
Pica's Deli
18 Ayers Village Road
Methuen, MA 01844
Orders through Toast are commission free and go directly to this restaurant
Featured Items

FRENCH FRIES
Crispy skin on shoestring fries.$5.00+
CHICKEN BACON RANCH WRAP
Crispy chicken, bacon, lettuce, tomatoes, cheddar and our house zesty ranch dressing on a wrap$12.00
STUFFED MEATBALL
Pica's famous sandwich for over 60 years!! Our house meatballs in a hollowed out Italian breadstick with Pica's Own marinara and melted provolone$13.00
FOOD
ARTISAN CREATIONS

THE "ANIMAL"
A heavy stack of slow cooked and thin sliced rare roast beef with extra‑sharp cheddar, a hit of creamy horseradish, crispy shallots, and rich onion marmalade. Big, messy, and built to dominate. Served with chips and pickles$17.00
THE WICKED TUNA
Mediterranean‑style tuna with capers, olives, and red onion, folded in lemon aioli and stacked on marble rye with fresh tomatoes. Bright, briny, and built with attitude. Served with chips and pickles.$15.50
THE PORCHETTA AGRODOLCE
Slow‑roasted porchetta with melted fontina, rosemary aioli, sweet agrodolce onions, and fresh arugula on grilled sourdough. Rich, bright, and built on true Italian flavor. Served with chips and pickles$17.00
THE GARDEN NITE (1939)
Crispy eggplant layered with whipped feta, harissa aioli, cucumbers, and tomatoes. A bright Mediterranean tribute to the flavors and spirit of the original Pica's Garden Nite Cafe est. 1939. Served with chips and pickles.$16.00
THE "RACHEL-ISH"
Roast turkey and crispy bacon piled with house coleslaw, pickles, and zesty aioli. A sharp, crunchy twist on the classic Rachel. Served with chips and pickles.$15.00
THE TURKEY DILLUXE
Roast turkey stacked with crispy bacon, dill Havarti, and herb mayo, finished with tomatoes, onions, and pickles. A bright, savory, house‑crafted classic served with chips and pickles$16.00THE ORCHARD BLT (bacon-leafy-tart)
Crispy bacon and sharp cheddar stacked with peppery arugula and tart Granny Smith apples, all hit with a punchy pecorino cream and a drizzle of hot honey. Salty, smoky, tangy, sweet, and spicy—this BLT comes in swinging from every angle$16.00OUT OF STOCK
PUCCIA (PICA-POCKETS)
Philly Puccia
Thin‑sliced steak piled into a hot, airy puccia with melted American cheese, sautéed peppers and onions, and all the classic cheesesteak drip—wrapped in that crisp, blistered Pica pocket. It’s the Philly you know, baked into our signature Italian street‑bread.$16.00OUT OF STOCKPuccia Italiano
A hot, airy puccia packed with a chopped Italian—Imported prosciutto, sopressata, Genoa salami, mortadella, hot capicola, and provolone—topped with shredded lettuce, tomatoes, pickles, red onion, and our House Vinaigrette. All the bold deli flavors you expect, baked into our crisp, blistered Pica pocket.$16.00OUT OF STOCK
Puccia di Parmigiana
Crispy chicken cutlet tucked into a hot, airy puccia with melted provolone, our zesty house marinara, and a sprinkle of grated Pecorino Romano. It’s the classic chicken parm—crunchy, cheesy, and saucy—baked into our signature blistered Pica pocket$16.00OUT OF STOCKThe Big Polpette (Meatball Pucchia)
House meatballs simmered in our house marinara, tucked into a hot, airy puccia with melted provolone and a dusting of grated Pecorino Romano. Big, saucy, Sunday‑gravy energy inside our crisp, blistered Pica pocket$16.00OUT OF STOCK
APPS AND SIDES
HOUSE SPECIALS

CHICKEN BARB
The Merrimack Valley's Food Cousin to 45's>>> Slow Braised and Piled High Tender Pulled Chicken in our Homemade Chicken Stock, Crisp Iceburg Lettuce and Mayo on a Roll. Correct, There is No BBQ Sauce on this Sandwich.$13.00
REUBEN
Pica's House Smoked Pastrami Sliced Thin and Piled High with Sauerkraut, Swiss Cheese and 1000 Island Dressing Pressed on Marble Rye$14.00
SAUSAGE RABE
Coarse ground house seasoned pork with sauteed broccoli rabe, provolone and American cheese on a toasted subroll$14.00
THE ANGRY RABE
The deliciously sassy sibling of our sausage broccoli rabe: Course Ground House Seasoned Hot Italian Sausage with Sauteed Broccoli Rabe, Provolone and American Cheese.$14.00
STUFFED MEATBALL
Pica's famous sandwich for over 60 years!! Our house meatballs in a hollowed out Italian breadstick with Pica's Own marinara and melted provolone$13.00
CLUCKING PIG
Pica's Own Chicken Cutlet, Provolone, Marinara, Fresh Basil and Peppered Bacon$14.00
PICA'S SMASHBURGER
Our version of this iconic burger! Two thin coarse ground steak patties with american cheese, lettuce, tomato, pickles, red onion and our secret Pica Sauce on a perfectly grilled brioche bun$12.00
THE PICADILLA
Picas smash burger quesadilla: “The Picadilla” Our smash patties, mixed cheese, shredded lettuce, red onions, tomatoes, pickle cubes and smash sauce all hugged together in a warm tortilla. 👊🏻$14.00BLT
$12.00+
ITALIAN
HOUSE ITALIAN
Imported Sopresatta, Genoa Salami, Mortadella and Provolone with Oil, Tomatoes, Pickles, and Red Onion on an 8" fresh baked sub roll$12.00+ITALIAN DELUXE
Imported Prosciutto, Sopressata, Genoa Salami and Mortadella with Provolone, Oil, Tomatoes, Pickles, and Red Onions.$14.00+
MUFFALETTO (New & Improved)
SERVED BY THE PICA FAMILY FOR OVER 60 YEARS... GENOA SALAMI, MORTADELLA, HOT CAPICOLA AND OUR HOMEMADE OLIVE SALAD UNDER MELTED PROVOLONE$15.00
STEAK AND CHEESE
WRAPS

CHICKEN BACON RANCH WRAP
Crispy chicken, bacon, lettuce, tomatoes, cheddar and our house zesty ranch dressing on a wrap$12.00
MEDITERRANEAN WRAP
Grilled chicken, lettuce, tomato, cucumber, kalamata olives, feta cheese, red onions and greek dressing on your choice of white or wheat wrap$12.00
CHICKEN CAESAR WRAP
Grilled chicken, romaine lettuce, our "actual" homemade Caesar dressing and shredded pecorino Romano on a white or wheat wrap$12.00
CUTLETS
CUTLET COMBO DELUXE
Pica's Hand Breaded and Fried Chicken Cutlets, Provolone, Fresh Mozzarella, Imported Prosciutto, Tomatoes, Red Onions, Pickles, and Our House Vinaigrette Served with chips and pickles$14.00+
CUTLET CAPRESE
Our house breaded chicken cutlets with tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, fresh basil and balsamic glaze$13.00+
CHICKEN PARMIGIANA
Pica's Own Chicken Cutlets, House Marinara and Provolone on Fresh Tripoli Bread$13.00+EGGPLANT PARMIGIANA
Our breaded eggplant cutlets, house marinara and provolone on a fresh Tripoli subroll served with chips and pickles$15.00+
GRILLED CHEESE

BRISKET GRILLED CHEESE
House smoked brisket with provolone, swiss and cheddar cheese on grilled garlic sourdough$14.00
DILL PICKLE GRILLED CHEESE
Dill havarti and american cheese with tangy pickles on grilled garlic sourdough$13.00
JAMMIN GRILLED CHEESE
Tangy 3-pepper colby jack and american cheese with our homemade bacon onion jam pressed between two slices of perfectly grilled thick garlic sourdough$14.00
TRIPLE CROWN
Our 3 most popular grilled cheese concoctions united in an epic culinary mash-up. Brisket, Pickle and Jammin Grilled cheese, 2 lbs of amazingness!!!$22.00
SALADS
GREEK SALAD
Spring Mix, Tomatoes, Cucumbers, Red Onions, Kalamata Olives, Pepperoncinis and Feta Cheese$12.00CAESAR SALAD
Crisp Romaine Lettuce with Parmesan Cheese, Croutons and Our Homemade Caesar Dressing$12.00GARDEN SALAD
Little Leaf Lettuce, Tomatoes, Cucumbers and Red Onion$10.00STRAWBERRY SPRING SALAD
$12.00
Build Your Own
CHIPS
Ruffles 1.5oz
$2.00OUT OF STOCKDoritos Nacho 1.75oz
$2.00OUT OF STOCKDoritos Cool Ranch 1.75oz
$2.00OUT OF STOCKFox Family Large Salt 7oz
$4.00OUT OF STOCKFox Family Large BBQ 7oz
$4.00OUT OF STOCKFox Family Salt & Vinegar 2oz
$2.50OUT OF STOCKFox Family Salt 1.8 oz
$2.50Fox Family Wicked Hot BBQ 1.8oz
$2.50OUT OF STOCKLay's BBQ 1.5oz
$2.00OUT OF STOCKLay's Sour Cream & Onion 1.5oz
$2.00OUT OF STOCKLay's Regular Chips 1.5oz
$2.00OUT OF STOCKWachusett Salt 4.5oz
$3.50OUT OF STOCKWachusett BBQ 4.5oz
$3.50OUT OF STOCKWachusett Salt and Vinegar 4.5oz
$3.50OUT OF STOCKWachusett Sour Cream and Onion 4.5oz
$3.50OUT OF STOCKDeep River Bbq
$2.50OUT OF STOCKDeep River Sea Salt
$2.50Deep River Sour Cream and onion
$2.50
Beverages
Water
12oz Soda
Pepsi 12oz
$2.00Diet Pepsi 12oz
$2.00Mug Root Beer 12oz
$2.00Ginger Ale 12oz
$2.00Starry 12oz
$2.00Mountain Dew 12oz
$2.00Diet Mountain Dew 12oz
$2.00Mountain Dew Cream Soda 12oz
$2.00Baja Blast 12oz
$2.00OUT OF STOCKMug Sugar Free 12oz
$2.00OUT OF STOCKHawaiian Punch 12oz
$2.00Grape Crush 12oz
$2.00Orange Crush 12oz
$2.00Diet Ginger Ale
$2.00OUT OF STOCKA&W Rootbeer
$2.00
Pure Leaf
Gatorade
Celsius
Red Bull
Bubbly
Bubbly Lime 16 oz
$3.00OUT OF STOCKBubbly Blackberry 16 oz
$3.00OUT OF STOCKBubbly Cherry 16oz
$3.00OUT OF STOCKBubbly Blackberry 12oz
$2.50OUT OF STOCKBubbly Cherry 12oz
$2.50Bubbly Lime 12 oz
$2.50OUT OF STOCKBubbly Raspberry 12oz
$2.50Bubbly Blueberry Pomegranate 12oz
$2.50Bubbly Coconut Pineapple 12oz
$2.50
| Sunday | 11:00 am - 5:45 pm |
| Monday | 11:00 am - 8:00 pm |
| Tuesday | 11:00 am - 8:00 pm |
| Wednesday | 11:00 am - 8:00 pm |
| Thursday | 11:00 am - 8:00 pm |
| Friday | 11:00 am - 8:00 pm |
| Saturday | 11:00 am - 8:00 pm |
Pica’s serves scratch‑made, Italian‑American deli food built on real ingredients, bold flavors, and the kind of craft you only get from a kitchen that cooks everything with intention. Our sandwiches are stacked on fresh bread, layered with house sauces, sharp cheeses, slow‑roasted meats, and bright vegetables. Every build has its own personality — some nostalgic, some aggressive, all unmistakably ours. We don’t cut corners. We roast, fry, slice, and season in‑house, using the same techniques our family has carried for generations. Whether it’s a classic done our way or a signature creation with attitude, every sandwich is made to be big, honest, and full of flavor






