Skip to Main content
  • Peter Pan Diner

    • Home
    • /
    • Bay Shore
    • /
    • Peter Pan Diner
    Restaurant banner image
    American

    Peter Pan Diner

    999 Sunrise Highway

    Bay Shore, NY 11706


    Orders through Toast are commission free and go directly to this restaurant


    Call

    Hours

    Directions

    Gift Cards

    DESSERT / ICE CREAM
    BREAKFAST
    BURGERS / HOT DOGS
    BETWEEN THE BREAD
    WRAPS / PANINIS / QUESADILLAS

    DESSERT / ICE CREAM

    Desserts

    • Affogato

      Vanilla ice cream meets espresso, pure bliss.
      $7.99
    • Apple Pie

      $6.99
    • Apple Pie À La Mode

      $9.99
    • Assorted Layer Cakes

      $7.49
    • Banana Split

      3 scoops ice cream, choice of 3 toppings.
      $14.99
    • Biscoff Shake

      Vanilla ice cream, Biscoff cookie butter, Biscoff cookie rim, topped with a Biscoff cookie.
      $9.99
    • Black and White Cookie

      $4.75
    • Brooklyn Egg Cream

      $4.99
    • Brownie

      $5.99
    • Brownie Sundae

      2 scoops ice cream, brownie, walnuts, whipped cream, chocolate drizzle.
      $11.99
    • Café Nutella Freeze

      A silky, cold brew milkshake blended with rich Nutella and creamy vanilla ice cream for a smooth, chocolate coffee rush. Irresistibly indulgent with a cool café-style finish.
      $9.99
    • Carrot Cake

      $7.49
    • Chocolate Pudding

      $5.49
    • Classic Favorite Milkshakes

      Choice of flavor.
      $8.15
    • Cookies N Cream-A-Licious Shake

      Oreo ice cream and crumble rim, topped with whipped cream and Oreo cookies.
      $9.99
    • Creamsicle

      Vanilla ice cream and orange soda.
      $6.99
    • Creamy Cheesecake

      $8.49
    • Creamy Rice Pudding

      $5.49
    • Creamy Strawberry Cheesecake

      $9.49
    • Frozen Hot Chocolate

      Topped with whipped cream and chocolate shavings.
      $8.15
    • Ice Cream (Double Scoop)

      Vanilla, chocolate, strawberry, mint chocolate chip, cookies n’ cream, moose tracks, sherbet, sugar free.
      $6.49
    • Ice Cream (Single Scoop)

      Vanilla, chocolate, strawberry, mint chocolate chip, cookies n’ cream, moose tracks, sherbet, sugar free.
      $4.49
    • Jumbo Cookie

      $4.49
    • Klondike Avalanche

      A towering vanilla-chocolate milkshake served in a glass with a crushed Oreo cookie rim, drenched in rich chocolate and caramel, crowned with whipped cream, crunchy chocolate chips, and a full Klondike bar on top. Cold, creamy, and outrageously indulgent; this one is an avalanche of pure chocolate bliss.
      $13.75
    • Lemon Meringue

      $7.49
    • Mini Cake

      $10.49
    • Minty Chocolate Chip Shake

      Mint chip ice cream topped with whipped cream and chocolate chips.
      $9.99
    • Moose Tracks Shake

      Moose Track ice cream swirled with chocolate syrup peanut butter, topped with whipped cream and peanut butter chips.
      $9.99
    • Old Fashioned Root Beer Float

      Choice of ice cream.
      $6.99
    • Strawberry Dream Shake

      A creamy strawberry milkshake made with strawberry ice cream, topped with whipped cream, juicy strawberries, and a classic strawberry shortcake ice cream bar.
      $13.75
    • Strawberry Shortcake Sundae

      2 scoops vanilla ice cream on top of buttery pound cake, strawberry sauce and whipped cream.
      $11.99
    • Sundae Your Way

      2 scoops ice cream, choice of 2 toppings.
      $11.99
    • Tartuffo

      Vanilla, Chcolate & Strawberry ice cream with a cherry center covered with a hard chocolate shell.
      $6.99
    • The Candy Explosion

      A classic banana split taken to the extreme — banana, three scoops of ice cream layered with chocolate syrup, caramel, piled high with chopped Snickers, Twix, Reese's, and M&M's, finished with whipped cream and cherries. Sweet, crunchy, chocolatey, and completely over the top.
      $15.99
    • The Cookie Tower Shake

      A thick, cookies n cream milkshake served in a chocolate sprinkle rimmed glass, layered with chocolate syrup, topped with a mountain of whipped cream and an ice-cream sandwich. Creamy, crunchy, and stacked sky-high with classic chocolate-vanilla goodness.
      $13.75
    • Toasted Almond

      $7.99
    • Triamisu

      $7.99

    BREAKFAST

    Sandwiches & Wraps

    • One Egg & Cheese Sandwich

      One Egg, American Cheese on a Club Roll
      $7.20
    • One Egg On A Kaiser Roll

      One Egg on a Club Roll
      $6.15
    • Breakfast Wrap up to 3 Items

      Your choice of three ingredients with three scrambled eggs. Served with your choice of side.
      $18.85

    Omelets

    • Greek Omelet

      Herbs, Feta Cheese, Onions and Spinach. Served with toast and your choice of side.
      $18.55
    • Western Omelet

      Ham, Peppers and Onions. Served with toast and your choice of side.
      $18.55
    • Farmer's Omelet

      Bacon, Ham, Mushrooms and Sausage. Served with toast and your choice of side.
      $18.55
    • Veggie Omelet

      Spinach, Mushrooms, Onions, Broccoli, Roasted Roma Tomatoes. Served with toast and your choice of side.
      $18.55
    • Avocado Omelet

      Bacon, Roasted Roma Tomatos and Pepper Jack. Served with toast and your choice of side.
      $18.55
    • Turkey Avocado Fusion Omelet

      Turkey, Avocado, Roasted Roma Tomatoes,Spinach and Swiss Cheese. Served with toast and your choice of side.
      $18.55
    • Mexican Omelet

      Chili, Cheddar Cheese and Sour Cream. Served with salsa, toast and your choice of side.
      $18.55

    Pancakes

    • Baked Apple And Cinnamon Swirl Pancakes

      $17.50
    • Banana Walnut And Caramel Sauce Pancakes

      $17.50
    • Blueberry And Almond Pancakes

      Topped with whipped cream.
      $17.50
    • Chocolate Chip Pancakes

      $17.50
    • Classic Pan Stack Pancakes

      $13.40
    • Oreo And Nutella Pancakes

      $17.50
    • Peanut Butter Pancakes

      $17.50
    • Short Stack Pancakes

      $10.30
    • The Big Stack Show Pancakes

      Fresh Strawberries, Banana and Bluberries
      $17.50

    French Toast & Waffles

    • Belgian Waffle

      A golden, crisp on the outside, light-and-fluffy on the inside Belgian Waffle, made fresh to order
      $13.40
    • Belgian Waffle Topped With Fresh Fruit

      A golden, crisp on the outside, light-and-fluffy on the inside Belgian waffle, made fresh to order. Topped with fresh fruit.
      $17.50
    • Chicken & Waffles

      Golden, crispy Fried Chicken tenders served over a warm, fluffy Belgian Waffle.
      $21.10
    • French Toast Bites

      Topped with Strawberries, Bluberries, Bananas and Nutella,
      $16.95
    • French Toast With Fruit

      Challah Bread french toast topped with Strawberry, Banana and Blueberries
      $17.00
    • Peter Pan Original French Toast

      Made with Challah Bread
      $15.95

    BURGERS / HOT DOGS

    Burgers

    • Cali Burger

      8oz Beef Burger topped with Smached Avocado, Bacon and Melted Swiss Cheese served on a Toasted Brioche Bun with Fries. Alternate burger options: 6oz. Turkey, Veggie, Black Bean Chipotle and Double Smashed
      $20.60
    • Call My Doctor Burger

      8 oz Beef Burger smothered with Blue Cheese, Sauteed Onions and Bacon on a Toasted Brioche Bun with Fries. Alternate burger options: 6oz. Turkey, Veggie, Black Bean Chipotle and Double Smashed
      $20.60
    • Cubano Burger

      8oz Beef Burger with Jack Daniels Pulled Pork, Diced Pineapple and Swiss Cheese served on a Toasted Brioche Bun with Fries. Alternate burger options: 6oz. Turkey, Veggie, Black Bean Chipotle and Double Smashed.
      $20.60
    • Jumbo Burger [No Fries]

      8oz Beef Burger on a Toasted Brioche Bun. Alternate burger options: 6oz. Turkey, Veggie, Black Bean Chipotle and Double Smashed
      $12.90
    • Jumbo Burger Deluxe

      8oz Beef Burger on a Toasted Brioche Bun, served with Fries Alternate burger options: 6oz. Turkey, Veggie, Black Bean Chipotle and Double Smashed
      $18.05
    • Loaded Double Smash Burger

      Two Smashed Patties, layered with Melted Cheese, Bacon, Shoestring Onions, Shredded Lettuce, Tomato and House Sauce, served on a Toasted Brioche Bun with Fries.
      $20.60
    • Lone Star Chili Cheeseburger

      8 oz Beef Burger loaded with Beef Chili and Cheddar Cheese on a Brioche Bun with Fries. 8oz Beef Burger on a Toasted Brioche Bun. Alternate burger options: 6oz. Turkey, Veggie, Black Bean Chipotle and Double Smashed
      $20.60
    • Patty Melt

      8 oz. Beef Burger smothered with Sautéed Onions, American Cheese and House Sauce on Grilled Rye Bread. 8oz Beef Burger on a Toasted Brioche Bun. Alternate burger options: 6oz. Turkey, Veggie, Black Bean Chipotle and Double Smashed
      $20.60
    • Peter Pan's Classic Sliders (4)

      Four classic sliders with sauteed Onions and American Cheese.
      $20.60
    • Pizza Burger

      8 oz. Beef Burger topped with Marinara Sauce and Melted Mozzarella Cheese, served on a Toasted Brioche Bun with Fries. Alternate burger options: 6oz. Turkey, Veggie, Black Bean Chipotle and Double Smashed
      $18.95
    • PPD House Burger

      8 oz. Beef Burger topped with Blue Cheese, Shoestring Onions and House Sauce on a toasted Brioche Bun with Fries. Alternate burger options: 6oz. Turkey, Veggie, Black Bean Chipotle and Double Smashed
      $20.60
    • Mexi Max Burger

      8 oz. Beef Burger topped with Pepper Jack Cheese, Guacamole, Bacon and Tomatoes on a toasted Brioche Bun with Fries. Alternate burger options: 6oz. Turkey, Veggie, Black Bean Chipotle and Double Smashed
      $20.60
    • The Unique Greek Burger

      8 oz. Beef Burger topped with Feta Cheese, Kalamata Olives, Tomato, spiced with Greek Oregano and Tzatziki Sauce on a Toasted Brioche Bun with Fries. Alternate burger options: 6oz. Turkey, Veggie, Black Bean Chipotle and Double Smashed
      $20.60

    Hot Dog Heaven

    • Classic Hot Dogs [2]

      Two classic Hot Dogs with your choice of toppings served with Fries.
      $10.30
    • Chili Cheese Dog

      Two Hot Dogs topped with homemade Chili and Melted Chedder Cheese.
      $11.35

    BETWEEN THE BREAD

    Sandwiches

    • BLT

      Bacon, Lettuce and Tomato on your choice of Bread served with Fries or Soup
      $13.40
    • Classic Reuben

      Corned Beef or Pastrami with Sauerkraut, melted Swiss, Thousand Island Dressing on grilled Rye Bread. Served with Potato Salad Served with Fries or Soup
      $20.60
    • Grilled Cheese

      Classic Grilled Cheese with your choice of bread and cheese, grilled to golden perfection served with Fries or Soup
      $12.35
    • Pear & Fig Formaggio Melt

      Creamy Gruyère Cheese, sweet sliced Pear, and rich Fig Jam layered between your choice of bread and grilled until golden brown with a perfectly crisp, buttery finish Served with Fries or Soup
      $16.50
    • Tuna Melt

      Tuna Salad served with melted American Cheese on your choice of bread served with Fries or Soup
      $15.45
    • Tuna Salad Sandwich

      Homemade Tuna Salad on your choice of bread served with Fries or Soup
      $14.45
    • Chicken Salad Sandwich

      Homemade Chicken Salad on your choice of bread served with Fries or Soup
      $14.45
    • Turkey Club Sandwich

      Turkey, Lettuce, Tomato, Bacon on your choice of bread served with Fries or Soup
      $19.60
    • Grilled Chicken Club Sandwich

      Grilled Chicken, Tomato, Lettuce and Bacon on your choice of bread served with Fries or Soup
      $19.60
    • Fried Crispy Chicken Sandwich

      Golden, crispy fried chicken breast topped with our signature sauce and served on a buttery Toasted Brioche Bun. Served with Fries or Soup
      $19.60
    • Texas Smoke Sandwich

      Fried Chicken, melted Chedder Cheese, Bacon, BBQ Sauce on a toasted Sourdough Bread served with Fries or Soup
      $20.60
    • Philly Cheesesteak

      Oven roasted Prime Rib, Onions and Peppers topped with Cheese Sauce Served with Fries or Soup
      $26.75
    • Steakhouse Sandwich

      Sliced Skirt Steak, grilled Onions and Peppers topped with Melted Provolone and Chimichurri Sauce on Garlic Bread Served with Fries or Soup
      $25.75
    • New Champ

      Sliced oven roasted Prime Rib with Chedder Cheese and Mushrooms on a Toasted Hero Served with Fries or Soup
      $25.75
    • Roast Beef Sandwich

      Roast Beef with Lettuce and Tomato Served with Fries or Soup
      $16.50
    • Hot Open Roast Beef

      Served with Fries or Soup
      $22.65
    • Hot Open Turkey

      Served with Fries or Soup
      $22.65
    • Long Islander Sandwich

      Fried Filet, Shredded Lettuce, Tomato, and Tarter Sauce on a Brioche Bun, served with Fries or Soup
      $22.65
    • Chili Melt Sandwich

      Chili, Chedder Cheese, Jalapenos on your choice of Bread served with Fries or Soup
      $14.45
    • Carving Board Sandwich

      Create your own sandwich served with Fries or Soup
      $15.50

    Souvlaki/Gyro

    • Souvlaki

      Served with Greek Salad and your choice of Rice, Fries or Soup
      $25.75
    • Chicken Souvlaki

      Served with Greek Salad and your choice of Rice, Fries or Soup
      $25.75
    • Gyro

      Served with a Greek Salad and Rice, Fries or Soup
      $19.60
    • Chicken Gryo

      Chicken Gyro served with Greek Salad and Rice, Fries or Soup
      $19.60

    WRAPS / PANINIS / QUESADILLAS

    Wraps

    • Brooklyn Bridge Pastrami Wrap

      Hot NY Style Pastrami, Swiss Cheese and Sauerkraut served with Fries or Soup
      $19.60
    • Buffalo Chicken Wrap

      Fried Chicken Strips Topped with Frank's Hot Sauce, Jack Blend Cheese, Lettuce, Tomato Served with Fries or Soup
      $19.60
    • Chicken, Avocado, BLT Wrap

      Served with Fries or Soup
      $19.60
    • Greek Salad Chicken Wrap

      Grilled chicken, Romaine Lettuce, Tomato, Cucumber, Red Onion, Kalamata Olives, Feta Cheese, Tzatziki and Greek Salad Dressing Served with Fries or Soup
      $19.60
    • Grilled Chicken Caesar Salad Wrap

      Grilled Chicken, Caesar Salad, Crouton served with Fries or Soup
      $19.60
    • Hot Honey Chicken Wrap

      Crispy Chicken, Cole Slaw, diced Bacon, Pickles and Hot Honey Served with Fries or Soup
      $19.60
    • Steakhouse Wrap

      Grilled Skirt Steak, Sauteed Onions & Peppers, melted Jack Cheese and Chipotle Aioli Served with Fries or Soup
      $21.80
    • Korean BBQ Steak Wrap

      Grilled Skirt Steak coated in a savory Korean BBQ Sauce, layered with Rice, Broccoli and Lettuce Served with Fries or Soup
      $20.75
    • Taco Wrap

      Beef or Turkey, Cheddar Cheese, Lettuce, Sour Cream and Tomato with Salsa on the Side. Served with Fries or Soup
      $19.60
    • Tom Turkey Wrap

      Roasted Turkey, Lettuce and Tomato Served with Fries or Soup
      $18.55
    • Gobble Gobble Wrap

      Roast Turkey and Stuffing Served with Fries or Soup
      $18.00
    • Mango Tango Wrap

      Grilled Chicken, Lettuce, Mandarin Oranges, Pineapple, Red Pepper Served with Fries or Soup
      $19.60

    Paninis

    • Ham And Cheddar Melt Panini

      Honey Maple Ham, Sharp Cheddar Cheese, Tomato, Pickle slices, Honey Dijon Mustard Served with Fries or Soup
      $20.35
    • Peter Pan Panini

      Grilled Chicken, Mozzarella, Grilled Spinach and Roasted Red Peppers Served with Fries or Soup
      $20.35
    • Steak And Blue Pressed Panini

      Sliced Skirt Steak, Crispy Onions and Blue Cheese Served with Fries or Soup
      $23.65
    • Turkey Club Panini

      Roasted Turkey, Bacon, Cheddar Cheese, Roasted Red Peppers and Tomato Served with Fries or Soup
      $20.35
    • Veggie Panini

      Mushrooms, Mozzarella Cheese, Onion, Black Olives, Roasted Red Peppers and a Balsamic Glaze. Served with Fries or Soup
      $20.35

    Quesadillas

    • Chicken Quesadilla

      Grilled Chicken, Onions, Peppers and Jack Blend Cheese Served with Fries or Soup
      $22.65
    • Garden Of Eatin' Quesadilla

      Grilled fresh Spinach, Garlic, Tomatoes, Onions and Black Beans sautéed in Olive Oil with your choice of Cheese, Salsa and Sour Cream Served with Fries or Soup
      $22.65
    • Pork And Cheese Overload Quesadilla

      Creamy Mac & Cheese, Pulled Pork folded in a crispy Tortilla Served with Fries or Soup
      $22.65
    • Roman Holiday Quesadilla

      Grilled Shrimp, Garlic, Mozzarella Cheese, Olive Oil, Onions, Tomatoes Served with Fries or Soup
      $25.70
    • South Of The Border Quesadilla

      Chili, Beans, Fresh Spinach, Three Cheeses, Salsa and Sour Cream Served with Fries or Soup
      $20.60
    • Steak Quesadilla

      Skirt Steak, Jack Cheese, Fried Mushrooms, Onions Served with Fries or Soup
      $25.70

    All hours
    Sunday8:00 am - 9:45 pm
    Monday8:00 am - 9:45 pm
    Tuesday8:00 am - 9:45 pm
    Wednesday8:00 am - 9:45 pm
    Thursday8:00 am - 9:45 pm
    Friday8:00 am - 10:45 pm
    Saturday8:00 am - 10:45 pm
    Restaurant info

    Welcome Back to Peter Pan Diner For over 70 years, Peter Pan Diner has been a cherished part of the community. Today, we’re proud to welcome you back to a diner that has been thoughtfully rebuilt and reimagined. Honoring the classic traditions you’ve loved for generations while embracing fresh, modern flavors in a renewed, welcoming space. Our menu continues to celebrate the comfort, familiarity, and flavors that define Peter Pan. From morning to night, serving hearty breakfasts and made-to-order omelets, signature hamburgers, freshly crafted sandwiches, crisp salads, and delicious dinner entrées. Blending timeless favorites with contemporary touches. To our loyal guests, neighbors, and friends, thank you for your continued support and for welcoming us back. Whether you’re stopping in for a quick coffee, a family meal, or a late-night bite, Peter Pan Diner remains a place where comfort, connection, and good food come together. We look forward to serving you for many years to come.

    Location

    999 Sunrise Highway, Bay Shore, NY 11706

    Directions


    Similar restaurants in your area

    Brightwaters Inn
    View restaurantnext
    Brightwaters Village Deli
    View restaurantnext
    Exit 42 Bagel & Deli 270 Spur dr S
    View restaurantnext
    Khyber Grill & Gyro 270 Spur dr S Khyber
    View restaurantnext
    Roto
    View restaurantnext
    Le Dock
    View restaurantnext
    Search similar restaurants
    © 2026 Toast, Inc.
    Toast
    • About Toast
    • For restaurants
    • Terms of Service
    • Privacy Statement
    • Do not sell my
      personal information
    Made with love in Boston
    • Instagram
    • X (formerly Twitter)
    • Facebook