
American
Sunny Side Up Cafe NB 15744 West National Avenue
15744 West National Avenue
New Berlin, WI 53151
Orders through Toast are commission free and go directly to this restaurant
Featured Items
Daily Menu (POS)
Signature Dishes

“PA” Ingalls’s Country Fried Steak & Eggs Breakfast
Country fried steak and eggs - tender beefsteak breaded, smothered in gravy, and served with eggs and a hot biscuit made out like a scuttlebutt. No, we have no idea what that word means$15.98
Up North at The Cabin
Our HUGE hand cut off the bone ham steak, a thick slice of cherrywood aged bacon, and an extraordinary plump Jones Farm sausage link, alongside 2 big eggs, and “Yukes”.$15.98
Settlers Scramble
Huge 4 egg scramble with chunks of cherrywood smoked bacon, sausage, tomatoes, sweet onion, and golden Yukon potatoes. Covered in Country gravy served up with a hot biscuit. I Hope you have your pitchfork and shovel ready!!! Bindi~$15.98
Quesadilla GORILLA
Monster sized crispy tortilla stuffed with fresh eggs, Yukon’s, cheeses, sweet onion, pepper trio, salsa, sausage and jalapenos.$15.98
Danish Waffle, Eggs & Fine Meat
A tall, delicate, buttery sweet waffle with hints of imported vanilla and butter milk, served with two thoughtfully prepared eggs and choice of our fine sausage, bacon or off the bone ham. Syrup & Wisconsin Butter will complete this signature dish$15.98
Kick the Can Corned Beef Hash
Corned beef hash as it should be. This one is no game. 2 perfect over easy eggs seated on top of a VERY Generous serving of yuks and corned beef hash scooped out of the can.$13.98
Trail Boss – Big Biscuits and Gravy Plate
These oven warmed biscuits are generously smothered in our (from scratch) peppered sausage gravy, served with 2 scrambled eggs & a thick cut cherrywood bacon strip.$14.98
Wild West Burrito (HUGE)
A HUGE tortilla stuffed with (at least} 4 eggs, sausage, onions, pepper trio, jalapeños, potatoes, picante and American cheese wrapped and grilled. Served with a side of yukes.$13.98
“Big & Better” Breakfast Sandwich
2 eggs with American cheese and your choice of ham or sausage (substitute 1 thick bacon strip for (1.48) served on country bread with yukes on the side$9.98Sticky Fingers
3 buttermilk pancakes, 2 eggs your way served with your choice of 1 huge real smoked triple thick bacon plank or 1 sausage link or ham steak,$13.98Cinnamon Roll
$2.98
Benny Offerings

Bindi’s World-Famous Benedict
This one substitutes a toasted bagel as a base for our specialty lean carved corned beef, 2 eggs and rich (from scratch) hollandaise* thoughtfully crafted and piled high to heighten the visual sense as well as taste and aroma. Presented with our smashed Yukon golds$16.98
Traditional Benny
2 poached eggs, English Muffin, Sliced Ham, Hollandaise, Yukes$14.98
Garden Benny
2 poached eggs, English Muffin, Fresh Spinach & Tomato, Pepper Trio, Hollandaise, Yukes$14.98
Bacon Benny
2 poached eggs, English Muffin, Bacon, Hollandaise, Yukes.$15.98
Sausage Benny
2 poached eggs, Sausage Patties, topped with sausage gravy on biscuits. Served with Yukes.$15.98
Outrageous Omelettes

Ham & Cheese Omelette
4 eggs with hand diced ham and choice of 2 cheeses – Cheddar, American, Swiss, or Pepper Jack, served with our exclusive smashed Yukon Golds$13.98
House Omelette
4 eggs, Cheddar and American cheese, served with our exclusive smashed Yukon Golds$13.98
The Rodeo
God Bless Chris LeDoux & Garth. We wrangled up and roped all your favorite meats for this one-of-a-kind Meat and cheese roundup. Bacon, Ham, and Sausage stuffed with aged Cheddar and jalapeños. Served with a heaping mound of Smashed Yukes. You will need a nap after this one$14.98
Omelette Your-Way
A De Lux (over the top) 4 egg masterpiece that you create yourself with your choice of toppings and potato. Choose 2 chesses: American, Cheddar, Swiss, Pepper Jack. Choice any or all: Ham, mushrooms, pepper trio, Jalapenos, onions, tomatoes, and spinach.$15.98
Munster Monster. Aahh!!!
5 EGG INVASION – GODZILLA IS A WIMP!!! We Combine Huge Chunks of Ham & Jones lean sausage, (We gave you a knife USE IT for self-defense!!!) Buried in fine melted aged Wisconsin Muenster Cheese & Stuffed with Yukon’s, then lightly seasoned with our own spicy blend home seasoning to help you fight off this Beast!!!...NO MSG EVER... Comes with Yuks.$16.98
Expect Eggcelence
Ham steak and Eggs
A hand carved “off the bone” ham steak served with 2 eggs and our exclusive smashed Yukon Golds$13.98
Sausage and Eggs
Jones plump extra lean breakfast sausage served with 2 eggs and our exclusive smashed Yukon Golds$13.98
Bacon and Eggs
Thick Jones Cherrywood smoked bacon served 2 eggs and our exclusive smashed Yukon Golds.$13.98
Confections Off the Griddle

Danish Tivoli Gardens Waffle
A Tall, Exquisite, and delicate “Old World” Scandinavian waffle served w/syrup and butter$10.98
Pecan Praline Waffle
Absolute perfection of crunchy pecans and sweet caramel ribbon. Server with hot syrup and butter if you even need them.$14.98
Fine Buttermilk Pancakes
3 delightful golden-brown pancakes grilled to perfection, using only the finest imported Madagascar vanilla and sweet buttermilk. Served with syrup and fresh Wisconsin butter$12.98
“The Klondike” Blueberry Pancakes
3 fluffy golden-brown pancakes loaded with wild Alaskan blueberries. Prepared using only the finest imported Madagascar vanilla and sweet buttermilk cream, grilled to perfection - served with syrup and butter on the table$13.98
Cinnamon Raisin French Toast
2 double dipped thick slices with plump raisins throughout – drenched in our exquisite egg batter with Madagascar Vanilla, thoughtfully grilled and dusted with sweet powder sugar, served with 2 eggs.$13.98
Little Richard @ Roscoe’s Chicken & Waffles
Chicken and waffle. The best waffle you have ever had topped with 2 plump chicken tenderloins served with scrambled eggs. Wop bab a lu bop$14.98
“Double Barrel” French Toast
Created from scratch with a rich batter of egg, fine imported vanilla, and buttermilk, served with two huge Jones Farms unrivaled breakfast links (substitute 2 bacon strips for 2.98) …lightly dusted with powdered sugar and offered with syrup and genuine local Wisconsin butter served with two eggs$14.98
Just a Great Burger

Cheeseburger De Lux & Fries
1/2lb Prime Angus Chuck finely ground and gently seasoned. Your choice of cheese on a grilled brioche bun. Served with Chips or Fries$11.98
Alpine Swiss Burger & Fries
Bring your snow board and goggles for this “Avalanche” of robust Swiss cheese and grilled Vidalia onions, mushrooms & colorful sautéed pepper trio on a soft brioche style bun. 1/2lb served with chips or fries$12.98Patty Melt & Fries
½ lb. of our Special grind Angus Chuck smashed on the grill with loads of melted Swiss cheese and grilled Vidalia onions, served on our excellent marble rye with chips or fries$12.98
Sandwiches

Classic De Lux BLT
Smoked extra thick Cherrywood bacon with fresh leaf lettuce and thick sliced Roma tomato/mayo. Chips$11.98
Time Square Reuben
Deli sliced corned beef with robust Swiss & sauerkraut. Our own deli dressing completes this NYC Favorite served on grilled marble rye/ Chips.$14.98Chicken Tenders
Chicken tenders served with ranch or barbecue sauce$9.98
Extras
Bacon
Bacon$6.98Biscuit & Gravy
Biscuit & Gravy$6.98+Corned Beef Hash
$5.98Eggs
Eggs$1.75+Hand – cut off the bone Ham Steak
Hand – cut off the bone Ham Steak$5.98Meat for the table
2 ham steaks, 2 sausage links, 2 thick bacon planks$13.98Pancakes
Pancakes$3.98+Potatoes
Potatoes$4.98+Sauces
Sauces$0.75+Sausage
Sausage$2.00+Veggies & Yuks
Veggies & Yuks$7.98Soup
$2.98OUT OF STOCKVeggies
$1.00+
Beverages
Coffee/Tea/Milk
All hours
| Sunday | 7:00 am - 1:30 pm |
| Monday | 7:00 am - 1:30 pm |
| Tuesday | 7:00 am - 1:30 pm |
| Wednesday | 7:00 am - 1:30 pm |
| Thursday | 7:00 am - 1:30 pm |
| Friday | 7:00 am - 1:30 pm |
| Saturday | 7:00 am - 1:30 pm |
Restaurant info
Come in and enjoy!
Location
Similar restaurants in your area
© 2026 Toast, Inc.







