
Pizza
Phoenicia Pizza 28
5575 NY-28
Phoenicia, NY 12464
Orders through Toast are commission free and go directly to this restaurant
Breakfast
Egg Sandwich
$3.00+Toast
$0+OUT OF STOCKThe Skinny
on a roll, 2 egg whites, tomato, spinach, turkey, swiss$8.50BEC SPK
BACON- EGG- AND CHEESE- SALT- PEPPER- KETCHUP served on a roll with 2 fried eggs and american cheese$7.25Hungry Man Hero
on a hero- 3 fried eggs, bacon, ham, sausage, hashbrown$14.00Roll with Butter
$2.25Bagel
$2.25
Lunch
CREATE YOUR OWN
$8.00BLTA
bacon, lettuce, tomato, avocado, and mayo$12.25+ONTEORA
EGGPLANT OR GRILLED CHICKEN, PESTO, ROASTED RED PEPPERS, FRESH MOZZ, BALSAMIC VIN$12.25+SHOKAN
CHICKEN CUTLET, BACON, CHEDDARELLA, HOT SAUCE, LETTUCE, TOMATO, RANCH OR BLUE CHEESE ON TOASTED GARLIC BREAD$12.25+LUMBERJACK
CHICKEN CUTLET, MELTED MOZZARELLA, BACON, LETTUCE, TOMATO, MAYO ON TOASTED GARLIC BREAD$12.25+RESERVOIR
CHICKEN CUTLEY, BACON, CHEDDARELLA, BBQ SAUCE, LETTUCE, TOMATO, CRISPY ONIONS ON TOASTED GARLIC BREAD$12.25+MERCY
CHICKEN CUTLET, BACON, CHEDDARELLA, LETTUCE, TOMATO, RANCH OR SOUTHWEST DRESSING ON TOASTED GARLIC BREAD$12.25+CORDON YOU
chicken, ham, cheddarella, crispy onions, lettuce, tomato & russian dressing on toasted garlic bread$12.25+FREAKING PIG
BBQ PULLED PORK, GARLIC, CHEDDARELLA, CRISOY ONIONS, COLESLAW, ON TOASTED GARLIC BREAD$12.25+REUBEN
PASTRAMI, SAUERKRAUT OR COLESLAW, SWISS, RUSSIAN DRESSING OR MUSTARD, ON TOASTED GARLIC BREAD$12.25+ZACH ATTACK
HOT ROAST BEEF WITH GRAVY, BACON, CHEDDARELLA, CRISPY ONIONS ON TOASTED GARLIC BREAD$12.25+PATRIOT
ROAST BEEF, HAM, TURKEY, AMERICAN CHEESE, LETTUCE, TOMATO, HONEY MUSTARD$12.25+SHIRLEY
TURKEY, SWISS, SPINACH, ROASTED RED PEPPERS, BALSAMIC VIN$12.25+BADA BING
SALAMI, PEPPERONI, HAM, PROVOLONE, LETTUCE, TOMATO, ONION, ROASTED RED PEPPER VIN$12.25+SUPER TUNA MELT
TUNA SALAD, MELTED CHEDDARELLA, BACON, LETTUCE, TOMATO ON TOASTED BREAD$12.25+
Dinner
Starters
Waffle Fries
$6.25Mozzarella Sticks (5)
served with tomato sauce$7.75Wings
$8.75+Garlic Knots Deluxe (6)
served over tomato sauce baked with mozzarella cheese$7.75
Garlic Mozz. Bread with sauce
Served with tomato sauce$5.75Garlic Bread with sauce
Served with tomato sauce$5.75Fried Ravioli (5)
fried cheese ravioli served with tomato sauce$7.75
Garlic Knots
Served with tomato sauce$1.15
Calzones 🧀

Cheese Calzone
Made to order with mozzarella, parmesan and ricotta cheese- served with side of tomato sauce$22.50
Stuffed Calzone
Made to order with mozzarella, parmesan, ricotta cheese, and your additional stuffings- served with a side of tomato sauce$22.50Spinach Artichoke Calzone
Made to order- stuffed with mozzarella, parmesan, ricotta cheese, and our famous spinach artichoke sauce$25.00
Specialty Pies

Grandma Pie
Pomodoro sauce base with - mozzarella, garlic, fresh basil$20.50+Grandma Vodka Pie
Vodka sauce base with - mozzarella, fresh mozzarella, fresh basil$20.50+Popeye Deluxe Pie
Spinach sauce base with - artichoke, mozzarella$20.50+Hunter Mountian
ricotta, garlic, mozzarella$22.50+Phoenician Pie
Fresh mozzarella base with fresh tomato, fresh basil, balsamic glaze$22.50+Big Papa Pie
Tomato sauce base with - meatball, sausage, pepperoni, bacon, and mozzarella$25.00+Freaking Pig Pie
Pulled Pork, Garlic, Cheddarella, Crispy Onions, BBQ Sauce$25.00+Mama Bear Pie
Vodka sauce base with - sausage, pepper, onion, and cheddarella$25.00+Mercy Pie
Chicken cutlet, bacon, cheddarella, southwest or ranch dressing$25.00+Pizza 28 Pie
Tomato sauce base with - meatball, sausage, pepperoni, mushrooms, onions, peppers, garlic, and mozzarella$25.00+Rail Trail Pie
Tomato sauce base with - mushroom, onion, olives, garlic, eggplant, broccoli, and mozzarella$25.00+
Reservoir Pie
Chicken cutlet, bacon, cheddarella, BBQ sauce, and crispy onions$25.00+
Shokan Pie
Chicken cutlet, bacon, cheddarella, hot sauce with blue cheese dressing or ranch$25.00+Emerson
tomato sauce base with- pineapple, ham, bacon, mozzarella$25.00+OUT OF STOCKHudson
chicken cutlet, garlic, mozzarella, basil, crispy onions, sesame dressing$25.00+
Pizza Pies
Pizza Pops
Sausage with Peppers Parm Pizza Pop
$14.95Sausage Parm Pizza Pop
$14.95Eggplant Parm Pizza Pop 🍆
$14.95Meatball Parm Pizza Pop
$14.95Chicken Parm Pizza Pop
$14.95Pepperoni Pizza Pop
Pizza roll served with tomato sauce$13.95Roswell Pizza Pop
$15.95Bada Bing/ Stromboli Pizza Pop
$15.95Big Papa Pizza Pop
$15.95
Salads 🥗
Garden Salad
Carrots, tomatoes, cucumbers, onions, served with romaine lettuce, and roasted red pepper vinaigrette$12.50+Jimmy's Caesar Salad
Shaved parmesan, croutons, served with romaine lettuce, and caesar dressing$12.50+Rip Van Winkle Salad
Carrots, cucumbers, crispy onions, served with romaine lettuce, and sesame ginger dressing$12.50+Yaya Salad
Feta, black olives, carrots, cucumbers, tomatoes, onions, pepperoncini, served with romaine lettuce, and roasted red pepper vinaigrette$12.50+COBB
AVOCADO, HARD BOILED EGG, LETTUCE, TOMATO, BLUE CHEESE CRUMBLES, BALSAMIC VIN$12.50+Christmas Salad
SPINACH, ONION, BLUE CHEESE CRUMBLES, GLAZED PECANS, SLICED ALMONDS, DRIED CRANBERRIES, BALSAMIC VIN$12.50+
Homemade Dinners
Italian Dinners
Baked Parmesan Dinners
Baked Ziti Dinner
$15.95Chicken Cutlet Parmesan Dinner
$18.95Grilled Chicken Parmesan Dinner
$18.95Eggplant Parmesan Dinner
$17.95Meatball Parmesan Dinner
$16.95Meatball with Sausage Parmesan Dinner
$17.95Sausage Parmesan Dinner
$16.95Sausage with Peppers Parmesan Dinner
$16.95Eggplant Parmesan 7 Inch Platter
$15.95Chicken Cutlet Parmesan 7 Inch Platter
$15.95Sausage Peppers Parmesan 7 Inch Platter
$15.95Meatball Parmesan 7 Inch Platter
$15.95
All hours
| Sunday | 11:00 am - 7:00 pm |
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | 11:00 am - 7:00 pm |
| Wednesday | 11:00 am - 7:00 pm |
| Thursday | 11:00 am - 7:00 pm |
| Friday | 11:00 am - 8:00 pm |
| Saturday | 11:00 am - 7:00 pm |
Restaurant info
We are a mom and pop pizza shop located in Phoenicia New York in the heart of the Catskills
Location
5575 NY-28, Phoenicia, NY 12464
© 2026 Toast, Inc.






