
Pizza
Red Wagon Pizza Co 5416 Penn Ave S
5416 Penn Ave S
Minneapolis, MN 55419
Orders through Toast are commission free and go directly to this restaurant
Featured Items

P.S.O.
Caramelized-onion red sauce, house cheese, sausage, spicy cup pepperoni, & hot habanero honey.$18.00
Banh Mi
Sweet soy-glazed pulled pork,* house cheese, ginger-pickled carrots, radishes, cucumber, jalapeño, cilantro, & Sriracha aioli. *Contains gluten$18.00
Roasted Veggies
Seasonal vegetables with carrot-ginger vinaigrette, crispy chickpeas, & fresh herbs. Gluten-Free, Vegan.$15.00
Main Menu
Sides
Appetizers

Bar Chips
Gaufrette-style seasoned with rosemary, garlic salt, & black pepper. Served with Sriracha aioli. Gluten-Free, Vegetarian.$8.00
Roasted Veggies
Seasonal vegetables with carrot-ginger vinaigrette, crispy chickpeas, & fresh herbs. Gluten-Free, Vegan.$15.00
Wings
Dry jerk rub or Buffalo. Served with green goddess or bleu cheese. Gluten-free.$17.00
Meatballs
Beef & ricotta with marinara, parsley, & pecorino romano. Gluten-free.$16.00
Garlic Cheese Bread
Garlic confit, house cheese blend, & pecorino romano on house-made bread with marinara.$12.00
Salads
Kid's Menu

Kid Meatballs
$5.00
Kid's Broccoli
$4.00
Rigatoni Marinara
Rigatoni with marinara & pecorino romano.$10.00
Buttered Noodles
Buttered Noodles.$8.00
10" Kid's Pizza - Cheese
$12.00
10" Kid's Pizza - Pepperoni
$14.50
10" Kid's Pizza - Sausage
$15.50
Annie Banannie
Banana crème pie in a *compostable* jar!$8.00
Kid Brownie
Half-sized gluten-free brownie with fresh whip.$5.00
Vanilla Chocolate Chunk Ice Cream Sandwich
Chocolate chunk cookie, simply vanilla ice cream, & chocolate chunk cookie crunch.$7.00
Dessert

Gluten-Free Brownie
Gluten-free brownie, heavy whipped cream, fire-charred cherries & candied pistachios.$11.00
Kid Brownie
Half-sized gluten-free brownie with fresh whip.$5.00
Annie Banannie
Banana crème pie in a *compostable* jar!$8.00
Vanilla Chocolate Chunk Ice Cream Sandwich
Chocolate chunk cookie, simply vanilla ice cream, & chocolate chunk cookie crunch.$7.00
Giggle Bar
Chocolate soufflé cake, salted caramel ice cream, candied pretzels, hot fudge, & hard chocolate shell.$8.00
Strawberry Cheesecake Ice Cream Sandwich
Cheesecake ice cream in between 2 strawberry cookies, rolled in strawberry- graham crunch.$7.00
Pizzas

Banh Mi
Sweet soy-glazed pulled pork,* house cheese, ginger-pickled carrots, radishes, cucumber, jalapeño, cilantro, & Sriracha aioli. *Contains gluten$18.00
Carl the Cuban
12-hour citrus-Cuban pork, shaved ham, house cheese, dill pickles, & French's mayo.$17.00
Cheese Pizza
Cheese Pizza.$12.00
Detroit
Red sauce over house cheese (Motor-City Style) with green peppers & pickled red onions.$14.00
Double Pep
Red sauce, garlic oil, pepperoni, cheese, more pepperoni, & more cheese.$16.00
Margherita
Red sauce, house & fresh mozzarella cheeses, cherry tomatoes, garlic confit, fresh basil, pecorino romano, extra virgin olive oil, & black pepper. Vegetarian.$16.00
McLovin' It
Hamburger, cheddar & American cheeses, diced onion, lettuce, pickles, toasted sesame seeds, & special sauce.$16.00
Off the Wagon
Red sauce, Mortadella,* house & Stracciatella di Mozzarella cheeses, & crushed pistachios. *Contains pistachio$17.00
Olive Oyl
Pesto,* green olives, artichokes, mushrooms, house & ricotta cheeses, lemon, & black pepper. Vegetarian.$17.00
P.S.O.
Caramelized-onion red sauce, house cheese, sausage, spicy cup pepperoni, & hot habanero honey.$18.00
Pepperoni Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza.$14.50
Popeye
Garlic oil, spinach, sausage, house & Robiola cheeses, lemon, & black pepper.$20.00
Red Wagon Pizza
Red sauce, house cheese, sopressata, sausage, banana peppers, & fig balsamic.$18.00
Sausage Pizza
Sausage Pizza.$15.50
Pasta
Frozen, Market & Merchandise

Frozen Tortellini alla Panna (Entree-Size)
You know it, you love it. Now enjoy it right from your own freezer. Hand-rolled pasta filled with spinach, lemon & ricotta, served with a creamy white wine sauce, ham & peas. This pack makes an entree for one or an appetizer for two. Includes 6 tortellini, sauce with ham & peas, and instructions for reheating to perfection.$20.00
RWPCo Fig Balsamic
We infuse our balsamic vinegar with sweet figs for a perfect tang on every slice of our Red Wagon Pizza. Use your own bottle to brighten salads, glazes, desserts or you know, pizza. 4oz Glass Squeeze Bottle.$8.00
RWPCo Flour Blend
Our proprietary Heritage Wheat flour blend of Emerson and Red Fife. Perfect for pizza dough at home or try it today for your favorite baking recipe.$10.00
RWPCo Garlic Salt
A finishing touch on our Red Wagon Pizza, our garlic salt is the perfect dusting for pizza, popcorn, steak, chicken, salad... (I mean we could go on, but why steal away your creativity?)$6.00
RWPCo Red Pepper Flakes
Crushed red pepper is a pizzeria staple, but getting the seeds stuck does not have to be part of the deal! Our pulverized red pepper distributes evenly on your favorite pizza, pasta, BBQ...$6.00
RWPCo Seasoning Duo
Finish your own pizzas Red Wagon-style. Our house garlic salt and crushed red pepper are the perfect addition to any dish!$12.00
RWPCo Red Sauce
The heart of a good pizza is in the sauce, and you can find all our love in this one! Tomato, garlic, and all our favorite spices ready for your next pizza night! 16oz Glass Jar.$12.00OUT OF STOCK
T-Shirt 10 yr Anniversary
$35.00+
Wagon Glass
22oz wagon-etched glass. Adorable.$5.00
Spoodle
Merging the best qualities of a serving spoon and a ladle, this portion spoon provides unmatched convenience and consistency. The stainless steel construction is built to stand up to continued use. (4oz.)$12.00
Beverage
Take-Out Beverage

12oz J's Kombucha - Rasp-Lime-Ginger (Can)
Stellar flavor constellations unfold as raspberry, lime and ginger coalesce in a multitude of enchanting harmonies.$8.00
15.5oz Yerba Mate - Bluephoria (Can)
Bluephoria provides a euphoric burst of blueberry, elderberry, and yerba mate. High Energy Infusion: The strength of coffee, the health benefits of tea, and the euphoria of chocolate. Yerba mate contains 24 vitamins and minerals, 15 amino acids, and abundant polyphenols; yerba mate nourishes while it stimulates.$8.00
200mL Phony Negroni
Nuanced notes of Tuscan juniper, southern Italian citrus and florals provide slightly sweet and herbal notes, with a familiar backbone of bitterness Negroni enthusiasts expect. These layered botanicals paired with a touch of carbonation provide a silky mouthfeel that mimics the bite of alcohol.$13.00
500mL San Pellegrino (Bottle)
$6.00
8.4oz PARCH Prickly Paloma (Can)
A citrus and bittersweet cocktail that showcases the lively pairing of Organic Blue Weber Agave, Prickly Pear Cactus Fruit, Grapefruit & Orange Bitters, Lime juice, floral-tart Hibiscus and Desert Botanicals.$10.00
8oz 3LECHE Tonic Water (Can)
$5.50
8oz Ispahan (Can)
Raspberry, cocoa nib, lychee, & guava$9.00
ORDER NOTES
Utensils & Napkins
If you use a credit card, Red Wagon Pizza Co 5416 Penn Ave S will charge an additional 3.00% ($0.00) to help offset processing costs. This amount is not more than what Red Wagon Pizza Co 5416 Penn Ave S pays in fees.
All hours
| Sunday | 11:00 am - 9:00 pm |
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | 4:00 pm - 9:00 pm |
| Wednesday | 4:00 pm - 9:00 pm |
| Thursday | 4:00 pm - 9:00 pm |
| Friday | 11:00 am - 9:00 pm |
| Saturday | 11:00 am - 9:00 pm |
Restaurant info
Serving Happiness in South Minneapolis.
Location
5416 Penn Ave S, Minneapolis, MN 55419
© 2026 Toast, Inc.








