American
Rollie Pollie's
3421 University Ave
Star City, WV 26505
Orders through Toast are commission free and go directly to this restaurant
Hoagies and Sandwiches
Appalachian Roast Pork
Pulled roast pork on garlic bread with sauteed garlicky greens and aged provolone- smoky, messy, and built like Appalachia$8.99+OUT OF STOCKThe Throwback
Pulled Pork with pickles, red onions, banana peppers, and yellow mustard- a no-frills old school banger with just enough bite to keep it loud$7.99+OUT OF STOCKThe Oots
Classic Italian Beef House-shaved beef tenderloin stacked hot with melted provolone, spicy giardiniera and a side of au jus for the full dip-drip experience$9.99+F.B.I
A full blown Italian riot- capicola, salami, mortadella, pepperoni, two cheeses, chip for the crunch factor, lettuce, tomato, onion, mayo, ranch vinaigrette, pepper relish$8.99+The Lamonica
A crispy chicken cutlet knockout on garlic bread loaded with garlicky greens, melted mozzarella, aged provolone, and a balsamic finish that hits rich, sharp, and loud$9.99+Parmageddon
A red-sauce wrecking ball- crispy fried chicken, melty mozzarella, sharp parmesan, and marinara on garlic bread, built sloppy in the best possible way$9.99+Big Hoss
Slow-roasted pulled pork with sweet-smoky BBQ, pickles, red onions- sticky, tangy, and straight up built to make a mess$8.99+OUT OF STOCKPo' Mountain Boy
Juicy shrimp fried stacked with lettuce, tomato, dill pickle, and Cajun ranch- a coastal-style handheld with West Virginia attitude$9.99+WV Chopped Cheese
An NY street legend migrated to Appalachia- chopped Angus beef, melty American, fried onions, lettuce, tomato, and holler sauce$10.99+Traditional BLT
A proper bacon-stacked BLT on grilled Texas toast- crispy, juicy, mayo-heavy and built the way a BLT should be when you're not playing cheap$7.99+
CheeseSteaks
All cheesesteaks are made with house shaved beef tenderloin or shaved antibiotic free chicken breast
Classic
The straight-up classic- shaved steak or chicken, sweet sauteed onions, melty yellow cheese, built hot and heavy the way a proper cheesesteak should be$8.99+MotownPhilly
A pepper loaded classic with attitude- shaved steak or chicken, sweet onions, tri-color peppers, banana peppers, and yellow American$8.99+Buffalo Soldier
Garlic bread, buffalo heat, pepper jack, and a cool ranch finish- a loud, messy cheesesteak that punches first, and asked questions later$9.99+Truffle Shuffle
A rich, funky monster- shaved steak or chicken on garlic bread with sauteed onions, portobellos, mozzarella, parmesan, and our famous truffle kissed chubby sauce$9.99+Smokehole
Sweet smoky BBQ, melty cheddar, tangy slaw, and crunchy fried onions piled over shaved steak or chicken- a backroads BBQ cheesesteak with some bite$9.99+Almost Heaven
A full-send comfort bomb- shaved steak or chicken mixed with creamy mac 'n ' cheese- hot, heavy and absolutely not here to be subtle$9.99+Crack
A full on guilty pleasure cheesesteak- bacon, American, mozzarella, cream cheese and ranch piled over shaved steak or chicken, it's completely off the rails$9.99+Gee Whiz
A creamy, drippy, cheese-bomb cheesesteak- shaved steak or chicken, sweet onions, yellow American, and house cheese sauce melting into every bite$9.99+
Burgers
All burgers are half pound ground chuck and brisket mix served on Texas toast or served medium unless you specify otherwise.
Consuming raw or undercooked meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish, or eggs may increase your risk of foodborne illness, especially if you have certain medical conditions.
The OG
A no BS charbroiled burger on Texas toast topped to your liking- beefy, juicy and built to let the fire do the talking$10.99+Wake & Bake'N
A hangover hero- charbroiled burger, American cheese stuffed bacon, fried egg, ketchup, mayo$14.99+Shroom N' Swiss
Charbroiled beef, buttery portobellos, creamy Swiss on grilled Texas toast- simple, rich, and built like a diner burger that grew up in the hills of WV$13.99+The Frenchie
A charbroiled boil gone full French onion- sauteed sweet onions, mozzarella, provolone, topped with crispy fried onions and au jus for dunking$13.99+The Smokeshow
Sending smoke signals- charbroiled burger stacked with smoked cheddar, bacon, onion rings, pulled pork, and Southwest ranch$15.99+OUT OF STOCKNapalm
Hot, sloppy and it will set you ablaze- pepper jack, pepper relish, jalapenos, grilled banana peppers, and chipotle ranch$14.99+Bigfoot
A double decker double stack monster- two charbroiled patties, bacon, American, provolone, lettuce, tomato, onion, pickle, and holler sauce. This one will leave tracks$19.99+
Chicken Sammies
MTO Chicken Sammie
Straight up chicken sandwich on grilled Texas toast- juicy grilled or crispy fried. Built as your blank canvas to load up however you want$9.99+OG Chicken Sammie
Can't go wrong- juicy grilled or crispy fried chicken with lettuce, pickles, and holler sauce$10.99+Buff Chick Sammie
A hot-and-cool chicken sandwich done right. Grilled or crispy fried chicken, loaded with buffalo heat, smoked cheddar, mozzarella, lettuce, pickles, and ranch$11.99+The Smokehole Chicken Sammie
Sweet Smoky Crunchy- Stacked with pickles, onions, French fried onions, smoked cheddar, Southwest ranch$12.99+Chickie Parm
Hot marinara, melted mozzarella and provolone and a hit of parmesan. A messy red sauce classic$12.99+
Salads
Consuming raw or undercooked meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish, or eggs may increase your risk of foodborne illness, especially if you have certain medical conditions.
Motown Steak Salad
A full-blown meal piled high with char-grilled Beef Tenderloin, fries, mozzarella, cheddar, hard boiled egg, beets, cucumbers, pepperoncini, tomatoes, pickled red onion, and croutons, crunch and freshness in every bite.$15.99Motown Chicken Salad
A loaded chicken salad that eats like a full meal — grilled chicken piled high with fries, tomatoes, cucumbers, cheeses, hard boiled egg, beets, pickled red onion, pepperoncini, and croutons.$14.99Veggie Bomb
A loaded no-meat salad piled with fries, cheeses, beets, pepperoncini, tomatoes, cucumbers, and pickled red onions — it eats like a meal, not a side.$12.99Side Salad
Mixed greens, tomato, cucumber, pickled red onions, beets, pepperoncini, mixed cheese$4.99
Egg Rolls
All egg rolls come one per order. Small burrito size. The OG Rollie Pollie favorites. This is how it all started.
CANNOT BE MODIFIED
Crack Chicken
Our famous crack chicken packed heavy with grilled chicken, bacon, cream cheese, mozzarella, cheddar, and ranch. Rich crunchy and extremely addictive$8.99Buff Chick
Grilled chicken, buffalo sauce, mozzarella, cheddar, and a hint of ranch. Spicy, cheesy, and built to hit hard$7.99Pierollgie
A classic comfort staple. Mashed potatoes, fried onions, cheddar. Simple but delicious$7.99Motownphilly
Shaved steak, sauteed onions, peppers, and cheese. A cheesesteak you can crush with one hand$8.99Mountaineer Mac
BBQ pulled pork and house made mac 'n' cheese. Simple, rich, straight up comfort$7.99Return of the Mac
If a hug was edible. House made Mac 'n' Cheese wrapped up and fried to perfection$7.99Pepperollie
Shredded pepperoni, mozzarella, and provolone$7.99
Vegan and Vegetarian
We try to include something delicious for everyone!
Steakless Cheesesteak?
A meatless monster loaded with portobellos, chickpeas, sautéed onions, and melty cheese (vegan cheese available) — hearty, messy, and built like the real deal. You will Swear You're Cheating!$8.99+Portobello Burger
A big grilled marinated portobello cap with real burger energy — smoky, juicy, and built to hit like a meatless heavyweight on Grilled Texas Toast$8.99+OUT OF STOCKChickpea and Black Bean Burger
A house made meatless burger with real bite — ground chickpeas, black beans, and bold flavor on Texas toast or wrapped up your way. May turn some Carnivores to the other side.$9.99+Return of the Mac Egg Roll
If a hug was edible. House made Mac 'n' Cheese wrapped up and fried to perfection$7.99Pierollgie Egg Roll
A classic comfort staple. Mashed potatoes, fried onions, cheddar. Simple but delicious$7.99Veggie Bomb Salad
A loaded no-meat salad piled with fries, cheeses, beets, pepperoncini, tomatoes, cucumbers and pickled red onions — it eats like a meal, not a side.$12.99Side Salad
Mixed greens, tomato, cucumber, red onions, beets, pepperonicini, mixed (or vegan) cheese.$4.99Plain Jane Mac Bowl
A full-size bowl of creamy house mac and cheese, finished hot with extra cheese and Toasted Bread Crumbs on top — big, rich, and built to eat like a meal.$10.99Pickle Ricks
Seven baby dill pickles wrapped in wontons, fried crispy, and served with house ranch — crunchy, briny, and stupidly snackable.$7.99Bigg Mozz
Huge fried mozzarella sticks with a crispy shell and a melty center — cheesy, stretchy, and built to steal the table.$10.99Hot Pepper Cheese Logs
Crispy panko-breaded hot pepper cheese logs served with honey mustard — melty, spicy, and built to bite back$9.99Portobello Fries
Crispy panko-breaded portobello strips served hot with house ranch or horseradish cream sauce — earthy, crunchy, and way more addictive than they have any right to be.$11.99OUT OF STOCKRingers
Hand cut double battered onion rings fried golden and served with holler sauce— crispy, salty, and built for the kind of table that steals each other’s food.$8.99Veggie Potheads
5 Crispy Veggie filled potstickers served with a side of house tso$8.99Plain Jane Fries
Fresh Cut Curly Fries$2.99+Shore Fries
Fresh-cut fries hit with malt vinegar, Old Bay aioli, and parsley — salty, tangy, and built with straight-up boardwalk energy.$10.99Snappy Crab Fries
Fresh-cut fries hit with garlic sauce and Old Bay — salty, buttery, and built with full-on boardwalk energy.$10.99Chubby Chasers Fries
Fresh-cut fries loaded with Parmesan, Chubby Sauce, scallions, and a balsamic glaze finish — creamy, salty, tangy, and ridiculously addictive.$10.99Joe Mama Fries
Fresh-cut fries tossed in Joe Sauce — messy, punchy, and the kind of side that stops being a side real fast.$10.99Ranch-Rageous Fries
Fresh-cut fries dusted in dry ranch and hit with house ranch, scallions, and dill — cool, herby, and way more addictive than they should be.$10.99
Mac Bowls
All Mac Bowls are Over the Top Cheesy, Melty and served in 50 oz bowls. Smaller portions of Regular Mac and Cheese can be found is Apps, Sides, and Shareables
Plain Jane Mac Bowl
A full-size bowl of creamy house mac and cheese, finished hot with extra cheese— big, rich, and built to eat like a meal.$10.99Buff Chick Mac Bowl
A big bowl of creamy mac loaded with grilled or fried chicken, buffalo heat, and a cool ranch finish — rich, messy, and built to hit every time.$14.99Motownphilly Mac Bowl
A monster bowl of creamy mac loaded with shaved steak or chicken, peppers, onions, and extra cheese sauce — basically a cheesesteak and mac bowl had a beautiful accident.$14.99+Boss Hog Mac Bowl
A giant bowl of creamy mac piled with pulled pork, sweet-smoky BBQ, Bacon and crunchy fried onions — heavy, messy, nap-worthy.$14.99OUT OF STOCKCrack Mac Bowl
A giant bowl of creamy mac loaded with chicken, bacon, cream cheese, and ranch topped with Mozzarella— rich, reckless, and impossible to eat politely. Order with caution you may become addicted!$14.99Rita Mac
A Sunday-dinner style mac bowl loaded with chopped fried chicken cutlet, marinara, mozzarella, aged provolone, grated Parmesan, and garlic toast — rich, comforting, and made in loving memory of my Nana Rita.$14.99
Fries
Our famous fresh cut curly fries!
Plain Jane Fries
Fresh-cut fries fried golden and served hot — simple, crispy, and never just an afterthought.$2.99+Cheese Fries
A big pile of fresh-cut fries drenched in our house cheese sauce — simple, sloppy, and exactly what cheese fries should be.$9.99Loaded Fries
A mountain of fresh-cut fries smothered in house cheese sauce, bacon, and ranch, finished with scallions — sloppy, heavy, and built to disappear fast.$12.99Chubby Chasers
Fresh-cut fries loaded with Parmesan, Chubby Sauce, scallions, and a balsamic glaze finish — creamy, salty, tangy, and ridiculously addictive.$10.99Shore Fries
Fresh-cut fries hit with malt vinegar, Old Bay aioli, and parsley — salty, tangy, and built with straight-up boardwalk energy.$10.99Joe Mama Fries
Fresh-cut fries tossed in Joe Sauce — messy, punchy, and the kind of side that stops being a side real fast.$10.99Ranch-Rageous
Fresh-cut fries dusted in dry ranch and hit with house ranch, scallions, and dill — cool, herby, and way more addictive than they should be.$10.99Snappy Crab Fries
Fresh-cut fries hit with garlic sauce and Old Bay — salty, buttery, and built with full-on boardwalk energy.$10.99Motownphilly Fries
A full-on cheesesteak fry pile loaded with steak or chicken, onions, peppers, and house cheese sauce — messy, heavy, and built like a meal.$14.99+Squealer Fries
A full-blown pork-and-bacon fry pile loaded with BBQ, house cheese sauce, and scallions — smoky, cheesy, greasy, and exactly what it should be.$15.99OUT OF STOCKGubba Bumps
Snappy Crab Fries taken all the way up — fresh-cut fries with garlic sauce, Old Bay, and shrimp, built loud with straight boardwalk energy.$16.99+Pizza Fries
Fresh-cut fries buried under pepperoni, mozzarella, provolone, and red sauce — like a late-night pizza run crashed into a loaded fry basket.$12.99
Tendies and Shrimp
Apps, Shareables, & Sides
Bigg Mozz
Huge fried mozzarella sticks with a crispy shell and a melty center — cheesy, stretchy, and built to steal the table.$10.99Chicken Fried Bacon
4 pieces of thick cut slab bacon hand breaded and fried golden with your choice of dipping sauce$10.99Hot Pepper Cheese Logs
Crispy panko-breaded hot pepper cheese logs served with honey mustard — melty, spicy, and built to bite back$9.99Kettle Cooked Chips
$0.99Mac Daddy Fry Balls
Crispy fried mac and cheese balls served with Cajun ranch — crunchy outside, molten in the middle, and built like pure comfort.$9.99Pickle Ricks
Seven baby dill pickles wrapped in wontons, fried crispy, and served with house ranch — crunchy, briny, and stupidly snackable.$7.99Portobello Fries
Crispy panko-breaded portobello strips served hot with house ranch or horseradish cream sauce — earthy, crunchy, and way more addictive than they have any right to be.$11.99OUT OF STOCKPotheads
5 Crispy fried potstickers served hot with Tso Good sauce — crunchy outside, savory inside, and built to disappear fast.$8.99+Ringers
Hand cut double battered onion rings fried golden and served with holler sauce — crispy, salty, and built for the kind of table that steals each other’s food.$8.99Side of Greens
$3.99Side of Mac n Cheese
$3.99
Kiddos
Kid Dog
A simple kid-size hot dog done right — no fuss, no nonsense, just an easy win.$7.99Kid Mac
A kid-size bowl of creamy mac and cheese — simple, cheesy, and always a safe bet.$8.99Kid Tenders
Two jumbo hand-breaded tenders served with your choice of side — crispy, juicy, and kid-approved.$8.99Kid Grilled Cheese
Buttery grilled Texas toast stuffed with melty cheese and served with a kid-size side — simple, classic, and always a win.$7.99Kiddie Burger
A simple kid-size burger done right, served with your choice of side.$9.99PB&J
A classic crunchy peanut butter and red raspberry jelly sandwich with your choice of side — simple, nostalgic, and always an easy win.$7.99
Drinks
Desserts
Mothman's Molten Mystery
Peanut butter and jelly encased in egg roll wrappers and fried crispy. Watch out- it's not an omen, it's just raspberry jam.$7.99The Flatwoods Fried Phantom
A mysterious encounter of peanut butter and marshmallow fluf, encased in egg roll wrappers and fried crispy. It's out of this world, but found right here in the hills.$7.99
All hours
| Sunday | 12:00 pm - 5:00 pm |
| Monday | 11:00 am - 2:00 pm |
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | Closed |
| Thursday | 11:00 am - 8:00 pm |
| Friday | 11:00 am - 9:00 pm |
| Saturday | 12:00 pm - 9:00 pm |
Restaurant info
Two Ingredients: Flavor and Love
Location
© 2026 Toast, Inc.
Made with 
in Boston
in Boston
