Skip to Main content
  • Pizzeria New York - Pickerington 833 Hill Rd N

    • Home
    • /
    • Pickerington
    • /
    • Pizzeria New York - Pickerington 833 Hill Rd N
    Restaurant banner image
    Pizza

    Pizzeria New York - Pickerington 833 Hill Rd N

    833 Hill Rd N

    Pickerington, OH 43147


    Orders through Toast are commission free and go directly to this restaurant


    Call

    Hours

    Directions

    Gift Cards

    Food Menu Online
    Drinks Menu
    Drinks Menu Online
    ‌
    ‌

    Featured Items

    • 16in" XL Pizza

      $18.00
    • 14in" Large Pizza

      $16.00
    • 12in" Medium Pizza

      $14.00

    Food Menu Online

    Pizza

    • 12in" Medium Pizza

      $14.00
    • 14in" Large Pizza

      $16.00
    • 16in" XL Pizza

      $18.00
    • XL Slice Pepperoni

      $6.00
    • XL Slice Cheese

      $5.00

    Appetizers

    • Bread Sticks (4)

      Garnished with garlic butter and parmesan cheese served with a side of Marinara
      $5.00
    • Cheese Pinwheels (4)

      Garnished with garlic butter and parmesan cheese served with a side of Marinara
      $12.00
    • Cheesy Breadsticks (4)

      Garnished with garlic butter and parmesan cheese served with a side of Marinara
      $7.00
    • French Fries (Basket)

      Fresh cut in house
      $6.00
    • Garlic Knots (5)

      Garnished with garlic butter and parmesan cheese served with a side of Marinara
      $5.00
    • Loaded Fries (basket)

      Fresh cut in house, Smothered with Cheddar Cheese, Bacon and Jalapeños
      $8.00
    • Pepperoni Pinwheels (4)

      Garnished with garlic butter and parmesan cheese served with a side of Marinara
      $13.50
    • Pepperoni Rolls (6)

      Garnished with garlic butter and parmesan cheese served with a side of Marinara
      $8.00
    • Garlic Bread with cheese (3)

      Served with marinara sauce
      $5.00
    • Garlic Bread (3)

      Served with marinara sauce
      $4.00
    • Mozzarella Sticks (5)

      $9.00
    • Baked Meatballs (3)

      Homemade Meatballs Smothered with Mozzarella cheese and Marinara
      $12.00

    Wings & Tenders

    • Boneless Wings (10)

      Buttermilk dipped chicken, breaded and deep fried.
      $12.00
    • 5 Traditional Wings

      Fresh naked chicken wings
      $7.00
    • Chicken Wings (Traditonal) (10)

      Fresh naked chicken wings
      $14.00
    • Chicken Tenders (4)

      Buttermilk dipped chicken, breaded and deep fried.
      $10.00

    Salads

    • Caesar Salad

      Romaine Lettuce, Asiago Cheese, Parmesan Cheese and Croutons
      $6.00+
    • Greek Salad

      Romaine Lettuce, Red Onions, Black Olives, Bannana Peppers, Feta Cheese
      $6.00+
    • Tossed Salad

      Romaine Lettuce, Tomatoes, Red Onions, Croutons and Cheddar Cheese
      $6.00+
    • Chicken Caesar Salad

      Grilled Chicken with Romaine Lettuce, Asiago Cheese, Parmesan Cheese and Croutons
      $8.00+
    • Fried Chicken Salad

      Fried Chicken, Romaine Lettuce, Tomatoes, Red Onions, Croutons and Cheddar Cheese
      $12.00

    Subs

    • 6in Cajun Bourbon Sub

      Fried Chicken, Mozzarella Cheese,Bourbon Sauce, Bacon, Red onions.
      $9.00
    • 6in Chicken Parm Sub

      Fried Chicken, Mozzarella Cheese, Parmesan Cheese, Marinara
      $9.00
    • 6in Buffalo Chicken Sub

      Mild Buffalo Sauce, Fried Chicken, Mozzarella Cheese, Lettuce, Tomato, Red Onions
      $9.00
    • 6in Italian Sub

      Ham, Capicola, Salami, Pepperoni, Provolone Cheese, Romaine Lettuce, Red onions, Tomato, Bannana Peppers, Italian Dressing
      $9.00
    • 6in Meatball Sub

      Homemade Meatballs, Marinara, Mozzarella Cheese, Parmesan Cheese
      $9.00
    • 12in Cajun Bourbon Sub

      Fried Chicken, Mozzarella Cheese,Bourbon Sauce, Bacon, Red onions.
      $13.00
    • 12in Chicken Parm Sub

      Fried Chicken, Mozzarella Cheese, Parmesan Cheese, Marinara
      $13.00
    • 12in Buffalo Chicken Sub

      Mild Buffalo Sauce, Fried Chicken, Mozzarella Cheese, Lettuce, Tomato, Red Onions
      $13.00
    • 12in Italian Sub

      Ham, Capicola, Salami, Pepperoni, Provolone Cheese, Romaine Lettuce, Red onions, Tomato, Bannana Peppers, Italian Dressing
      $13.00
    • 12in Meatball Sub

      Homemade Meatballs, Marinara, Mozzarella Cheese, Parmesan Cheese
      $13.00

    Entrees

    • Chicken Parmesan

      Bed of Pasta, Marinara, Fried Chicken, Mozzarella Cheese, Parmesan Cheese
      $15.00
    • Fettucini Alfredo

      Bed of Fettucine Noodles, Alfredo Sauce
      $14.00
    • Spaghetti & Meatballs

      Bed of Pasta, Marinara, Homemade Meatballs, Parmesan Cheese
      $13.00
    • Chicken Fettucini Alfredo

      Fresh Grilled Chicken, with alfredo sauce
      $18.00

    Calzones & Strombolis

    • Calzone

      Garnished with garlic butter and parmesan cheese served with a side of Marinara
      $14.00
    • Stromboli

      Garnished with garlic butter and parmesan cheese served with a side of Marinara
      $15.00

    Specialty Pizzas

    • 14in Barbecue Chicken

      Barbecue Sauce, Grilled Chicken, Mozzarella cheese
      $22.00
    • 14in Buffalo Chicken

      Mild Sauce, Grilled Chicken, Mozzarella Cheese
      $22.00
    • 14in Chicken Alfredo

      Alfredo sauce, Grilled Chicken, Mozzarella cheese
      $24.00
    • 14in Chicken Bourbon

      Bourbon Sauce, Bacon, Red onions, Mozzarella Cheese
      $24.00
    • 14in Meat Special

      Pizza Sauce, Bacon, Ham, Pepperoni, Sausage, Mozzarella Cheese
      $24.00
    • 14in New York White

      Garlic Butter Sauce, Ricotta, Tomatoes, Mozzarella Cheese
      $24.00
    • 14in Paps Special

      Pizza Sauce, Banana Peppers, Green Peppers, Mushrooms, Onions, Pepperoni, Sausage, Mozzarella Cheese
      $24.00
    • 14in Three Cheese

      Pizza Sauce, Asiago Cheese, Ricotta Cheese, Mozzarella Cheese
      $24.00
    • 14in Triple Pepperoni

      Pizza Sauce, Pepperoni, Spicy Pepperoni, Old World Pepperoni, Mozzarella Cheese
      $24.00
    • 14in Veggie Primavera

      Pizza Sauce, Green Peppers,Mushrooms, Onions, Tomatoes, Mozzarella Cheese
      $19.00
    • 14in Hawaiian

      Bacon, Ham, Pineapple
      $24.00
    • 14in Diablo

      Pepperoni, Bacon, Jalapeño, Ricotta, with red pepper flakes
      $24.00
    • 14in Chicken Bacon Ranch

      Grilled Chicken, Bacon, Ranch
      $24.00
    • 16in Barbecue Chicken

      Barbecue Sauce, Grilled Chicken, Mozzarella cheese
      $24.00
    • 16in Buffalo Chicken

      Mild Sauce, Grilled Chicken, Mozzarella Cheese
      $24.00
    • 16in Chicken Alfredo

      Alfredo sauce, Grilled Chicken, Mozzarella cheese
      $26.00
    • 16in Chicken Bourbon

      Bourbon Sauce, Bacon, Red onions, Mozzarella Cheese
      $26.00
    • 16in Greek Pizza

      Pizza Sauce, Feta, Red onions, Black olives, Spinach, Mozzarella cheese
      $26.00
    • 16in Meat Special

      Pizza Sauce, Bacon, Ham, Pepperoni, Sausage, Mozzarella Cheese
      $26.00
    • 16in NewYork White

      Garlic Butter Sauce, Ricotta, Tomatoes, Mozzarella Cheese
      $26.00
    • 16in Paps Special

      Pizza Sauce, Banana Peppers, Green Peppers, Mushrooms, Onions, Pepperoni, Sausage, Mozzarella Cheese
      $26.00
    • 16in Three Cheese

      Pizza Sauce, Asiago Cheese, Ricotta Cheese, Mozzarella Cheese
      $26.00
    • 16in Triple Pepperoni

      Pizza Sauce, Pepperoni, Spicy Pepperoni, Old World Pepperoni, Mozzarella Cheese
      $26.00
    • 16in Veggie Primavera

      Pizza Sauce, Green Peppers,Mushrooms, Onions, Tomatoes, Mozzarella Cheese
      $23.00
    • 16in Hawaiian

      Bacon, Ham, Pineapple
      $26.00
    • 16in Diablo

      Pepperoni, Bacon, Jalapeño, Ricotta, with red pepper flakes
      $26.00
    • 16in Chicken Bacon Ranch

      Grilled Chicken, Bacon, Ranch
      $26.00

    Desserts

    • Canolli

      $4.00
    • Zeppoles

      Fried Pastry, Powdered Sugar
      $6.00

    Sauces

    • Ranch

      $0.79
    • Bleu Cheese

      $0.79
    • Garlic Butter

      $0.79
    • Marinara

      $0.79
    • Italian

      $0.79
    • French

      $0.79
    • Caesar

      $0.79
    • Balsamic Vinaigrette

      $0.79

    Drinks Menu

    2 Liters

    • Starry

      $3.69
    • Root beer

      $3.69
    • Pepsi

      $3.69
    • Mountain Dew

      $3.69
    • Dr Pepper

      $3.69

    20oz

    • Pepsi

      OUT OF STOCK
      $2.59
    • Diet Pepsi

      OUT OF STOCK
      $2.59
    • Dr Pepper

      $3.00
    • Rootbeer

      OUT OF STOCK
      $2.59
    • Mountain Dew

      $3.00
    • lemonade

      $2.59
    • Water

      $2.00
    • Gatorade

      $2.79

    Fountain Soda

    • Pepsi

      $2.75
    • Diet Pepsi

      $2.75
    • Dr Pepper

      $2.75
    • Rootbeer

      $2.75
    • Lemonade

      $2.75
    • Sierra Mist

      $2.75
    • Orange Crush

      $2.75
    • Water

    • Mountain Dew

      $2.75

    Drinks Menu Online

    2 Liters

    • Cherry Pepsi

      OUT OF STOCK
      $3.69
    • Starry

      $3.69
    • Root beer

      $3.69
    • Pepsi

      $3.69
    • Diet Pepsi

      OUT OF STOCK
      $3.69
    • Mountain Dew

      $3.69
    • Dr Pepper

      $3.69
    • Gatorade

      $2.79
    • Water

      $2.00

    All hours
    Sunday11:45 am - 9:00 pm
    MondayClosed
    Tuesday4:00 pm - 9:00 pm
    Wednesday4:00 pm - 9:00 pm
    Thursday4:00 pm - 9:00 pm
    Friday4:00 pm - 10:00 pm
    Saturday11:00 am - 10:00 pm
    Restaurant info

    Come in and enjoy!

    Location

    833 Hill Rd N, Pickerington, OH 43147

    Directions


    Similar restaurants in your area

    Beyond Dough Pizza 1520 Cross Creek Blvd
    View restaurantnext
    Grapevine Pizza & Cafe 8581 Refugee Road
    View restaurantnext
    Cardo's Pizza & Tavern - Pickerington
    View restaurantnext
    Kingy's Pizza Pub
    View restaurantnext
    Ella's in Canal (Local Bar & Grill)
    View restaurantnext
    Loose Rail Brewing 37 W Waterloo St
    View restaurantnext
    Search similar restaurants
    © 2026 Toast, Inc.
    Toast
    • About Toast
    • For restaurants
    • Terms of Service
    • Privacy Statement
    • Do not sell my
      personal information
    Made with love in Boston
    • Instagram
    • X (formerly Twitter)
    • Facebook