Skip to Main content
  • Righteous Slice Rexburg

    Righteous Slice Rexburg
    • Home
    • /
    • Rexburg
    • /
    • Righteous Slice
    Restaurant banner image
    Pizza

    Righteous Slice

    175 W. 2nd South Ste 100

    Rexburg, ID 83440


    Orders through Toast are commission free and go directly to this restaurant


    phone icon

    Call

    clock icon

    Hours

    waypoint sign icon

    Directions

    gift icon

    Gift Cards

    Appetizers
    Drinks
    Salads
    New York Pizzas
    Neapolitan Pizzas
    Desserts
    Shakes
    Extras

    Featured Items

    • New York Pepperoni Pizza

      Giant, hand-stretched pizza topped with naturally sweet California tomatoes, our house blend of cheeses, and more than 100 cup-and-char pepperonis, baked at 600 degrees in our electric deck oven.

      $25.00
    • Neapolitan Bee Sting

      Oregano, assorted spicy Italian cured meats, ricotta, Howell’s Honey, fior di latte, pecorino Romano, crushed San Marzano tomato sauce

      $15.00
    • Cheesy Garlic Bread (V)

      Hand stretched Italian pizza dough baked with shredded mozzarella, Romano cheese, garlic, olive oil and oregano (vegetarian)

      $8.00

    Appetizers

    • Cheesy Garlic Bread (V)

      Hand stretched Italian pizza dough baked with shredded mozzarella, Romano cheese, garlic, olive oil and oregano (vegetarian)

      $8.00

    Drinks

    • Fresh Squeezed Lemonade

      Bright, fresh lemons squeezed in-house just like Grandma used to make poured over chewy ice in a 16 oz cup.

      $3.00
    • Raspberry Lemonade

      Our fresh squeezed lemonade with a sweet shot of our homemade raspberry sauce.

      $5.00
    • San Pellegrino

      Imported from Italy, like many of the best things in life, these lightly carbonated beverages are flavored with real fruit and other things that taste good.

      $2.75
    • Mexican Coke

      This is the real deal imported from Mexico. If you haven't tried it you haven't really tasted Coca Cola!

      $2.75
    • Regular Fountain Drink

      24 ounces of refreshing Pepsi products. Choose from the classics or find an exciting new flavor.

      $2.95
    • Large Fountain Drink

      32 ounces of refreshing Pepsi products. Just right to quench your thirst for Righteousness.

      $3.35

    Salads

    • Fresca (V)

      Fresh baby arugula, mixed greens, strawberries, finely grated Parmesan, candied nuts with sweet balsamic reduction (vegetarian)

      $12.00
    • Hail Caesar

      Romaine, Parmesan, pancetta and Caesar dressing on a fresh baked focaccia

      $15.00
    • Side Salad (V)

      A small portion of crisp Romaine with grape tomatoes, finely grated Parmesan and choice of dressing.

      $5.00
    • The Italian Job

      Mixed greens, provolone, fresh mozzarella, finely grated Parmesan, pancetta, pepperoni, ham, tomatoes, imported Castelvetrano green olives, onion, pepperoncini topped with a sweet balsamic reduction

      $16.00

    New York Pizzas

    New York Pizzas (Serves 3 - 4 people)

    • New York Bee Sting

      Zoe's Meats spicy salami, Ezzo cup-and-char pepperoni, our award winning tomato sauce and house blend of cheeses, finished with Howell's Honey and dollops of ricotta.

      $32.00
    • New York Che Figata

      Featuring Point Reyes Blue cheese, Parmesan, fresh and sliced mozzarella, and provolone cheeses with fig spread and a swirl of balsamic. No Sauce. Inspired by Tony Gemignani's Cal Italia.

      $25.00
    • New York Cheese Pizza (V)

      This wonder will bring back memories of a bygone era with hand-stretched dough, sweet tomato sauce, and our house blend of cheeses. Baked at 600 degrees in our electric deck oven. Second place Northwest Region, International Pizza Challenge 2022.

      $19.00
    • New York Forbidden Fruit

      Does pineapple go on pizza? It does on this one! Fresh, hand-cut pineapple, pepperoni, jalapeños and ricotta give this week's special a little sweet and a little heat.

      $32.00
    • New York Godfather

      This is a pizza you can't refuse. House-made meatballs, pepperoni, roasted mushrooms, provolone, and Parmesan with mozzarella and red sauce.

      $32.00
    • New York Hang Ten

      Fresh hand-cut pineapple, thinly sliced ham, and thin cut red onions with red sauce and our house blend of cheeses.

      $28.00
    • New York Hog Heaven

      House made sausage, thinly sliced cooked ham, and pepperoni with our sweet tomato red sauce, house cheese blend. Baked at 600 degrees in our electric deck oven.

      $32.00
    • New York Humble Pie

      House-made sweet Italian sausage and thin sliced red onion with red sauce and house blend of cheeses cooked in our Pizza Master electric deck oven at 600 degrees.

      $25.00
    • New York Margherita

      This is NOT your traditional Margherita pizza. Our New York style crust is topped with sweet tomato sauce, house blend of cheese, olive oil and fresh basil.

      $25.00
    • New York Meat Your Maker

      Eat, drink, and be merry ... this one has ALL the meats -- Ezzo pepperoni, Zoe's spicy salami, house made Italian sausage, meatballs, pancetta, and ham with tomato sauce and our house blend of cheeses.

      $45.00
    • New York Pepperoni Pizza

      Giant, hand-stretched pizza topped with naturally sweet California tomatoes, our house blend of cheeses, and more than 100 cup-and-char pepperonis, baked at 600 degrees in our electric deck oven.

      $25.00
    • New York Praise the Lard

      Spicy salami, house-made Italian sausage, pancetta (Italian bacon), mozzarella, red sauce, Parmesan, and basil.

      $34.00
    • New York Spud Harvest

      House-made sweet Italian sausage, potato, rosemary, on our house blend of cheeses, finished with fresh baby arugula & finely grated Parmesan

      $28.00
    • New York Sweet Italian

      House-made sweet Italian sausage, thin sliced red onion, and our house blend of cheeses.

      $25.00
    • New York True Believer

      Pepperoni and mushroom, two of Nature's finest flavors, on a bed of our house blend of cheeses and naturally sweet red tomato sauce cooked at 600 degrees in our Pizza Master deck oven.

      $25.00
    • The Zealot

      For the pizza lover who wants it all -- pepperoni, sausage, ham, mushrooms, onions, Castelvetrano green olives and sweet bell peppers with red sauce and our house blend of cheeses. Baked at 600 degrees in our Pizza Master electric oven.

      $34.00
    • New York BYO Pizza

      Want to chart your own course and express your inner pizza chef? Add toppings and finishes to your heart's content. BYO options may be priced higher than similar items from our standard menu.

      $19.00

    Neapolitan Pizzas

    Neapolitan Pizzas (Serves 1 - 2 people)

    • Neapolitan Bee Sting

      Oregano, assorted spicy Italian cured meats, ricotta, Howell’s Honey, fior di latte, pecorino Romano, crushed San Marzano tomato sauce

      $15.00
    • Neapolitan Capricciosa

      Ham, artichoke, kalamata olive, mushroom, fior di latte, pecorino Romano, crushed San Marzano tomato sauce, basil, olive oil

      $15.00
    • Neapolitan Che Figata! (V)

      Fior di latte, Point Reyes Blue Cheese, shredded mozzarella-provolone blend, Romano cheese, fig spread, & balsamic. No sauce

      $12.00
    • Neapolitan Cheese Pizza

      $10.00
    • Neapolitan Forbidden Fruit

      Fresh, hand cut pineapple with pepperoni, jalapeno peppers, and finished with ricotta.

      $15.00
    • Neapolitan Godfather

      A pizza you can't refuse. House-made sweet Italian meatballs, cup-and-char pepperoni, shredded mozzarella-provolone blend, mushrooms, pecorino Romano, crushed San Marzano tomato sauce, oregano

      $15.00
    • Neapolitan Hang Ten

      Ham, pineapple, & fire roasted onion, shredded mozzarella-provolne blend, pecorino Romano, crushed San Marzano tomato sauce, oregano

      $13.00
    • Neapolitan Hog Heaven

      House-made sausage, sliced ham, and pepperoni with red sauce and our house blend of cheeses.

      $15.00
    • Neapolitan Humble Pie

      House-made sweet Italian sausage and thin sliced red onion with red sauce and our house blend of cheeses.

      $13.00
    • Neapolitan Margherita (V)

      Fior di latte, pecorino Romano, crushed San Marzano tomato sauce, basil, olive oil (vegetarian)

      $10.00
    • Neapolitan Marinara (VE)

      No cheese, extra San Marzano tomato sauce, olive oil, oregano and garlic (vegan)

      $9.00
    • Neapolitan Pepperoni

      Red sauce, shredded mozzarella-provolone blend, Romano cheese, oregano, DOUBLE cup-and-char pepperoni, oregano

      $12.00
    • Neapolitan Popeye (V)

      House made basil pesto, spinach, artichoke, fior di latte, provolone & lemon will build your muscles and put a smile on your face. Allergen alert: Our basil pesto contains pine nuts and/or walnuts.

      $15.00
    • Neapolitan Praise the Lard

      Spicy salami, house-made sweet Italian sausage, & pancetta (Italian bacon), fresh mozzarella, pecorino Romano, crushed San Marzano tomato sauce, basil, oregano, olive oil

      $16.00
    • Neapolitan Spud Harvest

      House-made sweet Italian sausage, potato, fresh mozzarella, Romano cheese, rosemary, olive oil finished with fresh baby arugula & finely grated Parmesan

      $14.00
    • Neapolitan Sweet Italian

      House-made sweet Italian sausage, fire roasted onion, fresh mozzarella, olive oil.

      $12.00
    • Neapolitan True Believer

      Pepperoni and mushroom, two of nature's finest flavors, on a bed of our house blend of cheeses and naturally sweet tomato sauce.

      $13.00
    • Neapolitan Build Your Own Pizza

      Shredded cheese blend, oregano, Romano cheese and olive oil topped with your choice of Righteousness

      $9.50

    Desserts

    • Star Witness

      Stunning star-shaped creation with Nutella, cream, & raw sugar baked and then drizzled with warm Nutella and sprinkled with powdered sugar (vegetarian)

      $12.00

    Shakes

    Rexburg’s famous shakes, only at Righteous Slice
    • Banana Cream Pie

      Fresh slices of real banana swirled with house-made graham cracker crumble crust.

      $6.00
      OUT OF STOCK
    • Cookie Monster

      Me want cookie! Homemade cookie dough and crumbled Oreo in an icy blue swirl of soft vanilla ice cream.

      $6.00
      OUT OF STOCK
    • Grasshopper

      Refreshing mint and crunchy Oreo cookies. This is one shake your can master, young Grasshopper.

      $6.00
      OUT OF STOCK
    • Huckleberry Cheesecake

      The sweetest lie you’ll ever swallow. Fake huckleberry syrup, canned blueberry pie filling, and frozen cheesecake bits. Too good to be true.

      $6.00
      OUT OF STOCK
    • Nutella Brownie

      Ciao amici! Homemade brownie and Nutella. Prego!

      $6.00
      OUT OF STOCK
    • Raspberries -n- Cream

      Homemade raspberry sauce gives this shake the sass your momma tried to slap out of you.

      $6.00
      OUT OF STOCK
    • Reese's & Peanut Butter

      This baby is peanut butter forward. We take authentic Reese's Peanut Butter Cups and add a scoop of real peanut butter to make your peanut buttery chocolaty dreams come true.

      $6.00
      OUT OF STOCK
    • S'Mores

      Homemade chocolate fudge sauce and graham cracker crumble with marshmallow cream -- better than the campfire favorite treat.

      $6.00
      OUT OF STOCK
    • Salted Caramel Brownie

      Caramel and salt. We didn't invent either of these things. But we did put them with brownies. Were we the first to do it? Probably. But if not, we also did it. Yum.

      $6.00
      OUT OF STOCK
    • Pumpkin Pie

      You've never had a pumpkin pie shake like this! Real, homemade pumpkin pie, made by a real grandma shoved into a generous portion of soft sever and mixed just right, with a dash of cinnamon. Mmmmm boy!

      $7.00
      OUT OF STOCK

    Extras

    • Crushed Red Pepper Packet

      A tiny packet that packs a punch, these Flatiron peppers will light you up!

      $0.25
    • Howell's Honey Cup (2 oz)

      Honey tastes better when it's local. That's why we source our Honey from Howell's Honey Farm, right here in Rexburg.

      $2.00
    • Ranch Cup (3.25 oz)

      There's no ranch like home made ranch, and ours is just that. Home made. Take that, factory made ranch.

      $2.00
    • Caesar Cup (3.25 oz)

      A great Caesar dressing is house-made. Ours in not. But it's good. Really good.

      $2.00
    • Marinara Cup (3.25 oz)

      Marinara means "of the sea" in Italian. Well, maybe not exactly that. But something to do with sailors. Our marinara sauce is made from Italian tomatoes that are grown near the sea. Maybe that's why they call it "marinara." We don't really know.

      $1.00
    • Balsamic Cup (2 oz)

      $2.00
    • Olive Oil Cup (2 oz)

      We use CORTO Truly extra virgin olive oil from California. Harvested at the peak of flavor and produced with craftsmanship, this olive oil is smooth and a little peppery.

      $2.00
    • Basil Pesto Cup 3.25 oz

      Vibrant fresh basil, pure extra virgin olive oil, hard grated cheese, and crushed walnuts make this pesto one-of-a-kind.

      $3.00
    • Nutella Cup 3.25 oz

      This cup of Nutella is a regular cup of Nutella, with nothing added and nothing special. But if you want it, we will make it for you.

      $2.00

    All hours
    SundayClosed
    Monday11:00 am - 9:00 pm
    Tuesday11:00 am - 9:00 pm
    Wednesday11:00 am - 9:00 pm
    Thursday11:00 am - 9:00 pm
    Friday11:00 am - 10:00 pm
    Saturday11:00 am - 10:00 pm
    Restaurant info

    We’re pizza extremists — we strive to create something special, memorable, genuine. We hope you find that we are unlike anything else. And we sincerely hope you love it.

    Location

    175 W. 2nd South Ste 100, Rexburg, ID 83440

    Directions


    Similar restaurants in your area

    Lucy's NY Pizza - Roberts 2874 E 650 N
    View restaurantnext
    Papa Q’s Yellowstone Food Village
    View restaurantnext
    Lucy's NY Pizza - Hitt 2770 S 25th E
    View restaurantnext
    Lucy's NY Pizza - Broadway
    View restaurantnext
    U Pick Red Barn Bread Barn & Pizza 2726 Rollandet St
    View restaurantnext
    Sauce
    View restaurantnext
    Search similar restaurants
    © 2025 Toast, Inc.
    Toast
    • About Toast
    • For restaurants
    • Terms of Service
    • Privacy Statement
    • Do not sell my
      personal information
    Made with love in Boston
    • Instagram
    • X (formerly Twitter)
    • Facebook