Pie Safe Baking Company 102 W Main St

An adorable 7.5 inch heart shaped brownie with a buttercream border.

Cheesecake sampler includes 4 heart shaped 2 inch cheesecakes in individual pans, flavors include classic NY style, Red Velvet, Brownie and strawberry cheesecake

The pie sampler will include 4 individual 3 inch pies, flavors include Cherry, Chocolate chess, Apple and an exclusive Raspberry pie

Perfectly tart granny smith apples complimented by rich cinnamon spice, nestled into our scratch made, all butter crust, dusted with a sugar crunch.

Juicy, tart red cherries cooked to perfection and topped with a cinnamon sugar crumble.

A true classic, our Pecan pie is made with a sweet brown sugar filling, pecan halves are folded in to give you the perfect bite every time!

Nothing says 'happy holidays' like a silky smooth pumpkin pie. Put the perfect touch to any fall gathering with our freshly baked Pumpkin Pie!

A twist on our classic, sweet brown sugar pie filling, folded in with chocolate chips and pecan halves. The chocolate chip pecan pie has earned it's spot as our best sold pie!

A silky custard pie packed with spice

Create your perfect party tray! Get all one flavor or choose two! Cookie trays come with 2 dozen 2oz cookies

Create your perfect Party tray! Make it all one flavor or choose two! Brownie tray comes with 24 bite size brownie squares

Why just have one when you can have both? Create your perfect party tray by choosing one cookie and one brownie flavor! Each party tray will come with one dozen 2oz cookies and one dozen bite size brownie squares.

Our classic NY style cheesecake with the perfect creamy vanilla flavor

velvety chocolate cheesecake with house made brownie chunks throughout the batter, topped with a generous sweet, fluffy chocolate whipped cream and more brownie pieces!

Our classic NY style cheesecake topped with a layer of house made carrot cake and cream cheese frosting

The perfect addition to any holiday spread. 24 mini cookies, choose two flavors or choose all one flavor!

Sweet and tangy key lime pie on our crushed graham cracker crust and topped with vanilla whipped cream

Granny smith green apples baked in house with rich brown sugar and cinnamon spices deliver a sharp bite balanced perfectly with our flaky sugar dusted pie crust

Our Cherry Pie is made with Tart Cherries, which offers a delightful balance of sweetness and tartness, loaded into our signature flakey buttery crust topped with lattice crust

Rich chocolate custard-style pie reminiscent of brownie batter

Fluffy whipped cream cheese folded with house made strawberry jam and piled high in our graham cracker crust, topped with fresh whipped cream and sliced strawberries

Toasted pecans folded into a rich brown sugar filling, baked in our signature all-butter crust until perfectly gooey and golden. A timeless Southern favorite.

A decadent combination of crunchy pecans and melty chocolate chips in a rich, buttery filling, all nestled inside our flaky all-butter crust. Loved by guests year after year, this pie has been a customer favorite since the day we opened.

Our classic NY style cheesecake with the perfect creamy vanilla flavor

velvety chocolate cheesecake with house made brownie chunks throughout the batter, topped with a generous sweet, fluffy chocolate whipped cream and more brownie pieces!

Our classic creamy NY style cheesecake topped with house made strawberry compote, whipped cream and fresh sliced strawberries

Real blueberries and fresh lemon zest are folded into our signature cheesecake batter, topped with Blueberry whipped cream and fresh blueberries. (Photo features our mini version, the cheesecake ordered will be a full size 10 inch cheesecake)

Caramelized onion, bacon, garlic, and a blend of Cheddar, White cheddar, and asiago cheese folded into our light, fluffy egg base and baked to perfection

fresh chopped spinach, marinated artichokes, garlic and herb blended Ricotta cheese folded into our light and fluffy egg base, baked to perfection

Honey baked ham, Cheddar cheese, garlic and hashbrowns folded into our light and fluffy egg base and baked to perfection

House roasted red peppers, spinach, garlic and feta folded into our light and fluffy egg base and baked to perfection

Our Apple Pie is made from tart and crisp Granny Smith Apples, paired with warm cinnamon spices and topped with a lattice crust

Our Cherry Pie is made with Tart Cherries, which offers a delightful balance of sweetness and tartness, loaded into our signature flakey buttery crust topped with lattice crust

A true classic, our Pecan pie is made with a sweet brown sugar filling, pecan halves are folded in to give you the perfect bite every time!

A decadent combination of crunchy pecans and melty chocolate chips in a rich, buttery filling, all nestled inside our flaky all-butter crust. Loved by guests year after year, this pie has been a customer favorite since the day we opened

Rich chocolate custard filling baked into our buttery flakey crust.

Fresh lime zest and Key Lime Juice make a sweet and tart filling with a whipped cream topping and baked into a graham cracker crust.

Toasted Coconut and Vanilla Pastry Cream folded into our signature all butter crust and topped with house made whip cream and toasted coconut.

Creamy, tangy sour cream custard loaded with strawberries, baked in a flaky crust and topped with buttery brown sugar oat crumble.

Our classic NY style cheesecake with the perfect creamy vanilla flavor

velvety chocolate cheesecake with house made brownie chunks throughout the batter, topped with a generous sweet, fluffy chocolate whipped cream and more brownie pieces!

Our classic NY style cheesecake topped with a layer of house made carrot cake and cream cheese frosting

Our creamy strawberry cheesecake topped with fresh vanilla whipped cream, House made strawberry compote and fresh sliced strawberries