
American
Sarabeth's Upper West Side
423 Amsterdam Avenue
New York, NY 10024
Orders through Toast are commission free and go directly to this restaurant
DINNER
Appetizers

Velvety Tomato Soup
cheddar cheese, dill$16.00
Meatballs
pomodoro, basil$17.00
Crispy Calamari
spicy marinara, garlic aioli$20.00
Bang Bang Shrimp
ginger, sweet chili, avocado, micro mint$15.00Baby Beet Salad
herb goat cheese, raspberries, orange-balsamic gastrique, baby watercress$16.00
Guacamole & Chips
$20.00Burrata
maple roasted squash, hazelnut crumble, cranberry gastrique, verjus grapes$18.00
Crab & Guacamole
homemade chips$22.00
Salads

5 Lettuce Caesar Salad
shaved Parmesan, garlic & herb croutons$16.00
Sarabeths Chopped Salad
cherry tomatoes, cucumbers, onion, garbanzo beans, red peppers, salami, feta, kalamata olives, lemon oregano vinaigrette$19.00
Power Bowl
shredded kale, quinoa, pistachios, apples, beets, goat cheese, sherry shallot vinaigrette$19.00
Seafood Cobb Salad
Main Lobster, crab meat, shrimp, avocado, bacon, egg, tomato, onion, blue cheese$33.00
Sammy's & Entrees

Classic Lobster Roll
remoulade, coleslaw, chips$36.00
Adult Grilled Cheese
3 cheeses, pretzel bread, house-made pickles, velvety tomato soup$24.00
One Great Burger
aged cheddar, pickled green tomatoes, bacon, jalapeño marmalade, sautéed onions, house cut french fries$25.00
Steak Frites
steak, house cut fries, béarnaise sauce$36.00
Faroe Island Salmon
pee wee potatoes, saffron cauliflower puree, dill oil$32.00
Farm Chicken
confit chicken croquette, vegetable saute, herb jus$29.00
Chicken Pot Pie
wild mushrooms, rainbow carrots, fingerling potatoes, herb béchamel$29.00
Crab Cake Sandwich
sesame bun. tartar sauce. house cut french fries$27.00
Pan Seared Branzino
artichoke hearts, fava beans, couscous, saffron tomato broth$31.00OUT OF STOCKJumbo Shrimp Scampi Bucatini
sun gold tomatoes, capers, scallions, spicy herb breadcrumbs$28.00
Sides
BEVERAGES
Coffee

Latte
$7.00
Cappuccino
$7.00
Espresso
$4.75
Double Espresso
$7.50
Macchiatto
$5.00
Cortado
$6.00
Moccha
$7.00
Americano
$6.00
Cafe Au Lait
$5.00
Flat White
$5.50
Iced Decaf Coffee
$5.00
Iced Latte
$7.00
Iced Cappuccino
$6.00
Iced Americano
$7.00
Hot Tea
$5.00
Iced Tea
$5.00
Hot Chocolate
$8.00
Milk
$4.00
Chocolate Milk
$5.00
Chai Latte
$8.00
Iced Chai Latte
$8.00
To Go Coffee
$5.00
To Go Decaf Coffee
$5.00
To Go Cold Brew
$6.00
Lavender Latte
$7.00Pumpkin Spice Latte
$7.00Pumpkin Spice Cappuccino
$7.00Vanilla Latte
$7.00Vanilla Cappuccino
$7.00
Juice & Mocktails
DESSERTS
Sarabeth's Desserts

Chocolate Truffle Cake
strawberry raspberry sauce$14.00
Apple Crostata
apple crostata, vanilla gelato, caramel sauce$14.00
Locally Made Gelato & Sorbet
Seasonal sorbet, sea salt caramel gelato, vanilla gelato, chocolate gelato$14.00
Single Scoop of Gelato or Sorbet
Guests' choice of vanilla gelato, chocolate gelato, sea salt caramel gelato, and mango sorbet.$5.00Strawberry Almond Shortcake Sundae
toasted coconut, whipped cream, vanilla gelato$14.00
All hours
| Sunday | 8:00 am - 8:45 pm |
| Monday | 8:00 am - 9:45 pm |
| Tuesday | 8:00 am - 9:45 pm |
| Wednesday | 8:00 am - 9:45 pm |
| Thursday | 8:00 am - 9:45 pm |
| Friday | 8:00 am - 9:45 pm |
| Saturday | 8:00 am - 9:45 pm |
Restaurant info
Come in and enjoy!
Location
© 2026 Toast, Inc.






































