Skip to Main content

  • Peter Pan Diner

    • Home
    • /
    • Bay Shore
    • /
    • Peter Pan Diner
    Restaurant banner image
    American

    Peter Pan Diner

    999 Sunrise Hwy

    Bay Shore, NY 11706

    Orders through Toast are commission free and go directly to this restaurant

    Call

    Hours

    Directions

    Gift Cards

    DAILY SPECIALS - WEDNESDAY
    FOOD MENU

    Featured Items

    • Jumbo Burger Deluxe

      Your choice of patty served on a toasted bun with your Choice of French Fries, Onion Rings, Lettuce, Tomato, Coleslaw and a Pickle.
      $16.44

    • Our Famous Greek Salad

      Crisp Romaine Lettuce Topped with Feta Cheese, Cucumber, Grape Leaves, Greek Olives, Red Onion and Tomatoes with Greek Dressing
      $21.78

    • Matzoh Ball Soup

      Matzo Balls and Broth
      $7.50+

    DAILY SPECIALS - WEDNESDAY

    Soup of the Day

    • Mexican Fiesta

      $7.50+

    FOOD MENU

    Daily Soups

    • Chicken Noodle Soup

      $7.50+

    • French Onion Soup

      Served with Cheese and Bread
      $8.52+

    • Matzoh Ball Soup

      Matzo Balls and Broth
      $7.50+

    • Onion Soup

      $7.50+

    • Tomato Basil Soup

      $7.50+

    Bagels, Muffins & Toast

    • Bagel

      $3.11

    • Bagel w/Cream Cheese

      $5.15

    • Blueberry Muffin

      $3.23

    • Bran Muffin

      $3.23

    • Buttered Toast

      With your choice of Jelly or Marmalade.
      $2.63

    • Cinnamon Toast

      Your choice of bread.
      $3.71

    • Corn Muffin

      $3.23

    • Danish

      OUT OF STOCK
      $5.10

    • English Muffin

      $3.11

    • Hard Roll

      $2.87

    • Pizza Bagel

      $10.67

    Egg & Omelettes

    Served with Home Fries or French Fries and Toast.

    • Two Eggs

      Served with toast and your choice of side.
      $9.30

    • Steak & Two Eggs

      Served with toast and your choice of side.
      $9.30

    • Breakfast Quesadilla

      Jack Cheese, Onions, Peppers and Sausage in your Choice of Tortilla.
      $18.71

    • Cheese Omelette

      Your choice of Cheese. Served with toast and your choice of side.
      $15.54

    • CYO Breakfast Wrap

      Your choice of 3 ingredients with 3 scrambled eggs. Served with home fries, salsa and sour cream.
      $18.48

    • CYO Omelette 3 Items

      Your Choice of 3 Ingredients. Served with Home Fries or French Fries and Toast.
      $20.22

    • Egg Sandwich

      On your Choice of Bread

    • Eggs Benedict

      Poached Eggs and Canadian Bacon covered with Hollandaise Sauce on a buttered toasted English muffin. Served with your choice of side and fruit cup.
      $17.99

    • Farmer's Omelette

      Bacon, Ham, Mushrooms and Sausage. Served with toast and your choice of side.
      $15.96

    • Greek Omelette

      Herbs, Feta Cheese, Onions and Spinach. Served with toast and your choice of side.
      $17.46

    • Meat Omelette

      Your choice of Protein. Served with toast and your choice of side.
      $15.96

    • Mexican Omelette

      with Chili, Cheddar Cheese and Sour Cream. Served with toast and your choice of side.
      $17.58

    • Spanish Omelette

      Onions, Hot Peppers and Tomato Sauce. Served with toast and your choice of side.
      $14.82

    • Tomato & Feta Omelette

      Served with toast and your choice of side.
      $17.46

    • Western Omelette

      Ham, Peppers and Onions. Served with toast and your choice of side.
      $14.16

    Griddle Specialties

    Served with Butter and Syrup.

    • Belgian Waffle

      Served with Butter and Syrup.
      $12.66

    • French Toast

      Served with Butter and Syrup.
      $12.30

    • Short French Toast

      Served with Butter and Syrup.
      $10.26

    • French Toast Deluxe

      with One Egg, Bacon, Ham and Sausage. Served with Butter and Syrup.
      $20.34

    • Pancakes Deluxe

      with One Egg, Bacon, Ham and Sausage. Served with Butter and Syrup.
      $20.34

    • Peter Pancakes

      Choose from One of our Specialty Pancakes... Served with Butter and Syrup.
      $16.44

    • Short Peter Pancakes

      Choose from One of our Specialty Pancakes... Served with Butter and Syrup.
      $14.28

    • Traditional Pancakes

      Served with Butter and Syrup.
      $12.30

    • Short Stack Pancakes

      Served with Butter and Syrup.
      $10.26

    Appetizers

    • Baked Clams

      $16.20

    • Chicken Tenders

      $17.40

    • Chicken Wings

      $17.40

    • French Fries

      Choice of Regular Cut, Seasoned Curly, Seasoned Waffle, Steak or Sweet Potato.
      $9.36

    • Fried Calamari

      Served with Marinara Sauce.
      $20.22

    • Loaded Nachos

      Topped with your choice of Beef Chili or Chicken, Cheese, Tomatoes, Jalapeños and Olives.
      $18.96

    • Mozzarella Sticks

      Served with Marinara Sauce.
      $18.30

    • Onion Rings

      $9.36

    • Pepperoni Pizza Fries

      Pepperoni, Olive Oil and Pizza Sauce with your Choice of Fries.
      $14.16

    • Potato Skins

      Served with Jack Cheese Blend, Bacon & Sour Cream.
      $14.40

    • Spinach Pie

      $14.70

    • Stuffed Mushrooms

      $16.20

    Tantalizing Salads

    Served with Choice of Dressing.

    • Caesar Salad

      Crisp Romaine Lettuce, Croutons, Parmesan Cheese and Creamy Caesar Dressing.
      $18.35

    • Chef's Salad

      Assorted Greens with Ham, Roast Beef, Turkey, American & Swiss Cheese, Red Onion, Tomatoes, Cucumber, Olives and Hard Boiled Egg
      $27.36

    • Chicken Salad Platter

      Scoop of Chicken Salad, Coleslaw and Potato Salad Served over Assorted Greens with Cucumber, Olives, Red Onion, Tomatoes and Hard Boiled Egg. With your Choice of Dressing
      $18.78

    • Cobb Salad

      Assorted Greens with Chicken, Bacon, Avocado, Bleu Cheese Crumble, Red Onion, Tomatoes, Cucumber, Olives and Hard Boiled Egg with Bleu Cheese Dressing
      $27.36

    • Crispy Chicken Salad

      Assorted Greens with Fried Chicken Cutlet Strips, Bacon, Cheddar Cheese, Red Onion, Cucumber, Black Olives and Grape Tomatoes
      $25.98

    • Egg Salad Platter

      Scoop of Egg Salad, Coleslaw and Potato Salad Served over Assorted Greens with Cucumber, Olives, Red Onion and Tomatoes. With your Choice of Dressing
      $18.78

    • Fruiti-aki Salad

      Assorted Greens with Teriyaki Chicken, Mandarin Oranges, Strawberries, Blueberries, Grape Tomatoes, Pineapple Ring, Red Onion, Cucumber and Sliced Almonds with Raspberry Vinaigrette
      $25.98

    • Our Famous Greek Salad

      Crisp Romaine Lettuce Topped with Feta Cheese, Cucumber, Grape Leaves, Greek Olives, Red Onion and Tomatoes with Greek Dressing
      $21.78

    • Santa Fe Cajun Chicken Salad

      Assorted Greens with Grilled Cajun Chicken, Croutons, Cucumber, Jack Cheese Blend, Olives, Red Onion and Tomatoes with Guacamole, Sour Cream and Salsa as Dressing (3 Choices Only Included)
      $25.98

    • Spinach Salad

      Mushroom, Bacon, Hard Boiled Egg, Red Onion, Tomatoes, Cucumber, Olives over Baby Spinach Leaves.
      $22.32

    • Tossed Salad

      Assorted Green with Cucumber, Onion, Olives and Tomato. With your Choice of Dressing.
      $17.51

    • Tuna Salad Platter

      Scoop of Tuna Salad, Coleslaw and Potato Salad Served over Assorted Greens with Cucumber, Olives, Red Onion and Tomatoes. With your Choice of Dressing
      $20.15

    Grilled Cheese Sandwiches

    An Array of Grilled Cheese Sandwiches Served with Choice of: Cup of Soup or Choice of Fries.

    • Hot & Spicy Grilled Cheese

      Pepperoni, Hot Peppers, Grilled Onion with Pepper Jack Cheese.
      $16.62

    • Greek Grilled Cheese

      Greek Olives, Oregano, Hot Peppers, Diced Tomatoes with Feta Cheese & Swiss Cheese.
      $16.62

    • Mac & Cheese Grilled Cheese

      Macaroni & Cheese, Diced Bacon with Cheddar Cheese.
      $16.62

    • That's Italian Grilled Cheese

      Diced Tomato Bruschetta, Garlic Seasoning with Mozzarella.
      $16.62

    • Turkey Club Grilled Cheese

      Roast Turkey, Bacon, Pesto with Mozzarella.
      $16.62

    • Pizza Pepperoni Grilled Cheese

      Oregano, Pepperoni, Tomato Sauce with Mozzarella.
      $16.62

    • BLTC

      Bacon, Lettuce, Tomato with Cheddar Cheese.
      $16.62

    • Chili Cheddar Grilled Cheese

      Beef Chili, Jalapeños with Cheddar Cheese.
      $16.62

    • The Breakfast Cheese Scramble

      Scrambled Egg, Bacon and Diced Sausage with American Cheese.
      $16.62

    Paninis

    Our Special Panini Grill will Toast and Press your Sliced Italian Bread and Warm your Sandwich Ingredients. The Results are Delicious. Served with your Choice of Side.

    • Black Forest Ham Panini

      Honey Maple Ham, Cheddar Cheese and Tomato with Honey Mustard. Served with your Choice of Side.
      $21.36

    • Peter Pan Panini

      Grilled Chicken, Mozzarella, Grilled Spinach and Roasted Red Peppers. Served with your Choice of Side.
      $21.12

    • Turkey Club Panini

      Roasted Turkey, Bacon, Cheddar Cheese, Roasted Red Peppers and Tomato with your Choice of Dressing. Served with your Choice of Side.
      $21.24

    • Tuscany Panini

      Fried Eggplant, Mozzarella and Grilled Red Peppers Served with Balsamic Vinaigrette Dressing. Served with your Choice of Side.
      $21.36

    • Veggie Panini

      Mushrooms, Mozzarella Cheese, Onion, Black Olives, Roasted Red Peppers and a Balsamic Glaze. Served with your Choice of Side.
      $20.34

    Quesadillas

    Your Choice of Tortilla, Served with Salsa and Sour Cream.

    • Cheese Quesadilla

      Jack Blend Cheese. Served with Salsa and Sour Cream.
      $14.52

    • Chicken Quesadilla

      Grilled Chicken with Onions, Peppers and Jack Blend Cheese. Served with Salsa and Sour Cream.
      $20.34

    • Garden of Eatin'

      Grilled Fresh Spinach with Black Beans, Garlic, Onions and Tomatoes sautéed in Olive Oil and Jack Blend Cheese. Served with Salsa and Sour Cream.
      $21.12

    • Lo-Carb Grilled Chicken

      Grilled Chicken with Bacon, Mushrooms, Onions and Jack Blend Cheese on a Whole Wheat Tortilla. Served with Salsa and Sour Cream.
      $21.12

    • Lo-Carb Grilled Steak

      Grilled Steak with Bacon, Mushrooms, Onions and Jack Blend Cheese on a Whole Wheat Tortilla. Served with Salsa and Sour Cream.
      $25.50

    • Mediterranean Sunset

      Grilled Chicken sautéed with Artichoke Hearts, Mozzarella Cheese, Olive Oil, Roasted Red Peppers, Tomatoes. Served with Salsa and Sour Cream.
      $22.62

    • Roman Holiday Quesadilla

      Grilled Shrimp with Garlic, Mozzarella Cheese, Olive Oil, Onions, Tomatoes. Served with Salsa and Sour Cream.
      $24.78

    • South of the Border

      Beef Chili, Beans, Fresh Spinach, Tomatoes and Jack Blend Cheese. Served with Salsa and Sour Cream.
      $20.34

    • Steak Quesadilla

      Grilled Steak with Mushrooms, Onions and Jack Blend Cheese. Served with Salsa and Sour Cream.
      $24.78

    Triple Deckers

    With Lettuce and Tomato on your Choice of Bread with Coleslaw and Pickle. Served with Choice of Potato Salad or French Fries.

    • Chicken Salad & Bacon

      $20.34

    • Egg Salad & Bacon

      $20.34

    • Ham / Swiss & Bacon

      $20.34

    • Roast Beef & Bacon

      $20.34

    • Sliced Turkey & Bacon

      $20.34

    • Tuna Salad & Bacon

      $20.34

    • Tuna Salad / Sliced Eggs & Bacon

      $20.34

    Peter Pan Wraps

    Served with Cup of Soup or French Fries.

    • CYO Wrap

      Create Your Own Wrap
      $20.34

    • Beef Taco Wrap

      with Cheddar Cheese, Lettuce, Sour Cream and Tomato with Salsa on the Side.
      $20.46

    • Beef Teriyaki Wrap

      Beef Teriyaki with Grilled Vegetables
      $21.60

    • Black Bean Burrito Wrap

      Beans, Guacamole, Rice and Melted Cheddar Cheese.
      $18.36

    • Brooklyn Bridge Pastrami Wrap

      Hot NY Style Pastrami, Swiss Cheese and Sauerkraut
      $20.34

    • Buffalo Chicken Wrap

      Fried Chicken Strips Topped with Frank's Hot Sauce, Jack Blend Cheese, Lettuce, Tomato. Served with Bleu Cheese Dressing
      $20.22

    • Caesar Salad Wrap

      With Caesar Salad and Croutons
      $13.14

    • Chicken Caesar Salad Wrap

      With Caesar Salad and Croutons
      $20.34

    • Chicken Gyro Wrap

      Crisp Romaine Lettuce with Cucumber, Feta Cheese, Greek Olives, Red Onion and Tomatoes with Greek Dressing
      $18.83

    • Chicken Teriyaki Wrap

      Chicken Teriyaki with Grilled Vegetables
      $21.60

    • Cold Salad Wrap

      Your Choice of Egg, Chicken or Tuna Salad with Lettuce and Tomatoes.
      $19.07

    • Famous Tom Turkey Wrap

      Roast Turkey with Lettuce and Tomato
      $19.08

    • Gobble-Gobble Wrap

      Sliced Roast Turkey, Stuffing, Cranberry Sauce and Turkey Gravy
      $19.74

    • Greek Salad Chicken Wrap

      Crisp Romaine Lettuce with Cucumber, Feta Cheese, Greek Olives, Red Onion and Tomatoes with Greek Dressing
      $20.34

    • Greek Salad Wrap

      Crisp Romaine Lettuce with Cucumber, Feta Cheese, Greek Olives, Red Onion and Tomatoes with Greek Dressing
      $13.14

    • Gyro Wrap

      Crisp Romaine Lettuce with Cucumber, Feta Cheese, Greek Olives, Red Onion and Tomatoes with Greek Dressing
      $18.83

    • Mango Tango Wrap

      Grilled Chicken with Lettuce, Mandarin Oranges, Pineapple, Red Pepper,
      $20.34

    • New York Wrap

      Roast Beef with American Cheese and Coleslaw
      $20.34

    • Peter Pan Wrap

      Grilled Chicken with Basil Sauce, Lettuce and Tomato
      $19.86

    • The Grill Wrap

      Grilled Chicken with Lettuce, Feta Cheese, Red Peppers, Tomato and Honey Mustard
      $19.74

    • Turkey Taco Wrap

      with Cheddar Cheese, Lettuce, Sour Cream and Tomato with Salsa on the Side.
      $20.46

    Sandwich Classics

    on your Choice of Bread. Served with Coleslaw and Pickle.

    • BLT Sandwich

      Bacon, Lettuce and Tomatoes
      $11.94

    • Chicken Salad Sandwich

      With Lettuce
      $11.40

    • Corned Beef Sandwich

      $16.43

    • Egg Salad Sandwich

      With Lettuce
      $10.92

    • Grilled Cheese

      With your Choice of Cheese
      $10.32

    • Pastrami Sandwich

      $16.43

    • Roast Beef Sandwich

      $16.43

    • Tuna Salad Sandwich

      With Lettuce
      $11.88

    • Turkey Sandwich

      $16.43

    Specialty Sandwiches

    Served with Coleslaw and Pickle.

    • Chicken Salad Melt

      On your Choice of Bread, Topped with your Choice of Cheese. Served with Fries.
      $16.08

    • French Dip

      Roast Beef & Mozzarella Cheese on Garlic Bread. Served with your Choice of Fries.
      $21.96

    • Fried Filet of Sole Sandwich

      On your Choice of Bread with Lettuce, Tomato & Tartar Sauce. Served with your Choice of Fries.
      $22.55

    • Meatball Parmigiana Hero

      Served with your Choice of Soup or Fries.
      $18.36

    • Monte Cristo

      Ham, Turkey and Swiss Cheese on French Toast with Thousands Island Dressing on the Side. Served with Potato Salad or Fries.
      $21.36

    • Reuben

      With your Choice of Meat with tangy Sauerkraut on Grilled Rye Bread and melted Swiss Cheese. Served with Potato Salad or Fries.
      $20.34

    • Sliced London Broil Sandwich Deluxe

      on Garlic Bread with Lettuce & Tomatoes. Served with French Fries.
      $28.32

    • Texas Smoke

      Grilled or Fried Chicken with Cheddar Cheese and Bacon on toasted Sourdough Bread topped with our Smoke Flavored BBQ sauce. Served with Fries.
      $21.12

    • The New Champ

      Sliced oven Roasted Prime Rib with melted Cheddar Cheese and sautéed Mushrooms on a toasted Hero. Served with Fries.
      $21.96

    • Tuna Salad Melt

      On your Choice of Bread, Topped with your Choice of Cheese. Served with Fries.
      $16.08

    Specialty Chicken Sandwiches

    Served with French Fries, Coleslaw and Pickle.

    • Grilled Chicken Italian Style

      With Bacon and Mozzarella on a Roll with Lettuce & Tomato.
      $19.20

    • Grilled Chicken American Style

      With Ham and American Cheese on a Roll with Lettuce & Tomato.
      $19.20

    • Grilled Chicken Parmigiana Style

      Tomato Sauce and Mozzarella Cheese on a Roll with Lettuce & Tomato.
      $19.20

    • Chicken Sandwich Deluxe

      With your Choice of Two Toppings, On a Roll with Lettuce & Tomato.
      $20.70

    Greek Specialties

    • Chicken Gryo

      On Pita with Greek Salad and your Choice of Rice or French Fries.
      $23.28

    • Gyro

      On Pita with Greek Salad and your Choice of Rice or French Fries.
      $23.28

    • Chicken Souvlaki

      On Pita with Greek Salad and your Choice of Rice or French Fries.
      $23.40

    • Pork Souvlaki

      On Pita with Greek Salad and your Choice of Rice or French Fries.
      $23.40

    • Spinach Pie Dinner

      Served with Rice or Potato and Soup or Salad.
      $23.22

    Hot Open Sandwiches

    Served with Potato & Vegetable and Soup or Salad.

    • Hot Open Roast Beef

      with Beef Gravy. Served with Potato & Vegetable and Soup or Salad.
      $27.54

    • Hot Open Turkey

      with Turkey Gravy and Cranberry sauce. Served with Potato & Vegetable and Soup or Salad.
      $27.54

    Hot Dog Heaven

    Served with French Fries.

    • Classic Hot Dog (2)

      Two Hot Dogs with Choice of Toppings. Served with Fries.
      $10.08

    • Chili Cheese Dog (2)

      Topped with Homemade Beef Chili and Melted Cheddar Cheese. Served with French Fries.
      $11.94

    Burger Corner

    Served on a Toasted Bun with Coleslaw and Pickle. Burger Available in: 8 oz. 100% Pure Beef Burger, Turkey, Veggie or Black Bean Chipotle.

    • Jumbo Burger

      Your choice of patty served on a toasted bun with coleslaw and pickle.
      $11.64

    • Jumbo Burger Deluxe

      Your choice of patty served on a toasted bun with your Choice of French Fries, Onion Rings, Lettuce, Tomato, Coleslaw and a Pickle.
      $16.44

    • Pizza Burger

      Mozzarella Cheese and Marinara Sauce. Your choice of patty served on a toasted bun with coleslaw and pickle.
      $12.30

    • Pizza Burger Deluxe

      Mozzarella Cheese and Marinara Sauce. Your choice of patty served on a toasted bun with coleslaw and pickle.
      $17.10

    • Twin Burger Deluxe

      2 Burgers. Your choice of patty served on toasted buns. Served with French Fries, Onion Rings, Lettuce, Tomato, Coleslaw and Pickle
      $23.87

    Specialty Burgers

    Served on a Toasted Bun with Coleslaw and Pickle. Choice of: 8 oz. 100% Pure Beef Burger, Turkey Burger, Veggie or Black Bean Chipotle Burger. Choice of: Mashed Potatoes, Regular Cut Fries, Seasoned Curly Fries, Seasoned Waffle Fries, Steak Fries or Sweet Potato Fries.

    • Cali Burger

      Fresh Sliced Avocado, Bacon and Melted Swiss Cheese
      $19.19

    • Call My Doctor Burger

      Chunky Bleu Cheese with Bacon
      $19.19

    • Call the Fire Department Burger

      Hot Peppers, Pepper Jack Cheese and Sliced Ham. Served with Frank's Red Hot Sauce
      $19.19

    • Cowboy Burger

      BBQ Sauce, Bacon, Mushrooms, Fried Onions, Pepper Jack Cheese.
      $19.19

    • Cubano Burger

      Jack Daniels Pulled Pork, Diced Pineapple and Swiss Cheese.
      $19.19

    • Lone Star Chili Cheeseburger

      Loaded with Beef Chili and Cheddar Cheese. Served with Sour Cream and Salsa.
      $19.19

    • Patty Melt

      Served on Grilled Rye Bread, Smothered with Sautéed Onions, American Cheese and Russian Dressing
      $19.19

    • Peter Pan's Classic Sliders

      (4) Sliders on warm buns; with Grilled Onions
      $15.54

    • Siciliano Burger

      Fresh Grilled Spinach, Tomato Bruschetta, Mozzarella Cheese and a touch of Balsamic Glaze
      $19.19

    • The Mexi Max

      Bacon, Guacamole, Jalapeños, Pepper Jack Cheese and Tomatoes
      $19.19

    • The Unique Greek

      Feta Cheese, Kalamáta Olives and Plum Tomatoes all Spiced with Greek Oregano. Served with Homemade Tzatziki.
      $19.19

    Fajitas

    with Onions, Peppers, Tomatoes and Jack Blend Cheese.

    • Chicken Fajitas

      $21.42

    • Chicken & Steak Fajitas

      $29.99

    • Steak Fajitas

      $34.79

    • Shrimp Fajitas

      $34.79

    Specialty Dinners

    • BBQ Ribs & Chicken

      Served with Potato, Vegetable and Soup or Salad.
      $32.46

    • Beef & Reef

      Romanian Steak with Two Stuffed Shrimp, One Baked Clam and Onion Ring. Served with Potato, Vegetable and Soup or Salad.
      $48.84

    • Broiled Romanian Steak & Shrimp Scampi

      Served with Potato, Vegetable and Soup or Salad.
      $48.84

    • Broiled Shrimp Bruschetta

      Sautéed Garlic Shrimp with Onions, Tomatoes and Olive Oil over toasted Garlic Bread. Served with Potato and Soup or Salad.
      $32.39

    • Chicken Athenian

      Stuffed Chicken Breast with Spinach and Feta Cheese. Served with Potato and Vegetable and Choice of Soup or Salad.
      $39.54

    • Chicken ala Greco

      Broiled in Garlic Butter Sauce with Herbs, Fresh Green Peppers, Onions and Tomatoes Over Rice or Potato. Served with Vegetable and Soup or Salad.
      $36.48

    • Chicken Parmigiana

      Served over Spaghetti with Grape Tomatoes. Served with Soup or Salad
      $32.39

    • Fried Jumbo Shrimp Parmigiana

      Served over Spaghetti. Served with Soup or Salad
      $42.12

    • Broiled Salmon

      Garlic, Fresh Spinach and Grape Tomatoes Sautéed in Olive Oil. Served with Potato & Soup or Salad.
      $33.59

    • Key West

      Chicken Breast topped with Asparagus, Mozzarella Cheese and Scampi Sauce. Served with Potato & Soup or Salad.
      $38.76

    • Oriental Sesame Seed Chicken

      with Oriental Vegetables over Rice or Potato. Served with Soup or Salad.
      $36.24

    • Shrimp & Chicken Scampi

      Served with Potato & Vegetable and Soup or Salad.
      $40.62

    • Sliced Teriyaki Steak

      with Oriental Vegetables over Rice or Potato with Garlic Bread. Served with Soup or Salad.
      $32.70

    • Teriyaki Combo

      Beef, Chicken and Shrimp with Oriental Vegetables over Rice or Potato, Served with Soup or Salad.
      $42.54

    Dinner Entrees

    Served with Soup or Salad, Potato and Vegetable.

    • Broiled Lamb Chops

      Served with Potato & Vegetable and Soup or Salad.
      OUT OF STOCK
      $42.66

    • Broiled Pork Chops

      with Applesauce. Served with Potato & Vegetable and Soup or Salad.
      $35.70

    • Broiled Romanian Steak

      Served with Potato & Vegetable and Soup or Salad.
      $44.03

    • Fried Chicken in a Basket

      Served with Potato & Vegetable and Soup or Salad.
      $24.59

    • London Broil

      with Mushroom Sauce. Served with Potato & Vegetable and Soup or Salad.
      $36.47

    • Roast Prime Rib of Beef

      Served with Potato & Vegetable and Soup or Salad.
      $45.30

    • Roast Spring Chicken

      Served with Potato & Vegetable and Soup or Salad.
      $28.91

    • Roast Turkey

      with Stuffing. Served with Potato & Vegetable and Soup or Salad.
      $32.58

    Captain Hook's Seafood

    Served with Soup or Salad, Potato and Vegetable.

    • Broiled Filet of Lemon Sole

      With Butter Sauce. Served with Potato & Vegetable and Soup or Salad.
      $38.22

    • Broiled Jumbo Shrimp Scampi

      With Butter & Garlic Sauce. Served with Potato & Vegetable and Soup or Salad.
      $42.47

    • Broiled Scallops

      with Butter Sauce. Served with Potato & Vegetable and Soup or Salad.
      OUT OF STOCK
      $42.47

    • Broiled Seafood Combo

      Shrimp, Scallops, Filet and Baked Clam. Served with Potato & Vegetable and Soup or Salad.
      $42.47

    • Fried Seafood Combo

      Shrimp, Scallops and Filet. Served with Potato & Vegetable and Soup or Salad.
      $42.47

    • Fried Scallops

      Served with Potato & Vegetable and Soup or Salad.
      $40.98

    • Fried Filet of Sole

      Served with Potato & Vegetable and Soup or Salad.
      $38.22

    • Stuffed Filet of Sole

      With Crabmeat Stuffing or Spinach and Feta. Served with Potato & Vegetable and Soup or Salad.
      $40.74

    • Stuffed Jumbo Shrimp

      With Crabmeat Stuffing. Served with Potato & Vegetable and Soup or Salad.
      $45.00

    Kids Menu

    For Kids 12 and Under.

    • Kids Breakfast Special

      One Pancake, One Egg & Two Slices of Bacon.
      $8.87

    • Kids Grilled Cheese

      $9.59

    • Kids Beef Sliders

      Served with French Fries.
      $9.59

    • Kids Cheese Pizza

      $8.39

    • Kids Cheese Quesadilla

      Served with Salsa.
      $10.79

    • Kids Chicken Tenders

      Served with French Fries.
      $10.79

    • Kids Fried Filet of Sole

      Served with Potato & Vegetable.
      $11.99

    • Kids Hamburger

      Served with French Fries.
      $9.59

    • Kids Hot Dog

      Served with French Fries.
      $8.39

    • Kids Mac & Cheese

      $10.79

    • Kids Roast Beef

      Served with Potato, Vegetable & Gravy.
      $10.79

    • Kids Roast Turkey

      Served with Potato, Vegetable & Gravy.
      $10.79

    • Kids Spaghetti

      with Marinara Sauce.
      $10.79

    Side Dishes

    • Avocado

      $5.16

    • Bacon

      $6.48

    • Baked Potato (AFTER 4pm ONLY)

      $4.55

    • Beets

      $4.55

    • Canadian Bacon

      $8.58

    • Chickpeas

      $4.55

    • Coleslaw

      $3.48

    • Corned Beef Hash

      $8.99

    • Cottage Cheese

      $5.51

    • Feta Cheese

      $6.30

    • French Fries

      Choice of Regular Cut, Seasoned Curly, Seasoned Waffle, Steak or Sweet Potato.
      $9.36

    • Fried Onions

      $2.75

    • Garlic Bread

      $5.39

    • Grape Leaves (5)

      $5.03

    • Ham

      $6.48

    • Home Fries

      $8.16

    • Mac & Cheese

      $9.23

    • Onion Rings

      $9.36

    • Pita

      $3.54

    • Potato Salad

      $4.86

    • Sausage

      $6.48

    • Side of Spaghetti

      Your choice of sauce.
      $10.38

    • Side Salad

    • Sliced Turkey

      $6.66

    • Turkey Bacon

      $6.66

    • Turkey Sausage

      $6.66

    • Vegetable of the Day

      $4.55

    Beverages

    • Chocolate Milk

      $4.20+

    • Coffee

      $3.66+

    • Decaf Coffee

      $3.66+

    • Herbal Tea

      $5.10

    • Hot Chocolate

      $3.60

    • Hot Tea

      $3.66+

    • Iced Coffee

      $4.68

    • Brewed Iced Tea

      $4.68

    • Juice

      Choice of Apple, Cranberry, Grape, Grapefruit, Orange, Pineapple, Tomato, V8
      $6.11

    • Lemonade

      $4.50

    • Milk

      $3.96+

    • Soft Drinks

      $4.68

    Ice Cream Shakes

    Made with Hershey's Ice Cream.

    • Banana Pudding Shake

      $9.11

    • Brooklyn Egg Cream

      Your choice of ice cream flavor
      $5.63

    • Classic Shake Favorite

      Your choice of ice cream flavor
      $7.91

    • Cookies & Cream-a-Licious Shake

      Vanilla ice cream with Oreo cookies
      $9.11

    • Minty Mint Chip Shake

      Mint chip ice cream
      OUT OF STOCK
      $9.11

    • Mocha-Choco-Latte Shake

      Coffee ice cream and chocolate syrup
      $9.11

    • Moose Tracks Shake

      Vanilla ice cream with chocolate swirl and peanut butter cups
      $9.11

    Sweet Endings

    • Ice Cream 1 Scoop

      1 Scoop of your choice of Flavors!
      $4.62

    • Ice Cream 2 Scoops

      2 Scoops of your choice of Flavors!
      $7.50

    • 7 Layer Cake

      $7.56

    • Peach Crumb Pie

      OUT OF STOCK
      $6.59

    • Apple Pie

      $6.59

    • Apple Turnover

      $5.63

    • Baklava

      Greek pastry dessert.
      $6.59

    • Black & White Cookie

      $4.74

    • Black Forest Cake

      $7.56

    • Blueberry Pie

      $6.59

    • Bread Pudding

      $7.19+

    • Brownie

      $5.15

    • Cannoli Cake

      OUT OF STOCK
      $7.56

    • Cannoli Cheesecake

      OUT OF STOCK
      $9.30

    • Carrot Cake

      OUT OF STOCK
      $7.56

    • Checker Board Cake

      $7.56

    • Cheesecake

      OUT OF STOCK
      $7.56

    • Cherry Pie

      $6.59

    • Chocolate Brownie Cheesecake

      $9.30

    • Chocolate Chip Cookie

      $4.74

    • Chocolate Cream Pie

      OUT OF STOCK
      $6.90

    • Chocolate Pudding

      $7.19+

    • Chocolate Raspberry Cake

      $7.56

    • Death by Chocolate Cake

      OUT OF STOCK
      $7.56

    • Lemon Coconut Cake

      OUT OF STOCK
      $7.56

    • Lemon Meringue Pie

      $6.59

    • Linzer Tart Cookie

      $4.74

    • Napolean

      $7.14

    • Rainbow Cake

      $7.56

    • Rainbow Crumb Cake

      $9.30

    • Red Jello

      $6.90

    • Red Velvet Cake

      $7.56

    • Rice Pudding

      $7.19+

    • Sprinkles Cookie

      $4.74

    • Strawberry Cheesecake

      OUT OF STOCK
      $9.30

    • Strawberry Shortcake

      OUT OF STOCK
      $7.56

    • Tiramisu Cake

      $7.56
    All hours
    Sunday8:00 am - 9:45 pm
    Monday8:00 am - 9:45 pm
    Tuesday8:00 am - 9:45 pm
    Wednesday8:00 am - 9:45 pm
    Thursday8:00 am - 9:45 pm
    Friday8:00 am - 10:45 pm
    Saturday8:00 am - 10:45 pm
    Restaurant info

    Come in and enjoy!

    Location

    999 Sunrise Hwy, Bay Shore, NY 11706

    Directions

    Similar restaurants in your area

    Peter Pan Diner
    View restaurantnext
    Brightwaters Inn
    View restaurantnext
    Brightwaters Village Deli
    View restaurantnext
    Exit 42 Bagel & Deli 270 Spur dr S
    View restaurantnext
    Khyber Grill & Gyro 270 Spur dr S Khyber
    View restaurantnext
    Roto
    View restaurantnext
    Search similar restaurants
    © 2026 Toast, Inc.
    Toast
    • About Toast
    • For restaurants
    • Terms of Service
    • Privacy Statement
    • Do not sell my
      personal information
    Made with love in Boston
    • Instagram
    • X (formerly Twitter)
    • Facebook