausage, bacon, and Canadian bacon
      $17.95
    • Chix Bacon Bruschetta

      White sauce, mozzarella, roasted chicken, bacon, bruschetta tomatoes topped with Parmesan cheese
      $17.95
    • Sicilian

      Red sauce, mozzarella, roasted red peppers, Kalamata Olives, onions, salami and pepperoni
      $17.95
    • Garden Pizza

      Red sauce, mozzarella, wood-fired bruschetta tomatoes, green olives, onion, mushrooms and roasted red peppers
      $16.95
    • German

      White mustard sauce, mozzarella, sausage, onion, cabbage, and sauerkraut
      $17.95
    • Greek

      Red sauce, mozzarella, feta cheese, roasted red peppers, onions and kalamatas olive, pepperoncinis
      $16.95
    • Hawaiian

      Walnut Sauce, mozzarella, Canadian bacon, roasted peppers, onions, pineapple chutney
      $17.95
    • Nutty Italian

      Walnut pesto, mozzarella, salami, roasted red peppers, pepperoni and onions
      $17.95
    • Pepperboy After Shift Pizza

      White Sauce, Black Pepper Eggs, Bacon, Sausage, Canadian Bacon, Onions, and Red Peppers lots of love!!
      OUT OF STOCK
      $17.95
    • Pickle Power

      Dill white sauce, Mozzarella cheese, dill pickles, and dill seasoning sprinkle
      $16.95
    • Pizza blueberry n beet

      White sauce, walnut pesto, mozzarella and blueberry chutney topped with roasted red and yellow beets, mushroom, onion and peppers drizzled with mustard creme
      $17.95
    • Sinfully Simple Onion

      True to the Italian mantra of 5 ingredients or less--crust, olive oil, tomato sauce, mozzarella and onions
      $16.95

    Desserts

    • Turtle Cheesecake

      OUT OF STOCK
      $7.00
    • chocolate Flourless Torte

      $8.00

    All hours
    SundayClosed
    MondayClosed
    Tuesday4:00 pm - 8:45 pm
    Wednesday4:00 pm - 8:45 pm
    Thursday4:00 pm - 8:45 pm
    Friday4:00 pm - 8:45 pm
    Saturday11:00 am - 8:45 pm
    Restaurant info

    https://www.toasttab.com/pepperboy-pizza-new-ulm-5-s-valley-street/rewardsSignup

    Location

    126 North Minnesota Street, New Ulm, MN 56073

    Directions


    Similar restaurants in your area

    Dino's Pizzeria
    View restaurantnext
    KAVO Italian Eatery
    View restaurantnext
    Jake's Stadium Pizza - Mankato
    View restaurantnext
    Legends Bar & Grill Mankato CI&S/Legends Mankato
    View restaurantnext
    The Lucky Lure Madison Lake
    View restaurantnext
    The Orange Door 301 Main Street North
    View restaurantnext
    Search similar restaurants
    © 2026 Toast, Inc.
    Toast
    • About Toast
    • For restaurants
    • Terms of Service
    • Privacy Statement
    • Do not sell my
      personal information
    Made with love in Boston
    • Instagram
    • X (formerly Twitter)
    • Facebook