This restaurant does not have any images
Sandwiches
Shaffer's Deli
Pickup Only
Featured Items
All American Jr. Cheeseburger
Shaffer's perfectly seasoned & juicy fresh (NEVER FROZEN) one patty= 1/4 pound smash burger! With your choice of cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion, pickles, and your choice of condiments between a perfectly toasted burger bun. Add on fresh cut fries or tots for $1.50 more and make it a meal. Pictured is with Kelly's homemade chili sauce and nacho cheese for an extra charge.$8.00
Chicken Tender Sub/Wrap
Crispy Chicken Tenders, with your choice of sub or wrap (white or wheat), cheese, and includes shredded lettuce, tomato, and mayo.$7.00+Chopped Chicken, Bacon, Ranch
$15.00
Deli Sandwich Combos
Italiano
Ham, Salami, Pepperoni, Salad Peppers, House-made Aioli, between toasted and pressed bread.$16.00
Cuban "Cubano"
Smoked and hand pulled pork, Sliced Ham, Swiss cheese, dill pickles, and our house made cuban mustard on Ciabatta Bread. All deli sandwiches come with a dill pickle and choice of a side.$16.00
Reuben
Corned Beef, Pastrami or Turkey on toasted Jewish Rye, Marble Rye, or Italian bread smothered in sauerkraut, cheese, and Thousand Island. All deli sandwiches come with a dill pickle and choice of a side.$13.00+
Pastrami
Thin Sliced Pastrami, on marble rye or Italian bread with swiss cheese, pickles, spicy mustard or our house made creamy horseradish sauce. All deli sandwiches come with a dill pickle and choice of a side.$13.00+
Club
Sliced turkey, ham, bacon, your choice of cheese, lettuce, tomato, and mayo. All deli sandwiches come with a dill pickle and choice of a side.$13.00+
Smash Burgers
Patty Melt
This traditional patty melt is an American classic that bridges the gap between a cheeseburger and a grilled cheese sandwich. It consists of a fresh pressed 1/2 pound ground beef patty, deeply caramelized onions, melted Swiss cheese, topped with Thousand Island dressing, and all held together by two slices of perfectly toasted golden-brown Jewish Rye bread.$13.00
All-American Cheeseburger
Shaffer's perfectly seasoned & juicy fresh (NEVER FROZEN) two patty= 1/2 pound smash burger! With your choice of cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion, pickles, and your choice of condiments between a perfectly toasted burger bun. Add on fresh cut fries or tots for $1.50 more and make it a meal.$10.00All American Jr. Cheeseburger
Shaffer's perfectly seasoned & juicy fresh (NEVER FROZEN) one patty= 1/4 pound smash burger! With your choice of cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion, pickles, and your choice of condiments between a perfectly toasted burger bun. Add on fresh cut fries or tots for $1.50 more and make it a meal. Pictured is with Kelly's homemade chili sauce and nacho cheese for an extra charge.$8.00
Bacon Burger
Shaffer's perfectly seasoned & juicy fresh (NEVER FROZEN) two patty= 1/2 pound smash burger! With crispy fresh cooked bacon and your choice of cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion, pickles, and your choice of condiments between a perfectly toasted burger bun. Add on fresh cut fries or tots for $1.50 more and make it a meal.$12.00
Big Head Burger
Shaffer's perfectly seasoned & juicy fresh (NEVER FROZEN) three patty= 3/4 pound smash burger! With your choice of cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion, pickles, and your choice of condiments between a perfectly toasted burger bun. Add on fresh cut fries or tots for $1.50 more and make it a meal.$14.00
Chili & Cheese Burger
Shaffer's perfectly seasoned & juicy fresh (NEVER FROZEN) two patty= 1/2 pound smash burger! You get a choice of sliced cheese plus Kelly's homemade chili sauce, and nacho cheese, between a perfectly toasted burger bun. Add on fresh cut fries or tots for $1.50 more and make it a meal.$12.00
Chipotle Jalapeno Burger
Shaffer's perfectly seasoned & juicy fresh (NEVER FROZEN) two patty= 1/2 pound smash burger! With your choice of cheese, grilled onions & jalapenos, a delicious & spicy house made chipotle sauce, between a perfectly toasted burger bun. Add on fresh cut fries or tots for $1.50 more and make it a meal$12.00
Cowboy Burger
Shaffer's perfectly seasoned & juicy fresh (NEVER FROZEN) two patty= 1/2 pound smash burger! With your choice of cheese, crispy fresh cooked bacon, a crispy battered onion ring, lettuce, tomato, and BBQ sauce between a perfectly toasted burger bun. Add on fresh cut fries or tots for $1.50 more and make it a meal$12.00
Mushroom Swiss Burger
Shaffer's perfectly seasoned & juicy fresh (NEVER FROZEN) two patty= 1/2 pound smash burger! With Swiss cheese, grilled mushrooms, and mayo between a perfectly toasted burger bun. Add on fresh cut fries or tots for $1.50 more and make it a meal$12.00
Philly Burger
Shaffer's perfectly seasoned & juicy fresh (NEVER FROZEN) two patty= 1/2 pound smash burger! With provolone cheese, grilled fresh peppers & onions, and mayo between a perfectly toasted burger bun. Add on fresh cut fries or tots for $1.50 more and make it a meal$12.00
Shaffer's Chopped Signatures
Chopped Cheese
Our Signature Hot Sub. Chopped cheese is a New Yorker's comfort food. Shaffer's Deli brought it to Y-town. Our fresh burgers (3/4 pound) are grilled and chopped, mixed with sautéed onions, cheese (typical is American) is added and chopped, all placed inside a toasted bun slathered with ketchup & mayo, and topped with lettuce and tomato...and Bada Bing Chopped Cheese!$15.00
Chopped Italian
There’s something special about Shaffer's Chopped Italian. It’s everything you love about a classic Italian Sub, but taken up a notch! The Chopped Italian has bold flavors and a consistent, satisfying bite every time. It’ll be the best chopped Italian sub you’ve ever had!$15.00Chopped Chicken
Perfectly chopped, seasoned and grilled chicken breast mixed with your choice of cheese, veggies, condiments, and extra's$14.00Chopped Reuben
You won't be disappointed with this lean corned beef perfectly seasoned, chopped, cooked on the flattop with Swiss Cheese, Kraut, and Thousand Island!$15.00Chopped Pastrami
You won't be disappointed with this lean and smoky Pastrami, chopped, seasoned & cooked on the flattop, with Swiss cheese (or other cheese of your choice), and topped a house-made horseradish sauce or spicy mustard. Add one of our house made slaws for some extra zing!$15.00Chopped Chicken, Bacon, Ranch
$15.00
Chopped Turkey, Bacon, Ranch
Delicious and lean sliced turkey breast, heated and chopped on the grill with just the right seasonings, your choice of cheese, topped with crispy bacon, creamy ranch, and nestled between our fresh toasted bun.$15.00Chopped Turkey & Swiss
Delicious lean turkey breast chopped, perfectly seasoned & cooked on the flattop, with your choice of cheese, veggies, condiments, and extras.$15.00Chopped Ham & Cheese
Delicious & lean Virginia ham chopped with your choice of cheese, veggies, condiments, and extra's.$14.00
Hot Subs/Wraps
Meatball Splash or Sub (Kelly's Homemade)
Enjoy 3 of Kelly's large delicious homemade all beef meatballs, your choice of sliced cheese, topped with Kelly's homemade Italian sauce & Parmesan cheese. Choose in a Sub or on top of toasted Italian Bread "The Splash"OUT OF STOCK$13.00
Steak Philly
This delicious steak sub is filled with 8 oz of sliced sirloin perfectly cooked and seasoned, with a cheese of your choice, grilled peppers & onions, and mayo.$16.00
Chicken & Italian Greens (Kelly's Homemade)
Kelly's delicious Italian Greens (made in house) placed on top of our perfectly seasoned chicken with a gooey melted cheese of your choice and placed inside a toasted 8" sub.$13.00Chicken Philly
Seasoned & grilled chopped chicken breast with sautéed peppers & onions, cheese of choice, and mayo,$13.00Grilled Chicken
Chicken breast chopped, seasoned, and cooked on the flattop with melted cheese of your choice, hand cut tomatoes, shredded lettuce and mayo.$13.00
Buffalo Chicken Philly
Grilled chicken breast cooked with grilled peppers & onions, smothered in Buffalo Sauce, topped with three slices of melty cheese (your choice). Choose Sub or Wrap (White or Wheat)$13.00
Beer Battered Fish Sub
Delicious & Crispy 8.5 oz Beer Battered Haddock Sub includes fresh lettuce, tomato, tartar, and your choice of cheese.OUT OF STOCK$15.00
Chicken Parm Sub
Chicken tenders, cheese of your choice, homemade Italian sauce, and topped with parmesan cheese.$6.50+
Chicken Tender Melt
Four crispy chicken tenders, choice of cheese, bacon, and ranch inside toasted and pressed sub.$13.00Chicken Tender Sub/Wrap
Crispy Chicken Tenders, with your choice of sub or wrap (white or wheat), cheese, and includes shredded lettuce, tomato, and mayo.$7.00+
Pulled Pork
Smoky Pulled Pork shredded in house, with your choice of cheese, BBQ sauce, sliced pickles, and onions.$13.00
Shrimp Po' Boy
Sweet Battered Shrimp, Cheese of your choose, hand shredded lettuce, tomato, and a house made Remoulade sauce.$14.00
Cold Subs/Wraps
Italian
This sub has all of the Italian meats: Salami, Pepperoni, and Capicola, cheese of choice, fresh vegetables including shredded lettuce, tomatoes & red onions, and topped with Oil & Vinegar.$5.50+Deluxe
$5.50+Build Your Own Cold Sub/Wrap
Now you can build your own cold sub or wrap. You can add anything you want on it from the size, to the type of meat, cheese, & veggies, and anything extra. Have fun creating that special sub.
Wings
Bone In Wings (5)
These wings are crispy on the outside and tender, juicy, and meaty on the inside! They taste so good you might even want to leave them naked!$8.00
Bone in Wings (10)
These wings are crispy on the outside and tender, juicy, and meaty on the inside! They taste so good you might even want to leave them naked!$16.00
Boneless Wings 1 pound
These boneless wings are crispy on the outside and juicy & meaty on the inside! We have a variety of delicious sauce options or dry rubs. Try our homemade House-blend BBQ sauce. It's sweet with heat.$14.00
Boneless Wings half pound
These boneless wings are crispy on the outside and juicy & meaty on the inside! We have a variety of delicious sauce options or dry rubs. Try our Golden BBQ$7.50
Fried Sides
Fresh Cut Fries Large
Fries are fresh cut daily.$6.00Fresh Cut Fries Small
$3.00
Tator Tots Large
Crispy tator tots.$6.50Tator Tots Small
$3.50
Fried Mushrooms
Delicious battered mushrooms are deep fried to crispy perfection.$6.50
Fried Veggie Combo
Onion Rings, Mushrooms, Cauliflower, Zucchini$10.50
Mozzarella Sticks (5 jumbo)
$9.00
Onion Rings
Delicious crispy battered and fried onion rings.$6.50Family Size Fries
$9.00
House made Potato Chips
OUT OF STOCK$6.00+
Soup
Stuffed Pepper Soup
Kelly's homemade stuffed pepper soup will be sure to warm you up and the coldest of days. A blend of spices, fresh ground beef, tomatoes, onions, peppers, and jasmine rice creates a delicious flavorful soup.OUT OF STOCK$4.75+
Hearty Chicken Noodle Soup
Kelly's homemade hearty & thick chicken noodle soup. Chicken, onions, celery, carrots, and seasonings make up this delicious soup to warm your soul.OUT OF STOCK$4.75+Mac & Cheese (scratch made)
OUT OF STOCK$4.75+
Italian Wedding Soup
Delicious homemade wedding soup made with all beef meatballs, escarole, vegetables, and other seasonings to make this flavorful soup. Reminds you of Nona's.OUT OF STOCK$4.75+
Pretzel Bites
These delicious pretzel bites are crunchy on the outside and warm and soft on the inside. You can choose them to be coated in cinnamon & sugar paired with a side of Kelly's homemade cream cheese dip or get them lightly salted with your choice of topping or a dipping sauce on the side. (Pictured are the Cinnamon Sugar Pretzel Bites)
Salted Pretzel Bites
Soft on the inside yet crispy on the outside. Served warm and salted.$7.50
Cinnamon and Sugar Pretzel Bites
Craving something delicious, warm, and sweet? Soft on the inside and crunchy on the outside. Covered in cinnamon & sugar and served with our homemade cream cheese dip.OUT OF STOCK$7.50
Salads
Grilled Sirloin Steak Salad (fries included)
This delicious steak salad is filled with 8oz of sliced sirloin perfectly cooked and seasoned, fresh cut lettuce, tomato, cucumber, onion, mild peppers, shredded cheese, egg, and fresh cut friesOUT OF STOCK$17.00Chicken Tender Salad (fries included)
Fresh cut lettuce, tomato, onion, cucumber, mild peppers, shredded cheese, egg, chicken tenders, and fresh cut fries.OUT OF STOCK$15.00
Grilled Chicken Salad (fries included)
Fresh cut lettuce, tomato, onion, cucumber, mild peppers, shredded cheese, egg, grilled chicken breast (sliced in house), and fresh cut fries.OUT OF STOCK$16.00
Chef Salad (fries not included)
Fresh cut lettuce, tomato, cucumber, onion, mild peppers, shredded cheese, egg, sliced ham, turkey, and salamiOUT OF STOCK$15.00
Garden Salad (fries not included)
Fresh cut lettuce, tomato, cucumbers, onion, mild peppers, shredded cheese, and an egg.OUT OF STOCK$11.00Side Salad (fries not included)
Fresh cut iceburg lettuce, tomato, cucumber, onion, mild peppersOUT OF STOCK$3.75
Cold Sides
Killer Brownies
Chocolatier Brownie
A rich chocolate brownie made with premium milk chocolate chips—soft and moist with a thin crackle top.$3.00
The Brookie Brownie
Golden chocolate chip Killer Cookie™ baked atop rich chocolate chip fudge brownie. Soft on the inside with a slightly chewy edge.$3.00
Kitchen Sink Brownie
A layer of vanilla blonde brownie, mixed with rainbow sprinkles and topped with M&M'S® and mini chocolate chips, is baked atop a moist chocolate brownie.OUT OF STOCK$3.00
Cold Drinks
Arizona Half & Half-Arnold Palmer (bottle)
22 fluid oz$2.00
Lipton Sweet Tea (bottle)
22 fluid ozOUT OF STOCK$2.00
Unsweet Tea-Pure Leaf
$2.00
Peach Tea-Lipton
$2.00
Coca-Cola
Coca-Cola Original Taste — the crisp, refreshing taste you know and loveOUT OF STOCK$1.00
Coke Zero
Enjoy the great taste of Coca-Cola with zero sugar, zero calories$1.00
Diet Coke
Take a Diet Coke break with this refreshing, no-calorie soft drink$1.00
Crush Grape
$1.00
Crush Orange
$1.00Diet Dr. Pepper
$1.00Dr. Pepper
OUT OF STOCK$1.00
Mountain Dew
$1.00Mountain Dew Diet
$1.00
Mountain Dew Baja Blast
$1.00Mountain Dew Zero
$1.00
Rootbeer-A&W
$1.00
Sprite
Classic, cool, crisp lemon-lime flavored taste that's caffeine free$1.00
Sprite Zero
Clear, crisp lemon-lime flavored, zero sugar soda will keep you refreshed and inspiredOUT OF STOCK$1.00
Water-Bottled
$1.00
All hours
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | 11:00 am - 5:00 pm |
| Wednesday | 11:00 am - 5:00 pm |
| Thursday | 11:00 am - 5:00 pm |
| Friday | 11:00 am - 5:00 pm |
| Saturday | 11:00 am - 3:00 pm |
Restaurant info
The Shaffer Trio (Mark, Kelly, and Dominic) are proud of our commitment to creating high quality foods as our passion for flavor shines through each and every product we create. Using only the finest locally sourced ingredients our talented chefs create an array of mouthwatering menu options that cater to all palates such as “The Reuben” loaded with thinly sliced corned beef and topped with our secret tangy sauce. You can also choose from one of our juicy signature smash burgers (always fresh and never frozen), a variety of 16” subs, and sides to accompany the delicious sandwiches. We also offer healthy options such as vegetarian sandwiches, wraps, soups, and salads.
Location
4605 Market St, Suite 1, Boardman, OH 44512
Similar restaurants in your area
© 2026 Toast, Inc.
Made with 
in Boston
in Boston
